PDA

View Full Version : New CGI movie


Pages : 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7

AquaParade
06-07-2021, 01:05 PM
I might be overreaching, but I found it interesting that Kevin never re-tweeted Seth Rogen's tweet. Seems like something he might do based on his twitter activity in the past, but then again he isn't even promoting the release of Last Ronin issues, so maybe it's random.

Slash-Dash
06-20-2021, 10:51 AM
I might be overreaching, but I found it interesting that Kevin never re-tweeted Seth Rogen's tweet. Seems like something he might do based on his twitter activity in the past, but then again he isn't even promoting the release of Last Ronin issues, so maybe it's random.

I wouldn't look that deep into it.

Technogeek29
06-20-2021, 10:52 PM
I'm not holding my breath, it's Hollywood and it's cracked out hacks who nowadays seem to be throwing darts at a board. The Turtles acting like regular children but then slowly becoming the cynical assassins later in life? A compelling story could be written from that? But Seth's description however vague doesn't lead me to believe that is the case here. Kinda really just seems we're trying to appeal to the common denominator which don't care and won't care. I expect this to be as dark as SOTO.

IndigoErth
06-25-2021, 07:43 PM
A little surprised they didn't do a set of those "class notes," one for each Turtle.

NinjaPug
07-12-2021, 09:08 AM
The head of Nickelodeon made a quick comment on Rogen's movie:

We’re really excited about Seth Rogen’s new Turtles film, which will be theatrical. It’s a new retelling of Turtles and that will reignite that franchise and that movie comes in August 2023.

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/fairly-oddparents-revival-blues-clues-movie-nickelodeon-brian-robbins-1234979714/

Leo656
07-12-2021, 12:15 PM
"The New New NEW TMNT Reboot, Ver. 359". That's EXACTLY what we need for this franchise. :lol: More "reinvention" and "Everything you thought you knew is wrong!" stuff.

"Awesome". Wake me up when it tanks.

AquaParade
07-12-2021, 12:29 PM
They're sitting on a gold mine and don't know what to do with it.

Though, to be fair, Seth Rogen is a savvy business choice at this point. He does find success.

Leo656
07-12-2021, 12:49 PM
Outside of selling overpriced action figures to 40-year olds, how is TMNT "a gold mine"? That goes against every single thing we've seen since 2003, which has been nothing but one face-bump after another as each new version fails to recapture lightning in a bottle.

It's not popular or relevant in anything but an "I 'Member That!" sense. The movies and cartoons which were ostensibly designed to "capture a new audience" failed utterly to do that, repeatedly. Only the kids who cared in 1992 still care, for the most part, with VERY few exceptions who by no means disprove the "rule".

The absolute most this brand can hope for is that in 2032 some of the kids who watched the 2012 cartoon make enough noise to get some nostalgic action figures aimed at them.

It's NOT an "evergreen" property and it baffles me why some people think it is or can be. They can't even sustain a line of mass-market toys at retail or keep a cartoon show on the air.

I think it'll continue tp do okay the way stuff like MOTU or Thundercats does okay, in how every few years some toys come out aimed at collectors and older fans. But just like every attempt to "reinvent" or reinvigorate those brands tends to fail - because they were a product of their time that Specific People liked for Specific Reasons - that's how it's gonna be for TMNT. Those People grew up and the specific things they liked about those properties can't be recreated outside of the time and place they were originally conceived in. Trying to get back there again is a fools' errand predestined for failure.

So sure, some occasional Nostalgia Bait like the NECA/Super 7 toys or the upcoming video game. That's how TMNT survives into the future. But "a goldmine"? It hasn't been a "goldmine" since somewhere around 1993, let's just call it like it is. And it never will be again.

It's just not that popular, and hasn't been for ages. Not being a dick, just being pragmatic. For a property to be "a goldmine", people have to care first. And if it's not FW TMNT, people Do Not Care, haven't cared, and WON'T care. That's just the way it is.

AquaParade
07-12-2021, 01:07 PM
Outside of selling overpriced action figures to 40-year olds, how is TMNT "a gold mine"? That goes against every single thing we've seen since 2003, which has been nothing but one face-bump after another as each new version fails to recapture lightning in a bottle.

It's not popular or relevant in anything but an "I 'Member That!" sense. The movies and cartoons which were ostensibly designed to "capture a new audience" failed utterly to do that, repeatedly. Only the kids who cared in 1992 still care, for the most part, with VERY few exceptions who by no means disprove the "rule".

The absolute most this brand can hope for is that in 2032 some of the kids who watched the 2012 cartoon make enough noise to get some nostalgic action figures aimed at them.

It's NOT an "evergreen" property and it baffles me why some people think it is or can be. They can't even sustain a line of mass-market toys at retail or keep a cartoon show on the air.

I think it'll continue tp do okay the way stuff like MOTU or Thundercats does okay, in how every few years some toys come out aimed at collectors and older fans. But just like every attempt to "reinvent" or reinvigorate those brands tends to fail - because they were a product of their time that Specific People liked for Specific Reasons - that's how it's gonna be for TMNT. Those People grew up and the specific things they liked about those properties can't be recreated outside of the time and place they were originally conceived in. Trying to get back there again is a fools' errand predestined for failure.

So sure, some occasional Nostalgia Bait like the NECA/Super 7 toys or the upcoming video game. That's how TMNT survives into the future. But "a goldmine"? It hasn't been a "goldmine" since somewhere around 1993, let's just call it like it is. And it never will be again.

It's just not that popular, and hasn't been for ages. Not being a dick, just being pragmatic. For a property to be "a goldmine", people have to care first. And if it's not FW TMNT, people Do Not Care, haven't cared, and WON'T care. That's just the way it is.

Nah. It's a goldmine. The right TMNT movie would make absolute bank. If James Gunn can make that kind of money giving us Guardians of the Galaxy, there is no doubt in my mind he could do it with TMNT.

It's a great property with a ton of interest that isn't being utilized. Again look to the last ronin as a microcosm. TMNT comics sell very mediocre numbers, but all of the sudden, you do something that speaks to the roots of the franchise and TMNT is the most talked about and sold comic of the year. It's insane. And it speaks to the potential of the franchise when handled right.

Secondly, arguing that a franchise isn't a goldmine, when it has consistently survived on the air, on toy shelves, and in the culture, despite every incarnation since 2003 being, in your words, a "face bump" is crazy to me. If the brand can survive such awful treatment for over 18 years, then it stands to reason it would thrive under proper treatment.

Where you are absolutely wrong is that people don't care unless it's FW. The opening weekend of the Platinum Dunes movie did very well. It wasn't marketed as Fred Wolf - like at all. It was a gritty, loud, Michael Bay action movie from the looks of things. And people were willing to eat it up until they realized just how ****** it tasted and the box office dropped. But the interest was there.

Yup, not a doubt it my mind that a TMNT movie done by a team that knows TMNT and knows how to make a good movie, would be the box office hit of the summer. People adore the concept.

Sumac
07-12-2021, 01:16 PM
Reignite? Or burn to the ****ing ground?
Because, with Viacom at the head it seems like a more likely scenario.

Leo656
07-12-2021, 01:26 PM
We'll see if it ever happens. So far? Hasn't been the case in Ever.

It's not a brand that thrives, it merely endures. If people cared, it'd be as big as Batman. Batman gets sh*tty handling all the time. Bad comics, bad movies, bad cartoon shows... and yet, Batman is "evergreen".

TMNT, on its best day, would need a rocket up its ass to get that kind of popularity. It's not JUST that most versions of the TMNT property since the 2000s have been lousy (although that definitely doesn't help a damn thing), it's that like it or not, only ONE version of the brand has ever been overwhelmingly popular and successful, and that version ended 30 years ago.

Even the "good" (or "Less Bad") versions, like 4Kids or the 2012 cartoon, barely left any mark on the pop culture landscape. They didn't "sell". They did "okay", but even 2012 has totally become an "Oh, yeah, that show existed" kind of thing, mostly-forgotten as soon as it ended.

You say "people" (in general) "adore" the TMNT concept.

I think that's proven horsesh*t. What people "adore" is generally a cartoon they watched 30+ years ago when they were 7, and otherwise they don't give a sh*t. People do NOT care about TMNT. SOME people care a lot, just like MOTU or Thundercats or anything else. "People", in general, though, don't give a single sh*t about anything but that One Version.

Even something like Transformers is like a thousand times more popular and relevant than TMNT is. Which sort of proves that presentation or "products put out by people who really care" means f*ck-all nothing, because you can't get much worse than how THAT brand has been presented over the last 20 years, yet it's completely bulletproof.

I'd like to admire your enthusiasm, I just find it at odds with objective reality. The only people who "adore" the TMNT concept are on this forum and you could fit all of 'em on a single-decker bus. Everyone else only cares about FW Nostalgia and nothing else.

If I saw people caring about Ninja Turtles, I'd say "People care about Ninja Turtles". But that's not what I see and hasn't been for a long time. If/When I see it becoming a "goldmine" rather than a vehicle for selling $60 action figures to people suffering a midlife crisis, then trust me, I'll say so.

But I don't THINK that's ever going to happen. If it was, it would've happened by now.


Where you are absolutely wrong is that people don't care unless it's FW. The opening weekend of the Platinum Dunes movie did very well. It wasn't marketed as Fred Wolf - like at all. It was a gritty, loud, Michael Bay action movie from the looks of things. And people were willing to eat it up until they realized just how ****** it tasted and the box office dropped. But the interest was there.


I don't think I'm wrong about that at all. If anything, that movie being so abysmal only pushed people further into the FW comfort zone and rejecting anything else. Which is why the sequel went full-on FW, only to fail because - once again - push comes to shove, people DON'T care about TMNT.

Viacom's biggest failure is in TRYING to make it some Big Giant Blockbuster thing when it ISN'T that. The more they try and MAKE it that, the more they screw it up.

Look, since the 90s we've had Sh*t Reboots and Great Reboots with TMNT, and reboots in-between. What they ALL have in common is that regardless of approach, and regardless of quality, they've ALL under-performed against expectations.

You can read that data any way you choose. What it tells ME is, "TMNT was 'popular' from 1987 through 1992, and since then it's a relic that gets trotted out for a Nostalgia Pop but nobody who wasn't there for the first round actually, truly gives a sh*t."

Again, when the mythical TMNT reboot comes out that sets the world on fire, I'll admit people give a sh*t about Ninja Turtles. I don't think they do, and nothing I've seen YET has me convinced that this brand is "popular" to the level of being "a goldmine".

IndigoErth
07-12-2021, 03:17 PM
Kind of sucks to just automatically feel skeptical or pessimistic, but after one bombed show and the result of the last two films before it... here we are.

Personally, I bet we could very well see the TMNT someday hit the age Batman is and still be around, but they need to wise up and stop handling them the way they currently are.

At what point do they grasp that reinventing and retelling over and over is not the way to succeed. Stop trying to reinvent the wheel hoping for Turtlemania 2.0. If someone has ideas for great new adventures for them without starting over and effing up who they are as characters, great.

As a property that has been around for over 37 years, I don't think we need to keep reintroducing them at this point. Everyone more or less knows who they are and any clueless outliers who are interested can go check out other media first and find out.

If they want to reignite it then it's pretty clear that kids these days are a hard sell, and a lot of stuff doesn't stick with them for very long, so they need to stop dragging their heels and be smart about it and look to where the money is. Last Ronin sounds like it's doing pretty well, the Batman/TMNT movie went over quite good... get the act together and get a PG13 series happening that may also catch the interest of even casual viewers who like good, gritty shows and might make them TMNT fans in the long run.

If you pull new adults in who are the interested in checking out more of the franchise, then you may end up pulling the kids in, too.


Before the TMNT mention that article includes "Audiences want more of the things they love and that’s how you build brand loyalty." Sounds pretty counter to constantly reinventing things.

Leo656
07-12-2021, 03:38 PM
Constant reboots and "reinterpretations" do more harm than good. I'll always believe that. You don't NEED 30 different conflicting versions of a character or concept. Questions like "Where did the Ninja Turtles come from?" and "Who is April?" don't need multiple-choice answers. There NEEDS to be consistency or else people just tune out.

Like with Batman, there's always some differences in the minutiae of his origins or what his costume looks like, but the biggest differences between iterations are usually more tonal than anything. Yes, there's discrepancies in the finer details like what movie the Waynes were out to see on the night Bruce's parents got killed, or WHO the killer even was, but the basic pieces of the puzzle never change TOO much. The character(s) and storylines have generally been pretty consistent since their inception. The reason we see people say things like "If I see Batman's parents get shot one more time, I'm gonna scream" is because it's SUCH a consistent story that it genuinely doesn't need to be retold in each and every iteration.

Compared to TMNT, where every version bears practically no resemblance to any other past the surface textures. Characterizations, origin stories, and entire characters and plot elements are either non-existent or totally different from one version to the next. Some people think that's "fun" and "neat"; I say it's useless clutter. "Who is April O'Neil?" "Which one? There's like eight or nine of them, now." Terrible.

Also, when you're constantly rebooting something, not only do you get non-stop origin rehashes BUT you also never get too many steps past the origin story in the first place. No TMNT version except for Mirage Vol. 4 ever took the story beyond "Year Two" or so in their journey, and no "mainstream" version ever really has, outside of "flash-forward" possible future arcs.

Like I'm not even a huge fan of FW TMNT, but by this point I'd genuinely be more excited for a movie or cartoon that revisits that universe but picks it up with like, the TMNT in their early-20s or something, rather than another full reboot/alternate universe. Like how MOTU: Revelations isn't a true "sequel" to the Filmation MOTU cartoon but sort of "pretends" to be in that same universe but just moves the story forward a bit... that, to me, would be something I'd appreciate from a TMNT project, more so than "New TMNT Universe #678".

We've had a few decent TMNT "universes" that had good story and characters, and lots of good stories still untold. We don't need to keep "scanning the Multiverse" for "new and different" versions, I truly and honestly think that only makes things worse.

CyberCubed
07-12-2021, 04:40 PM
If the Turtles really do start off as human teenagers before they're mutated (instead of just pet turtles like usual), then this movie is doomed from the start. Human Turtles is even worse than nostril turtles, it'll be the biggest jump the shark moment in TMNT history.

Just makes me sick to my stomach just thinking about it. God I hope this isn't the case.

AquaParade
07-12-2021, 04:50 PM
We'll see if it ever happens. So far? Hasn't been the case in Ever.

It's not a brand that thrives, it merely endures. If people cared, it'd be as big as Batman. Batman gets sh*tty handling all the time. Bad comics, bad movies, bad cartoon shows... and yet, Batman is "evergreen".

It does endure rather than thrive, I agree. But you said yourself that every incarnation has fallen flat since 2003. If the brand can endure for 18 years under crap treatment, then yeah, it stands to reason that it could thrive with proper treatment.

Batman is the least fair comparison, in this instance. The Dark Knight trilogy, B:TAS, Arkham Asylum games, Batfleck, Alan Moore, Grant Morrison....Has TMNT ever had treatment this good in their existence? The answer is a resounding "no." I mean, you can take some of those examples and try telling me why they actually suck, but it's an impossible sell when comparing their quality to the likes of what we have gotten under the TMNT banner.
Batman get's plenty of weak material, but he can survive it easily, because has an abundance of great material. Choose an apt comparison.


I don't think I'm wrong about that at all. If anything, that movie being so abysmal only pushed people further into the FW comfort zone and rejecting anything else. Which is why the sequel went full-on FW, only to fail because - once again - push comes to shove, people DON'T care about TMNT.

It doesn't matter if that movie pushed people into a FW comfort zone (which I don't think it actually did) because the point remains that the opening box office was very big, despite the film not resembling the Fred Wolf cartoon at all. That point hasn't changed. It shows that you can sell TMNT in a big way without Fred Wolf.
Same with my Last Ronin example. It shows that you can garner massive interest without the Fred Wolf concept. It shows that people are hungry for something else. The Last Ronin also shows that not all tmnt is created equal, and it's not going to be received equally. Why is The Last Ronin selling hotter than any other comic book this year, while the ongoing flounders? Why is that?

Even many casual fans who grew up loving Fred Wolf rather see something more "adult" on screen. Nostalgia is powerful, but people want those properties to grow up with them, the same way all the Marvel and DC characters did. Yeah, people remember their Batman pajamas too, but it doesn't mean they want to see some toddler-fair when they go to the movie theater. They want The Dark Knight. TMNT is only different in that there is nothing for the older fans to cling to, until very recently inside of a dying medium.

Viacom's biggest failure is in TRYING to make it some Big Giant Blockbuster thing when it ISN'T that. The more they try and MAKE it that, the more they screw it up.

The issue isn't that they've gone too big. It's just the execution. TMNT works as a blockbuster franchise as well as any other comic.

Look, since the 90s we've had Sh*t Reboots and Great Reboots with TMNT, and reboots in-between. What they ALL have in common is that regardless of approach, and regardless of quality, they've ALL under-performed against expectations.

I'm glad you brought this up, but the key point here is that they underperformed after having stellar opening weekends. It's insane how much leverage tmnt has gotten from audiences. People show up every opening weekend, hoping it will be great, and then it dwindles as word of mouth gets around.


I'd like to admire your enthusiasm, I just find it at odds with objective reality. The only people who "adore" the TMNT concept are on this forum and you could fit all of 'em on a single-decker bus. Everyone else only cares about FW Nostalgia and nothing else.

If that were true, there would be no TMNT brand anymore. Casual fans care as much about TMNT as they do about any random Marvel character, and that's enough. You think all the people who make up Spider-Man box office post on a Spider-Man forum? They simply grew up with the character and still enjoy seeing him treated in a way suitable for older viewers.


You can read that data any way you choose. What it tells ME is, "TMNT was 'popular' from 1987 through 1992, and since then it's a relic that gets trotted out for a Nostalgia Pop but nobody who wasn't there for the first round actually, truly gives a sh*t."

I feel like this gets away from the point that doing TMNT right will bring in big audiences. I'm not sure whether I agree or disagree, but I don't think it betrays the idea that doing TMNT right would lead to massive success.

Leo656
07-12-2021, 07:49 PM
With regard to the Batman comparison, no, you're correct, the closest thing TMNT has ever gotten to some of the stuff Batman has, quality-wise, would be the 1990 movie, and since then nobody's even attempted to present anything in that vein with the property.

In theory, you might be correct in that if someone did present a more "serious, grown-up" iteration that was objectively well-made, then it MIGHT just be the spark that lights a fire. Maybe, possibly.

But it's tough to really say. For one thing, we've seen on this forum many times where people have sworn that having "the characters grow up with them" is the LAST thing many of them want from this franchise. The "broken base" problem is worse with this franchise than perhaps any other, mostly because of all the numerous disparate versions. Like sure, some Batman fans prefer the Adam West version, but MOST people rightly tell those people to go sit in the corner and let the Big Kids direct the Batman conversations. It's different with TMNT; to a ton of people who identify as "TMNT fans", they want it balls-out, over-the-top goofy; "It should be goofy and stupid because that's the way it works BEST." You and I, we think differently. But y'know what? I'm gonna say that we're outvoted, and pretty soundly at that. And if ever anyone disputes that notion, the other people can (rightly) claim that the only version of TMNT that ever became a huge global phenomenon was one of the goofiest, stupidest and objectively slapdash, half-assed versions of it, which means it isn't a matter of either quality or effort.

FW being "the only TMNT anyone ever cared about" skews the entire argument because it isn't even a matter of opinion; it's Objective Fact whether we like it or not, all anyone has to do is look at the numbers. And until a "serious, grown-up" version comes along that succeeds in equal, or even comparable measure to FW TMNT, it's impossible to say with any certainty that "THAT's the Magic Bullet". Me, I'd like nothing more than for EVERY version of TMNT to follow the 1990 film's aesthetic; for all I know, though, it'd tank. We can't say "If TMNT had its own 'Batman Begins', it'd be a huge hit." We truly don't know that, we can only say "Well that's what *I* want to see and think would work best."

And I mean sure, it's worth a shot. But it's a moot point, because as I've mentioned before, Viacom bought the brand to sell cheap toys to little kids every 5-10 years, and that's ALL they care about or are interested in. They sincerely, truly, 100% do not care about what ANY "TMNT Fan" outside of that age group thinks. This brand is f*cking Scooby-Doo, now, and that's all it's ever gonna be unless they sell it to WB one day, which is Highly Unlikely.

I mean, okay, "Last Ronin", again. It doesn't matter! I'm sincerely glad you like the book so much, but for the 100th time if it leads to anything of substance beyond maybe another mini-series, I'll eat a goddamn shoe. It's a comic book mini-series that sold copies which, if it were an ongoing series ten years ago, it would've been cancelled for "low sales". It only looks like a huge triumph because the other TMNT books sell so poorly.

When you're drowning in sh*t, ANYTHING that sparkles looks like a diamond. Last Ronin is a "here's your 'grown-up' TMNT, now shut up" bone for the Big Kids. It's NOT going to affect Viacom's overall approach to presenting or marketing TMNT in any meaningful way, and if it does I'll lead the parade.

But you don't need a crystal ball to see that that's NOT going to happen.

Sumac
07-12-2021, 09:25 PM
I think TMNT can easily be around for as long as Batman, the problem is that it will exist as number of desperate mediocre variations appearing and disappearing quickly from people's memory.

And aside form FW most people won't remember any of them or consider them "good enough".

I would like situation to be different, even if that'd require modern retelling of FW series. But it is unlikely to happen.

Leo656
07-12-2021, 09:53 PM
I pretty much feel the same.

They'll still be selling TMNT-branded products many years from now, just like some companies still sell products based on Dick Tracy or The Shadow or Green Hornet or Flash Gordon. But are those properties "popular" or "relevant" in any significant way, anymore? Absolutely not, that's not even a conversation. They only exist to say "Hey, remember this? It existed!" And that's all they ever will be. That's TMNT's future as well, 100%.

I definitely think some company will still be selling TMNT action figures and statues in 50-60 years (and that most or all of those products will be based on FW and nothing else). But that's going to be 100% of TMNT's existence or "relevance".

It's never going to be 1989 again. It's not even going to be 2003 again. It's never even going to come close.

That isn't "doomsaying", it's just plain paying attention and refusing to live in Make-Believe Land. TMNT isn't incredibly popular, hasn't been for ages, and it would take nothing short of a legit miracle to ever make it so again.

