View Full Version : New CGI movie
vicsavage
06-30-2020, 11:18 AM
https://www.cbr.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-nickelodeon-cg-reboot/
newfan
06-30-2020, 11:33 AM
Just seen it pop up on the net, I'll wait for Nick to announce before I take it too seriously.
This I.P. is perfect for CGi animated flicks....
NinjaPug
06-30-2020, 11:42 AM
Just seen it pop up on the net, I'll wait for Nick to announce before I take it too seriously.
It's legit. The trades are reporting it.
Seth and Evan are big comic book fans so maybe they'll lean into the Mirage books with this.
Vicky82
06-30-2020, 11:55 AM
So no Live action movie then, but hopefully this will be better than the 2014 and 2016 movies.
I like the 2007 movie but I hope this has the Shredder in it.
neatoman
06-30-2020, 11:56 AM
Does this replace the new PD project or are both still being produced? They can't be the same movie because they have different writers.
RaphaelinSTL
06-30-2020, 11:56 AM
Interesting.
RaphaelinSTL
06-30-2020, 11:59 AM
I would've still loved something more "practical" ... but alas.
newfan
06-30-2020, 12:03 PM
It's legit. The trades are reporting it.
Seth and Evan are big comic book fans so maybe they'll lean into the Mirage books with this.
Just saw, eating my words here :)
As others have said, wonder if it is instead of the PD reboot.
ZariusTwo
06-30-2020, 12:11 PM
Deadline article also says the Rise of the TMNT Netflix movie is still happening, it'll be separate from this
https://deadline.com/2020/06/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-cg-movie-reboot-from-nickelodeon-seth-rogens-point-grey-pictures-1202973764/
SoccerNinja
06-30-2020, 12:19 PM
Deadline article also says the Rise of the TMNT Netflix movie is still happening, it'll be separate from this
https://deadline.com/2020/06/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-cg-movie-reboot-from-nickelodeon-seth-rogens-point-grey-pictures-1202973764/
That was never in question
IndigoErth
06-30-2020, 12:35 PM
Interesting. Kind of hope this is separate from the PD reboot, as I prefer my Turtles live action for the big screen and still want a live action one to be happening, so not real crazy about a fully CGI movie, but if it turns out good then still look forward to seeing it and glad to see more attention given for the TMNT. And get to be this Nick Animation Studio's first CG theatrical film? Pretty cool, hopefully turning out a really good film will be of the utmost importance then.
After weeks of occasional rumors of other things that weren't true, it's nice to finally hear something that sounds like it is.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 12:42 PM
Very interesting that all the rumors were just bubbling to the surface...
BTW, Deadline is pretty dang accurate. I trust this.
The Turtle Terminator
06-30-2020, 12:43 PM
It can?t be worse than the 14 and 16 movies. Surely...
80gmrp
06-30-2020, 12:45 PM
It can?t be worse than the 14 and 16 movies. Surely...
Personally, I didn’t think the 2016 movie was that awful, but as long as it’s based on the more serious side than the kiddy side, I’ll be content. Not giving my hopes up on that front, though.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 12:50 PM
I really won't know how optimistic I am about this until they give us an idea of the story or tone they are going for. This isn't sounding like the live-action gritty take on TMNT I'm still hoping for, but there's definitely potential here.
newfan
06-30-2020, 12:50 PM
Same here, can't have any real feelings until just a little more is known, PG-13 would be nice but even a PG is better than a U. I don't feel this will be the dark and gritty people want but that doesn't mean it has to be the youngest end either. Just gonna have to wait and see what info comes.
Zulithe
06-30-2020, 12:52 PM
I love TMNT 2012 so you know i'm about the CGI.
2007 film story wasn't my thing but it definitely showed the huge potential that's there.
I'm excited for this. I just hope it can win me over since Rise sure couldn't.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 12:58 PM
Lol, all I can find, so far, regarding Seth Rogen's relationship with TMNT:
https://twitter.com/sethrogen/status/463077981985181696
ranger_scout
06-30-2020, 01:27 PM
I think it is smart for Nickelodeon to do a CG animated movie like 2007?s ‘TMNT’ film. Since Seth Rogan is involved I‘d imagine there will still be a large amount of humor.
Sharman
06-30-2020, 01:45 PM
I really won't know how optimistic I am about this until they give us an idea of the story or tone they are going for. This isn't sounding like the live-action gritty take on TMNT I'm still hoping for, but there's definitely potential here.
Yeah, I'm totally on the same wave-length
Diorm
06-30-2020, 01:55 PM
All in CG? I mean... we already got a movie in 2007 and a full series in 2012 all in CG. What can they bring that is new? Unless its a PG 13 CG wich was never done. But they wont. How can you sell figures with a PG 13 CG movie? I need more info. But the news for now is just... meh.
Vicky82
06-30-2020, 02:12 PM
All in CG? I mean... we already got a movie in 2007 and a full series in 2012 all in CG. What can they bring that is new? Unless its a PG 13 CG wich was never done. But they wont. How can you sell figures with a PG 13 CG movie? I need more info. But the news for now is just... meh.
We've had 5 live action movies and 1 CG movie and 2007 movie wasn't by Nickelodeon though. So what else can they do apart from Live action and CG? an animated movie? but Netflix is already doing that with Rise and I don't fancy seeing a animated movie on the big screen.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 02:23 PM
I just imagine that all we need is for Seth Rogen to hit it off with Kevin Eastman when they inevitably do a meet & greet. Then Kevin can let him know what?s good with the Mirage books, if he isn?t already aware (which I can imagine Seth being up on, honestly).
Diorm
06-30-2020, 02:29 PM
It's just that, the 2007 CG movie was cool at the time because it was the first to do CG and we never got anything else. Since then we got a serie that went low and high on a lot of stuff about the TMNT. So a new CG movie is not appealing anymore.
And since we never got a live serie, a live movie is still something new.
Maybe CG that is less cartoony?... But nothing like the look of the last two movies.
NinjaPug
06-30-2020, 02:47 PM
We've had 5 live action movies and 1 CG movie and 2007 movie wasn't by Nickelodeon though. So what else can they do apart from Live action and CG? an animated movie? but Netflix is already doing that with Rise and I don't fancy seeing a animated movie on the big screen.
A CG movie is an animated movie.
Vicky82
06-30-2020, 02:55 PM
A CG movie is an animated movie.
Well cartoon movie then, I always assumed animated movies and CG movies are 2 different things.
Galactus
06-30-2020, 02:58 PM
Can't say I'm all that thrilled at the idea to be honest that this is instead of a live action feature. Flitting back and forth between live action and animated I think gives a bad impression of the franchise as if it can't make up its mind on what direction to
If this is in addition to then then would be better but I'm not sure TMNT is as big as Spider-Man or Batman which can support multiple versions at the same time. Heck as good as Into The Spider-Verse was it hardly set the box office alight.
There is little way this wouldn't be a kiddie fest - albeit a well written kiddie fest. However if this is indeed in addition to a live action feature this may be a solution to the age old Mirage vs Fred Wolf. The cgi animated feature could be like the 80s show and the live action be a Mirage inspired movie.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-30-2020, 03:10 PM
Hooray. TMNT meets the Sausage Party.
Diorm
06-30-2020, 03:10 PM
Or, since 80s nostalgia is a thing right now, they will make a movie that looks like the Fred Wolf serie for the general public.
"Oh yeah I remember those turtles from when I was a kid!"
Hey, that's not what I want, but that may be something they would do.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 03:32 PM
Hooray. TMNT meets the Sausage Party.
Yep. My thoughts exactly. Nothing worth getting excited about here unless you're super-desperate for more TMNT product. The fact that Seth Rogen is producing it tells you absolutely everything. The man never met a fart joke he didn't like. And get ready for all the so very, very subtle allusions to why Mikey talks like he's baked all the time. Treat!
To put it more simply and eloquently:
"Seth Rogen producing a TMNT project?!"
https://i.imgur.com/i7KSh7U.gif
IndigoErth
06-30-2020, 03:53 PM
Hooray. TMNT meets the Sausage Party.
Oh god, I knew there was something animated I should be recalling connected with his name... it was THAT? :tconfuse: Erm. (At least it being Nick will ensure that it won't be the mental image that just put in my head.)
Okay, slightly apprehensive now... Wish it would look more like the Injustice designs and tone, but that now makes me expect something more like the 2012 FW crossover designs at best, which would not be great. edit: I'd be happy with at least an in between option that looked a bit like the 2003 done in 3D animation.
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 04:01 PM
I'm excited for it. It could be a movie with Seth Rogen's style of humor. Now his humor may not be for everyone. But it could be fun.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 04:05 PM
I don't think it's accurate to take anything Seth Rogen is producing and personify it into a walking-talking version of him. Point Grey pictures has produced some pretty good stuff, like 50/50. Plus, didn't one of his companies produce the Preacher television series? I didn't watch it, but I love the comic and it seemed to be faithful in tone to the original stuff without inserting a Seth Rogen laugh-track.
Sure, when we have so little to go on, it can be easy to draw a conclusion like "Seth Rogen + TMNT = Teenage Mutant Stoner Turtles", but I think that is sort of a naive take honestly. Have we seriously never been surprised in Hollywood? People subvert expectations all the time. Todd Phillips directed The Hangover and then directed Joker.
Look, you guys could be totally on the mark, but I don't think it's foregone conclusion by any stretch. There are plenty of ways this could go.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 04:15 PM
Yeah, and Michael Bay was "only" producing the PD movies and his sensibilities had NOTHING to do with the final product. That was all just a happy accident. :roll:
It is what it is. As predicted, the people who love anything with a TMNT sticker and never care if it's garbage will and are doing a jig just because it's More TMNT Sh*t. Anyone with two eyes and any deductive reasoning skills whatsoever sees this train coming from far away, and we're not about to get steamrolled by it. We're way past "once bitten" with this brand by now.
This is just one more pile of dog sh*t on the burning dumpster fire this entire franchise has become. I can't wait for Viacom to shelve this whole stupid brand already instead of shoveling more garbage on the corpse.
F*ck TMNT. There, I said it. F*ck this entire franchise right in the goddamn ear. It's worthless. It died when Nick bought it and anyone who thinks we're ever getting any kind of "renaissance" are just as delusional as those waiting for The Rapture. Y'all deserve to be forever let down for never being able to see the forest for the trees.
F*ck this brand, f*ck this idea, f*ck Seth Rogen, and f*ck Nick/Viacom. F*ck this entire goddamn franchise. It's trash.
Lord Nightwalker
06-30-2020, 04:29 PM
I don't think this going to end well. I expect more of the same dumbed down clowning around garbage, just with a different shade of paint.When real details are forth coming, we'll see. But I full expect to say " I told you so."
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 04:32 PM
Yeah, and Michael Bay was "only" producing the PD movies and his sensibilities had NOTHING to do with the final product. That was all just a happy accident. :roll:
It is what it is. As predicted, the people who love anything with a TMNT sticker and never care if it's garbage will and are doing a jig just because it's More TMNT Sh*t. Anyone with two eyes and any deductive reasoning skills whatsoever sees this train coming from far away, and we're not about to get steamrolled by it. We're way past "once bitten" with this brand by now.