But they'll still be selling "Cowabunga!"-branded trinkets and Christmas tree ornaments several decades from now, just like they do with Charlie Brown or Garfield even though nobody's given a sh*t about that stuff for decades, either. So, I mean, there's that.

You just have to be realistic about these kinds of things, that's all.

Also? Unpopular Opinion Theater time, but it needs to be said: A major thing holding TMNT back from being truly "evergreen" the way stuff like Batman is, is that objectively, on its face, the entire TMNT concept is by far one of the all-time DUMBEST things to ever become a billion-dollar franchise. I say that "with love", but c'mon, let's just be real. If you tried to explain even the basics of TMNT to someone who had no idea what it was, it sounds like the lunatic ramblings of some ADHD-riddled pre-schooler.

Something so inherently stupid - no matter how "charming" - automatically has a limited shelf-life. It is absolutely one of those things people 100 years from now are going to look back on and say "Jesus, those people were stupid back then", like bell bottoms and pet rocks. It's a premise that certainly can be executed in a way so that it's NOT dumb, but it is, inherently, a dumb premise that requires a TON of delicate handling to present in a way that isn't stupid.

And before someone even tries to argue that "It's no more 'dumb' of a concept than a guy dressing up like a bat to go punch out criminals"... yes it is, by ten miles. Don't start.

LeotheLateBloomer
07-12-2021, 09:59 PM
Kind of sucks to just automatically feel skeptical or pessimistic, but after one bombed show and the result of the last two films before it... here we are.

Personally, I bet we could very well see the TMNT someday hit the age Batman is and still be around, but they need to wise up and stop handling them the way they currently are.

At what point do they grasp that reinventing and retelling over and over is not the way to succeed. Stop trying to reinvent the wheel hoping for Turtlemania 2.0. If someone has ideas for great new adventures for them without starting over and effing up who they are as characters, great.

As a property that has been around for over 37 years, I don't think we need to keep reintroducing them at this point. Everyone more or less knows who they are and any clueless outliers who are interested can go check out other media first and find out.

If they want to reignite it then it's pretty clear that kids these days are a hard sell, and a lot of stuff doesn't stick with them for very long, so they need to stop dragging their heels and be smart about it and look to where the money is. Last Ronin sounds like it's doing pretty well, the Batman/TMNT movie went over quite good... get the act together and get a PG13 series happening that may also catch the interest of even casual viewers who like good, gritty shows and might make them TMNT fans in the long run.

If you pull new adults in who are the interested in checking out more of the franchise, then you may end up pulling the kids in, too.


Before the TMNT mention that article includes "Audiences want more of the things they love and that’s how you build brand loyalty." Sounds pretty counter to constantly reinventing things.

Yeah, very true. After all these years of trying to "reinvent the wheel", Viacom still doesn't get it. How well is The Last Ronin doing, by the way?

AquaParade
07-13-2021, 05:22 AM
With regard to the Batman comparison, no, you're correct, the closest thing TMNT has ever gotten to some of the stuff Batman has, quality-wise, would be the 1990 movie, and since then nobody's even attempted to present anything in that vein with the property.

In theory, you might be correct in that if someone did present a more "serious, grown-up" iteration that was objectively well-made, then it MIGHT just be the spark that lights a fire. Maybe, possibly.

But it's tough to really say. For one thing, we've seen on this forum many times where people have sworn that having "the characters grow up with them" is the LAST thing many of them want from this franchise. The "broken base" problem is worse with this franchise than perhaps any other, mostly because of all the numerous disparate versions. Like sure, some Batman fans prefer the Adam West version, but MOST people rightly tell those people to go sit in the corner and let the Big Kids direct the Batman conversations. It's different with TMNT; to a ton of people who identify as "TMNT fans", they want it balls-out, over-the-top goofy; "It should be goofy and stupid because that's the way it works BEST." You and I, we think differently. But y'know what? I'm gonna say that we're outvoted, and pretty soundly at that. And if ever anyone disputes that notion, the other people can (rightly) claim that the only version of TMNT that ever became a huge global phenomenon was one of the goofiest, stupidest and objectively slapdash, half-assed versions of it, which means it isn't a matter of either quality or effort.

FW being "the only TMNT anyone ever cared about" skews the entire argument because it isn't even a matter of opinion; it's Objective Fact whether we like it or not, all anyone has to do is look at the numbers. And until a "serious, grown-up" version comes along that succeeds in equal, or even comparable measure to FW TMNT, it's impossible to say with any certainty that "THAT's the Magic Bullet". Me, I'd like nothing more than for EVERY version of TMNT to follow the 1990 film's aesthetic; for all I know, though, it'd tank. We can't say "If TMNT had its own 'Batman Begins', it'd be a huge hit." We truly don't know that, we can only say "Well that's what *I* want to see and think would work best."

And I mean sure, it's worth a shot. But it's a moot point, because as I've mentioned before, Viacom bought the brand to sell cheap toys to little kids every 5-10 years, and that's ALL they care about or are interested in. They sincerely, truly, 100% do not care about what ANY "TMNT Fan" outside of that age group thinks. This brand is f*cking Scooby-Doo, now, and that's all it's ever gonna be unless they sell it to WB one day, which is Highly Unlikely.

I mean, okay, "Last Ronin", again. It doesn't matter! I'm sincerely glad you like the book so much, but for the 100th time if it leads to anything of substance beyond maybe another mini-series, I'll eat a goddamn shoe. It's a comic book mini-series that sold copies which, if it were an ongoing series ten years ago, it would've been cancelled for "low sales". It only looks like a huge triumph because the other TMNT books sell so poorly.

When you're drowning in sh*t, ANYTHING that sparkles looks like a diamond. Last Ronin is a "here's your 'grown-up' TMNT, now shut up" bone for the Big Kids. It's NOT going to affect Viacom's overall approach to presenting or marketing TMNT in any meaningful way, and if it does I'll lead the parade.

But you don't need a crystal ball to see that that's NOT going to happen.

You missed the point, re: the last ronin.
It's not about "gee, I just like that book so much", it's a point in regards to the discrepancy in sales of TLR vs the ongoing, and what that means for the franchise.
Nowhere am I saying that TLR is going to be successful enough to get it's own blockbuster movie.
The point being made is that when you do TMNT right....something different happens. You go from 10k comic sales to 200k comic sales.
Now, to make a point, you don't need to reach 500k comic sales, you simply need to look at one vs the other and realize there is massive potential not being met on the ongoing.


And then you apply that line of thinking to other TMNT projects.


Sorry, but everytime I bring up TLR, you seem to get confused and go down this road of "I get it - you like it! But it's not going to revive the franchise!"....well, that's not what I'm saying.
Although, to be fair, you're comparing it's sales to comics that sold years ago, which is irrelevant. Spider-Man sells less comics now than he did before too, yet he's the top grossing film. He's still one of the top selling comics and you see that popularity reflected in pop culture. TLR sales are meaningful. There's no denying that.
In fact, the sales are not just high in comparison to lower-selling TMNT comics as you imply - they are high in comparison to every single comic book on the market.
And I can never forget to mention that they were $9 issues, which is always a harder sell!
And the sales are increasing by issue as the book goes on!

You can't seriously handwave it as simply being successful in contrast to other TMNT books. It's not the case.

Btw, will you eat a shoe when the next TLR project is announced, or does it have to be labeled an "ongoing" for it to count? Personally, I'd think that's a cop out. If they announce more, it's no longer a mini-series and you should eat the shoe. We could use the content around here. I'd even settle for a shoe-shaped gummi.

I mean, before you kept saying it won't lead to anything else. Now you're saying "it wont lead to anything else...substantial...except another mini-series."

Coola Yagami
07-13-2021, 11:10 AM
It still kinda doesn't count unless it's the main series. Like they can have this super awesome TMNT/Street Sharks crossover special, but like it doesn't count.

We desperately need the main book to get back on track.

AquaParade
07-13-2021, 11:13 AM
It still kinda doesn't count unless it's the main series. Like they can have this super awesome TMNT/Street Sharks crossover special, but like it doesn't count.

We desperately need the main book to get back on track.

Well, to be fair, we're not really discussing whether the book...."counts" or not... I don't think?

I'm confused.

Slash-Dash
07-13-2021, 01:21 PM
do you think we saw a glimpse of leo when they released the tweet with the release date?

CyberCubed
07-13-2021, 02:23 PM
It still kinda doesn't count unless it's the main series. Like they can have this super awesome TMNT/Street Sharks crossover special, but like it doesn't count.

We desperately need the main book to get back on track.

Comics will never be as mainstream as a TV show or movie anyway.

Even when IDW was "good" from issue 1-100...most people have no clue it exists or if they do they don't bother to follow it.

Leo656
07-13-2021, 02:31 PM
Comics will never be as mainstream as a TV show or movie anyway.

Even when IDW was "good" from issue 1-100...most people have no clue it exists or if they do they don't bother to follow it.

Sad but true.

Which is why I can't help but chuckle when people insist that The Last Ronin is going to "save" the franchise. At best, they do another "mature TMNT" mini-series that 99.99999% of the fanbase won't ever see or care about. It has no effect on the larger plans Viacom has for the TMNT brand whatsoever. It's literally only there so they can tell the 30+-year olds "You got your bottle, now stop crying about how 'Everything's for kids' and go play in the corner."

Like I'm glad it exists but in the "Big Picture" it's meaningless.

AquaParade
07-13-2021, 03:53 PM
Sad but true.

Which is why I can't help but chuckle when people insist that The Last Ronin is going to "save" the franchise. At best, they do another "mature TMNT" mini-series that 99.99999% of the fanbase won't ever see or care about. It has no effect on the larger plans Viacom has for the TMNT brand whatsoever. It's literally only there so they can tell the 30+-year olds "You got your bottle, now stop crying about how 'Everything's for kids' and go play in the corner."

Like I'm glad it exists but in the "Big Picture" it's meaningless.

Who is saying it is going to "save" the franchise?

I don't see anyone saying that. The franchise doesn't really need saving in any financial sense, but the book will certainly lead to more of the same. Companies do what makes the most money. There will be more comics in this vein, for sure. You were saying it was just a mini-series, now you're saying another mini-series is a possibility, in a couple months, they'll announce it and you'll accept it as reality. Then what? "well it'll never be a movie!" This is the direction we are headed lol. Don't be stubborn, Leo! Just let it unfold. More The Last Ronin is coming.
Maybe it'll influence future projects, but no, it won't "save" any franchises. Def more comics though. Not "at best".

Although I did make a comparison between the ongoing and The Last Ronin to point out the discrepancy in sales when you make a TMNT product right vs making a poor TMNT product. I think you're having a hard time differentiating that with whatever you're talking about.

Sumac
07-14-2021, 08:51 AM
I am afraid, it'll take much more to divert Viacom from their current stance on TMNT, than a one miniseries.

AquaParade
07-14-2021, 10:27 AM
I am afraid, it'll take much more to divert Viacom from their current stance on TMNT, than a one miniseries.

True, but no one is trying to say otherwise in this thread.

Again, the point I was making is that there is a discrepancy in sales between a book like the last ronin and the ongoing.
The difference in success is huge. Just huge. The sales are looking to be over 15-20 to 1.


I was saying if you apply that line of thinking, to say the movies, then it stands to reason that the movies could be a huge hit. A tmnt movie done right would make a ton of money. Much more than the PD films. That's my belief. That's the only point I'm making in this thread. That Viacom could make a ton of money if they took the franchise more seriously.

I'd be willing to have the discussion of 'whether TLR will have an effect on the brand' - I think that's an interesting discussion. But I don't want to conflate that with what I'm saying here. Two very diff things I think we're having trouble separating.

No worries though, happy to explain. Unless you were responding to someone else's point that I didn't see. In that case, nvm.

Sumac
07-14-2021, 11:23 AM
I would propose the problem is not only that TLR is that good, it is that mainline series has also degenerated into a furry shitshow.

AquaParade
07-14-2021, 12:06 PM
I would propose the problem is not only that TLR is that good, it is that mainline series has also degenerated into a furry shitshow.

I would argue the exact same. And I’d argue that the films are the same level of trash if not worse then the ongoing. Outdo the recent movies, like TLR outdid the ongoing and watch what happens, Viacom.

TylerD
08-03-2021, 10:12 AM
Kind of sucks to just automatically feel skeptical or pessimistic, but after one bombed show and the result of the last two films before it... here we are.

Personally, I bet we could very well see the TMNT someday hit the age Batman is and still be around, but they need to wise up and stop handling them the way they currently are.

At what point do they grasp that reinventing and retelling over and over is not the way to succeed. Stop trying to reinvent the wheel hoping for Turtlemania 2.0. If someone has ideas for great new adventures for them without starting over and effing up who they are as characters, great.

As a property that has been around for over 37 years, I don't think we need to keep reintroducing them at this point. Everyone more or less knows who they are and any clueless outliers who are interested can go check out other media first and find out.

If they want to reignite it then it's pretty clear that kids these days are a hard sell, and a lot of stuff doesn't stick with them for very long, so they need to stop dragging their heels and be smart about it and look to where the money is. Last Ronin sounds like it's doing pretty well, the Batman/TMNT movie went over quite good... get the act together and get a PG13 series happening that may also catch the interest of even casual viewers who like good, gritty shows and might make them TMNT fans in the long run.

If you pull new adults in who are the interested in checking out more of the franchise, then you may end up pulling the kids in, too.


Before the TMNT mention that article includes "Audiences want more of the things they love and that’s how you build brand loyalty." Sounds pretty counter to constantly reinventing things.

I feel like with the previous bombs, they will make the next (whatever it is they do) one very good..... They really can't afford to bomb another one........ Or so I hope.

shredder orokusaki
08-07-2021, 04:21 AM
Let see which one of the two will release first this or the live action movie.

Vicky82
08-07-2021, 05:26 AM
Let see which one of the two will release first this or the live action movie.

Well obviously it's this movie, it's confirmed to be released on August 2023. I expect the live action movie will be released in 2024/25.

IndigoErth
08-07-2021, 10:21 AM
I feel like with the previous bombs, they will make the next (whatever it is they do) one very good..... They really can't afford to bomb another one........ Or so I hope.
I hope so. Not sure the property itself can withstand constant bombs that turn audiences off. Question is, do these people even know what "good" looks like? And without trying to shoehorn them into present stupid cartoon trends that we're supposed to believe are good, but in many cases are pretty sub par compared to what cartoons used to be.

Galactus
08-07-2021, 04:24 PM
I feel like with the previous bombs, they will make the next (whatever it is they do) one very good..... They really can't afford to bomb another one........ Or so I hope.

That's easier said than done. No one in Hollywood sets out to make bad movies or ones that flop. If movie studios had a magic formula for making a movie good and successful there would be no bad movies or box office bombs.

There's a slight pang of sympathy I have for people involved in making these new movies. Making a good TMNT movie shouldn't be as difficult as Platinum Dunes made it look in 2014 with the constant re-writes and re-shoots but there's definitely aspects of this franchise that are difficult to translate into live action.

Add to that for decades people have incessantly argued that the best route for commercial success was to make the '87 animated series in live action. We know that know that most people in Hollywood who have handled the franchise have strongly believed the same but there has always been something to prevent the movie series going full Fred Wolf but finally with Out of the Shadows they finally made the old cartoon in live action and it bombed. Other than the 1990 movie none of the cinematic releases have been huge sellers but the one that they thought was basically a license to print money was the first to fail. I don't think anyone knows what to do with property right now. If that didn't work what will?

I strongly suspect the answers they come up with wont be what we fans want and given the track record wont be what the general public wants either.

Slap-Happy
08-16-2021, 04:40 PM
Varner Studios (who sculpted most of the original playmates figures) posted this on their Instagram today. Fairly certain its for this movie, as the Jost one isn’t even written yet

https://i.imgur.com/Hxdvuf8_d.webp?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&fidelity=medium

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 04:47 PM
Varner Studios (who sculpted most of the original playmates figures) posted this on their Instagram today. Fairly certain its for this movie, as the Jost one isn’t even written yet

https://i.imgur.com/Hxdvuf8_d.webp?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&fidelity=medium
I wonder if they are checking out the stuff that they plan on putting in the movie.

Varner Studios have been making TMNT toys in the 90s, Its possible the CGI animated movie will be FW inspired.

Check out the shop section which has a ton of TMNT concept art.
https://www.varnerstudios.com/tmnt-concept-art-1

Slap-Happy
08-16-2021, 05:03 PM
I wonder if they are checking out the stuff that they plan on putting in the movie.

Varner Studios have been making TMNT toys in the 90s, Its possible the CGI animated movie will be FW inspired.

Check out the shop section which has a ton of TMNT concept art.
https://www.varnerstudios.com/tmnt-concept-art-1
I mean if anything I think this means they’re more looking at the toy line for inspiration more than the cartoon, which is a step in the right direction IMO. The FW toon is just a kinda bad adaptation of the toy line.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 05:05 PM
I mean if anything I think this means they’re more looking at the toy line for inspiration more than the cartoon, which is a step in the right direction IMO. The FW toon is just a kinda bad adaptation of the toy line.
a lot of the toy line was from the cartoon, I looked at some of the concept art, and they have concept art for the Mona Lisa toy which was cool.

IndigoErth
08-16-2021, 05:07 PM
What am I not seeing...? Think a file type or something isn't supported by my browser. :tconfuse:

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 05:08 PM
What am I not seeing...? Think a file type or something isn't supported by my browser. :tconfuse:
The images load fine here on Chrome.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 05:09 PM
a lot of the concept art were used as the bases for the toys like the Mona Lisa one for example.

Its possible that the art department is looking at all there TMNT stuff to use for references.

Slap-Happy
08-16-2021, 05:14 PM
a lot of the concept art were used as the bases for the toys like the Mona Lisa one for example.

Its possible that the art department is looking at all there TMNT stuff to use for references.
That’s exactly what they are doing. But the toys have a specific aesthetic that’s different from a lot of other TMNT stuff. One of the artists posted on their story about the “collage” aspect of them, with the characters having a lot of intricate detail and stuff piled on them. It’s very flashy. They’re very aesthetically rich designs, and the philosophies used in those designs would translate very well to an animated film.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 05:21 PM
Here are the 3 other images from there Instagram post, a good view of all the sculps.
https://www.instagram.com/p/CSpf1KpB1CB/

Galactus
08-16-2021, 06:01 PM
Remember when the Platinum Dunes people invited journalists to the set and they came back with reports that fans need not worry, that TMNT was in good hands. Then none of the stuff they saw ended up being in the final movie.

Given the 95% of cg animated movies follow a very similar aesthetic, the one set all the way back in 1995 with Toy Story I don't see any studio not going in that direction with the new the designs of the new movie. Frankly I don't think they should anyway. The look of the toyline has a certain charm but I don't think it will translate well to animation.

Also since I know it's going to get brought up neither will bringing in every random character from the toyline. Say what you will about Form and Fuller but after the failure of Out of the Shadows they got that simply bringing in more characters from the 80s is not enough to hook people in. I don't trust that they've learned anything but at least they learned that.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 06:04 PM
Remember when the Platinum Dunes people invited journalists to the set and they came back with reports that fans need not worry, that TMNT was in good hands. Then none of the stuff they saw ended up being in the final movie.

Given the 95% of cg animated movies follow a very similar aesthetic, the one set all the way back in 1995 with Toy Story I don't see any studio not going in that direction with the new the designs of the new movie. Frankly I don't think they should anyway. The look of the toyline has a certain charm but I don't think it will translate well to animation.

Also since I know it's going to get brought up neither will bringing in every random character from the toyline. Say what you will about Form and Fuller but after the failure of Out of the Shadows they got that simply bringing in more characters from the 80s is not enough to hook people in. I don't trust that they've learned anything but at least they learned that.

They just don't fully get TMNT, The fact you got some people from Nickelodeon from the art department involved, Perhaps they are doing a lot more of the research for the animated movie, The fact they went to Varner Studios to check on there stuff, I doubt the people from Platinum Dune did any research.

Galactus
08-16-2021, 06:50 PM
It's definitely for the animated movie. I skimmed through the comments on the instagram post and Varner Studios replied to people it was for the Seth Rogen movie.

To damn Platinum Dunes with faint praise they did at skim various versions of TMNT for inspiration. You can tell the designs of the turtles and Shredder in the 2014 are based on the 2003 animated series designs just put through a Michael Bay 'everything has to huge and busy' filter. I can also buy that Zulli's turtles may have been an inspiration.

Likewise the turtle's truck in the sequel was a mash up of the party wagon and both the second and third battle shells from the '03 show. You can tell they at least watched a fair bit of the first two or three seasons of Fred Wolf show for inspiration particularly the Eye of Sarnath episodes.

I would hope Rogen and his people are doing a bit research that PD did but frankly taking inspiration from the toyline is not something I'd want to see.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 06:53 PM
It's definitely for the animated movie. I skimmed through the comments on the instagram post and Varner Studios replied to people it was for the Seth Rogen movie.

To damn Platinum Dunes with faint praise they did at skim various versions of TMNT for inspiration. You can tell the designs of the turtles and Shredder in the 2014 are based on the 2003 animated series designs just put through a Michael Bay 'everything has to huge and busy' filter. I can also buy that Zulli's turtles may have been an inspiration.

Likewise the turtle's truck in the sequel was a mash up of the party wagon and both the second and third battle shells from the '03 show. You can tell they at least watched a fair bit of the first two or three seasons of Fred Wolf show for inspiration particularly the Eye of Sarnath episodes.

I would hope Rogen and his people are doing a bit research that PD did but frankly taking inspiration from the toyline is not something I'd want to see.
I would really love for other TMNT properties to borrow from the toyline, There are so many characters who had figures, but these characters never showed up in the cartoons, movies or the comics.

It would be cool if they saw a character from the toyline, and decide to put that character in the movie because we haven't seen it done in any other medium.

Galactus
08-16-2021, 07:03 PM
I would really love for other TMNT properties to borrow from the toyline, There are so many characters who had figures, but these characters never showed up in the cartoons, movies or the comics.

It would be cool if they saw a character from the toyline, and decide to put that character in the movie because we haven't seen it done in any other medium.

And right on cue someone says that they want to see the movie use all the random characters from the toyline.

Haven't we learned that less is more when it comes to ancillary characters. We went through this when Laird sold the property to Nickledeon and some fans got very excited that we were going to not only see a return to the Fred Wolf characters and concepts but every random character from TMNT lore; Pizza Face and Half Court and Ace Duck and the like...then we started getting them and it became a case of be careful what you wish for.