This is just one more pile of dog sh*t on the burning dumpster fire this entire franchise has become. I can't wait for Viacom to shelve this whole stupid brand already instead of shoveling more garbage on the corpse.
F*ck TMNT. There, I said it. F*ck this entire franchise right in the goddamn ear. It's worthless. It died when Nick bought it and anyone who thinks we're ever getting any kind of "renaissance" are just as delusional as those waiting for The Rapture. Y'all deserve to be forever let down for never being able to see the forest for the trees.
F*ck this brand, f*ck this idea, f*ck Seth Rogen, and f*ck Nick/Viacom. F*ck this entire goddamn franchise. It's trash.
This is why we can't have nice things. Because of this up here. ^
Nice to see your support for TMNT. :roll:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-30-2020, 04:37 PM
This is why we can't have nice things. Because of this up here. ^
Nice to see your support for TMNT. :roll:
Marketing plays to the lowest common denominator, the lowest hanging fruit, the "shut up and take my money" crowd. And of course, the exhausted parents wanting to shut up the rugrats for an hour so they can take a nap or play naked twister.
So yeah, it's totally Leo's fault we can't have decent TMNT products. Or Andrew's. Or mine.
In Seth Rogen's defense, I loved "The Interview." And also the romantic political movie he did with Charlize Theron last year... title's escaping me at the moment.
But Rogen and TMNT is gonna be TMNT Sausage Party: Now with more Ejaculate Jokes. Or anal jokes. The man's not picky.
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 04:41 PM
Marketing plays to the lowest common denominator, the lowest hanging fruit, the "shut up and take my money" crowd. And of course, the exhausted parents wanting to shut up the rugrats for an hour so they can take a nap or play naked twister.
So yeah, it's totally Leo's fault we can't have decent TMNT products. Or Andrew's. Or mine.
In Seth Rogen's defense, I loved "The Interview." And also the romantic political movie he did with Charlize Theron last year... title's escaping me at the moment.
But Rogen and TMNT is gonna be TMNT Sausage Party: Now with more Ejaculate Jokes. Or anal jokes. The man's not picky.
You can't assume because Seth Rogen is involved. That movie will be filled with dick and fart jokes. He's done stuff that was family friendly. Though as a voice actor. So we have to give him the benefit of the doubt.
My hope with Seth Rogen in regards to TMNT. If he is one of those fans that grew up with the original series and the 1990 movie. And then he can do a CGI Movie that pays homage to those.
Vicky82
06-30-2020, 04:43 PM
I'm not really excited about this, because this movie will be on the same level as the 2007 movie but with a different story. However I rather have this than another Plantium Dunes TMNT movie.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 04:44 PM
This is why we can't have nice things. Because of this up here. ^
Nice to see your support for TMNT. :roll:
I don't support a f*cking logo on a sticker, pal, I support things worth supporting. Brand Names are meaningless. Grow up and get a clue.
YOU'RE the problem. You and your "If it says 'TMNT' on the label it's a masterpiece by default" horse sh*t. Brand loyalty is a f*cking cancer.
We "can't have nice things" because people in their goddamn 40s are still laughing at fart jokes and think THAT should be The Franchise. That's where this brand ought'a aim. Right at the Lowest Common Denominator.
You and your kind of "fans" can f*ck right off with your noise, pal. You have absolutely zero standards and blindly fall in love with anything that has a brand name sticker on it. That sucks. That ruins things for people with actual standards and taste. You're the entire reason we can only have TMNT products aimed at 5-year olds.
I know you're f*cking proud of yourself but if you had any sense whatsoever you'd be ashamed of yourself for being one of the primary reasons that this franchise is garbage now. "Yay! More garbage! At least it says 'TMNT' on the trash can!"
Every single thing you post about anything makes me sick. Kindly don't ever quote me again because I don't like replying to you. Everything about you disgusts me and it's time someone put you and people like you in your goddamn place. You're the reason the cancer has spread to the brain of this stupid franchise, and you're proud of it. That makes me sick. You have no idea. You have no idea how polite I'm being right now.
If you ever see fit to "call me out" again, I won't be so nice. "Enjoy your craphole, dumbass."
-------------
Seth Rogen is a Professional Buffoon. If he's putting up the money, the project is going to reflect his tastes. That's how these projects work. We already went through this sh*t with the Bay disaster. Kevin Smith might do a worse job, but it'd be the same ballpark of sh*t. If you know how these people think, you KNOW what to expect from anything they're in charge of. You'd have to be a drooling imbecile to think otherwise.
"More comedy" in itself is the last thing this franchise needs. "More SETH ROGEN style comedy" is even lower on the list than that.
Rogen's fans are all exactly like him: middle-aged clowns who still giggle at "Poo-poo pee-pee" sh*t. Perpetual 12-year olds. "Haha, that one farted! An' that one said a dirty word! Haha! Random Pot Reference Here Because That's Edgy!" F*ck Seth Rogen, everyone who looks like Seth Rogen, and anyone who ever paid money to watch his crap.
He was tolerable in 40-Year Old Virgin because he was in it for all of 4 minutes. If he's the guy making the creative decisions, it's gonna be sh*t. Again, you're more delusional than a Bible-thumping Baptist Flat Earther if you think otherwise. Delusional people can't be helped, they're delusional.
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 04:51 PM
I don't support a f*cking logo on a sticker, pal, I support things worth supporting. Brand Names are meaningless. Grow up and get a clue.
YOU'RE the problem. You and your "If it says 'TMNT' on the label it's a masterpiece by default" horse sh*t. Brand loyalty is a f*cking cancer.
We "can't have nice things" because people in their goddamn 40s are still laughing at fart jokes and think THAT should be The Franchise. That's where this brand ought'a aim. Right at the Lowest Common Denominator.
You and your kind of "fans" can f*ck right off with your noise, pal. You have absolutely zero standards and blindly fall in love with anything that has a brand name sticker on it. That sucks. That ruins things for people with actual standards and taste. You're the entire reason we can only have TMNT products aimed at 5-year olds.
I know you're f*cking proud of yourself but if you had any sense whatsoever you'd be ashamed of yourself for being one of the primary reasons that this franchise is garbage now. "Yay! More garbage! At least it says 'TMNT' on the trash can!"
Every single thing you post about anything makes me sick. Kindly don't ever quote me again because I don't like replying to you. Everything about you disgusts me and it's time someone put you and people like you in your goddamn place. You're the reason the cancer has spread to the brain of this stupid franchise, and you're proud of it. That makes me sick. You have no idea. You have no idea how polite I'm being right now.
If you ever see fit to "call me out" again, I won't be so nice. "Enjoy your craphole, dumbass."
If this bothers you so much. There are other versions out there that suits your need. For now. There are versions of TMNT that caters to all kinds of fans. Im being one who fully supports FW, Archie and now IDW. This new Movie will be its own thing. Another universe.
IndigoErth
06-30-2020, 04:51 PM
But Rogen and TMNT is gonna be TMNT Sausage Party: Now with more Ejaculate Jokes. Or anal jokes. The man's not picky.
https://images.gr-assets.com/hostedimages/1425712687ra/13920275.gif
Surely Nick will spare us at least that...
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-30-2020, 04:54 PM
https://images.gr-assets.com/hostedimages/1425712687ra/13920275.gif
Surely Nick will spare us at least that...
Fine. Feces jokes. Kids love feces and flatulence.
Vicky82
06-30-2020, 04:57 PM
Sausage Party is a R rated movie right, so the TMNT movie won't be on the same level as that.
Anyway isn't writer from Gravity Falls writing this movie. I've never seen Gravity Falls but I heard it's good.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 05:00 PM
Don't quote me, I said, guy. I wish you no harm on this Earth and I'm sure you're a good enough guy in Real Life but I'd just as soon we don't speak. Our values are polar opposites apart and I find every single interaction of ours to be distasteful.
People like you are why everyone thinks TMNT fans are manchildren with no taste, and it would be great if you didn't lean into it so much, or had any self-awareness whatsoever.
85 TMNT "universes" already exist and 81 of them are worthless crap. Be nice if we got something GOOD ever again, BUT I GUESS WE JUST DON'T NEED IT THAT BAD. :roll:
But yeah, I know your opinion, don't @ me. I'd sooner vote for AOC for President than I would ever, EVER agree with anything you say. That's as nice as I can be about it. Literally everything you can say to me is wasted text, we're never going to agree so just save yourself. Save us both.
Again, I wish you no harm in this life. I just think everything you say is wrong, quite ridiculously so, so please stay away from me. Be well, have a nice life, but for f*ck's sake don't talk to me. You're terrible for my blood pressure.
IndigoErth
06-30-2020, 05:00 PM
Fine. Feces jokes. Kids love feces and flatulence.
Yes, I don't doubt the butt and fart jokes, so many cartoons are full of them anymore as it is.
Venom
06-30-2020, 05:02 PM
Sausage Party is a R rated movie right, so the TMNT movie on the same level as that.
Anyway isn't writer from Gravity Falls writing this movie. I've never seen Gravity Falls but I heard it's good.
No, he's directing. Brendan O'Brien (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1895993/?ref_=fn_al_nm_2) is writing the screenplay.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 05:05 PM
No, he's directing. Brendan O'Brien (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1895993/?ref_=fn_al_nm_2) is writing the screenplay.
"From the guys who brought you the immortal classics 'Sausage Party' and 'Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates'..." :lol::lol::lol:
Holy sh*t, IT JUST KEEPS GETTING WORSE! Good Lord, we are living in the goddamn Injustice timeline.
Vicky82
06-30-2020, 05:08 PM
No, he's directing. Brendan O'Brien (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1895993/?ref_=fn_al_nm_2) is writing the screenplay.
Ah, ok. I haven't seen any of those movies. I also haven't seen many movies with Seth Rogen in.
2007 are my favorite TMNT designs so far, whether 2d or 3d, I know some don't like them but I loved them. I hope they don't stray too far from them.
frank_one
06-30-2020, 05:14 PM
Seth Rogen? We're doomed.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 05:17 PM
Ah, ok. I haven't seen any of those movies. I also haven't seen many movies with Seth Rogen in.
40-Year Old Virgin is actually good. But that's in spite of Seth Rogen, not in any way because of him. Most of his scenes are simple "Y'know how I know you're gay?" type "jokes". Again, literally everything he does has that "middle school class clown" type of "humor", it's just unavoidable because he's just an overgrown 12-year old (and, as stated, so are most of his fans). Maybe I'm coming off as harsh but it's all provably true just by looking at his body of work, anyone who's seen his stuff can tell you what his sensibilities are. That's true of most entertainers. You either like Jim Carrey or you don't, you like Adam Sandler or you don't, you like Tim Burton movies or you don't. There's very little middle ground on these things, if you know an entertainer you know their "style" and you know exactly what you're getting when you see their name on a project.
40-Year Old Virgin a decent movie altogether, though, in spite of Seth Rogen not because of him. I don't generally like "comedies" because they try way too hard most of the time and are very one-dimensional by design, but that one's actually pretty funny.
Or, since 80s nostalgia is a thing right now,
80s nostalgia has been a thing since the early 2000's, it just hasn't stopped for some reason, 90s nostalgia came but it didn't kill 80s nostalgia, it gave it another lump of air since now people mix and match the decades. Damn, let that decade die.