Don't get me wrong there's some figures that just conceptually look as if they'd be cool characters (Scale Tail for example) but not in a movie.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 07:06 PM
And right on cue someone says that they want to see the movie use all the random characters from the toyline.

Haven't we learned that less is more when it comes to ancillary characters. We went through this when Laird sold the property to Nickledeon and some fans got very excited that we were going to not only see a return to the Fred Wolf characters and concepts but every random character from TMNT lore; Pizza Face and Half Court and Ace Duck and the like...then we started getting them and it became a case of be careful what you wish for.

Don't get me wrong there's some figures that just conceptually look as if they'd be cool characters (Scale Tail for example) but not in a movie.
In a CGI movie they can, They can go all crazy and weird with the mutants.

Galactus
08-16-2021, 07:12 PM
In a CGI movie they can, They can go all crazy and weird with the mutants.

Just because they can doesn't mean they should.

Loading a story with a bunch of random characters has never been a good thing in TMNT. Even the 80s cartoon characters proved a tough sell for kids with Out of the Shadows so how are people going to feel about a bunch of characters they've never heard of and most of which were too silly even for Fred Wolf.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 07:14 PM
Just because they can doesn't mean they should.

Loading a story with a bunch of random characters has never been a good thing in TMNT. Even the 80s cartoon characters proved a tough sell for kids with Out of the Shadows so how are people going to feel about a bunch of characters they've never heard of and most of which were too silly even for Fred Wolf.
Since you put it that way, Perhaps they should, Because they can if they want.

IndigoErth
08-16-2021, 07:15 PM
Imo, I'd rather any thought of pulling inspiration from the old toyline was kept to tv series only.

If we'd gotten really good movies and were now on, say, a 4th or 5th sequel, maybe there would be room to play with that, but the first in a reboot really needs to avoid having other characters unnecessarily hog screen time (and budget) from the TMNT. I know some aren't crazy about it in a series either, but in terms of the time limit a film just really doesn't have nearly as much room for it.

If it was some kind of scenario like Ready Player One where you have a lot of characters that are essentially just background extras, then... okay, whatever, I guess, but that's still budget down the drain, and in this case kind of defeats the concept of what the TMNT is in the part of their story that is about them being isolated.

TigerClaw
08-16-2021, 07:18 PM
Imo, I'd rather any thought of pulling inspiration from the old toyline was kept to tv series only.

If we'd gotten really good movies and were now on, say, a 4th or 5th sequel, maybe there would be room to play with that, but the first in a reboot really needs to avoid having other characters unnecessarily hog screen time (and budget) from the TMNT. I know some aren't crazy about it in a series either, but in terms of the time limit a film just really doesn't have nearly as much room for it.
I disagree, They can look at those toys and get inspiration for what they can put in there movie, We still don't know what its gonna be like, It could be FW since Seth Rogen was a fan of the original.

Galactus
08-16-2021, 07:29 PM
If they were just Easter Eggs I could be down with that. Like Shredder trying to make a mutant army and we see a bunch of mutants in a cages and they are all characters from the toyline I could see that.

Then again I've always been with Peter Laird on this; too many mutants makes the turtles and Splinter feel less special. Of course not all those toy characters were mutants. Still anything other than an easter egg or a small role should require set up and frankly no one is going to sit through a TMNT about the origin of King Lionheart or whoever.

Also why does everyone assume Rogen is a fan of the property. We've gotten no interview confirming he's a fan of any version. Yet people assume he's a OG comic fanboy or an 80s Fred Wolf animated series fan.

CyberCubed
08-16-2021, 07:53 PM
Varner Studios (who sculpted most of the original playmates figures) posted this on their Instagram today. Fairly certain its for this movie, as the Jost one isn’t even written yet

https://i.imgur.com/Hxdvuf8_d.webp?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&fidelity=medium

The only thing I get out of this picture is wondering if the woman in the tank top has big boobs from the front. Anyone have a pic of her facing the other way?

IndigoErth
08-16-2021, 07:54 PM
If they were just Easter Eggs I could be down with that. Like Shredder trying to make a mutant army and we see a bunch of mutants in a cages and they are all characters from the toyline I could see that.
That would be an interesting way to toss some of them in there. :tcool:

And agree on other mutants needing to take up time, and time away from the TMNT, to establish their existence.

If anyone has watched that "Arlo the Alligator Boy" animated movie on Netflix, it's a really good example of mutant/hybrid characters living in a world otherwise dominated by humans and having zero explanation for why they exist... and have to be honest, it was a little bothersome.

The 2014 film was already bothersome enough in how much time it spend on characters besides the Turtles, I'd prefer not to keep repeating that. If it's their film, then I want to see what they are doing in it.



edit: *sigh* Cubed.

Leo656
08-16-2021, 08:19 PM
Yeah, but we know 'Claw doesn't care about TMNT in itself, as much as he likes TMNT for being a Furry Character Delivery System. So he's not interested in whether or not a movie is actually good, or whether it treats the primary TMNT cast well. He's just hoping for lots and lots of mutants to be in it so he can have more bait for whatever's going on in his head during private time.

Let's just be plain about it and call it like it is.

Hamato Yoshi
08-16-2021, 11:57 PM
If they made Mirage style video game and it was a hit then maybe Hwood would listen

TigerClaw
08-17-2021, 03:54 PM
I would love to see characters like Old Hob appear in the CGI or live action movie, He would be a cool character to bring into a movie, And someone like Idris Elba as the voice would be cool to hear.

LeotheLateBloomer
08-17-2021, 05:05 PM
I would love to see characters like Old Hob appear in the CGI or live action movie, He would be a cool character to bring into a movie, And someone like Idris Elba as the voice would be cool to hear.

Lol don't bring Idris Elba into this just because you're hyped for the recent Sonic news!:lol:

TigerClaw
08-17-2021, 05:08 PM
Lol don't bring Idris Elba into this just because you're hyped for the recent Sonic news!:lol:
Idris Elba as the voice of Old Hob would make him sound bad ass.

neatoman
08-17-2021, 05:17 PM
Idris Elba as the voice of Old Hob would make him sound bad ass.

Wouldn't Hob have an American accent? I always sort of imagined him sounding like Jack Nicholson or Alec Baldwin.

TigerClaw
08-17-2021, 05:46 PM
Wouldn't Hob have an American accent? I always sort of imagined him sounding like Jack Nicholson or Alec Baldwin.
Idris Elba can do an American accent too.

dawwe
08-24-2021, 11:05 AM
I wonder when we will start seeing the designs for the turtles. Probably in a year or something like that.

NinjaPug
09-02-2021, 03:21 PM
Comments from the head of Nickelodeon.:

We're really excited about the slate we've built, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles reinvention that's being produced by Seth Rogen. I saw a first animation of the movie last week and it's going to be amazing. It's hysterical. Quality matters more than ever now. We have to deliver quality and we're really excited about Turtles as a franchise in general.

https://www.viacomcbs.com/news/content-and-experiences/brian-robbins-on-prioritizing-kids-family-content-across-platforms

CyberCubed
09-02-2021, 03:39 PM
I'm sure the CG animation will look good. I just worry about the designs (rightfully so after both Rise and the 2014 movies), and the scary possibility they might be human teens before mutation.

Sumac
09-02-2021, 04:20 PM
I don't have any expectations at this point.

Some artist new to the franchise will decide to "leave his mark" on the legendary series and turn them into another abomination a-la Hulk-tles or cartoony clowns from Rise.

IndigoErth
09-02-2021, 04:53 PM
They may say that quality really matters, but I no longer trust that they recognize what "quality" even is when it come to TMNT...

If a "first animation" (test?) is "hysterical" right off the bat that makes me super skeptical. I don't care if there is some humor, TMNT is probably always going to have it, but I really hate this trend in animation where the humor feels too forced, and if "hysterical" is where the small leaks of info start, it gives me forced-humor vibes already.

I'd be grateful to be proven wrong though.

AquaParade
09-03-2021, 10:55 AM
For me, there are no expectations. Which is fine.

My personal hope is that this movie excels at whatever it is trying to do, so if I decide to check it out, out of curiosity, it will entertain or even surprise me. I basically have the same expectations I'd have for a new Saturday morning cartoon, which is zilch. Except here, they'll at least have more budget to play with.

But as far as looking forward to it or putting any eggs in the basket? No. I'm actually pretty content with the fact that the comics appeal to me again. If a movie turns up that sounds promising, that's a bonus.

Slash-Dash
09-21-2021, 11:49 AM
Comments from the head of Nickelodeon.:



https://www.viacomcbs.com/news/content-and-experiences/brian-robbins-on-prioritizing-kids-family-content-across-platforms

"reinvention" interesting.

Andrew NDB
09-21-2021, 12:12 PM
"We're really excited about the slate we've built, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles reinvention that's being produced by Seth Rogen. I saw a first animation of the movie last week and it's going to be amazing. It's hysterical."

So yeah. Comedy, then, just like the live action one is poised to be.

https://tenor.com/view/im-out-of-here-whatever-bitches-good-bye-gif-16711002.gif

AquaParade
09-21-2021, 12:15 PM
Eh, I'd probably settle for a TMNT comedy if it's actually funny. Like, way funnier than a Saturday morning cartoon. Like...actually funny. I don't know if I'm getting that across.

I suppose that is possible. Is it ideal? Not at all. But I'd probably enjoy it, unlike another extremely neutered action movie with terrible humor that doesn't excel at anything.

Still, I'm not holding my breath for this one.

IndigoErth
09-21-2021, 01:56 PM
Like...actually funny.
Would be nice. I don't even trust the companies that handle franchises like this to even know how to make them funny anymore.

I'm not against some humor that is integrated into it where it feels natural and makes sense. Stuff that just feels normal between siblings and crap that is just within the nature of living on this planet and being infallible beings, but I despise the forced "Durhur, look how weird and funny we're being!" kind of stupid humor.

Andrew NDB
09-21-2021, 03:30 PM
* Is it relatively faithful to the origin of the Turtles?

* Does it have actual "ninja action," with the Turtles actually using their weapons in a serious manner trying to hurt their opponents, if not killing them?

* Are the Turtles social outcasts, not a part of man's civilization but rather looking at it from a distance?

* Does it get into the "circle of vengeance" with the Hamatos and the Orokus?




If the answer to all of those is "Yes," then I'm OK with them leaning a bit more into comedy than maybe I'd be otherwise comfortable with (though only if it doesn't come at a cost to the action). I'm just fairly sure almost all of those are going to be a "No" whether speaking about this project or the live action one.

Wildcat
09-21-2021, 11:35 PM
Having their traditional origin is still a mystery but I’m sure it’ll have Ninja action and fighting. Even Rise had it. Every version has that.

They probably will be outcasts. Especially if they’re humans first. Unless it’s about mutants being common place. Highly doubt that.

Splinter and Shredder will most likely be included but I could see a different villain/rivalry taking the focus like the 2007 movie.

They did not need to confirm having a comedy side. It’s Nick and Seth Rogen. It was just a brief comment though. Weren’t gonna get any solid info from this.

Sumac
09-22-2021, 12:43 AM
"Hysterical"

...My expectation of good stuff from TMNT brand are hysterical.

IndigoErth
09-22-2021, 03:43 PM
If Shredder is in it he's probably like their evil shop teacher now.

TigerClaw
09-22-2021, 04:12 PM
If Shredder is in it he's probably like their evil shop teacher now.
Speaking of Shredder, I wonder what direction they will take him for this movie, They could go 87 Shredder, 1990 Shredder, 2003 Shredder, or even 2012 Shredder.

Or all of the above.

AquaParade
09-22-2021, 04:29 PM
If Shredder is in it he's probably like their evil shop teacher now.

Ha! Perfect.

Andrew NDB
09-22-2021, 05:12 PM
If Shredder is in it he's probably like their evil shop teacher now.

Or worse -- a republican.

IndigoErth
09-22-2021, 05:15 PM
Hey, I had an evil shop teacher in middle school. No idea of his politics though, I mean, he was an old guy so... maybe. :trazz:

edit: Ah, Mr. Thermon (or some such spelling), just recalled his name. They used to call him the Thermonator behind his back. Only one time we ever saw him not in a sour mood was when he got a call that his grandchild was born.

shredder orokusaki
09-23-2021, 05:33 AM
Speaking of Shredder, I wonder what direction they will take him for this movie, They could go 87 Shredder, 1990 Shredder, 2003 Shredder, or even 2012 Shredder.

Or all of the above.

In the 2014 and 2016 movies i was like in 2012 so now i will be like 2003 .

Jephael
09-23-2021, 11:58 AM
* Is it relatively faithful to the origin of the Turtles?

* Does it have actual "ninja action," with the Turtles actually using their weapons in a serious manner trying to hurt their opponents, if not killing them?

* Are the Turtles social outcasts, not a part of man's civilization but rather looking at it from a distance?

* Does it get into the "circle of vengeance" with the Hamatos and the Orokus?

If the answer to all of those is "Yes," then I'm OK with them leaning a bit more into comedy than maybe I'd be otherwise comfortable with (though only if it doesn't come at a cost to the action). I'm just fairly sure almost all of those are going to be a "No" whether speaking about this project or the live action one.

I definitely agree with you on those first three, but the "circle of vengeance" thing is usually what gets altered the most and it usually becomes simplified to "Splinter and Ninja Turtles versus Shredder and the Foot Clan"; I mean lets be honest with ourselves. We have never once seen Oroku Nagi be used in any adaptation outside the original comic book and in both the 1990 movie and 2012 cartoon it was Saki/Shredder himself who was in love with Teng Shen, while in the 2003 cartoon it was Hamato Yoshi's friend Mashimi who became his rival for Shen's love. Just out of curiousity, how important to you is it that the backstory with those characters plays out exactly how Eastman and Laird wrote it back in 1984?

Andrew NDB
09-23-2021, 12:15 PM
I definitely agree with you on those first three, but the "circle of vengeance" thing is usually what gets altered the most and it usually becomes simplified to "Splinter and Ninja Turtles versus Shredder and the Foot Clan"

In other words, it becomes rubbish. I don't like it to become rubbish.

I mean lets be honest with ourselves. We have never once seen Oroku Nagi be used in any adaptation outside the original comic book and in both the 1990 movie and 2012 cartoon it was Saki/Shredder himself who was in love with Teng Shen, while in the 2003 cartoon it was Hamato Yoshi's friend Mashimi who became his rival for Shen's love.

You can write out Nagi and kind of merge him into Saki, that's not super crucial. Though it does make Saki less sympathetic. Which is fine, if your bag is cardboard villains. Which, given that so many fans seem to love Bebop and Rocksteady and all of that, is apparently a lot of the fans out there.

Just out of curiousity, how important to you is it that the backstory with those characters plays out exactly how Eastman and Laird wrote it back in 1984?

Exactly? Zero. But the general bullet points should be there. Like how 2014 forgot to even include a reason how Splinter and Shredder would (or could) even know each other, let alone be out for revenge. Whoops!

sdp
09-23-2021, 06:30 PM
I called this movie being trash since the announcement, there were plenty of red flags even back then.

Jephael
09-24-2021, 10:46 AM
if your bag is cardboard villains. Which, given that so many fans seem to love Bebop and Rocksteady and all of that, is apparently a lot of the fans out there.

After the ending they were given in the 2012 series I'm willing to bet we'll see them become anti-heroes similar to what DC has been doing with Harley Quinn as of late.

Lord Nightwalker
09-24-2021, 09:11 PM
* Is it relatively faithful to the origin of the Turtles?

* Does it have actual "ninja action," with the Turtles actually using their weapons in a serious manner trying to hurt their opponents, if not killing them?

* Are the Turtles social outcasts, not a part of man's civilization but rather looking at it from a distance?

* Does it get into the "circle of vengeance" with the Hamatos and the Orokus?




If the answer to all of those is "Yes," then I'm OK with them leaning a bit more into comedy than maybe I'd be otherwise comfortable with (though only if it doesn't come at a cost to the action). I'm just fairly sure almost all of those are going to be a "No" whether speaking about this project or the live action one.

I agree with this. All of this. We've seen what happens when they go for comedy. It's not funny.

Leo656
09-25-2021, 04:15 PM
* Is it relatively faithful to the origin of the Turtles?

* Does it have actual "ninja action," with the Turtles actually using their weapons in a serious manner trying to hurt their opponents, if not killing them?

* Are the Turtles social outcasts, not a part of man's civilization but rather looking at it from a distance?

* Does it get into the "circle of vengeance" with the Hamatos and the Orokus?




If the answer to all of those is "Yes," then I'm OK with them leaning a bit more into comedy than maybe I'd be otherwise comfortable with (though only if it doesn't come at a cost to the action). I'm just fairly sure almost all of those are going to be a "No" whether speaking about this project or the live action one.

The origin being anywhere near faithful is probably 50/50 - I think going forward, each new iteration will have its own brand new origin to go with it; we've officially reached the point with this brand where nothing is sacrosanct and every bit of it is up for being "reinvented".

The other stuff, though, I have a strong feeling we will never see fully explored in a TMNT movie again, either animated or live action. It's a toy commercial for little kids and that's all it ever will be; anything too "heavy" or "deep", they're not gonna touch. It seems like the plan is to make each new version more "safe" and have a broad mainstream appeal.

I mean, look who owns it. End of story.

Lord Nightwalker
09-25-2021, 04:39 PM
Or worse -- a republican.

Or even worse, ANY career politician.
There's a reason I hate politics.

TigerClaw
09-25-2021, 05:32 PM
With the casting for the Super Mario Animated movie that happened this week, I hope the casting for the TMNT CGI movie is just as insane.

AquaParade
09-25-2021, 05:34 PM
One of them will be an up and coming musician, dipping into the acting world. Random speculation. Say, MGK as Raphael. I’ll give you stupid.

Galactus
09-25-2021, 07:09 PM
With the casting for the Super Mario Animated movie that happened this week, I hope the casting for the TMNT CGI movie is just as insane.

Is it really insane though?

Granted my head canon will always be that Mario is a scrappy Italian-American from Brooklyn. I've gotten used to the stereotypically Italian version but I've never been married to it so I'm more open than most to change in this regard but did people really think we were going to get a Charles Martinet inspired Mario in a full length movie? Chris Pratt would not be my ideal choice but I'm glad we're not getting over an hour or "woo hoos" and "mamma mia".

As for TMNT I'm sure they will try celebrity stunt castings as well as trying to work out which TMNT characters could be this franchises answer to the Minions and just how much should Donatello act like Sheldon Cooper.

TigerClaw
09-25-2021, 07:26 PM
Is it really insane though?

Granted my head canon will always be that Mario is a scrappy Italian-American from Brooklyn. I've gotten used to the stereotypically Italian version but I've never been married to it so I'm more open than most to change in this regard but did people really think we were going to get a Charles Martinet inspired Mario in a full length movie? Chris Pratt would not be my ideal choice but I'm glad we're not getting over an hour or "woo hoos" and "mamma mia".

As for TMNT I'm sure they will try celebrity stunt castings as well as trying to work out which TMNT characters could be this franchises answer to the Minions and just how much should Donatello act like Sheldon Cooper.
I love the casting though, Since they are heading to a more comedic direction, So hopefully they get a good voice cast for this movie too.

There will obviously be some big names for this one, and I'm sure Seth Rogen will voice a character on it.

Jephael
09-25-2021, 09:53 PM
I agree with this. All of this. We've seen what happens when they go for comedy. It's not funny.

It can work if done right, but there needs to be a balance between light-hearted and serious. Having Michelangelo constantly crack jokes in the 2003 series got old fast, as did him being a complete space-cadet in the 2012 series.

I think going forward, each new iteration will have its own brand new origin to go with it.

Well I hate to say it, but pretty much every adaptation since 1987 has pretty much done this already. It's all about trying to come up with a compelling variation of the story, while paying respect to what came before.

Leo656
09-25-2021, 10:06 PM
No, I don't mean small, incremental changes such as leaving Oroku Nagi out of it, or tweaking April's career. I mean they're gonna start going completely off the reservation and doing whatever they think is cute at any given moment. Because "Why Not".

We'll definitely be getting a version where they were aliens and not mutants (or maybe they'll be "Alien Mutants" but still extra-terrestrial). And another where they were human kids who turned into turtles and not turtles who became humanoid. And so on and so forth. Put money on it.

We've had a couple of failed reboots in a row; this is the point where the brand managers decide "The 'traditional' way of doing things with this property no longer works; therefore, we have to start changing anything and everything until we find something that sticks."

TMNT "traditionalists" and "purists", all may as well abandon ship. In the very near future, the only TMNT properties which will exist in the present-day sense will bear little to no resemblance to the TMNT you/I/we grew up with. Although they'll all probably resemble FW with regard to very obvious and one-dimensional "humor" that ages poorly, because for some reason that was the only thing anyone ever took away from this franchise; the bad jokes. THAT stuck as being "the bedrock" of the brand, everything else is up for grabs, go figure.

"Rise" failed specifically because they already took way too many liberties and changed way too much, to the point where MOST fans of TMNT said "Nah, this isn't TMNT, or at least not the type I want to see", but if nothing else you can always expect the people who work on these types of projects to take the exact wrong message from a show or movie's failure. In their eyes, they most likely think it failed because they didn't change ENOUGH, and that it was TOO similar to what we previously had (despite already being pretty much "TMNT In Name Only" already).

So if the only thing a person cares about is, "It's called TMNT and therefore the brand continues on", future projects will likely still hold something for them. Some people legit do not care what the product is, so long as it says "TMNT" on the label. I don't personally understand that, because I liked very specific things about the characters and the brand and all of those things are now gone, ergo so am I. BUT, some people only care that there are indeed turtles who occasionally do ninja-like things a little bit, and everything else can be altered at will.

But regardless, that's the way the wind is blowing. "Total reinvention". Wait and see.

As to whether those reinvented versions will "Pay respect to what has come before"... by definition, the very idea of "total reinvention" cancels out that possibility. A reinvention suggests, or sometimes even outright states, "My New Ideas are way better than your crappy Old Ideas." Whether true or not, that smacks of disrespect. A reinvention cannot by definition pay respect to what came before because it assumes - rightly or wrongly - that it's doing something Right that the previous one did Wrong.

Which is incredibly presumptuous, and usually turns out to be wrong in the long run. Which is why most "reinventions" ultimately fail.

The only time a "total reinvention" actually works out, is when the thing being reinvented is something that started out so bad that anything would be a major improvement. A case in point would be the original MLP compared to "Friendship is Magic"; FiM might not have been AS big of a deal if the original version (and all the ones after it) weren't total crap.

When your source material is already really good or really popular, though, more often than not your "reinvention" fails. In TMNT's case, whether your bag is Mirage or whether it's FW, either of those things would be hard to top. And they won't be. New versions will be very different, but not "better".

Jephael
09-25-2021, 11:23 PM
As to whether those reinvented versions will "Pay respect to what has come before"... by definition, the very idea of "total reinvention" cancels out that possibility. A reinvention suggests, or sometimes even outright states, "My New Ideas are way better than your crappy Old Ideas." Whether true or not, that smacks of disrespect. A reinvention cannot by definition pay respect to what came before because it assumes - rightly or wrongly - that it's doing something Right that the previous one did Wrong.

To me there is no right or wrong way to depict any fictional character, because everybody has there own view on them. Take Peter Pan for example, Remember the 90's cartoon that aired on Fox? It was way different than the Disney movie for obvious reasons and there have been other animated adaptations since with varying degrees of staying close to the original novel. As far as I know, the only time people were in an uproar over a remake was when they white-washed Tiger Lily.

Leo656
09-25-2021, 11:44 PM
Nobody's ever paid any attention to non-Disney Peter Pan material besides "Hook", is why. :lol: And frankly, nobody ever will. That property is very rapidly becoming the champion of "Most Reboots and Reinventions That Not One Person on Planet Earth Ever Asked For, Watched, Remembered, Or Cared About At All." A great example of companies having the "It made a lot of money Exactly One Time, so surely we can squeeze a little more milk from the tit! We have Modern Technology now! So surely, our version of this property will be better, and make even MORE money!" And then they do it for the 80th time and for the 80th time nobody cares. Go figure.

There are definitely Right and Wrong ways to interpret and present ANY fictional franchise or character, but it's not a One Size Fits All thing and there's a certain intangible in knowing what's Right and what's Wrong. It takes a certain kind of intuition to where you just plain know it when you see it; "Oh, yeah, THAT is dead wrong." And they're things that shouldn't need to even be explained as to WHY they are bad, but rather, it should just be implicitly understood.

I mean, if you need it EXPLAINED to you why Electric-Powers Superman With Blue Ice Skating Suit in the late-90s was awful and never even should've been pitched let alone attempted, you shouldn't be handling Superman. If you need it EXPLAINED to you why Every Single Thing about "The Last Jedi" was godawful, you shouldn't be handling Star Wars. And likewise, if you need it EXPLAINED to you why Shredder being a white guy named Eric Sacks is terrible, or why the Turtles being aliens is terrible, or why them being human kids who turn into mutant turtles is terrible... you shouldn't be handling TMNT, period.

There are definitely, positively, absolutely Rights and Wrongs. For ANY thing. "It's all fake anyway" doesn't wash. But it's not something one can teach and it differs from brand to brand, so it becomes very complicated. The fact that the exact wrong people get brought in to make the Big Decisions on this kind of stuff definitely doesn't help things one bit.

Like, you CAN reinvent the Frankenstein mythos so that he ends up working for some Top Secret government program and then he gets sent to Jupiter to fight space monsters. Or something. You CAN do that. But you shouldn't. Not every single dumb idea anyone ever farted out of their brain hole deserves a budget and a release date just because they had the idea.

Or, as Carlin once so eloquently said (while speaking to an altogether different topic), "Not every ejaculation needs a name."

Diorm
10-14-2021, 06:59 PM
The title of the movie might be: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles- The Next Chapter. For 2023.

oldmanwinters
10-14-2021, 08:15 PM
FroThe title of the movie might be: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles- The Next Chapter. For 2023.

Looks like VarnerStudios will have involvement, likely in the toy sculpting.

Posted on their Instagram story this evening:
http://i.imgur.com/fAeKJRZl.jpg (https://imgur.com/fAeKJRZ)

TigerClaw
10-14-2021, 08:25 PM
Looks like VarnerStudios will have involvement, likely in the toy sculpting.

Posted on their Instagram story this evening:
http://i.imgur.com/fAeKJRZl.jpg (https://imgur.com/fAeKJRZ)
The title was reviewed on an article from Variety that was posted today.
https://variety.com/lists/varietys-10-animators-to-watch-in-2021/joaquin-cocina-and-cristobal-leon/

Here's what it says about it.
“Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Next Chapter”

Growing up watching “Star Trek” fostered a love of sci-fi in Dallas native Kassai. But although he was a fan, it wasn’t until his sophomore year in college that he realized he could have a career in animation.

He moved to Los Angeles nine years ago to pursue his dream. “I couldn’t be one of those people without a job. I was too afraid,” he says. “So I locked that in from a distance first and then came here with some sense of security in mind at least.”

After a stint at Sony, where he worked on “The Emoji Movie,” among others, Kassai segued to Nickelodeon, where is now production designer on “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Next Chapter.” The film is scheduled to come out in 2023.

“I have loved that franchise since I was a kid,” he says, confessing that Raphael is his fave. “I have bedsheets and lunch boxes and T-shirts and socks. But now I am trying to re-create a unique interpretation that is not too distant from the original franchise that we all know and are familiar with, and also make it fresh.”

To make it new while not jettisoning what made “Ninja Turtles” so beloved, Kassai says, “you anchor yourself enough in the familiar elements of it so that it is easily recognizable but then you either add or enhance some of the existing charm of
the franchise.”

With modern animation tools and 3D, he feels a responsibility to make something cool for the new movie similar to “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse” and “The Mitchells vs. the Machines.”

“The franchise deserves that, I think.” — Shalini Dore
Seems like it will borrow from the original series since he's a production designer for it.

italianice388
10-14-2021, 09:34 PM
Nobody's ever paid any attention to non-Disney Peter Pan material besides "Hook", is why. :lol: And frankly, nobody ever will. That property is very rapidly becoming the champion of "Most Reboots and Reinventions That Not One Person on Planet Earth Ever Asked For, Watched, Remembered, Or Cared About At All." A great example of companies having the "It made a lot of money Exactly One Time, so surely we can squeeze a little more milk from the tit! We have Modern Technology now! So surely, our version of this property will be better, and make even MORE money!" And then they do it for the 80th time and for the 80th time nobody cares. Go figure.

There are definitely Right and Wrong ways to interpret and present ANY fictional franchise or character, but it's not a One Size Fits All thing and there's a certain intangible in knowing what's Right and what's Wrong. It takes a certain kind of intuition to where you just plain know it when you see it; "Oh, yeah, THAT is dead wrong." And they're things that shouldn't need to even be explained as to WHY they are bad, but rather, it should just be implicitly understood.

I mean, if you need it EXPLAINED to you why Electric-Powers Superman With Blue Ice Skating Suit in the late-90s was awful and never even should've been pitched let alone attempted, you shouldn't be handling Superman. If you need it EXPLAINED to you why Every Single Thing about "The Last Jedi" was godawful, you shouldn't be handling Star Wars. And likewise, if you need it EXPLAINED to you why Shredder being a white guy named Eric Sacks is terrible, or why the Turtles being aliens is terrible, or why them being human kids who turn into mutant turtles is terrible... you shouldn't be handling TMNT, period.

There are definitely, positively, absolutely Rights and Wrongs. For ANY thing. "It's all fake anyway" doesn't wash. But it's not something one can teach and it differs from brand to brand, so it becomes very complicated. The fact that the exact wrong people get brought in to make the Big Decisions on this kind of stuff definitely doesn't help things one bit.

Like, you CAN reinvent the Frankenstein mythos so that he ends up working for some Top Secret government program and then he gets sent to Jupiter to fight space monsters. Or something. You CAN do that. But you shouldn't. Not every single dumb idea anyone ever farted out of their brain hole deserves a budget and a release date just because they had the idea.

Or, as Carlin once so eloquently said (while speaking to an altogether different topic), "Not every ejaculation needs a name."

Agreed about all of this. "It's just fiction, relax" is ********. Look at Mickey Mouse, the strongest brand in American media, and tell me just how much he's changed over time. Let me answer that. 0%.

oldmanwinters
10-14-2021, 10:25 PM
Look at Mickey Mouse, the strongest brand in American media, and tell me just how much he's changed over time. Let me answer that. 0%.

I beg to differ!
https://retroist.com/mickey-mouse-suicide/

frank_one
10-15-2021, 04:30 AM
"Next chapter" can only mean this is a sequel to the original series.

Wildcat
10-15-2021, 04:51 AM
The logo is nice. Font looks like ooze if that means anything. Next Chapter implies a different period of their life. Maybe it’s not the usual Turtles vs Shredder story. Although neither was the 2007 movie.

I know it’s very early but it does not sound dumbed-down or just for laughs. It’s not going to be the “Adult” version some want but will probably be a legitimate cartoon everyone can enjoy.

Edit: I thought about it being a continuation of the FW cartoon right before I posted. It definitely sounds like the “first chapter” has already happened. If it was it’s own thing how can it be Next?

It’s just speculation for now but you don’t really name a completely new movie Next Chapter.

AquaParade
10-15-2021, 07:22 AM
"Next chapter" can only mean this is a sequel to the original series.

You'd think, but they could also just be out of names to use. I could see this being more of a meta-title, such as "Homecoming" was for Spider-Man. Sure, there was a "homecoming dance" in Spider-Man: Homecoming, but the more significant aspect was that Spider-Man was back with Marvel.

Could be a similar case here.

Sumac
10-15-2021, 07:32 AM
I know it’s very early but it does not sound dumbed-down or just for laughs. It’s not going to be the “Adult” version some want but will probably be a legitimate cartoon everyone can enjoy.
Neither was Next Mutation, but...

Vicky82
10-15-2021, 10:25 AM
So this was for this movie then.

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=63380&highlight=chapter

I wonder if this movie could be the start of a new series.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2021, 10:26 AM
One of them will be an up and coming musician, dipping into the acting world. Random speculation. Say, MGK as Raphael. I’ll give you stupid.

MGK is up and coming? He's been up and coming for like 12 years now. If he hasn't made it yet he isn't going to.

"Next chapter" can only mean this is a sequel to the original series.

That's definitely the implication. They might keep things a little nebulous, but it wouldn't surprise me one bit if it turns out this is a "some years later" take on the Fred Wolf series.

AquaParade
10-15-2021, 10:28 AM
MGK is up and coming? He's been up and coming for like 12 years now. If he hasn't made it yet he isn't going to.

Fair point.
It feels like he is still being pushed really hard though. Maybe I'm out of touch with a scene I want nothing to do with anyways.

With my expectations out the window, I am sort of interested to see more from this, I have to admit. Again, I know it won't be how I would want the turtles handled, by any means, but that doesn't mean there won't be something there I can enjoy.

newfan
10-15-2021, 10:39 AM
That's definitely the implication. They might keep things a little nebulous, but it wouldn't surprise me one bit if it turns out this is a "some years later" take on the Fred Wolf series.

Also the image gives me an OT vibe. Is it a stretch to wonder if the Brawl game having the OT TMNT is a coincidence? Movie isn't coming out for a while though and the OT are very known to maybe nothing to do with it.

AquaParade
10-15-2021, 10:54 AM
That's definitely the implication. They might keep things a little nebulous, but it wouldn't surprise me one bit if it turns out this is a "some years later" take on the Fred Wolf series.

One point against this would be Seth Rogen's implication that they want to focus on the "teenage" aspect. You can only shoot ahead so many years and retain that.

IndigoErth
10-15-2021, 05:17 PM
But now I am trying to re-create a unique interpretation that is not too distant from the original franchise that we all know and are familiar with, and also make it fresh.”

To make it new while not jettisoning what made “Ninja Turtles” so beloved, Kassai says, “you anchor yourself enough in the familiar elements of it so that it is easily recognizable but then you either add or enhance some of the existing charm of the franchise.”
Yeah, that's what they all say. What seems to be harder is not being blinded by too many new ideas (esp ones that should be scrapped) and recognizing how to balance that and not go too far with it. :tconfuse:

I'm fine if various versions what to bring an addition that might be worth keeping around, but people anymore try to be too grand and ambitious with changing things rather than just adding something good. Stop trying to eff up the Turtles.


Sorry, but that "logo" is atrocious, hope it isn't official. The "Turtles" part is, eh, okay, but paired with the two others just hurts to look at. Three fonts may be the acceptable limit, but those three crammed together... no... no no. Hope it's just what someone tried to throw together for fun. Someone who never had a class that went over font use.

Andrew NDB
10-15-2021, 05:52 PM
One point against this would be Seth Rogen's implication that they want to focus on the "teenage" aspect. You can only shoot ahead so many years and retain that.

Jumping from 15 to, say, 19 would be a big enough jump. Especially since he (stupidly) seems to be likening them to normal human teenagers.

TigerClaw
10-15-2021, 06:09 PM
We all don't really know what the Next Chapter really means, It could just mean another chapter in a saga that started in 1987 and continues on in present day, But doing a direct sequel to the 1987 turtles would have all the Turtles be adults by this time, and this movie will clearly focus on the teenage aspect of them.

if anything, It could just be a title that doesn't have any meaning, But as a way of saying this is a new TMNT based on the 87 series, But with a modern twist. The original series had the 80s aesthetic, and this movie could apply a modern day twist to the whole thing, Lots of things will still be recognizable in the designs, But made to look as if they are current times.

LeotheLateBloomer
10-15-2021, 10:20 PM
We all don't really know what the Next Chapter really means, It could just mean another chapter in a saga that started in 1987 and continues on in present day, But doing a direct sequel to the 1987 turtles would have all the Turtles be adults by this time, and this movie will clearly focus on the teenage aspect of them.

if anything, It could just be a title that doesn't have any meaning, But as a way of saying this is a new TMNT based on the 87 series, But with a modern twist. The original series had the 80s aesthetic, and this movie could apply a modern day twist to the whole thing, Lots of things will still be recognizable in the designs, But made to look as if they are current times.

No one wants an adult version of the 87 series. A new version where they're adults maybe.

ZariusTwo
10-16-2021, 02:58 AM
No one wants an adult version of the 87 series

Speak for yourself.

LeotheLateBloomer
10-16-2021, 03:08 AM
Speak for yourself.

Of course you do.:tlol: Well I guess technically Archie is close to that.

ZariusTwo
10-16-2021, 04:37 AM
Mirkos animation are presently hiring

https://www.mikrosanimation.com/en/projects/

TigerClaw
10-16-2021, 03:17 PM
This animated movie will be inspired by the original series, In the article Spider-Man: Into the Spiderverse is one of the animated movies that might be inspired from it, So I could see the animation having that comic book style, They can do the 87 TMNT in that sort of comic book style, It would a lot of vibrant colors like the original series had.

Galactus
10-16-2021, 04:33 PM
Would I rather a spiritual follow up to the '87 animated series over the the direction they seemed to be going in were the title characters were mutated humans and in high school? Yes.

Do I want a spiritual follow up to the '87 animated series? No.

I could live with it if there was some guarantee that the live action feature was a more original Mirage comic inspired movie. That way both sides of the fandom are satisfied but frankly I have my doubts a live action movie will come to fruition in the near future and if it does it wont be some lowest common denominator bullsh*t.

Also while I shouldn't be surprised that all at the top cannot let go of their heroine-like addiction to the Fred Wolf show it's strange that they haven't learned from the failure of the last movie which was basically the 80s cartoon in live action that it's not the route to go down. A cgi animated movie is going to be primarily aimed at children and we've seen more than once that trying to hook them in recreating a version of the property from over four decades ago is not hooking them in.

TigerClaw
10-16-2021, 04:37 PM
Would I rather a spiritual follow up to the '87 animated series over the the direction they seemed to be going in were the title characters were mutated humans and in high school? Yes.

Would do I want a spiritual follow up to the '87 animated series? No.

I could live with it if there was some guarantee that the live action feature was a more original Mirage comic inspired movie. That way both sides of the fandom are satisfied but frankly I have my doubts a live action movie will come to fruition in the near future and if it does it wont be some lowest common denominator bullsh*t.

Also while I shouldn't be surprised that all at the top cannot let go of their heroine-like addiction to the Fred Wolf show it's strange that they haven't learned from the failure of the last movie which was basically the 80s cartoon in live action that it's not the route to go down. A cgi animated movie is going to be primarily aimed at children and we've seen more than once that trying to hook them in recreating a version of the property from over four decades ago is not hooking them in.
What if the story involved the Turtles being turned into humans for a little while, There was this animated short that had the turtles turning into humans and being in High School with April.

VGACrpNOjtk

Galactus
10-16-2021, 05:18 PM
What if the story involved the Turtles being turned into humans for a little while, There was this animated short that had the turtles turning into humans and being in High School with April.

No thanks.

If this is some spiritual successor to the Fred Wolf show they already did the whole what if the turtles were humans (or at least one of them) and it was one of the most unpopular episodes of the entire 80s series.

We know they skimmed through episodes of the old show for inspiration for Out Of The Shadows and I wouldn't be surprised if that episode was the source of the sub plot of the turtles potentially becoming human. If I'm correct the fact they picked one of the least popular episodes of the show to draw from shows they didn't really get the franchise. That being said ss much as I railed against the inclusion of that particular plot line when I first saw it in the trailer I actually think it was handled fairly well. It had slight shades of X-Men: Class' in its treatment of a similar concept and was one of the better parts of what was an otherwise a terrible movie. The reason why it 'worked' though is because they didn't pull the trigger on turning the turtles human. Not to send one or more of the turtles on a journey to learn they were better as mutants, not as a joke to show the real life human actors.

It's a hokey idea but I'm sure a skilled writer could make the concept work but shouldn't a movie focus on characters and concepts that have reliably worked across the franchise rather than experiment or trying to make previously failed concepts work.

Leo656
10-16-2021, 07:04 PM
Speak for yourself.

Seriously, though? I mean, just to be fair, you're still annoyed about the LAST time someone did a "continuation" of a beloved 80s cartoon show, made by people who never actually watched the original. :trazz: I don't see one bit how This could possibly be any more satisfying than That was.

After all these 80s restarts that don't quite hit the mark (with some folks, anyway), I think it can now safely be said that if a person wasn't 4-8 years old during those shows' peak years, then that person simply does not "get it", and in turn any attempts to recapture "It" are doomed to be Flanderization at best. And nobody making any of the Big Decisions was 6 years old in 1988. We've seen countless times by now that it's impossible to "recapture the magic" by skimming Wikipedia and watching a few episodes off of a "Best Of" compilation, and then trying to build a new project off of that. And that's why it's best to "leave the memories alone", as it were.
-------------------------

I'm with Galactus in thinking that the last live-action movie should have conclusively proven once and for all that FW TMNT isn't the "magic bullet" to reignite some kind of widespread mainstream passion for the franchise. What puts me into an even more minority opinion position, though, is that I remain quite convinced that there IS no "magic bullet" and that TMNT is officially stumbling clumsily through the final days of its pop culture relevance, never to regain even a shade of its former glory. I mean, when your "big idea" is to just try the LAST failed idea over again and hope everyone's forgotten about it by then, you're officially out of ideas.

I kinda wonder what's more likely at this point: That the powers-that be get SO desperate that they actually try and "revisit" the 1990 movie's aesthetic... or that they just retire the brand outright because not enough people care about it. Of those two options, I sincerely think the latter is the more likely option. Too bad. It's like they all forgot what a big deal it was the ONE time they tried to present TMNT to the mainstream in a way where it WASN'T just fluff and pablum. I mean, they immediately forgot back then, too, since they immediately abandoned that aesthetic forever starting with the sequel... but by now that's like the one thing they HAVEN'T tried.

I can't help but wonder what it is about this franchise that makes the people trying to adapt it for film think - in spite of all evidence - that going goofier, skewing younger, and all that is the best way forward in spite of all evidence to the contrary. One would think that if "Let's make it a little bit goofier each time" hasn't worked, at some point they'd take a swing and say "Let's try to make a more serious version this time" just for the sake of a different approach. I mean, if the definition of "insanity" is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result... eh, I'unno.

Wildcat
10-17-2021, 12:52 AM
I never really thought of Oots as a FW adaptation. It felt more like they just borrowed stuff because they’re popular.

Krang is barely seen and the Technodrome is stopped before it’s rebuilt. Even the turtle van/truck was barely shown in either one. It’s not even a factor. The FW elements were treated so poorly.

Plus people were already put off by the first.

If Next Chapter is in continuity with the FW cartoon I’m sure it’ll do a much better job since that would be the point of them making it instead of just introducing elements in a sequel.

Honestly, seeing the logo has gotten me excited. FW or not.

ZariusTwo
10-17-2021, 03:57 AM
Seriously, though? I mean, just to be fair, you're still annoyed about the LAST time someone did a "continuation" of a beloved 80s cartoon show

More annoyed at how the fans of said continuation treat fans who are not. I would not mind it too much if it were any other type of show either:P

I never really thought of Oots as a FW adaptation. It felt more like they just borrowed stuff because they’re popular.

Krang is barely seen and the Technodrome is stopped before it’s rebuilt. Even the turtle van/truck was barely shown in either one. It’s not even a factor. The FW elements were treated so poorly.

This exactly. I mean, I still think OOTS was a fun time, but they were trying to cram a whole season's worth of world building and arcs into a short amount of screen time, and not taking the team to think things through. It was also a course-correction from a franchise that already lacked the courage of it's own convictions in it's first entry.

If the 2K12 Nick show could learn from Turtles Forever with it's crossovers, then the films can learn from the mistakes of OTTS.

Wildcat
10-17-2021, 06:01 AM
I agree. Too much course correction from the beginning was really the main problem imo.

I know other movies go through changes during the course of being made. I can accept a lot of things but it’s very apparent in the 2 Bay movies. I guess it was less in Oots but they were just trying to make up for the first one.

I’ll always believe they should have stuck with whatever they wanted to do and how it turned out was just that. Would have been more interesting at least.

Sumac
10-17-2021, 05:24 PM
Also while I shouldn't be surprised that all at the top cannot let go of their heroine-like addiction to the Fred Wolf show it's strange that they haven't learned from the failure of the last movie which was basically the 80s cartoon in live action that it's not the route to go down.
Because, that is the only time when TMNT was super successful?
Look at most reboots / remakes in the recent years - the common thing is that all of them tried to replicate most successful period in the history of the franchise, because, they didn't know what else could they do.