All in CG? I mean... we already got a movie in 2007 and a full series in 2012 all in CG. What can they bring that is new?
I need more info. But the news for now is just... meh.
Well by that logic...We've already had 3 live action movies and 1 live action show, we've alredy had 3 traditional 2d animated series, we've already had 2 live action with cg movies, we've already had a 2D movie.
I don't even know what you would want, a 4D animated show?
CyberCubed
06-30-2020, 05:30 PM
As long as there are no nostrils or noses on the Turtles, that alone will make it better than the Bay films.
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 05:48 PM
Its funny seeing people thinking that the movie will be at the level of Sausage Party when it most certainly will not. Seth Rogen has done family friendly before. Nickelodeon is involved. They are not gonna let there IP be filled with potty humor and all that stuff.
One of the Turtles probably Mikey is gonna provide most of the humor. But I would love to see Raph have the sense of humor he had from FW. I miss that Raph.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 05:52 PM
Yeah, and Michael Bay was "only" producing the PD movies and his sensibilities had NOTHING to do with the final product. That was all just a happy accident. :roll:
It is what it is. As predicted, the people who love anything with a TMNT sticker and never care if it's garbage will and are doing a jig just because it's More TMNT Sh*t. Anyone with two eyes and any deductive reasoning skills whatsoever sees this train coming from far away, and we're not about to get steamrolled by it. We're way past "once bitten" with this brand by now.
This is just one more pile of dog sh*t on the burning dumpster fire this entire franchise has become. I can't wait for Viacom to shelve this whole stupid brand already instead of shoveling more garbage on the corpse.
F*ck TMNT. There, I said it. F*ck this entire franchise right in the goddamn ear. It's worthless. It died when Nick bought it and anyone who thinks we're ever getting any kind of "renaissance" are just as delusional as those waiting for The Rapture. Y'all deserve to be forever let down for never being able to see the forest for the trees.
F*ck this brand, f*ck this idea, f*ck Seth Rogen, and f*ck Nick/Viacom. F*ck this entire goddamn franchise. It's trash.
It's hard for me to follow the logic of "I have examples of this happening so it will definitely happen 100% of the time, Game over, man!."
I've also seen a lot of projects come from creators you wouldn't expect. Whether that means surprisingly good, surprisingly bad, or just different.
I guess I'm taking the controversial take of "there is a possibility this isn't total ****." :p
Its funny seeing people thinking that the movie will be at the level of Sausage Party when it most certainly will not. Seth Rogen has done family friendly before. Nickelodeon is involved. They are not gonna let there IP be filled with potty humor and all that stuff.
One of the Turtles probably Mikey is gonna provide most of the humor. But I would love to see Raph have the sense of humor he had from FW. I miss that Raph.
I have to agree with this. I don't fault anyone for thinking this is going to blow. But I feel like there are so many gaps in logic on the way to assuming this will be anything like Sausage party. You guys know this thing has to sell toys, right?
newfan
06-30-2020, 06:06 PM
I'd be lying if I said that the more I read the thread (seeing other works) that I wasn't now feeling it could more straight up goofy comedy and less just having an element of comedy. I'll try to reserve judgment still though.
I'd be lying if I said that the more I read the thread (seeing other works) that I wasn't now feeling it could more straight up goofy comedy and less just having an element of comedy. I'll try to reserve judgment still though.
It's all baseless speculation, the movie will be whatever the one fronting the money wants the movie to be.
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 06:13 PM
In the next couple of months or a year from now we'll starting hearing about the casting. Its gonna be interesting to see who they choose to voice the Turtles, April, Splinter, Casey Jones, The Shredder and whoever else that might be in this new CGI movie.
Its interesting where Seth Rogen would take this franchise. Though I would've love to see people like Lord and Miller tackle TMNT.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 06:16 PM
A big Sony producer was just quoted the other day saying that animation development is already on the rise due to the virus and the ease of doing animation work from home. He also commented that because the children's animation market it so saturated, studios are beginning to develop animation for other markets, like teens and adults.
Trends get around in Hollywood. It's worth keeping those comments in mind. I'm not counting on this movie being for adults, but it's plausible that it has an edge to it.
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 06:18 PM
A big Sony producer was just quoted the other day saying that animation development is already on the rise due to the virus and the ease of doing animation work from home. He also commented that because the children's animation market it so saturated, studios are beginning to develop animation for other markets, like teens and adults.
Trends get around in Hollywood. It's worth keeping those comments in mind.
The movie will more then likely be PG-13.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-30-2020, 06:23 PM
Its funny seeing people thinking that the movie will be at the level of Sausage Party when it most certainly will not. Seth Rogen has done family friendly before. Nickelodeon is involved. They are not gonna let there IP be filled with potty humor and all that stuff.
One of the Turtles probably Mikey is gonna provide most of the humor. But I would love to see Raph have the sense of humor he had from FW. I miss that Raph.
It's not going to be at the "adult" level as Sausage Party.
It's going to be irreverent, vapid, hollow, and soulless. And also much less funny than it thinks it is.
Andrew NDB
06-30-2020, 06:33 PM
Ehhh... I don't think a CGI movie is the way to go at all (plus, they've tried that)... but I love these guys. Their humor doesn't always hit, but it mostly does for me. Sometimes hysterically.
Their niche is like "guilty pleasure comedy." Everything they've done has what I would consider to be "heart," though. If TMNT has to go the comedic route, this is the route and hands I'd probably trust it most to.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
06-30-2020, 06:54 PM
Meh. I'd need to see some footage first
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 06:57 PM
I'm curious on who the voice casting will be. They'll get some big names for some of the voices no doubt.
Galactus
06-30-2020, 07:00 PM
As long as there are no nostrils or noses on the Turtles, that alone will make it better than the Bay films.
I was waiting for this post.
Andrew NDB
06-30-2020, 07:21 PM
I'm curious on who the voice casting will be.
I don't care, personally, but yes. It'd probably be Names.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 07:24 PM
It's not going to be at the "adult" level as Sausage Party.
It's going to be irreverent, vapid, hollow, and soulless. And also much less funny than it thinks it is.
Banging the nail right through the board, as usual.
Optimists befuddle me. I could never live with constant, soul-crushing disappointment. I don't root for things to be terrible, I just use deductive reasoning, and that reasoning turns out to be correct at least 95% of the time, so I see no reason whatsoever to switch gears NOW when I'm almost always right. When my gut tells me something is going to be awful, it almost always is. Chickbusters. The BayTurtles Flicks. Every Transformers movie after the first one (didn't see the Bumblebee one though). The last few Terminator movies. Birds of Prey. All of them screamed "This Is Terrible" in every single trailer and bit of pre-release footage, and lo and behold, all terrible. And all the while, there were a few people saying "Maybe this is all a mirage? Maybe there's some hidden layers of depth that the trailers just don't want to spoil for us?" When if they had simply taken the information right in front of their face at face value, they would have known well in advance exactly what they were getting.
I don't get it. When people tell you who they are, and what they're all about, and make no pretense about any of it, listen to them. It's not rocket science.
If Seth Rogen is ANY kind of "TMNT Fan", mark my words, he's one of the ones who watched the FW cartoon and the first two movies, hasn't paid any attention since, and like Kevin Smith and his He-Man project, he thinks the biggest problem with the original series was not enough lesbians and fart jokes, and he's gonna "fix" that "problem" now that he has the pen. That's it, that's all. All the pizza jokes and "Cowabunga", now with 40% more stoner humor. Treat.
Look man, I love Family Guy and Aqua Teen so I totally "get" lowbrow humor. But I don't want TMNT to be that and I don't want anyone with that as their "specialty" anywhere near it. End of story.
ABrown
06-30-2020, 07:43 PM
God it seriously pisses me off that the 4Kids series always has to be the forgotten version of TMNT:
"Following Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles launch in 1984 as a comic book, it was followed up by a hit 1987-1996 animated TV series, as well as a billion-dollar selling retail juggernaut across toys, apparel, video games, and more. New Line released three live-action movies between 1990-1993 which grossed $323.2M WW.
Nickelodeon brought the franchise to life again in 2012 with the CG-animated series Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and then reimagined the Heroes in a Half-Shell with the 2D-animated series Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles last year." - https://deadline.com/2020/06/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-cg-movie-reboot-from-nickelodeon-seth-rogens-point-grey-pictures-1202973764/
I'm sorry but Nickelodeon is NOT responsible for bringing the franchise "back to life".
Leo656
06-30-2020, 07:47 PM
I agree with you. But no pizza jokes, "Cowabunga", no Bebop or Rocksteady or Krang, so... to the simpletons it may as well not have existed at all. And it's so much better than anything Nick has done with the property, you can be sure that it'll never be mentioned again because it would make their current garbage look even worse by comparison.
2K3 was the last iteration that wasn't Highly Goddamn Questionable and probably the last thing like that we'll ever get, but... we don't make those decisions. I agree with you though. That was the last version of the franchise that made me do anything but sigh, the last "new version" that I really, really liked and even loved at times. A pity it's doomed to be entirely forgotten, all because it just wasn't silly enough and "TMNT is supposed to be silly."
I really wish we'd all appreciated it more at the time since it's as good as things will ever be again. It deserves more than to be the "black sheep" of the franchise, but that's exactly what it is. Even Next Mutation gets brought up more, and even spoken of fondly in many cases, compared to 2K3, which gets no mention at all and when it does it's "The Boring Version". If that doesn't tell you exactly what a bunch of glue-sniffers this goddamn fanbase is packed with, I don't know what will.
Good thing the movie isn't going to be for fogeys
Andrew NDB
06-30-2020, 08:02 PM
I'm sorry but Nickelodeon is NOT responsible for bringing the franchise "back to life".
Technically they are. There wasn't much of anything going on in 2009 pre-sale. A comic, barely. Nothing really in the pipeline but a movie that probably wasn't getting made at the trajectory of the time (the "gritty, Batman Begins-like" Fusco script, etc.).
Now, was what Nickelodeon pulled out of the ground any good? No. What they pulled out was like a fetid corpse, some kind of wight, rife with rainbow bandannas and cowabunga and Beebop.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 08:21 PM
I'd just as soon they stuff the corpse back in the ground and pour cement over the hole than get any more of what Nick keeps putting out.
I loved this brand more than almost anything at one time in my life, but holy sh*t is it painful to watch it keep getting butt-slammed in exchange for Happy Meal toys. Any kind of integrity it may have once had is long gone. Better to let it die.
I'm 100% fine with the stuff from Back Then and the occasional new action figure. We don't NEED "new stuff" when it's all so awful. We long ago passed the threshold of TMNT being more Crap than Good Stuff; it's officially like 80% Crap, now, maybe more. It was about 50/50 back in 2003 but we're way past saving things, now. MOST of what now stands as "TMNT" belongs in a dumpster, and the longer it stays "active", the more full that dumpster gets. But we're never going back to it being Mostly Good Stuff; that's not even within the realm of possibility anymore. They can reboot it every decade for the next 100 years, and we might get ONE halfway decent version out of it and the rest would be nothing but garbage, merely taking the last 15 years of the brand into account. It's unreasonable to expect anything different.