OOTS felt like FW adaptation to me, but it was beholden by mediocrity of the previous movie, as well, as horrible design of the Turtles and general inconsistences with a tone.

Leo656
10-17-2021, 06:57 PM
The problem with relying on FW as the benchmark is that it WAS super-successful... with kids. Kids in 1988. That has practically NO relevance to what would be successful NOW. People who are 6-10 years old in 2021 give less than zero f*cks what their parents liked when they were their age. And there simply aren't enough 40-year olds with a strong nostalgic passion for FW TMNT to pack a theater anymore.

So the Powers-That-Be are stuck in a situation where they're trying to serve two masters with every attempted reboot - the 40-year olds who still care about FW TMNT, and their offspring they may be trying to "nurture" into caring about TMNT. Except that neither of those groups of people is especially large. Especially the kids' market, which is more fickle with shorter attention spans than ever. The little kids who were all-in on the Nick TMNT cartoon, for example, generally don't care about it anymore, they've moved on to other things. They can't even be bothered to be nostalgic for "a little while ago", let alone for a period that was decades before they were born. And this is anecdotal, but most kids I know who were exposed to the FW cartoon thought it was godawful, even if they liked some of the later cartoons. That's just generally how these things work, anyway.

The immediate problem becomes, as we've all heard countless times, "you can't serve two masters" to begin with. You have to decide who you're trying to please and commit to that. But they've been very hesitant to do that, thus far, and every time one of the people up top speaks, they go back and forth about who they're really aiming for with This or That reboot. They're either trying to "grow the audience by attracting new kids" or "giving the old-school fans what they want", depending on the day. And frankly, you can't do both at the same time. It generally doesn't work. It's worked very, very, very rarely, like the more recent MLP reboots, but even then, that's only because the originals were so bad that the franchise had nowhere to go but up. So you really can't compare something like that to something like TMNT which actually had a ton of success and popularity way back when.

Part of the reason why I lean towards the 1990 movie so much as an example of what they ought to try and lean into, is because that's the only example where TMNT ever achieved any sort of TRUE mainstream success, not just with young children. To this day, whenever I show that movie to someone who never saw it, or who thought TMNT was nothing but "stupid kids' stuff", it never fails to mesmerize them. "Holy sh*t, that's actually a 'real' movie!" It was the same back in 1990, when millions of grown-ups who only tolerated the FW cartoon show because their kids were obsessed with it, were legitimately captivated by the live-action film. Otherwise there's no way it would have become the most successful independent movie ever made, nor kept that title for years upon years. If the movie had been like the show was - something parents smiled through gritted teeth at just because their kids were so in love with it - then it absolutely would not have done so well. As evidence of that, we have the sequels, which were loved by children but had MUCH less cross-over appeal with adults and non-fans.

To my way of thinking, that means the 1990 film was the franchise's true peak, because it proved conclusively that TMNT did not need to just be goofy stuff aimed at 6-year olds, that if handled well it could also enrapture their parents, or even win over non-fans. Simply put, NO other iteration of TMNT has ever managed to do that. And thus, if they're sincerely trying to make a movie that both kids and adults in 2021 will enjoy, then their best bet should probably be to go back to the ONLY time that they ever managed to pull that trick successfully. Trying to stick to the blueprint of a cartoon show that was a huge hit with people who were 8 over 30 years ago is questionable if you're sincerely trying to reach a large number of people. Put simply, there's no proof it can even be done.

But they did manage to please "everybody", exactly One Time, and they made a lot of money with it. One would think that, in a situation where all other attempts have failed, they'd look at what went right that One Time and study THAT blueprint instead.

Of course, that would require that the franchise be handled by people with concerns beyond selling action figures. So they're more likely going to just keep fumbling along and wondering why nothing they try actually works.

Chris
10-17-2021, 07:07 PM
The logo and the title certainly make me feel like this will be some form of soft reboot OT follow up. So MOTU Revelation but a CG movie instead of 2D series and aimed more at kids than the adults who grew up with the show (which would seem counter intuitive for an OT follow up but we're all used to this type of studio logic by now).

Honestly it would be far from the worst thing they have tried with the franchise. I'd place the idea of an animated OT sequel over the ideas behind both the 2014 reboot and Rise.

Personally if I was doing an OT follow up (loose continuity or not) I'd go the MOTU Revelation root and do a series aimed more at adults who grew up with the show. I guess the logic here would be that the OT was the biggest era for TMNT so an update of that aimed at kids might be the best way to get a new audience whilst parents are brought in by making it a "sequel" to what they grew up with. Must admit it would have me far more interested than another 2014 or Rise style reboot would have if this does turn out to be the case.

Leo656
10-17-2021, 10:51 PM
Personally if I was doing an OT follow up (loose continuity or not) I'd go the MOTU Revelation root and do a series aimed more at adults who grew up with the show. I guess the logic here would be that the OT was the biggest era for TMNT so an update of that aimed at kids might be the best way to get a new audience whilst parents are brought in by making it a "sequel" to what they grew up with. Must admit it would have me far more interested than another 2014 or Rise style reboot would have if this does turn out to be the case.

Yeah, but as MOTU Revelation proved, you do that and then you get people screaming about how it's "terrible" because it's not as light, fluffy and one-dimensional as the original show was.

But as I've oft-argued in defense of Revelation, if you DO try and do a show/movie/etc. that's 1:1 with the original, you'd get the ten to twenty people who remain in romantic love with that older version without irony to love it, and everyone else would think it was the dumbest thing ever that nobody thought to aim higher 30+ years later.

Sometimes, you really just can't win. Try and raise the stakes a bit, you get chastised for "ruining the innocence" of the original. Stick 1:1 with the original aesthetic, you get chastised for being out of touch and not having any new ideas.

To be blunt, this is why inevitably, companies just give up trying to reboot things altogether and stick them on a shelf. Popeye, Flash Gordon, The Shadow... all once super-popular, probably more popular in their day than TMNT ever was, accounting for different eras and standards of success... all now completely irrelevant because after any number of failed reboots, their handlers just decided it was too hard trying to force-feed them to an audience which no longer cared.

TMNT is going to be on the shelf right next to them much sooner rather than later. Kinda sad, but it's the natural order of things. Watching them flounder aimlessly in the meantime is pretty painful to watch.

Wildcat
10-18-2021, 12:26 AM
Ok I have not seen FW in its entirety since I guess I was kid. I honestly do not remember how it ended.

I don’t have all the DVDs. Just to season 4. I should probably get them but thought it’d get Blu Rays or a Special Edition by now. Seems the whole series is on YouTube so I’d like to watch it in case it’s removed. At least the final season.

Anyway it’s a solid cartoon even though some stuff is silly. By the time it ended it was pretty well rounded from what I can tell. It’s not nostalgia goggles either. I have not seen it years and I don’t remember half of it, like at all.

I’m sure some kind of follow up can be made that old and new fans can appreciate. TMNT already appeals to kids. I’m sure it would be portrayed so anyone can watch it and not need 10 seasons to understand it.

A lot of the FW elements were in the 2012 cartoon so newer fans are familiar with it and where it comes from. I’ve never seen Transformers G1 but I understand the history.

neatoman
10-18-2021, 02:39 AM
Ok I have not seen FW in its entirety since I guess I was kid. I honestly do not remember how it ended.

They use Krang's body to banish Dregg and Splinter declares them to the fully trained. That's the ending in a nutshell.


I don’t have all the DVDs. Just to season 4. I should probably get them but thought it’d get Blu Rays or a Special Edition by now. Seems the whole series is on YouTube so I’d like to watch it in case it’s removed. At least the final season.

The show had very poor quality control. An HD remaster would only make the show look or sound better in the technical sense of being more crisp. On Blu-Ray it would still be obvious that the frame-rate is choppy, that Mikey gets duplicated in one episode because of a layer issue, that characters sometimes talk with the wrong voice, etc. The short answer is that remastering it would be a waste.


Anyway it’s a solid cartoon even though some stuff is silly. By the time it ended it was pretty well rounded from what I can tell. It’s not nostalgia goggles either. I have not seen it years and I don’t remember half of it, like at all.

It was not a "solid" cartoon. Aside from the production errors, the show tended to suffer from having really bad scripts with really bad plots. Episodes were often concluded with some deus ex crap, forgot to explain key details or contained pointless filler.

And I know this might be a bit controversial to say but the humor in this show sucks too. It isn't even remotely funny. If it isn't some lame crap a pizza having weird topings, it's probably some really toothless snark or some random nonsense that comes out of nowhere.


I’m sure some kind of follow up can be made that old and new fans can appreciate. TMNT already appeals to kids. I’m sure it would be portrayed so anyone can watch it and not need 10 seasons to understand it.

Technically but even bother? Just go back to Mirage and make something new if you want to make something that appeals to an older audience. It's not like anyone actually remembers the 1987 cartoon accurately from when they were kids.


A lot of the FW elements were in the 2012 cartoon so newer fans are familiar with it and where it comes from. I’ve never seen Transformers G1 but I understand the history.

It pays lip service to those elements by using names and/or basic character designs, in all honesty there is barely even a connection, it's just there to trick you into thinking your nostalgia is being appealed to. Technically speaking it is true that both shows happen to have a character named Irma who is April's buddy, but even before this character was revealed to be an Utrom in disguise when it came to the new show, it was pretty clear that all they took from the old character was a name and not much else. The same goes for Mutagen Man, Rahzar, Tokka, Merdude, Dregg, Mona Lisa, The Punk Frogs, Wingnut, Slash and a few others.

And while we're on the subject, while people like to act as if the show was all "Muck Man, Mondo Gecko, Chrome Dome, all my faves galore!" and those characters are the ones to show up outside of the show, the truth is that when the Turtles weren't dealing with some random Shredder scheme, it was some random mad scientist or some other character that were never in anything else.

As awkward as this might be to admit, people are not really nostalgic for the show itself because they barely remember and don't care what the show was actually like, they are more nostalgic for the toyline the show was intended to market. That might be a little bit sad to think about but that really seems to be the case.

LeotheLateBloomer
10-18-2021, 02:40 AM
The problem with relying on FW as the benchmark is that it WAS super-successful... with kids. Kids in 1988. That has practically NO relevance to what would be successful NOW. People who are 6-10 years old in 2021 give less than zero f*cks what their parents liked when they were their age. And there simply aren't enough 40-year olds with a strong nostalgic passion for FW TMNT to pack a theater anymore.

The immediate problem becomes, as we've all heard countless times, "you can't serve two masters" to begin with. You have to decide who you're trying to please and commit to that. But they've been very hesitant to do that, thus far, and every time one of the people up top speaks, they go back and forth about who they're really aiming for with This or That reboot. They're either trying to "grow the audience by attracting new kids" or "giving the old-school fans what they want", depending on the day. And frankly, you can't do both at the same time. It generally doesn't work. It's worked very, very, very rarely, like the more recent MLP reboots, but even then, that's only because the originals were so bad that the franchise had nowhere to go but up. So you really can't compare something like that to something like TMNT which actually had a ton of success and popularity way back when.

Part of the reason why I lean towards the 1990 movie so much as an example of what they ought to try and lean into, is because that's the only example where TMNT ever achieved any sort of TRUE mainstream success, not just with young children. To this day, whenever I show that movie to someone who never saw it, or who thought TMNT was nothing but "stupid kids' stuff", it never fails to mesmerize them. "Holy sh*t, that's actually a 'real' movie!" It was the same back in 1990, when millions of grown-ups who only tolerated the FW cartoon show because their kids were obsessed with it, were legitimately captivated by the live-action film. Otherwise there's no way it would have become the most successful independent movie ever made, nor kept that title for years upon years. If the movie had been like the show was - something parents smiled through gritted teeth at just because their kids were so in love with it - then it absolutely would not have done so well. As evidence of that, we have the sequels, which were loved by children but had MUCH less cross-over appeal with adults and non-fans.

To my way of thinking, that means the 1990 film was the franchise's true peak, because it proved conclusively that TMNT did not need to just be goofy stuff aimed at 6-year olds, that if handled well it could also enrapture their parents, or even win over non-fans. Simply put, NO other iteration of TMNT has ever managed to do that. And thus, if they're sincerely trying to make a movie that both kids and adults in 2021 will enjoy, then their best bet should probably be to go back to the ONLY time that they ever managed to pull that trick successfully. Trying to stick to the blueprint of a cartoon show that was a huge hit with people who were 8 over 30 years ago is questionable if you're sincerely trying to reach a large number of people. Put simply, there's no proof it can even be done.

Pretty much. A version of an IP that was popular back then isn't as popular now. Adam West was what the public thought of Batman before the Keaton film changed the perception of the character. The recent Power Rangers film was based on MMPR (the one that introduced the world to PR and the one people remember the most) and sadly it didn't do well in box office. PR now is more than just MMRP with how many versions there are now. And when people think of MLP they now see FiM, not the 80s show.

I mentioned this in another thread but I've met people born between 94 to 99 that grew up with the 90s movies and not FW. The 90s movies (at least the first two) are now just as popular if not more than FW.

Chris
10-18-2021, 03:49 AM
Yeah, but as MOTU Revelation proved, you do that and then you get people screaming about how it's "terrible" because it's not as light, fluffy and one-dimensional as the original show was.

But as I've oft-argued in defense of Revelation, if you DO try and do a show/movie/etc. that's 1:1 with the original, you'd get the ten to twenty people who remain in romantic love with that older version without irony to love it, and everyone else would think it was the dumbest thing ever that nobody thought to aim higher 30+ years later.

Sometimes, you really just can't win. Try and raise the stakes a bit, you get chastised for "ruining the innocence" of the original. Stick 1:1 with the original aesthetic, you get chastised for being out of touch and not having any new ideas.

I don't disagree with any of this (and agree with you that the first movie is the sweet spot they should really be aiming for rather than FW).

I do think that if they go in this direction it will avoid the worst of the Revelation backlash as you won't have the whole "it's about Teela" thing. They'll probably do something similar to the 2007 movie and say April has been training so she can be a more active character, but the focus would be clearly on the turtles (and they don't have to worry about Netflix splitting the story in half either).

That said, I think it will be guilty of not raising the stakes, since it will be aimed more at kids. Which will also be the studio response to any adult fans' criticism. So less backlash, but also less point in doing it in the first place. Like you say, damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Let's be honest, if they do a FW "sequel" aimed at kids it's essentially being made for a new kids but with a nostalgia wrapper to loosely appeal to their parents. If we get something that all ages can truly enjoy (like the best Disney and Pixar stuff), that manages to hit the nostalgia button whilst offering something new I will be genuinely amazed. But, since they seem determined to avoid doing anything aimed at adults or drawing from Mirage, it's still a better idea than what they tried with 2014 and Rise.

Wildcat
10-18-2021, 04:24 AM
@ neatoman, well I know certain things about the show were silly like running gags and Shredders schemes. I’m sure there was a lot of filler and repetitive episodes based on how long it ran.

From the seasons I do have I don’t think it was as dumb as people make it out now. I think it was a solid action cartoon.

I did not expect a remaster to fix technical errors like the ones you mentioned. I’d just like it in HD with bonus content if possible.

The 2012 cartoon did more than just rename characters imo. I’ll agree on Irma but a lot of the FW elements were duplicated only with some differences or update. I think they did a good job working them.

Sumac
10-18-2021, 06:47 AM
But they did manage to please "everybody", exactly One Time, and they made a lot of money with it. One would think that, in a situation where all other attempts have failed, they'd look at what went right that One Time and study THAT blueprint instead.
Because, it was just one single movie, when TV series lasted for 10 seasons, had enormous merchandise machine build around, including few very successful video games. This is what most people remember when it comes to TMNT, even those who wasn't around in 1980s 90s.

So they base new TMNT shows around what they believe is the most popular. As for the movie, like Mirage comic books, it is mostly remembered by people who KNOW TMNT beyond TV series this days.

And I know this might be a bit controversial to say but the humor in this show sucks too. It isn't even remotely funny. If it isn't some lame crap a pizza having weird topings, it's probably some really toothless snark or some random nonsense that comes out of nowhere.
Nah, it was good for what it was.
I still find it more fun than burp jokes surrounding Mike from beginning of 2k3 or...majority of a humor from 2k12 series for that matter.

ZariusTwo
10-18-2021, 10:13 AM
Sometimes, you really just can't win. Try and raise the stakes a bit, you get chastised for "ruining the innocence" of the original.

I've read a couple of fanfics adapting Revelation and tweaking it more with the heart of the original MOTU and it really works. They don't forget the stakes but the characters aren't undermined nor unlikeable.

Leo656
10-18-2021, 06:02 PM
You and I just probably have vastly different opinions on what makes a protagonist "unlikeable", my brother. :tgrin:

I mean, my favorite movie(s) of all time is Young Guns (Part II automatically should be included in any conversation by default because it's less a "sequel" and more an organic continuation). That Billy the Kid was a bad egg! I mean yeah, he had boatloads of charisma - which is unavoidable when played by the incomparable Emilio Estevez! - but he was incredibly selfish, self-serving, narcissistic, and got ALL of his friends killed because of that.

You root for him because the "law" is corrupt and the "good guys" are even worse than he is, and because he's got those dimples and that incredibly charming laugh/cackle thing he does... but he's still just a real asshole, indisputably.

People are complicated. Characters, also, can be complicated. To me, it doesn't make them altogether unlikeable, depending. But of course, personal mileage can and will vary on such things. I'm just sayin'.

TylerD
10-19-2021, 03:21 PM
Ok I have not seen FW in its entirety since I guess I was kid. I honestly do not remember how it ended.

I don’t have all the DVDs. Just to season 4. I should probably get them but thought it’d get Blu Rays or a Special Edition by now. Seems the whole series is on YouTube so I’d like to watch it in case it’s removed. At least the final season.

Anyway it’s a solid cartoon even though some stuff is silly. By the time it ended it was pretty well rounded from what I can tell. It’s not nostalgia goggles either. I have not seen it years and I don’t remember half of it, like at all.

I’m sure some kind of follow up can be made that old and new fans can appreciate. TMNT already appeals to kids. I’m sure it would be portrayed so anyone can watch it and not need 10 seasons to understand it.

A lot of the FW elements were in the 2012 cartoon so newer fans are familiar with it and where it comes from. I’ve never seen Transformers G1 but I understand the history.

I have seen them all recently as I have all the DVD's, and I would be fine if they kind of wrapped the entire series into a new movie...... however leave out the final two seasons of the Red Sky episodes which were season 9 and 10 (I believe) that is when the season and show started going down the toilet for me.... They changed it and made it more dark which I was totally in favour of, but I just couldn't get on board with the new characters.

Sumac
10-19-2021, 03:37 PM
They changed it and made it more dark which I was totally in favour of, but I just couldn't get on board with the new characters.
RSS had a lot of weak elements, but new characters were one of its main weakness.

Interestingly they did a fine job with upgrading Shredder and Krang into real threats, even Rat King received cool makeover and then...they just threw them away. And then they did the same with Titan, Krakus, Carter, everyone except Dregg who was boring as ****.

RSS was like a collection of wrong choices wrapped into 3 seasons.

Slash-Dash
10-30-2021, 01:05 PM
Looks like VarnerStudios will have involvement, likely in the toy sculpting.

Posted on their Instagram story this evening:
http://i.imgur.com/fAeKJRZl.jpg (https://imgur.com/fAeKJRZ)

first look at the logo? absolving what I am seeing here....

when do you think we will get our first look at the designs of the turtles?

Chris
10-30-2021, 07:16 PM
I’d guess we’ll see a first look in the second half of next year. Movies don’t tend to do the whole “teaser trailer a year out” anymore but we should get a first look image around then. Very curious to see what direction they go in. If this does end up being a sort of sequel to FW I can still see the turtles having slightly different heights and buildings rather than all being the same

Slash-Dash
11-01-2021, 01:22 PM
I’d guess we’ll see a first look in the second half of next year. Movies don’t tend to do the whole “teaser trailer a year out” anymore but we should get a first look image around then. Very curious to see what direction they go in. If this does end up being a sort of sequel to FW I can still see the turtles having slightly different heights and buildings rather than all being the same

thank you.

TigerClaw
11-01-2021, 04:19 PM
It seems like Chris Pratt is your go to actor to voice beloved characters these days.

Do you think he would be cast for this animated movie? What character do you think Chris Pratt would be a good fit for?

Chris
11-02-2021, 10:44 AM
I try not to judge who would or wouldn't suit a character, especially for voice acting, as you never know what they could come up with in the booth. To stick with TMNT for an example, I would never have picked LOTR's Sean Austin as Raphael based on what I knew of his work but I loved him in the show.

I'm sure they could easily fill the voice cast with names like Chris Pratt and they'd be just fine, but I really hope they don't go with big names for this as I'd rather see voice actors get the work.

TigerClaw
11-02-2021, 04:07 PM
I try not to judge who would or wouldn't suit a character, especially for voice acting, as you never know what they could come up with in the booth. To stick with TMNT for an example, I would never have picked LOTR's Sean Austin as Raphael based on what I knew of his work but I loved him in the show.

I'm sure they could easily fill the voice cast with names like Chris Pratt and they'd be just fine, but I really hope they don't go with big names for this as I'd rather see voice actors get the work.
What if Chris Pratt was cast as Casey Jones?

Chris
11-03-2021, 05:19 AM
Like I said, I don't like to judge what roles people would or wouldn't suit, especially for voice work. On paper Stephen Amell was a good fit for Casey, but the way the character was written in the film was poor. On the flip side, Chris Evans isn't the first name to jump to mind for Casey but he did a good job in the CG film.

Pratt as Casey wouldn't make or break the film for me. It really would depend on how the character was written and how he voiced it. I just personally would rather they went for voice actors over big names. There's an overlap, and I wouldn't be against a few known names, but I'm just not a fan of stuffing animated films full of celebrity voices when it's more for marketing/publicity than for the film.

LeotheLateBloomer
11-03-2021, 06:15 AM
Tigerclaw is only bringing up Chris Pratt (twice) because of the recent news of him voicing Garfield and Mario. He brought up Idris Elba immediately after the announcement of him voicing Knuckles.

TigerClaw
11-03-2021, 03:38 PM
You know that this CGI movie is going to have some big names for the voices.

Though the Turtles will probably have younger voice actors, but for characters like Casey Jones, April, Shredder, and Splinter, They will get some big names for them.

Since Seth Rogen is producing, He'll get some well known actors in his circle to participate this animated movie.

Chris Evans was the voice of Casey Jones in the 2007 movie, But that was way before people knew him for Captain America.

Andrew NDB
11-03-2021, 04:04 PM
Like I said, I don't like to judge what roles people would or wouldn't suit, especially for voice work. On paper Stephen Amell was a good fit for Casey, but the way the character was written in the film was poor. On the flip side, Chris Evans isn't the first name to jump to mind for Casey but he did a good job in the CG film.

As far as I'm concerned, the voice actors could be "Random people we voice-auditioned in front of Macy's last week." Who even cares?

Leo656
11-03-2021, 07:05 PM
The producers care. No "star", no movie.

I mean, you're right, it technically shouldn't matter. And they can get away with using "no-names" to do the voices for a TV show, that's costing them nickels to produce.

But they already have a huge uphill battle just by doing ANY sort of TMNT movie nowadays after the BayTurtles movies and "Rise" pretty much buried the franchise. The movie could come out tomorrow, and you'd reach more people by getting on a bus, sticking your head out the window and yelling at random people passing by. I'm not convinced anybody really actually cares about TMNT anymore outside of this forum and a few people on FB groups and Twitter. It's damaged goods.

So, the producers aren't going to take any chances. They're going to stack the movie with as many "name" voice actors as they can get, hoping that each of their respective fanbases will pay to see the movie because they're in it. Figure you get four famous people to play the Turtles, a famous actress to voice April, and right there you've got five separate groups of fans who maybe won't care a great deal about TMNT but they'll pay to come see/hear Chris Hemsworth as Michelangelo, or whatever, just as a novelty.

So yeah, it shouldn't matter. But right now it's kinda the only thing that DOES matter. It's the only way the movie's gonna make any money.

TigerClaw
11-03-2021, 07:08 PM
I could see Tom Holland voicing one of the Turtles, Either Michelangelo or Donatello.

The Turtle Terminator
11-05-2021, 12:15 PM
I could see Tom Holland voicing one of the Turtles, Either Michelangelo or Donatello.

I'd guess Michelangelo out of the two. I can also see (or expect) Chris Pratt getting the role of Leonardo too.

Zog The Magnificent
11-05-2021, 12:34 PM
New idea: Chris Pratt voices all four turtles. And also Splinter.

AquaParade
11-05-2021, 12:36 PM
New idea: Chris Pratt voices all four turtles. And also Splinter.

After voicing a humanoid cat and an Italian, we can all see ninja turtles being his endgame.

IndigoErth
11-05-2021, 05:15 PM
Don't care who they choose, so long as the voices suit them and there are no jarring weird choices. And no shoving a weird choice on a Turtle that doesn't suit him just to get a big name involved.

Cowa
11-15-2021, 10:30 PM
I'd guess Michelangelo out of the two. I can also see (or expect) Chris Pratt getting the role of Leonardo too.

God forbid

CyberCubed
11-17-2021, 04:15 PM
I basically draw the line at humans turned into Turtles, or a white Eric Sachs Shredder. This movie better not have either.

Andrew NDB
11-19-2021, 02:38 PM
https://i.ibb.co/8mfNqs1/259130433-2691694177799566-1960933306316749885-n.jpg

IndigoErth
11-19-2021, 03:05 PM
Is this the official one? Or still a work in progress? It's a little more visually pleasant than that one on the shirt, but only a little. No offense to whoever is coming up with these.

Imo... maybe shorten up the vertical dimension as it looks kind of bulky, tone down the slimy look (the amount of texture within the letters is a bit too busy imo, esp with all the other "movement" added by the Nick logo and wavy mask tails), and integrate the "next chapter" part into it, preferably in small letters under "Turtles" (because it kind of looks like it was forgotten and thrown in last minute)...and it might be okay?

As it stands... the bulk of it and that basic "next chapter" text sort of looks like one of those self published titles on Amazon. Just saying.

Sumac
11-19-2021, 03:15 PM
Looks like semi-digested logo.
*BARF*

IndigoErth
11-19-2021, 03:55 PM
I doth tinkered a little...

https://i.imgur.com/vVit01v.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/YmwYeMq.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/0ZfGkhP.jpg

Not sure about fitting the "next chapter" text in there though... Plain Ariel in white seems so bland for a logo, but there is already a lot of fonts and colors happening. Went back and tried fitting it off to the right in green before posting to just kind of blend it in instead. (Nick logo text prob needs to shift upward a smidge.)

Andrew NDB
11-19-2021, 04:01 PM
I don't like the logo at all, but your 2nd version there is the best.

Leo656
11-19-2021, 05:30 PM
I don't like the logo at all, but your 2nd version there is the best.

I agree, definitely.

Wildcat
11-19-2021, 10:44 PM
IndigoErths edit is better. “Next Chapter” in plain text in the real one is just weird.

However I think it’s a pretty good logo variation. Using the red bandanna like that is cool. I could do without the orange Nick part.

AquaParade
11-19-2021, 11:14 PM
Looks like rainbow dog crap. I bet they’ll tweak it.

Leo656
11-19-2021, 11:51 PM
That "Next Chapter" font is balls. Cheap as hell, totally not professional-looking at all.

Poweranimals
11-20-2021, 01:39 AM
Why do they gotta ruin it by sticking "Nickelodeon" on there?

Andrew NDB
11-20-2021, 02:09 AM
Why do they gotta ruin it by sticking "Nickelodeon" on there?

Right? Not to put any shade on Nickelodeon, but if I see a movie with the Nickelodeon banner above it on the title or the poster, I'm automatically going, "Oh, OK. This is for little kids and goofy stuff and slime and etc.."

AquaParade
11-20-2021, 08:35 AM
Yeah, “Next Chapter” font looks slapped on, and just adds to the feeling that there is way too much going on.

The different fonts, the slimy texture over everything, the garish (imo) mash of orange and red, followed by “The Next Chapter” in just plain old font. It’s actually pretty funny. Clearly someone designed the logo and was told to add “The Next Chapter” at the bottom, afterwards. Sending this logo from bad to awful.

NinjaPug
11-20-2021, 08:54 AM
Looks fan-made / fake to me

frank_one
11-20-2021, 11:06 AM
It could get a little better if the mask ends were not symmetrical.

Papenbrook
11-21-2021, 07:55 PM
The studio doesn't know what they're doing or what they want.

That's ANOTHER franchise desecrated by Paramount ...

Zulithe
11-22-2021, 02:07 PM
Logo reminds me of Toxic Crusaders a little bit. Or a lot of other 80s/90s logos actually, so I don't think I dislike it as much as some of you.

It might really fit the style/vibe they are going for, we'll see.

Is it my fav TMNT logo out of the dozens we have had over the years? Well no, but I do like that it's different without being terrible.

frank_one
11-22-2021, 05:12 PM
I agree, it definitely has 80s/90s vibes and it's a good thing... I guess. I think most of us actually like it but at the same time we think it could be improved with minor changes.

Andrew NDB
11-22-2021, 05:30 PM
It looks like a joke logo. Like some kind of spoof thing.

Slash-Dash
11-27-2021, 11:09 AM
that logo has to be fake, right?

Panda_Kahn_fan
12-19-2021, 06:52 PM
If the title really is 'next chapter', then I think it's more likely a continuation of previous films, if only a loose continuation.

TigerClaw
12-19-2021, 08:56 PM
If the title really is 'next chapter', then I think it's more likely a continuation of previous films, if only a loose continuation.
The Next Chapter could mean that its a new version of TMNT, and maybe not a continuation of past versions.

IndigoErth
12-20-2021, 05:19 PM
So "next" doesn't mean anything?

TigerClaw
12-20-2021, 07:52 PM
So "next" doesn't mean anything?
Think about a title like Next Mutation, Was that show really about the Turtles experiencing another mutation? Nope, The title could mean anything.

Next Chapter could just be a way of saying, This is a new TMNT version, Another chapter in a franchise that could go either direction.

Panda_Kahn_fan
12-27-2021, 12:32 PM
Think about a title like Next Mutation, Was that show really about the Turtles experiencing another mutation? Nope, The title could mean anything.

Next Chapter could just be a way of saying, This is a new TMNT version, Another chapter in a franchise that could go either direction.

I seriously doubt that. If these were a total reboot, they would try to convey that in the title and marketing. As someone who has worked in marketing, I know they wouldn't call something the 'next chapter' if it's a fresh start, you try to capture the 'spirit/zeitgeist' of the product, while letting the audience know this version is an 'all-new' version of the thing they liked, but still close enough to get them interested and play on nostalgia. I would say with 98% certainty this is a continuation of a previous version,wither it is a loose continuation or a direct one remains to be seen.

Andrew NDB
12-27-2021, 12:56 PM
And TMNT 4 had the "New Generation" subtitle for years. It meant nothing.

Powder
12-27-2021, 08:34 PM
I seriously doubt that. If these were a total reboot, they would try to convey that in the title and marketing. As someone who has worked in marketing, I know they wouldn't call something the 'next chapter' if it's a fresh start, you try to capture the 'spirit/zeitgeist' of the product, while letting the audience know this version is an 'all-new' version of the thing they liked, but still close enough to get them interested and play on nostalgia. I would say with 98% certainty this is a continuation of a previous version,wither it is a loose continuation or a direct one remains to be seen.

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Wildcat
12-28-2021, 02:59 AM
What’s so funny about what they said? I agree Next Chapter heavily implies it’s a continuation of an existing version. FW seems to be the most likely. The 2007 movie already linked itself to the 90s ones.

It’s possible that it’s not and it’s referring to the next chapter of their lives in some way...older and new villains...but it’s still under “Teenage MNT” so it contradicts that idea. Unless they consider that their moniker that just does not change. Like a personal title.

Andrew NDB
12-28-2021, 03:18 AM
I dunno. That earlier Seth Rogen sketch thing implied it might be a next chapter of some fake TMNT that were former human teens.

Wildcat
12-28-2021, 04:09 AM
Ya that’s possible and I’m thinking the name will change by the time it comes out. Might be why the logo is plain text.

I forgot Seth Rogen actually said he liked the Teenage element and wanted to build off that. So forget anything about them being older.

Leo656
12-29-2021, 08:43 PM
I dunno. That earlier Seth Rogen sketch thing implied it might be a next chapter of some fake TMNT that were former human teens.

And sadly, we live in a time when "Well, why NOT?" is a good enough reason to just go ahead and do ANYTHING, no matter how stupid on its face. So you can rest assured that even if the Rogen movie isn't the one to use the horrible "TMNT who were humans first" idea, it will either be the very next reboot OR the one after that. Either way, it's inevitable.

Because now, "Why the heck NOT?" is good enough to get any terrible idea a budget and a release date. Back in my day, "Because it's f*cking stupid" was all the reason you needed NOT to go ahead and do stuff like that.

Panda_Kahn_fan
12-30-2021, 10:26 PM
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Laugh all you want, I used to work in marketing before the bug, and that is my opinion.

Leo656
12-31-2021, 12:56 AM
That does make logical sense.

Could be they're taking the "Masters of the Universe: Revelation" track with it. "It's a sequel to the show you watched as kids back in the '80s! Except, y'know... it totally isn't. Except for a few ways it kind of is, if you squint. It's just like you remembered it! Except, y'know, made by completely different people and with a totally different style and execution. But, y'know, other than THAT... it's TOTALLY the same, you guys!"

I wouldn't be shocked if it were "The Next Chapter" of the Turtles' lives after the end of the FW cartoon. Except, like MOTU: R, it won't "really" be that, for various reasons, it will just be "close enough if you squint and pretend real hard". Like for example how MOTU: R had to ignore the existence of She-Ra completely for legal/rights reasons, along with leaving out or ignoring huge chunks of other Filmation He-Man lore because it didn't fit the story they were telling with this new series, I expect they'd do the same for a "Next Chapter" of the FW TMNT cartoon. For example, if they do it, you can bet "Red Sky" will be ignored completely since most people never saw it and even fewer liked it. They'll probably ignore the end of the last pre-Red Sky season, too, and just jump in like it's "business as usual" for the TMNT except "a few years later".

But yeah, I can't see them LITERALLY doing a 1:1 direct continuation of FW, 4Kids, any of that stuff. But I CAN see them doing a movie that's a vague, "kinda/sorta/not literally" continuation a'la "Revelation". But it still wouldn't literally be "a direct sequel" because they'd most certainly ignore/retcon stuff people don't know about or didn't like, such as Red Sky, and also will most likely have a completely different art style and presentation. They will probably keep the same theme song, though, albeit a redone or "remixed" version.

Anyways, yeah, from a marketing standpoint there's no reason to call it "The Next Chapter" unless it's going to loosely follow something we already know about. FW is the only TMNT anyone in the casual audience cares about, so there's your answer, that's what it will be. Probably.

FW TMNT, through the Seth Rogen filter. Hmm. Thanks, I hate it!

Andrew NDB
12-31-2021, 02:05 AM
I just wish all I knew of Seth Rogen was only his movies and nothing else of what he's been loudly saying on Twitter and to anyone willing to listen, particularly lately. Because it isn't like one of these Hollywood guys where maybe they feel like they have to say certain things to continue to get work... no, he's really all about it.

Sumac
12-31-2021, 05:19 AM
I didn't know much about Rogen outside of the fact that dude had a stupid laugh, but after Santa Inc. I, sadly, have learnt more about him and the idea that this guy in charge of the new TMNT movie is...well...not inspiring.

On the other hand, we already have Campbell in charge of a comic book, so it is not like it is the first time this crap happen.
At least Rogen won't turn TMNT into his personal masturbatory fantasy about furries...right? Right!? :ohwell:

IndigoErth
12-31-2021, 03:13 PM
At least Rogen won't turn TMNT into his personal masturbatory fantasy about furries...right? Right!? :ohwell:
Well he already went there with food, so... total "why not" territory.


Not seen that Santa Inc thing, since I don't have HBO Max, but saw some review on it a couple nights ago...and about how it has totally bombed and hard. And this is the person expected to make a TMNT movie for Nick. Yep. I'm not even sure what to say to that.


edit: At this point I think I'd rather just call up Vanilla Ice and see if he wants to be involved and trust him to find people who give a crap and know what they're doing, no matter what his own particular angle of fandom is... It's at the point where it's like Hey, you're a known name and a known fan. Help. lol Dude pull some strings, ok?

Andrew NDB
12-31-2021, 03:33 PM
Not seen that Santa Inc thing, since I don't have HBO Max, but saw some review on it a couple nights ago...and about how it has totally bombed and hard. And this is the person expected to make a TMNT movie for Nick. Yep. I'm not even sure what to say to that.

Well, I looked at the Santa Inc. credits and Rogen doesn't appear to have any creative involvement with it at all. He was just a hired gun to play Santa.

IndigoErth
12-31-2021, 04:19 PM
Ah, okay, thought it was totally his 'masterpiece' and was then very, very afraid. lol

Andrew NDB
12-31-2021, 04:42 PM
Honestly, if I'd saw his name as screenwriter I wouldn't have been surprised, based on what he's been saying the last couple of years.

TigerClaw
12-31-2021, 05:10 PM
As how involve Seth Rogen is with the CGI movie, Its his production company that's making it, I don't know how involve he is with the making of it, But past interviews said he wanted to focus on the teenage aspect.

Leo656
12-31-2021, 06:18 PM
The only thing I've ever laughed at with Seth Rogen was 40-Year Old Virgin, and that was hardly because of him. And he was tolerable there because he's in it for like five minutes.

Also, funny in an ironic sense because much of his role in that movie is "Y'know how I know you're gay...?" jokes. Which he would want a person thrown in jail for nowadays. Awk-waaaaaard! Sadly, that's literally the funniest he's ever been.

Sumac
01-01-2022, 03:09 AM
I haven't watched Santa Inc., but I've heard about what kind of movie it is and what "values" Rogen espouses.

AquaParade
01-01-2022, 03:32 AM
Time for Viacom to look at the success of No Way Home and the trend of nostalgia - multiverse.

If you're a large studio, making a movie adaption of a comic, how do you not look at the success of No Way Home and ask yourself what you can do to get some of that cheddar?

I want those 1990 tmnt back so bad. Really, I can't even imagine seeing those characters on screen again. I never thought I'd see Tobeyman again, which was incredible, but this is the one way that could be topped for me, in a nostalgic movie magic sense. I'd get butterflies seeing those old Henson designs step out of the shadows.

Andrew NDB
01-01-2022, 04:41 AM
Time for Viacom to look at the success of No Way Home and the trend of nostalgia - multiverse.

If you're a large studio, making a movie adaption of a comic, how do you not look at the success of No Way Home and ask yourself what you can do to get some of that cheddar?

I want those 1990 tmnt back so bad. Really, I can't even imagine seeing those characters on screen again. I never thought I'd see Tobeyman again, which was incredible, but this is the one way that could be topped for me, in a nostalgic movie magic sense. I'd get butterflies seeing those old Henson designs step out of the shadows.

As in what? Have the Platinum Dunes get a new movie in which the 1990 TMNT guest star?

No. Dumb.

AquaParade
01-01-2022, 04:53 AM
As in what? Have the Platinum Dunes get a new movie in which the 1990 TMNT guest star?

No. Dumb.

Get your head out of the gutter. You can take inspiration from something without completely copying it.

The message to Hollywood is that you can bring back old characters and explain it away with a multiverse. There’s room for both. Doesn’t mean they have to share screen time necessarily.

Viacom seem sort of thick-headed, in regards to TMNT, so who knows. But if people start raving about Keaton-Batman again, it’ll only push the idea further.

NinjaPug
01-01-2022, 10:21 AM
Can Paramount even use the 90s Turtles in a movie if they wanted to since New Line/WB hold the rights to those movies?

AquaParade
01-01-2022, 11:11 AM
Can Paramount even use the 90s Turtles in a movie if they wanted to since New Line/WB hold the rights to those movies?

Good question. I don't know but the only hint I have is that one of the old screenwriters said they were trying to get Viacom to resurrect their version of tmnt a few years ago.

I'm not even trying to be a fanboy. It just makes business sense. When you've completely fumbled the ball on the new iterations and even studios with much more success are going back to the nostalgia well, it becomes an increasingly logical move.
1990 was a big success at the time. You ask adults coming out of NWH if they'd like to see the 1990 tmnt return and you're bound to get a ton of enthusiasm from most of them.

Then you have things like TLR blowing up, which further cements the idea that the roots of the franchise are the direction you need to head in.

This is the route I'd go down, even if it were my money on the line. Not that I count on Viacom doing it.

Wildcat
01-01-2022, 11:13 PM
Well there needs to be a decently popular new TMNT movie first to use the multiverse in a sequel. Which could happen with the next live action one.

I don’t think you should make a new movie that jumps straight into opening the multiverse. It’ll leave the new version underdeveloped and with barely any introduction.

Assuming it’s not using the cartoons it would be made up of the Current Turtles (new live action movie), 2014 Turtles and 90’s Henson Turtles.

frank_one
01-02-2022, 02:27 AM
Turtles Forever was great but we don't need a new one. The only way I can accept a movie with the 1990 Turtles is in a sequel of the old movies. No multiverse tricks, please.

Jephael
01-04-2022, 09:06 PM
As much as I love the multiverse idea, I'd rather that be done as an animated TV special on Nickelodeon or a comic book published by IDW. To be honest, I could care less if the TMNT ever get another feature film!

Big screen movies are kind of overrated in my personal opinion. I mean lets face it. You know why a lot of these super hero movies tank at the box office? Because there are thousands of stories about these characters that have been told via comic books and animated TV shows, and these studios try to cram several at a time into little bite sized 2 hour movies, and all that ever results in is a huge mess! I thought Spectacular Spider-Man was a great show that surpassed the Sam Raimi films because of just that. An animated series has the luxury of spacing out each story per episode, which is what I prefer. Heck, I hope at some point I hope Warner Bros. realizes they can have the same success doing an animated 7 season reboot of Harry Potter!

LeotheLateBloomer
01-04-2022, 09:33 PM
As much as I love the multiverse idea, I'd rather that be done as an animated TV special on Nickelodeon or a comic book published by IDW. To be honest, I could care less if the TMNT ever get another feature film!

Big screen movies are kind of overrated in my personal opinion. I mean lets face it. You know why a lot of these super hero movies tank at the box office? Because there are thousands of stories about these characters that have been told via comic books and animated TV shows, and these studios try to cram several at a time into little bite sized 2 hour movies, and all that ever results in is a huge mess! I thought Spectacular Spider-Man was a great show that surpassed the Sam Raimi films because of just that. An animated series has the luxury of spacing out each story per episode, which is what I prefer. Heck, I hope at some point I hope Warner Bros. realizes they can have the same success doing an animated 7 season reboot of Harry Potter!

This is very true. And financially for TMNT, it might be for the best.

TigerClaw
01-04-2022, 10:33 PM
It would be cool if they did a CGI movie of the TMNT Multiverse.

Galactus
01-05-2022, 09:10 PM
Time for Viacom to look at the success of No Way Home and the trend of nostalgia - multiverse.

If you're a large studio, making a movie adaption of a comic, how do you not look at the success of No Way Home and ask yourself what you can do to get some of that cheddar?

It's suprising that it's taken all this time for someone to suggest this. Usually whenever there's a hit comic book superhero movie very quickly there are people on here saying they should give TMNT the same treatment particularly given that it's something the franchise had done successfully in animation.

Still while fondly remembered I don't think the 90s movies had quite the cultural impact of the Raimi Spider-Man trilogy. While the Amazing Spider-Man series could be compared to the Platinum Dunes TMNT movies in the fact that there were maligned the former at least had a cult following and most people could probably agree that Garfield was a good actor in them and deserved another chance. There's a few people here and there online that argue "c'mon guys the Bay turtles weren't that bad" but I doubt there's enough that want them back that they'd be a draw.

There's also the hurdle that you'd have to set up a new live action version of TMNT first. One that is unique and distinct from the others before doing a multiverse crossover. No way could you open a new series of movies with a crossover.

Turtles Forever was great but we don't need a new one. The only way I can accept a movie with the 1990 Turtles is in a sequel of the old movies. No multiverse tricks, please.