I weep when I think of all the potential this brand once had to really BE something. But it never became much of anything - "popular" doesn't equal "Good" - and now it's forever a joke. Simple Things For Simple Minds. Nobody's ever going to bring any kind of respectability to the brand and the fans are always gonna be looked down upon like a bunch of manchild yokels, because nobody cares enough to push back. They're too happy to get anything with that little sticker on it.
It's a shame. Just a goddamn shame. TMNT was one of my Very Favorite Things once upon a time, and now every time I hear any news whatsoever, I cringe. It doesn't even deserve to keep going. It's a farce, and that's all it ever will be. A farce full of wasted potential.
Andrew NDB
06-30-2020, 08:29 PM
Everything I really loved as a kid in, say, the mid to late 90s has been swallowed up and either buried outright or changed into something horrible by Electronic Arts, Viacom, and Disney, respectively.
The day I got into the Sausage Party sneak peek at SDCC and managed to talk to Rogen:
http://imageshack.com/a/img924/7291/jeWQUE.jpg
http://imageshack.com/a/img922/2170/FEgeFJ.jpg
http://imageshack.com/a/img922/7051/HJEEBN.jpg
http://imageshack.com/a/img923/917/8ZocoB.jpg
http://imageshack.com/a/img924/4779/3JQaWr.jpg
He's like a much smarter, more in touch Kevin Smith.
SoccerNinja
06-30-2020, 08:57 PM
I'm excited for it. It could be a movie with Seth Rogen's style of humor. Now his humor may not be for everyone. But it could be fun.
I hope a plane crashes into your house. :)
Sincerely, Commenter42 <3
TigerClaw
06-30-2020, 09:01 PM
I hope a plane crashes into your house. :)
Sincerely, Commenter42 <3
Like I said. His humor isn't for everyone. and probably not for you in particular based on this comment.
Andrew NDB
06-30-2020, 09:04 PM
Sincerely, Commenter42 <3
Whoa... welcome back, man!
Leo656
06-30-2020, 09:10 PM
HAH, no, that's not the appropriate response to That Guy.
This forum needs its own version of ICE to keep people out once they've been banished. A wall would be nice.
The Federales have been notified, here's hoping they act swiftly for once. No Means No. Place is crawling with trolls already.
Andrew NDB
06-30-2020, 09:16 PM
What's wrong with CM42? He should get clemency. Good poster.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 09:21 PM
Not on his best day. Nothing but another troll putting on a front. We just slapped a Temp Ban on one'a them... and BOY is that some "coincidental" timing or what, huh?
The Rules say when you're booted, you stay out. What kind of person's life is so empty that they need to keep crawling under the fence into THIS sh*thole? It ain't like it's Vegas.
The guy was only ever here to stir sh*t. Your fascination with dirtbags and their insistence on sowing discord is bizarre to me. They don't deserve you defending them, especially those who admit that they just like stirring sh*t. This place is full of morons on a good day; morons AND jizz rags, we don't need.
We need to stop letting new people in, period. They're always just some bozo trying to weasel back in after they were booted for more than enough reasons.
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 09:24 PM
Cool pics, Andrew.
I understand being on the pessimistic side of things, I’m unsure about it too, but I just can’t get on the “I already know exactly what this will be and it sucks” train. I think it”s a bit arrogant, with a dash of “I don’t want to be hurt again” mixed in, if I’m being honest.
Idk, to me it’s really not so dire that I have to stamp this thing out into the ground before even giving the creative team a darn chance or even a word on the matter. It’s not so serious that my soul will go “splat” if I keep an open mind and end up disappointed.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 09:36 PM
Well, I'm nothing if not arrogant, so you're not altogether wrong. It's just completely not my fault that I'm always right.
It's statistics and deductive reasoning. Most things ARE terrible. If we acknowledge that as a Factual Statement, which it is, and on top of that if the visible evidence for something suggests it being terrible, then it's silly to disregard the evidence and live in false hope, that's all. It's begging for disappointment. If there's at least a 50% chance that ANY given thing can turn out terrible, and then you add certain other elements into the mix, it becomes VERY easy to predict things, that's all.
I mean Uwe Boll MIGHT have a good movie in him, because sure, anything's possible. Has he ever, or will he ever, actually MAKE a good movie? No, c'mon now, don't be silly.
It's soul-crushing to me because this franchise WAS one of my favorite things and now I hate myself for ever being stupid enough to give a sh*t about it in the first place. I generally don't get involved with anything that's so openly, unapologetically Stupid Sh*t For Morons as what this franchise has become, and the fact that at one time, for 5 minutes, it pretended that it had more potential than that is what enticed me. But no, that was a lie. TMNT really IS "stupid sh*t for morons" if you take it for the entirety of what exists under the branding, and I'm resentful for EVER having wasted my time on something so proudly and openly f*cking vapid.
I know I shouldn't care so much, but I do. I don't like having my time wasted or my intelligence insulted. This franchise has been almost nothing but both of those things for as long as I've been alive and it's only getting worse. Forgive me for finding that tragic. Things can and should be better. That's all.
EDIT: Hahaaaaa, GOT 'EM! Sayonara, F*ck-Face. If he wasn't just gonna come back with yet another fake account next week, I'd be more thrilled, but for now, Whooooooo.
Powder
06-30-2020, 09:41 PM
Ehhh... I don't think a CGI movie is the way to go at all (plus, they've tried that)... but I love these guys. Their humor doesn't always hit, but it mostly does for me. Sometimes hysterically.
Their niche is like "guilty pleasure comedy." Everything they've done has what I would consider to be "heart," though. If TMNT has to go the comedic route, this is the route and hands I'd probably trust it most to.
Pretty much this. It's an odd choice, but not necessarily bad. We can probably be guaranteed a bit of edge & warmth, & gags that will actually land. Might be cool.
If this means the Platinum Dunes movie has been cancelled, it's great news!
Leo656
06-30-2020, 09:46 PM
If this means the Platinum Dunes movie has been cancelled, it's great news!
For me, choosing between letting Seth Rogen handle the franchise, or letting Platinum Dunes keep their hands on it, is a lot like asking me if I'd rather saw my scrotum open with razor wire, or taking an Exacto knife and using it to snip the little piece of skin that connects my bottom lip to my gums.
In a perfect world, neither one of those things would even be in the conversation. They wouldn't even be a supposition or a hypothetical.
This whole year is some Monkey's Paw nonsense. I demand recompense.
neatoman
06-30-2020, 09:46 PM
I doubt the next Platinum Dunes movie is actually canned. I suspect this is like a Spider-Verse scenario, testing the potential of the franchise if you will.
By the way, since that movie will be a reboot, what shall we call the two previous movies? PD might not work anymore, seeing how PD is the production company for that movie.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 10:07 PM
I doubt the next Platinum Dunes movie is actually canned. I suspect this is like a Spider-Verse scenario, testing the potential of the franchise if you will.
By the way, since that movie will be a reboot, what shall we call the two previous movies? PD might not work anymore, seeing how PD is the production company for that movie.
I'unno about that. These things cost money and this franchise isn't exactly raking in the bucks these days. They really took a bath on the last cartoon and toyline, by all accounts, and NOBODY bought the toys based on the two PD movies, I mean absolutely NOBODY bought those toys and those toys were the only reason they made the movies. I kinda don't think they're in any position at all to try and release multiple movie projects at once and pray something hits. Maybe, but I doubt it. They don't have a money tree to shake to their heart's content; the last few most recent TMNT products released lost money. They're desperate, but that also means they have to be frugal. They can't weather loss after loss. So I doubt they have two movies in development, and if so they won't come out anywhere near each other, it'll be years apart if at all. It's like the "Rise" movie people keep talking about; That movie can only happen if they've already spent too much money on it and have to recoup SOME expense, because nobody wants it and it's not gonna make any money. That thing is only gonna come out if they feel like they have to make some of their money back, not because they expect it to make profit.
So there's theoretically THREE TMNT movies in development right now: An animated one based on a failed cartoon that the network is too ashamed to admit was cancelled, another live action PD movie when the last one lost about as much money as the GDP of most small countries, and now this Seth Rogen thing. Odds are slim that ALL of them see the light of day; two of them Nobody Wants, and the newest idea has a pretty slim chance of being decent either. Nick's gonna have to get very picky-choosy, that's just the way it is.
Not trying to be a Negative Nancy, simply being pragmatic. For all of these movies to be released, there'd have to be a promise of profit, and TMNT is no longer guaranteed to make money, they're actually starting to lose more than they pull in with ever-more frequency. It's actually at the point where if they SUCCEED at something, that's the Exception and not The Rule. So putting out three or even two TMNT movies at once... nah, I doubt it. They're not gonna make any money, why accrue that much expense? Older fans are now aware the brand is sh*t, and the little kids have already moved on to the next fad and don't care what comes next for TMNT, they're over it already, it's dead to them. Two or three movies even when the brand was popular would have been overkill... now that it's mostly-dead, that would be absolute lunacy on the part of Nick/Viacom. They're almost guaranteed to lose a fortune if they go that route. Nobody's fault but theirs, of course, but that's what they get.
As for what to call the other two PD movies... I'unno. I just call them "The sh*tty TMNT movies", since nothing else comes close. So far, anyway!
AquaParade
06-30-2020, 11:01 PM
Yeah, I guess I had assumed this takes the place of PD's next film, but I'll be glad if there are two films coming out. Honestly, keep throwing things at the wall for all I care. I just want one thing to stick, and if a mess is made in the meantime, at least it was interesting to watch unfold.
If PD has been canned, I'd love to hear more about it. Not that there would prob be much to learn. Might be cathartic though.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 11:11 PM
Honestly, keep throwing things at the wall for all I care. I just want one thing to stick, and if a mess is made in the meantime, at least it was interesting to watch unfold.
Just curious, and I swear I'm not trying to stir sh*t here, but are you also of the inclination to watch videos of car wrecks and people suffering gruesome skateboard injuries and things like that?
Not saying you are, and not casting any aspersions on your character, just saying that kinda sounds like how Those People talk and it jumped out at me. Like "Man, I'm glad it wasn't me whose brains were spilling on the concrete but damn if it wasn't funny to watch since it was someone I don't know." Some people really say those things.
I personally feel like there's more than enough suffering - and bad movies- in the world and we really don't need more of either, but that's me. I take no joy in watching people flail helplessly, I'd rather they just stay home. Then nobody has to lose and nobody gets hurt.
xChri5x
06-30-2020, 11:18 PM
I don't support a f*cking logo on a sticker, pal, I support things worth supporting. Brand Names are meaningless. Grow up and get a clue.
YOU'RE the problem. You and your "If it says 'TMNT' on the label it's a masterpiece by default" horse sh*t. Brand loyalty is a f*cking cancer.
We "can't have nice things" because people in their goddamn 40s are still laughing at fart jokes and think THAT should be The Franchise. That's where this brand ought'a aim. Right at the Lowest Common Denominator.
You and your kind of "fans" can f*ck right off with your noise, pal. You have absolutely zero standards and blindly fall in love with anything that has a brand name sticker on it. That sucks. That ruins things for people with actual standards and taste. You're the entire reason we can only have TMNT products aimed at 5-year olds.