I hear this a lot online but as I've already said the 1990 movie doesn't have quite the cultural impact that a revival would be a guaranteed hit. Also TMNT films will always be targeted at young people, ideally teenagers and people in their early twenties rather than little kids they targeted with the last movie and they will not be interested in a period piece set in the late 80s/early 90s.

You know why a lot of these super hero movies tank at the box office? ...

Wait...WHAT?!? It's the most globally dominant genre on the planet and has been for over a decade. Most comic book super hero movies are license to print money. The few that do fail are real **** ups.

AquaParade
01-06-2022, 09:51 AM
It's suprising that it's taken all this time for someone to suggest this. Usually whenever there's a hit comic book superhero movie very quickly there are people on here saying they should give TMNT the same treatment particularly given that it's something the franchise had done successfully in animation.

True. It's quite simple though - If you follow how Hollywood works, trends are a big deal, which is why you have people pondering whether another studio with a comic book property will consider hopping on whatever the latest bandwagon is.

That doesn't necessarily mean you need to copy it 1 for 1. There are a few messages that movie studios will receive from the success of No Way Home, and among those are

1. Multiverse crossover = popular
2. Bringing back old versions of characters = popular

They don't necessarily have to utilize those conclusions in the same way No Way Home did. They could end up copying one or the other.

Personally, I don't think they should give TMNT the No Way Home treatment, because I don't have much interest in seeing various versions of TMNT interact, and Turtles Forever does next to nothing for me. That said, I do think it would be both cool and profitable for Viacom to bring back the Henson 1990 TMNT. Not a "guaranteed hit", because few things are. It would generate a ton of excitement, if done right.


Still while fondly remembered I don't think the 90s movies had quite the cultural impact of the Raimi Spider-Man trilogy. I hear this a lot online but as I've already said the 1990 movie doesn't have quite the cultural impact that a revival would be a guaranteed hit.

Comparing anything to the cultural impact of Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy is an uphill battle, but I do think it's easy for even us here to underestimate how big the TMNT were when the 1990 film came out. There is a huge market of older TMNT fans, it's just not being catered to. We can't forget that TMNT 1990 was a record-breaker when it came out. The kids who watched that didn't disappear, they grew up and most of them watch MCU movies.

Andrew NDB
01-06-2022, 10:39 AM
99.9% of everyone, upon seeing the 2012 and 2003 and "Rise" universes interacting: "Huh. Who are they?"

AquaParade
01-06-2022, 12:41 PM
99.9% of everyone, upon seeing the 2012 and 2003 and "Rise" universes interacting: "Huh. Who are they?"

Henson or Fred Wolf versions of TMNT are the only ones that could generate enough fanfare to bring back, imo. Not to see them interact, but just in general. Those are the most successful and iconic versions of the characters.

Although, I do think there is a generation that probably holds 2012 pretty dear. It was somewhat successful.

Wildcat
01-06-2022, 10:47 PM
I think the 2003 Turtles would be recognizable. They lasted quite awhile and ended with Turtles Forever.

Nick 2012 would be too since it’s more recent and had a solid run.

Leo656
01-06-2022, 10:53 PM
Nobody remembers the 2003 TMNT since Nick decided to bury it for not being theirs. Most likely because it was miles better than their own schlock and they didn't want to compete with themselves.

I mean, people our age care about it. But as they've spent a decade now making crystal clear, "people our age" are 100% NOT the people Nick wants paying attention to this sh*tty franchise anymore. So you can forget that idea completely. Nick only wants people under age 10 to watch TMNT, and none of them know about the 2003 show.

Wildcat
01-06-2022, 11:09 PM
How have they buried it? No DVDs or reruns?

Theres other shows that don’t have DVDs or reruns. Beast Wars/Machines comes to mind. There’s DVDs but I’ve never seen reruns since it ended.

Leo656
01-06-2022, 11:24 PM
The simplest reply to your question is another question; specifically, "How have they NOT buried it?"

But yes, refusing to acknowledge its existence while also ensuring that it remains nigh-impossible for anyone to consistently watch via LEGAL means are a couple of really prominent examples of how much Nick hates that show and its fans.

It's very clear that we "aren't supposed to care about it" given the way Nick treats that show like the bastard stepchild of the franchise rather than "the show that saved the entire brand from permanent oblivion" which is what it actually was. I mean, things are sh*tty for the brand now, but they were even sh*ttier before the 4Kids show saved the entire franchise all on its own.

And as "thanks", Nick throws a tarp over it and demands we all forget. Because it's inconvenient to their narrative and also provides a stark contrast against their own mediocre CGI cartoon and its nonsense writing.

I guess it makes sense from Nick's perspective; I know the Nick show has its fans, but at the very least the first two (or three) Seasons of 4Kids wipes its proverbial ass with the Nick show, even without its "celebrity" voice actor gimmicks and shiny CGI paintjob. Nick wants their own products at the forefront, therefore they "can't" promote a much better product that was made by someone else, even though they own it now.

Still, it's petty and spiteful and does nothing but annoy fans like me who are already completely out of love with this brand and out of reasons to keep caring.

Wildcat
01-06-2022, 11:44 PM
I don’t know how that’s necessarily refusing to acknowledge it exists when other shows have similar situations.

They’ve actually aired reruns of the 2003 series on Nicktoons or TeeNick some years ago. They had a marathon that included Fast Forward, BttS and I think Turtles Forever.

TMNT 3 and the 2007 movie was recently on Cartoon Network which I thought was funny. Just you’d think Nick would air them.

TigerClaw
01-07-2022, 05:55 AM
I wish they acknowledge the 1987 series, The problem is that its from another studio, Don't you hate when TMNT is spread across different studios? Lionsgate owns the 1987 series, WB owns the 1990 and 2007 movies.

IndigoErth
01-07-2022, 10:28 AM
Not really, I feel like their wide net is part of their staying power.

Nostalgia cash grabbing be damned, had Nick/Viacom owned the FW series would they have really even bothered to put the complete series on disc anymore than they can't be bothered to do it with 2003? (Which, if I understand correctly, they do own?) They'd have probably just put it on their app instead, and now subscription streaming, and saved themselves the cost of producing and selling a hard copy... :tconfuse:

Lionsgate's only real way to profit from even having it is, I assume, giving us the disc set many wanted in their collection? Meanwhile Nick has other options and can't be bothered.

TigerClaw
01-07-2022, 04:45 PM
Not really, I feel like their wide net is part of their staying power.

Nostalgia cash grabbing be damned, had Nick/Viacom owned the FW series would they have really even bothered to put the complete series on disc anymore than they can't be bothered to do it with 2003? (Which, if I understand correctly, they do own?) They'd have probably just put it on their app instead, and now subscription streaming, and saved themselves the cost of producing and selling a hard copy... :tconfuse:

Lionsgate's only real way to profit from even having it is, I assume, giving us the disc set many wanted in their collection? Meanwhile Nick has other options and can't be bothered.
What's annoying is Nick doesn't even bother putting those episodes on blu-ray when they were all done in HD.

Andrew NDB
01-07-2022, 05:18 PM
What's annoying is Nick doesn't even bother putting those episodes on blu-ray when they were all done in HD.

It's very weird. It forces your hand to pirate. Why on earth would you pay money for craptacular DVD 480p versions of a thing that you could pirate and get in full 1080p?

neatoman
01-07-2022, 05:20 PM
I wish they acknowledge the 1987 series, The problem is that its from another studio, Don't you hate when TMNT is spread across different studios? Lionsgate owns the 1987 series, WB owns the 1990 and 2007 movies.

Uh, they probably would? Anyway, it's probably for the best that Viacom doesn't own the Fred Wolf show.

TigerClaw
01-07-2022, 06:16 PM
Uh, they probably would? Anyway, it's probably for the best that Viacom doesn't own the Fred Wolf show.
While each studio owns the rights to a version of TMNT, I doubt they could make another version of there TMNT since Viacom owns the IP, Just not those movies and original series.

For example, Warner Bros cannot do another TMNT based on the 90s movies even though they own the rights to those movies, just not the IP itself.

FredWolfLeonardo
01-07-2022, 07:26 PM
The one thing I appreciate about this movie is that it's going to be fully CG animated. The last CG animated tmnt film in 2007 looks absolutely gorgeous even all these years later so I wonder if this film is going to match or surpass that.

neatoman
01-07-2022, 07:48 PM
While each studio owns the rights to a version of TMNT, I doubt they could make another version of there TMNT since Viacom owns the IP, Just not those movies and original series.

For example, Warner Bros cannot do another TMNT based on the 90s movies even though they own the rights to those movies, just not the IP itself.

I know, that's kind of the reason it's ultimately a good thing. It essentially means the Fred Wolf show isn't part of the "official" TMNT franchise.

If nothing else, it means the Fred Wolf cartoon won't ever air on Nickelodeon, stream on Paramount+ or get discs printed by Viacom. They will never directly profit from it. Which in turn, hopefully, means they will eventually be fine with dropping it's imagery and ideas from the marketing so that the franchise can finally move on from it.

The absolute best case scenario would be if it turns out there is some kind of clause that prevents anyone from directly reviving the show or coming too close too it. You know, kinda like how Mattel can license He-Man all they want but unless Dreamworks gets the license, there can't be a direct continuation of the Filmation cartoon. I'm hoping there is something similar and I'm really hoping it's more draconian. Basically, what I hope is in place here, is that there is something that makes it impossible for anyone to make Fred Wolf Season 11, or even make a cartoon that resembles it too much. I doubt that's actually a thing, otherwise it would be difficult to explain why Turtles Forever and Trans-Dimensional Turtles exist, but it sure would be sweet schadenfreude if it did.

Sumac
01-08-2022, 12:40 AM
If nothing else, it means the Fred Wolf cartoon won't ever air on Nickelodeon, stream on Paramount+ or get discs printed by Viacom. They will never directly profit from it. Which in turn, hopefully, means they will eventually be fine with dropping it's imagery and ideas from the marketing so that the franchise can finally move on from it.
Won't happen: FW is too popular for that.

Leo656
01-08-2022, 02:51 AM
Was, maybe.

Like anything to do with TMNT, FW is only "popular" with 40-year olds. Nick's audience is 10 and under. To that audience, FW is just another "old, terrible" cartoon their parents watched back in "the Dark Ages". "Cartoons weren't even CGI back then, DAD. Why didn't you all just watch paint dry instead?" and so on.

If Nick thinks they're going to razzle-dazzle that mythical, rarer-than-unicorns "New Audience" by putting the FW cartoon in front of them, they're more out of touch than we thought.

It's probably still the most popular iteration among "real, authentic and actual" TMNT fans. But it's not like that counts for much since, as stated and very often demonstrated, Nick hates those people.

Andrew NDB
01-08-2022, 03:04 AM
Was, maybe.

Like anything to do with TMNT, FW is only "popular" with 40-year olds. Nick's audience is 10 and under. To that audience, FW is just another "old, terrible" cartoon their parents watched back in "the Dark Ages". "Cartoons weren't even CGI back then, DAD. Why didn't you all just watch paint dry instead?" and so on.

If Nick thinks they're going to razzle-dazzle that mythical, rarer-than-unicorns "New Audience" by putting the FW cartoon in front of them, they're more out of touch than we thought.

It's probably still the most popular iteration among "real, authentic and actual" TMNT fans. But it's not like that counts for much since, as stated and very often demonstrated, Nick hates those people.

I actually agree with all of this. I couldn't have put that better into words. And by "popular," let's be clear... this means "a faded vague memory of once playing with toys and a cartoon that sits better in memory than in actual rewatching." By said 40+ year olds. Yeah, you can get these people to occasionally light up and go, "Oh yeah! TMNT! I love TMNT! I think I had a Mutagen Rat King figure once, too!" but this amounts to very little beyond maybe the niche collecting side of things, like if NECA puts out some super exclusive and rare Rocksteady action figure wearing pink panties type crowd. This does not move the meter.

And again, I point to "Out of the Shadows" movie. You can say "oh, well, people were burned by 2014 so they weren't going to come to the 2016 movie regardless"... but wait. The entire internet including the Angry Gamer Guy has been telling us all they had to do was just give us Krang and Beebop and Technodrome and they'd have a goldmine for years. They finally DID that, and built the entire marketing campaign around specifically those things (I'm happy to post that hilariously terrible TV spot again if need be)... and guess what? Nobody showed. It didn't work. The experiment failed, and hard.

It turned out that about 20 years of "Well if they just did this then" was absolutely wrong. And I'm not going to lie. I kind of love that. But, you know... in a side kind of way. Like if I was a big zeppelin advocate, but then watched one crash down from the sky. Still sad, right? But if it was like an off-brand zeppelin that seemed sure to fail, always, long-term. Now, not so bad? More like, "wtf are you guys doing? Why use that brand of zeppelin, when I told you not to or a better one was plainly available to use?"

Leo656
01-08-2022, 03:43 AM
Nailed it, Andrew.

Full disclosure, though, in anticipation of a rebuttal from some people or persons who think it has to be one thing or another, I'm no longer convinced that a "better" or "more serious" take on TMNT would ever make the brand "popular" again, either. I used to think that, like ten years ago, but I don't anymore.

The thing is, I see how the younger generation entertains itself, how disposable their entertainment is to them and how they don't form long-lasting bonds with brands or characters the way we did. They don't do the whole "nostalgia" thing, to them old is just Old, and if it's old then they're done with it. The Nick cartoon, for example, is generally only still talked about by us, the G1 fans who watched some or all of it. Kids don't still care about it, they "outgrew" it. I really, honestly don't think that generation is going to "revive" the brand again through their nostalgic passion for ten years ago, the way we did in 2003. That reboot worked because our generation of fans were PASSIONATE about the brand and actively wanted to see it come back, and it helped us overlook some of the flaws in the 4Kids cartoon, the toys, the Mirage revival, etc. We carried it because TMNT mattered to us; it was more than just an old toy or cartoon, it had become part of who we were as people.

That's not true, to the same extent, of the younger crowd right now. To them it IS just an old silly thing they liked before they got into "cooler" stuff like Fortnite. Ask most kids who were 5-10 when they watched the Nick cartoon how excited they'd be for a big TMNT revival of some type, most of them would just say "eh". It's different. Everything. The times, the people, the products... Nothing is the same as it was twenty years ago, and I don't think it ever will be.

I really think now that the brand was heavily a product of its time that spoke strongly to a generation, for various reasons, but ONLY to that generation, as They/We are the only group of fans who ever STRONGLY bonded with the material and went back to it years later with the same level of enthusiasm. But I don't see that continuing. There was no huge surge of nostalgia in 2013 for the 4Kids show's anniversary; the kids who were 6 in 2003 didn't care enough to keep talking about it in 2013, and they're certainly not discussing it Now either. I don't see why it will be any different for the Nick cartoon. The 6-year olds of 2012 aren't automatically going to feel romantic and nostalgic about that cartoon again in 2022.

The only audience that has EVER come back consistently, are the 6-year olds of 1988. I really, honestly do think it's going to stay that way, and I think TMNT as a "brand" dies with us. There will always be toys, but I absolutely foresee a very near future where the cartoons, movies, and comics go away. We've already reached a point where the toys are the only things consistently making any money; it's not a far hop from there to "Fine, we just won't do the other stuff anymore." If the next movie flops, and then the NEXT one, whenever it may be... I think that's Game Over, officially. Nobody's going to spend $200 million to make a measly ten million (or LOSE ten million) dollars on a Ninja Turtles movie (or show, or video game, etc.) when the toys sell well even without those other things to "promote" them. TMNT action figures, T-shirts, etc. is a sustainable business model for whoever owns the brand. They can forever produce that stuff for pennies and make back billions. Movies and TV shows are not a sustainable business model, however, unless your brand shows a certain level of being "bulletproof". TMNT has never been that brand, as it's forever been a mixed bag at the best of times and its general fanbase is schizophrenic and bipolar.

Sounds kinda Doom N Gloom, maybe, and I confess that sometimes when I'm in a mood I can sound like I'm rooting for that to happen, but not so much that, really. It's more like, I just see the writing on the wall and if that's where things are headed then I'd like to skip the next three bad, failed retries and skip right to the "It's just a toy line for adults now" part. I just don't have a ton of patience, and as bad as tbe Bay stuff was I'm scared that the next one(s) might be even worse.

I swear though, I'm just being pragmatic. "Looking at the tea leaves" and just reading the general temperature of "TMNT Fans", who they are and what they respond to the most... This is sincerely the way I see things going. 15 years, I think. 20 if the next cartoon does better than expected.

AquaParade
01-08-2022, 10:03 AM
Millennial fans are willing to give TMNT chance after chance. TMNT are basically the “Sonic the Hedgehog” of the movie world. Started out great, the potential is still there, the sales are still there, but it’s been diminishing returns for decades now.

I truly believe it’s a “if you build it, they will come” situation. TMNT needs to be treated like other comic book properties, not other children’s properties. I maintain that most anyone my age willing to watch an MCU movie, would watch a TMNT movie, were it shown an equal amount of respect. People showed up for 07 and 2014, on opening weekends. They both started off strong. There is no shortage of goodwill from the audience.

Yes, it’s best known for being a children’s property, but most everything special about it came from the source. In the 90’s, Batman was most relevant in the form of Adam West, but that’s not what Burton tapped into for his film, and that’s not what reignited the character to the level he is at today. It’s not what people wanted anymore.
Sure, they smiled and reminisced about Adam West Batman, but it’s not what they wanted to see in modern times on the big screen. That’s what Viacom has trouble understanding.

Regarding Leo’s post, I don’t think we can accurately predict how much longer the franchise will last, but I do believe it’s future hangs in the balance of the next decade or so. I think there are a few years left to reinvigorate the franchise while there is still some goodwill left in the tank. I think the formula is sitting right there, in between the comics, the Henson film, and the MCU approach.

neatoman
01-08-2022, 06:35 PM
The only audience that has EVER come back consistently, are the 6-year olds of 1988. I really, honestly do think it's going to stay that way, and I think TMNT as a "brand" dies with us. There will always be toys, but I absolutely foresee a very near future where the cartoons, movies, and comics go away. We've already reached a point where the toys are the only things consistently making any money; it's not a far hop from there to "Fine, we just won't do the other stuff anymore." If the next movie flops, and then the NEXT one, whenever it may be... I think that's Game Over, officially. Nobody's going to spend $200 million to make a measly ten million (or LOSE ten million) dollars on a Ninja Turtles movie (or show, or video game, etc.) when the toys sell well even without those other things to "promote" them. TMNT action figures, T-shirts, etc. is a sustainable business model for whoever owns the brand. They can forever produce that stuff for pennies and make back billions. Movies and TV shows are not a sustainable business model, however, unless your brand shows a certain level of being "bulletproof". TMNT has never been that brand, as it's forever been a mixed bag at the best of times and its general fanbase is schizophrenic and bipolar.

Does that mean I could buy the rights as a discount fairly soon and finally produce that adult animated show I always wanted. I already have season 1 planned out!

Leo656
01-08-2022, 06:46 PM
Does that mean I could buy the rights as a discount fairly soon and finally produce that adult animated show I always wanted. I already have season 1 planned out!

You won't make any money on it but I wouldn't be shocked if the opportunity one day presents itself! :lol:

In all seriousness, I can see TMNT being one of those properties that Viacom (or whoever) just sits on forever once the well is dry, just to ensure nobody else gets a try. "Well, *we* can't make any money off of it... but just in case it's Us and not the brand that's the problem, we better make sure nobody else ever can, either." Disney does it a lot, buying stuff they'll never monetize just to spite everyone else. Or else "strip-mining" it to make a fast buck before sticking it on the back shelf.

In any case, I honestly doubt Viacom would actually try and sell it off once it was no longer incredibly profitable. There's always the 1% chance someone else can manage it better and turn it around, and then they're making money that was "yours" to make and you look like a dummy for letting it slip through your fingers. Nah, they'll just sit on it, that's what I think.

I think there are a few years left to reinvigorate the franchise while there is still some goodwill left in the tank. I think the formula is sitting right there, in between the comics, the Henson film, and the MCU approach.

I think the MCU is actually a huge part of the problem.

"TMNT as a blockbuster" doesn't work. Look, I don't want to be "That Guy" but TMNT, on its face, is a LOT more "dumb" as a premise than just about any other thing that's ever been super-popular. It works on a more intimate and small-scale level. It's never been as popular as Batman or X-Men or whatever, and never will be, because while most of that stuff is only like two steps removed from any sort of reality, TMNT is like ten steps removed. The farther you get into a premise that's completely implausible, the smaller your prospective audience becomes. It's not quite fair to compare it to super-hero fiction because while that stuff is just as implausible, at least most of the characters generally resemble human beings. TMNT, on the other hand, is "funny animal" stuff, which most people will always dismiss out of hand as farcical. If Batman were literally "a man who's part bat, or something," it would never have been as popular as it is.

BUT, super-hero stuff is the only thing that sells anymore, therefore anyone trying to make a TMNT movie is going to try and do it "MCU-style"... and that, to me, is a recipe for disaster. We saw with the last flick how misguided that approach is, they literally tried to do TMNT as a Marvel movie and it was godawful. ANY TMNT movie done in that style would be godawful. That type of presentation is too "big" for what TMNT ought to be.

Meanwhile, there's the fact that TMNT isn't actually popular enough to make such an endeavor worth it, to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a movie when there's not enough people who care about the brand to let it make its money back. TMNT isn't popular anymore. Why people insist on trying to compare it to things like Batman or X-Men which have never been out of fashion since their inception is puzzling, to me. It's not the same! Those brands didn't "die" twice. Sonic is a strange comparison as well because even though the games' reputations have taken a lot of lumps over the years, they've all sold incredibly well, even the "bad" ones. His comic book series is still one of the most successful licensed comics of all time, even if "real Sonic fans" who only cared about the games ignored it. So what we're seeing here, is people consistently compare TMNT - a franchise with a fanbase that has proven to be fickle and inattentive at the BEST of times - to things that have never been NOT-popular ever since they wer first popular. It's not 1:1.

Anyways, the conundrum with doing a TMNT movie is, the studios are in the mindset of "If we can't do TMNT as an MCU-style blockbuster, with all those same rewards, there's no point in even doing it." BUT, TMNT isn't popular enough to make MCU-style money, and even if there were enough people to fill those seats, the product would be terrible because TMNT works best as a smaller-scale, more "intimate" thing. Always has, always will.

I'd leave "the MCU" out of any equation that's trying to figure out how to make TMNT popular again, quite frankly. Square peg, round hole.