I know you're f*cking proud of yourself but if you had any sense whatsoever you'd be ashamed of yourself for being one of the primary reasons that this franchise is garbage now. "Yay! More garbage! At least it says 'TMNT' on the trash can!"
Every single thing you post about anything makes me sick. Kindly don't ever quote me again because I don't like replying to you. Everything about you disgusts me and it's time someone put you and people like you in your goddamn place. You're the reason the cancer has spread to the brain of this stupid franchise, and you're proud of it. That makes me sick. You have no idea. You have no idea how polite I'm being right now.
If you ever see fit to "call me out" again, I won't be so nice. "Enjoy your craphole, dumbass."
Wow, you're a specimen for sure. I gotta screenshot this beauty.
Leo656
06-30-2020, 11:24 PM
.....Thanks? :lol:
I mean, glad I could entertain you, I guess. Have I seriously never caught your eye before now, though? You've been here a while apparently. I've been way more mean than that to people. I'm not even drunk today, for one thing.
I mean I was speaking from the heart but it's not even my best "work". ((Shrug))
Wildcat
07-01-2020, 12:09 AM
I dont really care for Seth Rogen movies because Im not into marijuana but its just his company and Nick would obviously not allow a stoner comedy.
I look forward to it but Im not that excited at the moment. Not because of Seth Rogen I just prefer live action. I think it will be entertaining though. I liked TMNT 07.
I love cartoons and animation but when they get adapted into movies I want live action because I want to see them coming-to-life.
AquaParade
07-01-2020, 12:12 AM
Just curious, and I swear I'm not trying to stir sh*t here, but are you also of the inclination to watch videos of car wrecks and people suffering gruesome skateboard injuries and things like that?
Not saying you are, and not casting any aspersions on your character, just saying that kinda sounds like how Those People talk and it jumped out at me. Like "Man, I'm glad it wasn't me whose brains were spilling on the concrete but damn if it wasn't funny to watch since it was someone I don't know." Some people really say those things.
I personally feel like there's more than enough suffering - and bad movies- in the world and we really don't need more of either, but that's me. I take no joy in watching people flail helplessly, I'd rather they just stay home. Then nobody has to lose and nobody gets hurt.
I think the answer here is that to me a failed ninja turtle movie is nowhere near as bad as a hideous car wreck. And I'm minding the fact that you are using an analogy, but I just don't see it as that big of a deal if a tmnt movie is a disappointment. I'm fine following the development, rooting for it like a battered sports team, and hoping for the best. I've never been one to eat up anything and everything TMNT related, but I don't mind giving it a chance.
Andrew NDB
07-01-2020, 12:35 AM
I dont really care for Seth Rogen movies because Im not into marijuana
I'm not either, not even a little bit.
"The Interview"? Still hysterical. "This is the End"? Hysterical. "Pineapple Express"? Eh... a little overrated but OK. "Superbad"? Great!
Wildcat
07-01-2020, 12:45 AM
I'm not either, not even a little bit.
"The Interview"? Still hysterical. "This is the End"? Hysterical.Im not strictly against watching any of them just most of his trailers are portrayed as...plot - but the characters are high.
Is that what theyre actually like?
Leo656
07-01-2020, 12:57 AM
Aqua: As a Mets fan, I can almost understand.
As a rational human being, though, I often wonder WHY the hell I'm a Mets fan, because it just doesn't make ANY sense to be one unless you really, really love being disappointed. It's not like it's gonna improve, it is what it is and it ain't changing, ever. They're not gonna win The Big One, not in my lifetime. I could switch to a team with an actual chance, but I don't actually care enough about baseball to do so, so I really just don't pay attention anymore. Hurts too much to care so much, knowing in my heart that it's just not gonna get better. For my own sake, I had to just stop caring altogether. They'll always be "My Team", but even I fully acknowledge what a goddamn waste of life THAT is.
All the same feelings I get from following the Mets, when I bother, I now get from watching TMNT struggle impotently. And it makes me very, very sad. In both cases, we have a brand that was pretty great once upon a time, but now can't find its own ass with two hands and a map. And I'm sick of waiting for them to get their sh*t together and stop stinking up the joint. If it was gonna happen, it would've by now. If it ever happens, I'll celebrate, but until then... f*ck, man, I can't be bothered anymore. There's too many things that DON'T suck that demand my attention and affection. Things that are good consistently, and not just once every 15 or 20+ years.
In either brand's case, we're a long ways from '87 any way you look at it. And in both cases, I wonder why the hell I ever even bothered in the first place, when the total amount of joy I've gotten is minimal compared the amount of heartbreak and broken promises. If TMNT hadn't EVER been great, once or twice... if the Mets had NEVER won the Series at all... it wouldn't even matter and I wouldn't even care. But they DID touch greatness, once, and now... now it's like they don't even TRY. And in either case they fail because they deserve to, because they expect to succeed just by showing up and that's not how the game is played.
If you never touched greatness at all, nobody expects it from you, so no harm and no foul. But to actually reach that and then just not only fall short, but to forevermore be just fine with mediocrity, or even less than that... well, I can't abide it.
The '86 Series is all that Mets fans are ever gonna have, and the 1990 movie is all that TMNT fans are ever gonna have. That's the closest either one has ever come to being "respectable", or ever will. Doesn't have to be that way, but they made it that way, and that's the way it's gonna stay, forever. At some point, you stop trying to punch out the ocean and just realize that What It Is, Is What It Is, and "What We Hope It Can Be" just doesn't matter anymore.
I mean, if you go up to someone and say "I think the Mets are gonna win it all," they laugh and call you a crazy person, and rightly so. It's generally accepted that it can't happen, won't happen, period. So why is it so unthinkable, so outright impossible to accept, for some people, that TMNT has also had its day and is now just coasting on former glories which will never return? It's exactly the same thing.
I don't know, man. "Hope" as a concept just outright baffles me. Works fine in the context of fictional stories, but in Real Life it seems downright foolish. Most things, statistically, turn out to be Worst Case Scenarios. I don't make it that way, I merely Observe and Report. And I don't try to bring anyone down, I just... have to be realistic. I have to, it's just how I am. I'm far too old and far too jaded to keep saying, "Well... we'll get 'em next year." No, we ain't. Not next year, not the year after... it ain't happening. At some point, even the most hopeful kid realizes that Daddy didn't just go out for cigarettes and he ain't ever coming home. Acceptance has to occur before the healing can begin. If we cling eternally to false hope, there can be no acceptance, and in turn, no closure.
Daddy ain't coming home, and this brand is dead (or at least BRAIN-dead... I don't think anyone could argue THAT, at this point). It might take longer for some people to realize that than others, but... What We Want has nothing at all to do with The Way Things Really Are.
Could've been different, and I'll always wish it was. Part of me wishes I could be all "hopeful" and "optimistic", whether it be about this franchise or just in general, but... that requires a level of naivete and suspension of disbelief that I simply don't have in me anymore, and probably never did. I've always been a Realist, and Realists generally don't have time for anything that isn't quantifiable.
I really wonder in recent years why I ever bothered with this stuff. I was probably enchanted by potential rather than what was actually there, if I'm being totally honest. And that potential is what makes walking away so difficult, even though I know it's something I HAVE to do and even though I know that potential will never be realized. It's frustrating. Part of me feels like, the moment I turn my back, somehow we'll get that great movie or show or whatever, finally. The rational part of my brain knows better, but there's the same little voice in my head that tells battered wives that if they don't overcook the roast tomorrow, then they won't get a beating. That's why they don't leave, and that's why I haven't already turned my back on this brand even though I really can't stand it anymore. When you really love something, the Rational and Irrational parts of your brain are always at odds; you care when you shouldn't, and you don't abandon ship when it's obviously what needs to happen. "Because It Might Get Better Tomorrow".
-------------
Of all the movies Andrew mentioned, the only one I've seen any of that didn't seem like total dreck was "This Is The End". I haven't seen any of them in their entirety, but I've seen bits and pieces of most. They generally reinforce my opinion of, "If this is what passes for 'comedy', then I am apparently not a fan of 'comedy'." But I did see a few bits from "This Is The End" that made me snicker, mostly the Who's Gonna Rape Emma Watson bit. I've been tempted to pick it up but haven't seen it in a $5 bin yet.
I think I saw like 5 minutes of "Superbad" and wanted a house to fall on everyone involved. I'unno man.
sleeplessknight
07-01-2020, 02:58 AM
Wow, I've loved everything Seth Rogan has worked on and I'm super excited to hear this is happening. Superbad is one of my favorite movies ever. I can't wait to see this.
It wouldn't be out of place to have a bit of stoner comedy in TMNT, after all, Townsend Coleman's Michelangelo voice in the Fred Wolf incarnation is based on the Jeff Spicoli character from Fast Times at Ridgemont High. (in an interview, Townsend Coleman specifically says that Michelangelo's voice is based on Spicoli)
I can see some people here are really passionate about their favorite version of TMNT. I've enjoyed the original Mirage comics, the Fred Wolf series (although I must admit everything after season 1 has not aged well), Archie comic series, New Line movies, 2k3 series IDW comics and the 2012 series. I absolutely hate everything else but none of that detracts from my enjoyment of what I did like. I give it a chance and just take it or leave it but acknowledge that not everything has to be made to my tastes.
Also, is a movie really truely "live action" if the main characters are mocapped CGI? I mean, they're not even there, not the same way puppets and guys in suits are. "Live action" just seems like a really fancy and detailed way of saying CGI cartoon to me.
LeotheLateBloomer
07-01-2020, 03:25 AM
I'm not really excited about this, because this movie will be on the same level as the 2007 movie but with a different story. However I rather have this than another Plantium Dunes TMNT movie.
If this means the Platinum Dunes movie has been cancelled, it's great news!
My sentiments to these comments exactly. I'm not a big Seth Rogen guy myself and I'm not excited about this yet. But it could be something cool and as much as I want another live action film, I'd rather not give those clowns behind the last two films anymore chances!
Leo656
07-01-2020, 03:59 AM
My sentiments to these comments exactly. I'm not a big Seth Rogen guy myself and I'm not excited about this yet. But it could be something cool and as much as I want another live action film, I'd rather not give those clowns behind the last two films anymore chances!
The fact that the same people responsible for the last two disasters were even being CONSIDERED for a third swing kind of illustrates how screwy things really are, and how nobody involved with the decision-making for this brand really knows what they're doing, or has any kind of long-term plan. If one thing is for sure, it's that absolutely nobody who had a hand in writing, directing, overseeing, or otherwise "crafting" the last two movies should ever be allowed near the brand again.
Everything I've been reading says there is no third PD movie to come and that that's been the case behind closed doors for at least the past year, they just never formally announced it because they didn't know what else to do yet. This will be yet another "full reboot/reimagining" of TMNT and the PD universe is completely dead and buried, according to all pertinent information as of today. So, there's that at least.
And that's definitely a good thing by any stretch. I'm happy that's all over and done with, because nobody could ever objectively claim those films as any kind of victory (both movies on one disc, for $5, and STILL nobody buys the damn things, they just sit and rot in the bin :lol:). But this is still more of a lateral move than a forward one. It's like saying "Man, I'm glad I only have Hepatitis C and not AIDS." Clearly, man, but c'mon, neither of those things is a "win" and you'd be better off having neither one.
Shark_Blade
07-01-2020, 07:13 AM
I’m excited for it.:tgrin::tlove:
Bring back the cg visuals that I love.
Diorm
07-01-2020, 07:31 AM
Well by that logic...We've already had 3 live action movies and 1 live action show, we've alredy had 3 traditional 2d animated series, we've already had 2 live action with cg movies, we've already had a 2D movie.
I don't even know what you would want, a 4D animated show?
We don't speak about "THAT" live show. :lol:
What I want? A live show that looks like the first movie (or more R rated). At least a new movie that looks like it. I'm not alone.
What kind of person's life is so empty that they need to keep crawling under the fence into THIS sh*thole? It ain't like it's Vegas.
Ok that one got me XD
You're on fire in those posts Leo
CyberCubed
07-01-2020, 09:19 AM
So it's probably going to be like TMNT 2007 was...just for the new 2020 decade. Of course the Turtles designs are of the most importance after seeing the Bay movies and what Rise did with them.
They need to go back to the traditional designs without any gimmicks in order to succeed.
Andrew NDB
07-01-2020, 10:04 AM
It's also worth mentioning that Rogen was a hands-on producer for both "Preacher" and "The Boys," both excellent and brutal shows (especially the latter). He isn't just "stoner movie guy."
AquaParade
07-01-2020, 10:08 AM
It's also worth mentioning that Rogen was a hands-on producer for both "Preacher" and "The Boys," both excellent and brutal shows (especially the latter). He isn't just "stoner movie guy."
I knew he was involved with Preacher and mentioned it earlier but didn't know he was involved in The Boys, which was an excellent adaption. This dude is going to dig the black and white comics. I'm a big fan of the movie "50/50" he produced and acted in. Really good drama/comedy about cancer.
NinjaPug
07-01-2020, 10:15 AM
It's also worth mentioning that Rogen was a hands-on producer for both "Preacher" and "The Boys," both excellent and brutal shows (especially the latter). He isn't just "stoner movie guy."
Exactly. People labeling Rogen like that aren't aware of many projects that he's been involved in. His production company has put out some really good stuff recently.
Andrew NDB
07-01-2020, 10:38 AM
I knew he was involved with Preacher and mentioned it earlier but didn't know he was involved in The Boys, which was an excellent adaption. This dude is going to dig the black and white comics. I'm a big fan of the movie "50/50" he produced and acted in. Really good drama/comedy about cancer.
I also really liked him in "Funny People" with Sandler, one of the rare serious movies from Sandler (where Sandler's character has cancer and Rogen becomes like his apprentice). Though I don't think Rogen had anything to do with it creatively.
TigerClaw
07-01-2020, 11:40 AM
I knew he was involved with Preacher and mentioned it earlier but didn't know he was involved in The Boys, which was an excellent adaption. This dude is going to dig the black and white comics. I'm a big fan of the movie "50/50" he produced and acted in. Really good drama/comedy about cancer.
I rather he look into IDW.
Andrew NDB
07-01-2020, 11:42 AM
I rather he look into IDW.
Eh... no. Unless he just wants to take the reincarnation angle and nothing else.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2020, 11:47 AM
It's also worth mentioning that Rogen was a hands-on producer for both "Preacher" and "The Boys," both excellent and brutal shows (especially the latter). He isn't just "stoner movie guy."
That's a fair point. I was thinking more of his 3D animated stuff (only Sausage Party comes to mind) and forgotten he was involved in those adult comic adaptations. Even though they take some extreme liberties with the source material, they're definitely not for kids.
I'm still extremely leery though. I feel like the odds of "let's do something for fans of the original comics!" is about as likely as Ron Paul getting elected for President. :tlol:
What are the odds Seth Rogen is the torchbearer to show the world that TMNT isn't just for five-year-olds? I'm not betting on it. But I'll sing his praises if he surprises me.
IndigoErth
07-01-2020, 11:47 AM
Since we're getting word of this, I hope maybe some design art leaks aren't far behind. I mean, I know daring to throw anything out there is like baiting the sharks in this (or probably most any) fandom, but some direction will be nice and not let pure speculation, and arguments based on speculation, go on for too long.
That claim a while ago that Playmates would be re-releasing the old school Turtles and something rumored about a new series or whatnot to be announced this spring (and wasn't)... you think it actually had anything to do with this animated movie, not a series?
By the way, since that movie will be a reboot, what shall we call the two previous movies? PD might not work anymore, seeing how PD is the production company for that movie.
Hm, not much else to call it unless it has a distinct title to separate it like OotS does. Other than that I know I'll probably just be calling it "PD [insert year]."
What are the odds Seth Rogen is the torchbearer to show the world that TMNT isn't just for five-year-olds? I'm not betting on it. But I'll sing his praises if he surprises me.
That would be awesome, and would surprise me if Nick allowed it to happen. Though they already did once by letting that Batman vs TMNT movie become a thing, so who knows. (Though I probably will be considering this fully a kid thing until they show us otherwise.)
Would be nice if they finally did embrace the older fanbase who is always there willing to throw money at anything good.
AquaParade
07-01-2020, 11:57 AM
That claim a while ago that Playmates would be re-releasing the old school Turtles and something rumored about a new series or whatnot to be announced this spring (and wasn't)... you think it actually had anything to do with this animated movie, not a series?
My wild guess is that this deal was made quite recently. I'd wager that Platinum Dunes, who last year claimed they would go into production by the end of 2019, were completely stumped on how to move this thing forward and with corona virus stalling things even further, the deal was terminated and Viacom sought something in the animated realm they could get off the ground sooner rather than later, as animation has become a very popular option for studios ever since quarantine began.
Again, I stress "wild guess".
Andrew NDB
07-01-2020, 11:59 AM
What are the odds Seth Rogen is the torchbearer to show the world that TMNT isn't just for five-year-olds? I'm not betting on it. But I'll sing his praises if he surprises me.
I've always said, it just takes one guy with clout who is a real TMNT fan to make it happen.
Plus, think about it. What's more likely... Viacom/Nickelodeon sought out Seth Rogen all on their own one day, inexplicably... or Seth Rogen came up with a TMNT passion project and approached them? I feel like the latter, which is really the only way something good could come of it and not be Product or more McTMNT™.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-01-2020, 12:28 PM
I've always said, it just takes one guy with clout who is a real TMNT fan to make it happen.
Plus, think about it. What's more likely... Viacom/Nickelodeon sought out Seth Rogen all on their own one day, inexplicably... or Seth Rogen came up with a TMNT passion project and approached them? I feel like the latter, which is really the only way something good could come of it and not be Product or more McTMNT?.
Stop it. Dammit, STOP IT. Don't you DARE make me hopeful. :tlol:
Diorm
07-01-2020, 12:36 PM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EBiyGDvX4AU5Qdn.jpg
Then again, what would make Viacom/Nickelodeon interested...
Teddygaming reviews
07-01-2020, 12:40 PM
So it's probably going to be like TMNT 2007 was...just for the new 2020 decade. Of course the Turtles designs are of the most importance after seeing the Bay movies and what Rise did with them.
They need to go back to the traditional designs without any gimmicks in order to succeed.
those designs aren't that bad but they could do with a lot of improving but you can defiantly tell them apart other than the bandanna and weapon and sometimes belt. i am just wondering on the voices tho because at lest with the designs the can change them if they needed to.
CyberCubed
07-01-2020, 07:01 PM
Pretty sure the Platinum dune/Bay movies are over. The second movie did poorly in the box office and everyone involved commented on it and its been a few years later. Even doing a "reboot" with the same company probably isn't going to happen.
I think this new CG reboot is going to be the main movie-verse for the TMNT going forward. That's also why we haven't heard anything from Platinum Dunes in a while, it's most likely shelved whatever they were planning.
Leo656
07-01-2020, 07:06 PM
Both "Preacher" and "The Boys" completely missed the point of the books and were supreme examples of "In Name Only" adaptations. Screw that. Costumes on point, very little else. Anyone who watches the shows and ignores the comics is a fool; anyone who PREFERS the shows to the comics is a goddamn lunatic. No thanks.
You guys sure have a lot of faith in this guy. Not gonna lie, I cannot f*cking wait to say "I told you so." But hey, Y'all Do You. I'll keep a warm crying towel for ya.
Anyways. Cracked is awful nowadays, but they definitely hit the mark with this article:
https://www.cracked.com/article_28131_ninja-turtles-movies-work-best-when-not-played-laughs.html
sgtfbomb
07-01-2020, 07:39 PM
I'm trying to keep my judgments at least until we get an idea of what this look and feel like, but right now, it's not something I am terribly excited about.
On the subject of "bad movies," movies are my passion. I write about them. I love them. And I want to make them. But seeing a bad movie isn't really that big of a deal. I know, I know. "Time is sacred." But it's not that sacred. There are far worse things to do with your time than accidentally watch a bad movie.
Leo656
07-01-2020, 09:17 PM
I think this new CG reboot is going to be the main movie-verse for the TMNT going forward. That's also why we haven't heard anything from Platinum Dunes in a while, it's most likely shelved whatever they were planning.
I missed this before, but yes, according to everything floating around right now, that is the plan. I haven't read a single thing that indicates PD TMNT 3 is ever moving forward. And that wasn't going to even be "PD TMNT 3", anyways, but yet another full-reboot.
They're not going to do two reboot movies parallel to each other, just because one is live-action and the other CGI; they were both supposed to be theatrical releases, with everything that entails. The market can't support that and they can't afford to go that route, either, financially. They can't put two conflicting TMNT movies into theaters, it's one or the other and that's that. This is not a Spider-Man or Batman-level property where they can do that kind of thing. If they were putting out a live-action movie, then the CGI one would be a streaming and disc release; by all accounts, this is going to be a theatrical release, which means the live-action film is done away with. There's a lot more information about it floating around but that's the simplest explanation.
The third PD movie hadn't even gotten past the vague idea stage in three years, anyway; it was never gonna actually happen, they just didn't know what to say about it. And they know how much you guys love to cling to hope in spite of all objective reasoning; to announce formally "No, it's not happening" and then try to manage the fallout of that announcement was more of a hassle than they wanted to deal with.
Same thing with Marvel never doing an R-Rated "Deapool 3", which I also called well in advance and got told I was a loon. It's not happening, they're either gonna make it PG-13 or they're just not gonna do the movie at all, "because they don't need it that bad", as per Liefeld himself and others involved with the project, as of a couple weeks ago. But they don't wanna deal with the hassle of saying "Hey, we lied, sorry," so they're just keeping it very quiet in the hopes that everyone gets distracted and forgets about it. PD handled the TMNT 3 situation the same way; never gonna happen, never WAS gonna happen, but better to let it quietly fade away rather than cause another poutfest by formally announcing "No, it's not happening". Everything Is Spin, remember.
Anyways: This new project supersedes the old one; PD is not doing another TMNT movie, and the CGI movie will kick off the new TMNT movie universe, and carry the torch for the brand until they think that they can actually make money with a "real" movie again. Which could be 10 years from now or never, we'll have to wait and see.