Not that it matters. I'll believe anyone actually still cares about TMNT when I see it for myself. Until then, my forecast remains unchanged. MCU-style, 1990-movie style... nobody cares anymore. It's a thing everyone liked when they were kids that some people still like but most others grew out of. That should be okay.

neatoman
01-08-2022, 07:18 PM
You won't make any money on it but I wouldn't be shocked if the opportunity one day presents itself! :lol:

In all seriousness, I can see TMNT being one of those properties that Viacom (or whoever) just sits on forever once the well is dry, just to ensure nobody else gets a try. "Well, *we* can't make any money off of it... but just in case it's Us and not the brand that's the problem, we better make sure nobody else ever can, either." Disney does it a lot, buying stuff they'll never monetize just to spite everyone else. Or else "strip-mining" it to make a fast buck before sticking it on the back shelf.

In any case, I honestly doubt Viacom would actually try and sell it off once it was no longer incredibly profitable. There's always the 1% chance someone else can manage it better and turn it around, and then they're making money that was "yours" to make and you look like a dummy for letting it slip through your fingers. Nah, they'll just sit on it, that's what I think.



Oh darn it, and I actually have 35 episodes planned, better keep onto that on the off chance that the opportunity presents itself.
In case you're wondering what it looks like:

No, I haven't written any actual scripts, I'm not that crazy. Of course I'm not going that far for something that I almost certainly won't be given the chance to make. It's basically just really short descriptions of what stories to adapt and what changes if any might be a good idea to implement.
They are all Mirage stories, I don't have any truly original stories planned but some probably would end up rather stretched and fillery.
Some would be really fillery, the most extreme case is that episode 29-35 would be entirely dedicated to adapting the Fugitoid micro.

Yes, I know it's kind of stupid to write a plan for what's obviously a pipe dream. I just kind of find the process of making it somewhat therapeutic.

AquaParade
01-08-2022, 07:24 PM
The MCU element would be the reverence for the source material. The MCU isn’t perfect about this, but when compared to Comic adaptions before the MCU existed, it’s incredibly faithful to the source material. I wouldn’t say the PD films took that approach at all. They copied the portal in the sky and called it a day.

Hard disagree that TMNT as a property isn’t worth pouring a lot of money into, in hopes of blockbuster returns. The franchise has already proven itself as a blockbuster contender more than once. First with the record-breaking 1990 film, and again with the opening numbers for the 2014 film, before word of mouth destroyed it. I know it’s easy to be pessimistic, but that’s just not true. There is a proven audience for this stuff. I’m guessing the Seth Rogen film makes it’s money back and then some as well, even if it’s a poor representation of the franchise.

To modern general audiences, this property isn’t much different from X-Men or Guardians of the Galaxy. It’s just another property they grew up loving (or didn’t) and will go to see if done in a way that appeals to their current demographic. Comic book properties are in, nostalgia is in, TMNT consistently opens #1 on its opening weekend at the box office, despite disappearing for years at a time. To say the property isn’t capable of making money anymore is silly. It’s quality that is in question.

The Sonic analogy is appropriate because the audience is continually willing to forgive a property that continually falls short of its potential. You are pointing out that Sonic consistently sells high, and that’s great because it proves the point. Those games suck, but people keep buying them. TMNT movies have been bad to mediocre since 1990, yet every new version opens at #1, before everyone realizes it’s just another poor take.

I do agree that tmnt work best as something a bit more intimate but I think the 1990 film showed you can be a blockbuster while still being goofy, strange, and intimate.

TigerClaw
01-08-2022, 07:44 PM
I know, that's kind of the reason it's ultimately a good thing. It essentially means the Fred Wolf show isn't part of the "official" TMNT franchise.

If nothing else, it means the Fred Wolf cartoon won't ever air on Nickelodeon, stream on Paramount+ or get discs printed by Viacom. They will never directly profit from it. Which in turn, hopefully, means they will eventually be fine with dropping it's imagery and ideas from the marketing so that the franchise can finally move on from it.

The absolute best case scenario would be if it turns out there is some kind of clause that prevents anyone from directly reviving the show or coming too close too it. You know, kinda like how Mattel can license He-Man all they want but unless Dreamworks gets the license, there can't be a direct continuation of the Filmation cartoon. I'm hoping there is something similar and I'm really hoping it's more draconian. Basically, what I hope is in place here, is that there is something that makes it impossible for anyone to make Fred Wolf Season 11, or even make a cartoon that resembles it too much. I doubt that's actually a thing, otherwise it would be difficult to explain why Turtles Forever and Trans-Dimensional Turtles exist, but it sure would be sweet schadenfreude if it did.
They are never going to give up on the FW series, They will always find ways to do some crossover with them, We seen it done 3 times so far, I'm sure at some point they'll do another one and get the original VAs back, When it comes to nostalgia, FW isn't something they can't let go because it has a fanbase that grew up with it.

neatoman
01-08-2022, 08:18 PM
The MCU element would be the reverence for the source material. The MCU isn’t perfect about this, when compared to Comic adaptions before the MCU existed, it’s incredibly faithful to the source material. I wouldn’t say the PD films took that approach at all. They copied the portal in the sky and called it a day.

Well, I'd say the actual faithfulness of the MCU tends to fluctuate a bit and it's always hard to map any particular MCU story onto a pre-existing comic book story. The most extreme example I can think of is Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. The Ten Rings, Ta-Lo and Dweller in Darkness really didn't have anything to do with Shang-Chi in the comics... Or really each other beyond the fact that they all co-existed in the Marvel Universe.

When people say the MCU is more faithful than any previous adaptation, I wonder if it's only because of the shared universe concept and relatively accurate costume design. With something like Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy, even though those movies just lift pages from the comics and construct a new narrative, I can still point to pages of Spider-Man comics and show that quite a few of them made it into those movies, which is a little harder with the MCU. And if we're trying to say that earlier movies tried to scrub the weird or silly away from the source materical, the MCU does that too. Because I can remember that even early on the MCU did things like actively trying to make it seem as if Asgard wasn't a magic land populated by literal gods, declaring instead that they used advanced tech and even having Odin straight up say they aren't gods. That is admittedly a move they seemed to ignore later on but still.

If it's really just the shared universe and not much else, then it's less about being more faithful and more about the MCU having a bigger toolbox by not being as limited in the character selection.

If the PD movies were more like the MCU in it's approach... I'm not entirely sure what that would be?

Would it be something like this?:

TMNT 1
Casey Jones 1
TMNT 2
Fugitoid 1
April O'Neil 1
TMNT 3 guest starring the Fugitoid
Nobody 1
Radical 1
Justice Force 1
Casey Jones 2
Utroms 1
Shredder 1
Fugitoid 2
TMNT 4
Nobody 2
April O'Neil 2
Justice Force 2
TMNT 5


And so on and so forth? Because that's not exactly faithfulness on it's own, that's just doing a lot with the same continuity.

They are never going to give up on the FW series, They will always find ways to do some crossover with them, We seen it done 3 times so far, I'm sure at some point they'll do another one and get the original VAs back, When it comes to nostalgia, FW isn't something they can't let go because it has a fanbase that grew up with it.

... OK:

That fanbase is aging, the average Fred Wolf fan is probably over 40 years old.
The show has not been in re-runs since 1997 (somewhat ironic given that it qualifies for guaranteed syndication three times over), so it is doubtful a younger fanbase of that particular version exists in any meaningful capacity.
Having already done three crossovers does not mean another one will be made. The last one they made failed to get any attention
Barry Gordon is 73, Rob Paulsen is 65, Cam Clarke is 64, Townsend Coleman is 67, Peter Renaday is 86, Renae Jacobs is 64, Pat Fraley is 72 and James Avery is dead. How many more cameos do think you can squeeze out of them before one of them croaks and it becomes harder to call it a reunion?
Sooner or later they're going to have to give up on this version, they can't directly profit from it and eventually it will just make more sense to use a version they do own as the "basis".

I mean honestly, just give it time. Do you really care about those early Batman serials or did you just learn about them second-hand?

AquaParade
01-08-2022, 08:40 PM
Well if you're asking me, I'd say again that the shared universe element wasn't what I was referring to.

But I do think the MCU is quite faithful when you compare it to pre-2008 comic book movies. Spider-Man is a poor example for that comparison, because I'd agree with you that in some ways the Raimi versions were more faithful (though in some ways not).

I think its easy to point out where the MCU isn't faithful, but on the whole, it's the most faithful comic book film adaption ever, really. The shared universe is definitely a part of it's unique faithfulness to it's own source material, but that's just one example.

We could point out differences from the source material all day, and I don't see that as a negative, but on the whole, it's easy to see that the MCU is more faithful to it's source than TMNT usually is, no?
The spirit of the Marvel comics is certainly represented in the movies. You can't say that for TMNT, generally speaking. There's no comparison when it comes to which movies represent the source material more faithfully, 1990 film aside.


That all said, just for fun, if Viacom were to take a shared universe approach, which is probably tempting, I'd see them doing it in the current approach of utilizing streaming services. You can't do a Casey Jones movie, but you can do a mini-series on Paramount+. Same for April O'Neil or Oroku Saki.

But, all in all, I really don't think that's the best approach for the property. I think a low-budget blockbuster is where it's at. Along the lines of the 1990 film, or Deadpool, in terms of scope.

Leo656
01-08-2022, 09:45 PM
Yes, I know it's kind of stupid to write a plan for what's obviously a pipe dream. I just kind of find the process of making it somewhat therapeutic.

Fun is fun, brother. You do you, how you amuse yourself in your spare time is nobody else's business. No apology/explanation necessary.


The franchise has already proven itself as a blockbuster contender more than once. First with the record-breaking 1990 film, and again with the opening numbers for the 2014 film, before word of mouth destroyed it. I know it’s easy to be pessimistic, but that’s just not true. There is a proven audience for this stuff. I’m guessing the Seth Rogen film makes it’s money back and then some as well, even if it’s a poor representation of the franchise.

To the bold:
1. TMNT 1990 was mostly a "blockbuster" because it cost ten bucks to make. Yes, it did good business, but it's only barely a "real" movie, it's an indie film that got a studio picture-style release. It's like calling "The Blair Witch Project" a "blockbuster" because it made a million times its budget back; they spent a buck-fitty on it, if it were a "real" movie it would've only been considered a moderate success at best because it would've cost a ton more to make (even if it ended up being the exact same movie, more or less). TMNT 1990, same thing. Its financial success is in direct correlation with the fact it was a nickel-and-dime production. It was a GOOD one, they did a good job hiding the scotch tape, I'm just saying.

2. Yeah, there's a proven audience for TMNT. Every single one of them is 35+ and the pool has been shrinking exponentially every year as people die or get bored of it. There is no "new audience" and it's kind of silly by this point to really expect there to ever be.

Seriously, go wrangle enough "TMNT fans" aged 25 and under to fill a single movie theater. Seeing is believing, I'll believe there's a whole great big untapped audience for TMNT when I see it for myself. So far, all I see is the same 1988 kids doing their own best to keep things going, and nobody else cares.

FW isn't something they can't let go because it has a fanbase that grew up with it.

"Never" is a very long time and we're all gonna die someday. When the last of the "'80s Kids" is in the ground, FW dies with them. Nobody younger than us cares about that show.


When people say the MCU is more faithful than any previous adaptation, I wonder if it's only because of the shared universe concept and relatively accurate costume design.

Oh, definitely. I keep waiting for more people to realize that those movies are really all like, "Yo... this super-hero stuff is dumb, and you're dumb for liking it, you realize this, right?" but people generally don't. They're not in on the joke, and I guess it's because they're all razzle-dazzled by the costumes not looking like sh*t. So many of them are like, two steps more "faithful" than "Batman & Robin" was and yet nobody can see that but me, it seems.

It's like how the 2016 Ghostbusters reboot was all "This Ghostbusters stuff is SO DUMB and you're so dumb for taking it seriously. But whatever, here's a movie, ya goofy manbabies." That's what almost every Marvel movie feels like to me. Although granted, after Avengers 2 I've only seen snippets. But yeah, the entire MCU to me comes off as a giant goof that the audience somehow isn't in on.


But I do think the MCU is quite faithful when you compare it to pre-2008 comic book movies.

This is fair, although that wasn't a very high bar to clear. Before Raimi's Spider-Man flick, the most "faithful" super-hero movie was probably Batman '89, and that... well, everyone at DC initially hated it when it was released, so that just about says it all I think.

AquaParade
01-09-2022, 07:26 AM
Actually, TMNT 1990 was a success in spite of its low budget, not because of it. The movie didn’t just make it’s money back, it was the 9th highest grossing film of 1990, and a huge success by all accounts. Low budget made the film a money-maker for the studio. It didn’t make it a box office success. Huge difference.

And the audience was still there in 2014. The opening weekend did great before word out mouth got out on the film. I highly doubt the age demographic making up the 2014 audience was all 30+, but I’m sure someone can look that up. The property in a ripe spot to aim at all ages. Older fans remember and the property has always appealed to kids.

TigerClaw
01-09-2022, 08:49 AM
Actually, TMNT 1990 was a success in spite of its low budget, not because of it. The movie didn’t just make it’s money back, it was the 9th highest grossing film of 1990, and a huge success by all accounts. Low budget made the film a money-maker for the studio. It didn’t make it a box office success. Huge difference.

And the audience was still there in 2014. The opening weekend did great before word out mouth got out on the film. I highly doubt the age demographic making up the 2014 audience was all 30+, but I’m sure someone can look that up. The property in a ripe spot to aim at all ages. Older fans remember and the property has always appealed to kids.
Yep! TMNT is for all ages, Every generation has its favorite version of TMNT.

Sumac
01-09-2022, 05:20 PM
Yep! TMNT is for all ages, Every generation has its favorite version of TMNT.
I don't think it is the case, since aside from original series an the first movie, every other version of TMNT failed to make a real lasting impression.

Pretty much no-one talks about 2k3 series, very few mention 2k12 series this days and Rise...well...barely a blip on a radar. The same can be said about Bay movies. I would go so far as to say, that even Next Mutation is more remembered than any of the modern TMNT stuff.

AquaParade
01-09-2022, 05:28 PM
Both 2K3 and 2012 were restively popular with kids and lasted longer than the average children’s television program. Then people grew out of them. It doesn’t mean anything, really. I’d say the property is just as capable of gearing at all ages, as any other comic property.

Rise… didn’t catch on, but it hardly resembles what most people think of as TMNT, which probably only strengthens the point.

Leo656
01-09-2022, 06:00 PM
Kids were not the bulk of the people watching the 2003 show, the 2012 show, Rise, or the Bay movies. Not even close. Very few kids paid attention to ANY of that stuff.

"People Who Were Kids In 1988" were the overwhelming majority of people who paid any attention to ANY of it.

This is an oft-proven statement of Pure Fact and yet people keep trying to handwave it.

TMNT has never, and WILL never, prove successful in "growing it's audience into a new generation". They've struck out repeatedly at that. Only the original 80s fans have ever consistently cared. They/We are the ones who've kept everything afloat. Everyone else from 2003 onward has been fair-weather. Few to no "new fans" STAYED fans. If you got into TMNT any later than 1993, there's about a 1% chance you're still paying attention NOW.

I don't see how ignoring consistently-proven facts gets anyone anywhere, nor what point it serves. "I want the brand to stay popular!" Well, it's kinda not anymore. "I don't want the brand to die!" Well, tough, one day it will because everything does. I don't make the rules. The only consistent fact about the universe is entropy. Everything Dies.

Furthermore, we've reached a point where an overwhelming amount of TMNT products that have ever been produced are garbage. A few gems, a whole lotta raw sewage (appropriately). Why care so much? Why fight so hard to "save" it? Sure, there's always been some untapped story potential in it but that potential will never be realized because it's only for nose-pickers, now. So who cares if it dies? Like seriously, does TMNT have to go full-on Paw Patrol before we can collectively agree that it needs to be put out of its misery?

I don't get it, man. If there was ANY good stuff coming out, or on the horizon, that'd be a different story. But it's all crap, it's all GONNA be crap, and it's owned by a company that's not interested in making anything BUT crap. So again, who cares?

Brand had a good run. But it's peak was forever ago and we're beyond mere "diminishing returns" at this point. It's pathetic.

F*ck TMNT. I'm sayin' it. F*ck this franchise right in the goddamn ear.

I don't think it is the case, since aside from original series an the first movie, every other version of TMNT failed to make a real lasting impression.

Pretty much no-one talks about 2k3 series, very few mention 2k12 series this days and Rise...well...barely a blip on a radar. The same can be said about Bay movies. I would go so far as to say, that even Next Mutation is more remembered than any of the modern TMNT stuff.

Yep. Definitely.

Aside from selling 40-year olds their own childhood nostalgia, this brand has no relevance at all. Zero. None.

AquaParade
01-09-2022, 06:03 PM
Yeah, I'd need some type of proof that the majority of people watching 2003 and 2012 were adults.

As for your question regarding why I want to "save" the franchise or whatever, I really don't see it that way. I'm not defending the franchise or trying to save it, I'm just calling it like I see it.

Like, you're free to do your doom & gloom bit. I actually don't think the franchise is in a good place, and I won't bet on Viacom steering it in the direction it should go.
But I'm also not going to pretend the franchise is a dead fish that hasn't appealed to anyone under 35 since it's inception. I'm not going to pretend that it has no potential.

Leo656
01-09-2022, 06:26 PM
Then you're simply in denial. Deep.

AquaParade
01-09-2022, 06:38 PM
About kids watching the 2k3 and 2k12 shows? Nahhh

I mean, none of it has anything to do with denial, but especially not that. I have much more important things to be in denial about. This franchise having potential but being in a bad spot, is just the way it is.

Leo656
01-09-2022, 06:58 PM
There were a few. Nobody's denying there were a few.

But they were at most 10% of the audience watching. And most of them were the kids of people who come to this forum, trying to "educate" their kids about TMNT like "See, this is what I watched when I was your age!" If the kids didn't have their parents trying to shove their own interests down their throats, it's kind of up in the air how many kids would have chosen to watch TMNT of their own volition.

Regardless, it didn't take. ALMOST none of the kids from 2003 (or 2012) stuck around. Their parents did, because TMNT fans have always had Battered Wives' Syndrome. But the kids they tried to expose to TMNT? They liked it for a little while, then forgot about it.

Anecdotally, this forum has always been FULL of those same parents going, "Yeah, I tried to get my kid into TMNT but it didn't stick, bummer." But if you go out into the Real World and ask people, it's very much the same.

I'm not just making sh*t up because I hate what the brand has become. It's simple Observe & Report. OBVIOUSLY a few snot-nosed brats sat down to watch a new TMNT cartoon whenever one gets floated out there. But almost none of them stuck around long. Only ONE generation of kids has ever stayed fans of TMNT for longer than a year or so: Mine.

How many times does the cycle have to repeat itself before people can make peace with the fact that the brand hasn't had any actual penetration with kids since 1993? C'mon now. Furthermore, whenever I say things like "TMNT is actually NOT a kids property", that's exactly what I mean. It by definition can't be a "kids property" because kids haven't cared about it in 30 f*cking years, or at least they don't care for longer than five minutes.

It's like dude, I love MOTU but I'm not gonna stand over here in denial and pretend it's "popular" again (even though it IS arguably more "popular" than TMNT is right now, but that won't last), just because there's been two new cartoons, three new toy lines, and talk of a new movie all within a short span of time. I'm not pretending anyone younger than 35 is watching those cartoons or buying those toys; a few are, yeah, but ONLY the kids of people my age who watched the original. They're not "choosing" to watch MOTU, they're being "fed" MOTU by their parents, just like TMNT. And just like TMNT, they watch it for a few minutes and then get bored with it, because deep down no kid wants to like what their boring old parents liked.

But no, kids aren't the ones buying He-Man toys or watching He-Man cartoons in 2021/2022. They weren't the ones in 2003, either. By next year, the kids playing with the He-Man dolls their Dad bought them for Christmas will be completely over it and forgetting it ever existed. There's no "new audience" for THAT brand, either, and there never will be. All the new stuff coming out isn't a "renaissance", it's a Nostalgia Wave, and it's already peaked and it's already fizzling out; nobody watched the second half of "Revelation", and none of the kids the CGI MOTU reboot was created for are watching it, either, nor are they buying the toys. Only people my age are paying any attention.

Just like TMNT. It's the same f*cking thing. And y'know, that's fine! I don't even care. Stuff ends, and that's fine. But again, just because MOTU is getting way more heat right now than it has in decades, does that make it "popular"? NO, don't be dumb. It's my favorite thing ever but it hasn't been "popular" since 1987, and it never will be again.

TMNT is the same exact thing as MOTU. A nostalgia-act brand kept alive ONLY by people who were little kids 30+ years ago. Nobody else ever has, or ever will, give a sh*t. Not consistently.

The sky is blue, not pink. Wishing it were pink does not make it so, no matter how big a fan of pink you are.

AquaParade
01-09-2022, 07:59 PM
Nah, I’d need more than anecdotal evidence that only 10% of the audience of a children’s Saturday morning cartoon was made up of actual children.
Especially that the technodrome members and their children were keeping the show afloat.
There aren’t even enough dromers with children here to make up even a small portion of the audience needed to sustain a show for over 6 seasons. Sorry, but that’s just crazy to say that those shows were kept alive by the people coming to this forum.

Children cartoon audiences aren’t made up of 90% adults. It’s just not the case with most cartoons and I don’t see tmnt as being a major exception. I'm willing to bet a larger portion than the average cartoon audience were adults, but 90%? No.

You’re confusing the situation, when one of your points to the fact that kids don’t like tmnt, is that they grow out of it. That doesn’t mean kids don’t like tmnt, that means kids grow up.

Unfortunately, with comics as a dying market, the video game market relatively untapped, and stories aimed primarily at children, there is nothing for them to grow into. That doesn’t mean you can’t create a new branch of the franchise that appeals to both modern kids and adults, the same way the MCU or Batman does.

I gotta say, I find this whole back and forth about whether tmnt is capable of appealing to all ages in the same way Marvel does as pretty silly. I mean, we can pick it apart and dissect it but at the end of the day, the brand is perfectly capable of appealing to different demographics and has proven itself in that way many times over. The tricky part is appealing to both at once, but even that was done to a fair extent with the 1990 movie.

It's really not about how popular the franchise is or isn't right now, so we should avoid getting the two subject confused.