Literally the only "news" we've had in years about PD even wanting to do a third movie, reboot or otherwise, was Kevin Eastman saying "I totally swear, you guys!" And... well... c'mon, man, it's Kevin Eastman. :lol: The actual producers at PD said "No, we're not doing a third one" before the second one had been in theaters for even a week. Why anyone thought they'd change their minds has always baffled me; studios don't actually like losing money and they took a bath on the second one. Third one was ALWAYS wishful thinking, nothing more. Never even existed on paper. Total smoke.
As for this... they better hope more people show up this time than showed up in 2007, regardless of whether the movie is good or not. I get the feeling this is gonna be yet another rude awakening. Quality aside, I'm wondering how many times people are gonna need to be reminded that "TMNT isn't as popular as people think it is" before that actually sinks in. Last CGI movie sh*t the bed. If you're not Pixar, you're fighting an uphill battle in that space, and you have to fight with Disney. Do they have the legs for that? Disney goes out of their way to squash animated movies they're not involved with, and they tell the theaters what to do, so if Disney tells theaters to only run this thing twice a day, that's what they'll do, the thing won't make any money and then we're right back in the hole again.
Lot of odd choices here. I get why they think a CGI movie would be easier - or at least cheaper - than another live-action film, but in reality they might have just created an entirely new set of problems for themselves. First being, the general "CGI movies are not Real Movies" attitude - I don't agree with it exactly, but you can't deny it's a stigma that exists and is very prevalent - and Second being, Disney is a powerful enemy and now they're encroaching on "their" territory once again.
I'm not actually curious about the movie at all, I have a pretty good idea what it's gonna be, but I'm curious about the periphery. The Real Life stuff. Is it even gonna get a fair shake to succeed, regardless of quality? Will people even show up this time, when they didn't really bother for the last three TMNT movies (out of the 2007 movie, and the two PD ones, only the first PD movie really drew a dime, and not by much)? And if TMNT fans DON'T show up, what's the excuse gonna be THIS time?
Definitely gonna be interesting to see unfold from the Real Life perspective. Is this gonna be the first TMNT movie in 30 years to turn a real profit? Eeeeeehhhhhhh, I'm not sure I'd put money on it. But that's me. If they stayed home the last few times, I kinda think it's gonna be more of the same no matter what the movie itself turns out to be. It's just not a "blockbuster" property anymore and only really was for like two years forever ago. "Lightning in a bottle" and all that. But hey, we'll find out eventually. It's just gonna take a lot of luck and a few miracles, going solely on precedent.
The movie will be the direction that 2007 TMNT sequel with more jokes was going to be, it'll try to mimic Big Hero 6. It'll have a more cartoony look than say 2007/2012 designs, more pixar esque. It'll be aimed at a much younger audience than Out of the Shadows skewed. It'll be heavily inspired by Fred Wolf. It'll be more successful than the previous two movies.
The quicker you set your mind that this is what the project is going to be, the less disappointment you'll get when you see the designs and trailer eventually 2 years from today.
AquaParade
07-01-2020, 09:30 PM
Both "Preacher" and "The Boys" completely missed the point of the books and were supreme examples of "In Name Only" adaptations. Screw that. Costumes on point, very little else. Anyone who watches the shows and ignores the comics is a fool; anyone who PREFERS the shows to the comics is a goddamn lunatic. No thanks.
You guys sure have a lot of faith in this guy. Not gonna lie, I cannot f*cking wait to say "I told you so." But hey, Y'all Do You. I'll keep a warm crying towel for ya.
Anyways. Cracked is awful nowadays, but they definitely hit the mark with this article:
https://www.cracked.com/article_28131_ninja-turtles-movies-work-best-when-not-played-laughs.html
1. Nothing wrong with watching the show and not reading the comics. Of course, this doesn't apply to me in the case of Preacher or The Boys, but we've all watched movie adaptions for books we've never read. It's fine.
2. How did The Boys adaption miss the point of the comic? It was pretty faithful and, honestly, Millar's writing in that series can be grating at times. The show was just as good as the comic. I prefer it. It's subjective of course.
Preacher is a different story. I love the comic but a few episodes of the series couldn't draw me in. I can't really speak to it but I heard it annoyed a lot of fans.
3. Wow, that website is unreadable.
Literally the only "news" we've had in years about PD even wanting to do a third movie, reboot or otherwise, was Kevin Eastman saying "I totally swear, you guys!" And... well... c'mon, man, it's Kevin Eastman. :lol: The actual producers at PD said "No, we're not doing a third one" before the second one had been in theaters for even a week. Why anyone thought they'd change their minds has always baffled me; studios don't actually like losing money and they took a bath on the second one. Third one was ALWAYS wishful thinking, nothing more. Never even existed on paper. Total smoke.
Actually, they did announce a third movie on camera, last year. One of them sort of whipped it out while the other looked rather annoyed/shocked and replied "oh, I didn't know we were announcing that." It felt like the dude who announced it just wanted to sound busy with projects (lol), but it picked up steam and seemed possible enough.
Anyways, it's a good thing they are gone.
Leo656
07-01-2020, 10:19 PM
- Garth Ennis wrote The Boys, not Mark Millar.
- Sorry, I know Cracked's entire format sucks now. :lol: Used to be better. The guy's points, however, were solid. It's rare that anyone there even writes a single article that isn't dogsh*t and it just jumped out at me given the entire conversation.
- I could write a book about everything The Boys TV show missed the point of, but I don't feel like it and I didn't see all of it. In brief: Too sanitized, too toothless, too SJW-y, too many things twisted to make almost the opposite points of what the books were trying to say.
Not a bad cast, though. But still not enough to put the show even in the same league as the books, not by a mile.
- There's plenty wrong with watching a TV show or movie and ignoring the written works if you're a person who cares at all about getting "The GOOD Version Of A Story" and not just "Whatever Version Of The Story". I didn't make that rule and it's not my fault it's always true. "Adaptations" are trash by definition. Pabulum for the functionally-illiterate. It's always been that way, but now it's worse because people openly brag about never reading anything. Ignorance breeding more ignorance is all it is, and I don't like it. People should be reading more in general, not bragging about why they don't have to because "I already saw it on TV." That shouldn't be enabled.
- People from Marvel have said "on-camera" that R-Rated Deadpool 3 is also happening, too. Guess what? It's not. I'm not shocked that they lied, but the fact is, in both cases, they lied, to avoid people throwing a tantrum. That's all it is. There was NEVER a PD TMNT 3, not last year, not three years ago, not since PD TMNT 2 tanked. There was just some Fast Talk while they scrambled behind the scenes to try and figure out What Next. Nothing else. People can insist otherwise if they want, and I know plenty of people DO still think there was gonna be a third PD movie, but those people are simply fooling themselves. Some people insist Sasquatch is real, too, in spite of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. It is what it is. I'm not gonna change those people's minds, either, but you can bet that I'm gonna shake my head and laugh at 'em. Sometimes peoples' willful ignorance in defiance of all evidence and common sense is kinda funny.
It's more tragic and annoying, but sometimes kinda funny.
If anything, there was gonna be another full reboot rather than a TMNT 3. That Project somehow morphed into This Project, and now That Project is gone. Very simple.
AquaParade
07-01-2020, 11:04 PM
Thanks for the Garth Ennis/Mark Millar fact check. I get their works mixed up because they're both edgy as hell. I'm a fan though.
Regarding adaptions, we all have a movie or series we love that we haven't read the original work for and that's fine. Not everyone should be forced to drill through the Lord of The Rings tomes in order to appreciate the groundbreaking cinematic work. It's a different experience. Some people just prefer one to the other. Not to mention, someone may read plenty in the time they spend not watching The Boys. It's fine to pick and choose what you read and watch, not everything has to go hand in hand and you're not a fool for enjoying something for any reason ever. I mean, i assume there is a larger point you are trying to make but i get hunt up on details like this.
You're overthinking the third PD film however. People believed they were making a third because they said they were. It's fine. Hollywood is AlWAYS on shaky ground. Look at DC and WB. I mean, we can believe something is happening and not be surprised at all when it falls out from under us. Anyone who follows movie development on the internet understands that. Sure, it was all talk. I don't think anyone is actually *shocked* it's not happening. It's just reasonable to assume it was. Hell, many of us....here...were talking about how bad it *was* going to be.
Leo656
07-01-2020, 11:57 PM
I sometimes have to double-check which is which, too. :lol: We all flub, it happens, I made one today elsewhere, life goes on.
I can mostly distinguish Millar from Ennis because "Millar is the guy who swears he knows Superman better than anyone because he has one of Chris Reeve's authentic capes on his wall, but all of his Superman comic book proposals were absolute trash". :trazz: He and Ennis have both done some good stuff, I think Ennis is quite a bit better, though. I mean, he definitely puts a lot of himself in his work, and as a huge fan of super-heroes it's a bit odd, at times, to be a fan of his work because at times he's confessed that he outright hates them, hates the entire concept of them, and that a lot of The Boys was merely him speaking from the heart and wagging his finger at the reader, but I can't help it, he's a good writer and his points are fair and well-made even if I don't share his position. Like I love Bad Religion but completely disagree with them politically, I just can't help but love their music because it's well-done. Same thing.
Regarding PD TMNT 3, one of the main producers said out loud, while TMNT 2 was still in theaters, that there wasn't going to be another movie. The guys paying for the series said it wasn't gonna happen, while the second one was still ostensibly in theaters making money. That's always a bad sign. Could they have changed their mind later? Yeah, in theory, but why would they do that? To lose even more money? As I keep saying, I don't exist, nor make my points or positions, on "In Theory". I know lots of people do, but to me that's pretty silly. If I'm going to plant a flag, it's going to be based on factual evidence and not supposition. Again, I know that some people just like to shoot the sh*t", as it were, and entertain possibilities that are highly improbable and unlikely; to me, if I wanna masturbate, I'll watch porn.
If at ANY point in the last three years, anyone in power said "PD is doing another TMNT movie", it was nothing but a stall for time, to keep fans from whining to them about it while they figured out how to work the reboot. We all knew *A* movie would come along eventually, but the idea that PD was gonna do another one, even a reboot, was highly, highly unlikely. And all the supposition and speculation was mostly based on, "Well, everyone signed a three-picture deal", ignoring the fact that Hollywood contracts are printed on toilet paper and are just about as durable. Everyone in "Superman Returns" had a three-picture deal, too; still waiting on THAT one, 15 years later. They never "cancelled" it, it just... didn't happen. Same thing.
As for the topic of adaptations... eh, your opinion, your prerogative, I get your point but don't agree. With LOTR, for example, since you've brought it up, I've only seen the movies, but I've read enough ABOUT the books to understand, even as a relative neophyte, that the movies, while visually and musically stunning and inarguably well-acted, are fundamentally flawed in many ways and don't exactly do a great job of translating the material, with a lot of the substance being exchanged for spectacle. And I get that film is a visual medium and all, but it's unfortunate. I hope to read the books one day, but they're massive so I keep putting it off and I'm frankly not THAT big a fan of the property. But again, even without having read them, the books, I can say, are almost certainly better than the movies, and I say that having enjoyed the movies. But there's far too much "Man, they never should have cut/changed that" and a lot of poor choices made, for me to say the movies are "superior" to the books; they're not better, they're just easier to digest.
You're right that any and every individual has the right to be a philistine, but I in turn exercise my right to call them on it. "Elitist", perhaps, but again, it's entirely Not My Fault that not a single filmed adaptation has ever surpassed the printed works on which it was based. Not one, not ever. And it frankly can never happen. Because film, as a medium, simply has far too many restrictions and limitations to ever do proper justice to the stories they try and "adapt", so even if the person adapting it has their heart in the right place, it's still a shallow, inferior work by definition. Just like "All sequels by definition are inferior films"; some, a rare few, are more entertaining than their predecessors, for one reason or another, but they can't exist on their own without the supportive framework of the previous film(s), therefore, they are "inferior" even if by chance they become more entertaining, simply because they rarely stand on their own.
Movies and TV shows which adapt books and other literature are for people who are either too lazy to read or simply lack the imagination to enjoy a story without having certain things spoon-fed to them, such as what the characters look like or what plot points may otherwise be left to inference. Maybe that's not polite to say, but it is true to say. And if a person genuinely feels they shouldn't or "don't have to" pursue the Better Version of a story, whether it's TMNT or Frankenstein, and they're totally satisfied with a one-dimensional, watered-down, fast food version of that story that entirely strips all of the depth and nuance out of it, then yes, that's entirely their prerogative. But there's a word for those people: "Philistines", and it's by default a negative term because people should want to better themselves even if they don't want to. I didn't invent it, but if the shoe fits, etc.
So again, if people want to be philistines, fine. I can't force anyone to do anything even if it's in their own best interest. But they're not gonna preach to me in ignorance about their right to remain ignorant, and that I'm just a Big Meanie for calling them out on the fact that they're lazy and/or obstinate. They spend more time complaining about "I shouldn't have to read" than it would take them to Just Read. That's a choice. And it's one I don't respect.
Arrogant? Perhaps. Even elitist, if one prefers. But I'll own my arrogance. Ignorance is worse. Way, way, way worse. And any time I hear anyone say, "The movie/TV show was better", well... some people like Big Macs more than Prime Rib, too, that doesn't mean they're not totally wrong and crazy for putting that opinion out loud. And I'll keep calling it like I see it, even if that rubs some people wrong. In the end, I'm still right. People can take it or leave it.
Andrew NDB
07-02-2020, 12:01 AM
Never read "Preacher" or "The Boys." But both of those shows were awesome. Far moreso "The Boys."
At the very least, I'm convinced the important people responsible at least read those comics. Not so much for any TMNT project since the sale.
Leo656
07-02-2020, 12:21 AM
You really ought'a just read them already. Knowing you as I do - which isn't entirely, but we've spoken often and for a while - I can say you'll probably like them a lot, and most likely even better. I don't know that 100% but it's not a very bold prediction.
I can't force it, but you'd probably be very happy with both of them. I do hear a few people say that The Boys is... an "acceptable" adaptation. By contrast, I've never met anyone who really liked the Preacher comics who had anything but disdain for the TV show. It's one of those "ONLY people who never read the comics love it, and people who read the comics almost universally hate it" kinda shows. I didn't like it at all. Didn't see much but didn't care to.
The only "roadblock" is that they're pretty long series and tracking down the TPBs can be a pain in the ass. But they get away with stuff they could never do on TV, just for starters, but even beyond that, the points that the shows only touch on superficially, are extrapolated upon and given much, much more room to breathe in the books.
Then there's stuff like how they handled Starlight's sexual assault upon her joining the team, which, again, completely changed the story and missed the entire point about WHY certain events happened a certain way and who some of the characters even were by their very nature. I don't really want to get into it here because this isn't the place for it, but that's one thing the show did very, very poorly by and is in itself indicative of how far off the mark they came at the material from. I'm not even saying it's entirely their fault, it's just... you CAN'T film that book faithfully, you really can't. TV and film have too many restrictions, both creatively and in terms of "We're gonna get phone calls". Thus, they can't tell the story "properly" no matter how hard they tried. They're handcuffed. By default, it's an inferior work.
If you like the shows, you'll probably love the books. The books just have So Much More of everything you liked in the show, but better-written and unsanitized. More violence, more graphic content, better-written characters, more sex, more everything, with no creative handcuffs whatsoever. Again, knowing you as I do, I'd be shocked - absolutely shocked - if you read the books and still liked the show better.
Put it like this... "The Boys" TV show is to the comic book, as the 2K3 TMNT cartoon was to Mirage TMNT. They share some of the same stories, but it's COMPLETELY different in how they present that material, mostly because You Can't Do That On Television. So how you feel about that show's approach in adapting "City At War", for example, is exactly how I feel about The Boys TV show. Heart in the right place, but it ain't as good and never could be.
If you do end up reading them and still like the show better, than I'll buy you some nice vodka or something. :trazz: I just don't see it happening that way. But if you do like the show - and some comics fans do like it - then you really owe it to yourself to check out The Real Version. Even if you don't like it better, you'll almost certainly still like it a lot.
....You will like it better, though. Don't be scared of it, embrace it. :trazz:
Andrew NDB
07-02-2020, 12:25 AM
Actually I did go back and skim quickly over "The Boys," after I super enjoyed the show. I mean, I get it. But it seems like a slightly more 1:1 adaptation of the comics than Mirage TMNT to TMNT 1990, from what I read. Definitely veering off into different ways (as in Danny and Darth Shredder's halfway house of misfit kids) but I was never not engaged.
i.e., the new chick has to blow down the whole group instead of just 1 guy, etc..
Leo656
07-02-2020, 01:06 AM
Partly, but there's more stuff as the series goes on. That one thing is a much bigger change than it appears to be on the surface, though. The fact that in the original story she was "coerced, but willing", and the act of degradation so much more graphic, and the fact that she didn't really need much convincing, and it's more like, in the TV show, she's more presented as flat-out Just A Victim. Because lord knows we can't depict a woman making a choice to demean herself to obtain a favorable position, despite that being a thing that happens every day and in fact would be highly topical - albeit "problematic" - to discuss in light of the whole MeToo thing. Having her be a semi-willing participant in the books rather than "just" a victim changes the entire storyline, changes who the characters are, changes everything, even if it doesn't seem like a big change on the surface. It re-frames everything. And then where in the books, she gradually becomes more morally "gray" as her life gets worse and she loses her moral center and becomes more like those around her, with only Hughie as her "rock" to remind her that there are still Good People, the show has her do a full "babyface turn" early on, stripping her character of much of its depth and cutting out huge chunks of her journey in turn. And she's a main character. And as they explained the change, it was merely because it was too "problematic" to present her that way; in 2019 or whatever, the female protagonist CAN'T be flawed and make poor choices and do bad things, she HAS to only do bad things because she was forced to, she has to be more pristine and perfect than that, and that's not at all who that character is. Starlight's a very, very, very flawed character, but for the show they wanted a more "pure" example of a Strong Woman. But that isn't the character.
Everyone in the books is generally a ton more screwed up. Characterization always suffers in live action because there's just no time to get to know the characters in-depth. But it only reinforces my point about which is the superior medium for telling stories.
That's just for starters, though, but since it's one of the first events that happens in either version of the story, it's a pretty good example of, "You can't change One Thing without changing Everything." The show is... easier to digest, maybe, and more suitable for a mass audience. But right there, we're already watering things down. But aside from that, after like the second episode, it's not even the same story as the books anymore, it becomes TOTALLY different. Stuff like Butcher's affair with Rayner is important to the plot, "Couldn't do it, we'd offend people," they said. Nonsense. All the stuff with "Dakota Bob", Red River and the vast government conspiracy, all either thrown out or watered-down into absolutely nothing. It's a goddamn shame, is what it is.
I'll deign that it's probably better than most adaptations at trying to be spiritually faithful, at least. But they openly admitted that they changed certain things because "We didn't want to offend people", and that's entirely contrary to why that book even exists; not that the book was TRYING to offend anyone, but was very unapologetic about "We don't CARE if we offend anyone." Absolutely nothing was off-limits. The TV show has limits. It tries not to offend certain people, or to not go too deeply into certain topics. That right there, in and of itself, totally violates the spirit of the book. It's watered-down. Sanitized. Which is why I say it "misses the point" even if it gets some of the story beats close.
Based on what I saw in Season 1, there's so much different that I already know for a fact that some of the best stuff that happened later on in the books, just isn't gonna happen in the series in any way, shape, or form. Thus, I'm not very interested. I was disappointed with what I saw, checked Wikipedia to see what was coming next, and it's like "Yeah, nah, that's some weak sauce right there."
The show and the book both start off with the premise, "What if super-heroes were real, and they were all scumbags like the guys on Entourage or whatever?" After that, they have, like, nothing in common besides a few character names and the costumes. It's very, very much "2K3 TMNT" vs. "Mirage TMNT". Which isn't to say that 2K3 was awful, or that this show is awful, but they have a very similar, and similarly shallow, approach to their far-superior source material in both cases.
I do like the cast, though. I think people forgive a lot because of the good cast. I just wish a "real" adaptation were possible. As it is... eh. I can just read the books again. Like I said, some of the Best Stuff from later on simply can't even happen, based on Season One, so... I don't care what they come up with. They already lost me.
You simply can't adapt a story that was designed to push boundaries and challenge people, within a medium that is inherently defined by its boundaries and goes out of its way not to challenge anyone. You can't go from "No Limits" to "Here, Some Limits" without changing the entire thing irreparably. Which is exactly what they did. It has its moments, and I won't fault anyone for being entertained by it, but it is, once again, an inferior work by default.
Technogeek29
07-02-2020, 02:29 AM
So long as we're not digging up that old corpse the OT I can be a little hopeful and so long as it's not going too far into zanny and different for no reason other than "because" You can pop into the ROTTMNT section to read my feelings on that show.
TigerClaw
07-02-2020, 05:32 AM
So long as we're not digging up that old corpse the OT I can be a little hopeful and so long as it's not going too far into zanny and different for no reason other than "because" You can pop into the ROTTMNT section to read my feelings on that show.
I rather get the FW universe. But set in 2020 and not the 80s/90s. Remove all the 80s/90s dressing and add the 2020 dressing. I would love to see how these character act in modern times rather then act like there in the 1980s.
Shark_Blade
07-02-2020, 05:48 AM
I rather get the FW universe. But set in 2020 and not the 80s/90s. Remove all the 80s/90s dressing and add the 2020 dressing. I would love to see how these character act in modern times rather then act like there in the 1980s.
Sounds good.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-02-2020, 05:52 AM
I rather get the FW universe. But set in 2020 and not the 80s/90s. Remove all the 80s/90s dressing and add the 2020 dressing. I would love to see how these character act in modern times rather then act like there in the 1980s.
This is pretty much the last thing I'd want
AquaParade
07-02-2020, 08:04 AM
Leo regularding adaptions, you've opened up and admitted yourself that you watched LOTR without reading the books. Give other people the same liberty without labeling them as fools. Sure, you "read a lot about" those books, but that ain't the same thing.
You are by no means a philistine if you are someone who chooses to watch a movie instead of read a book. You might be a philistine if you ONLY choose to watch movies but read no books, but if I spend all day studying politics and science, then sit down to watch The Boys, without having read the comics, I'll be damned if someone is going to call me a philistine. In conclusion: reading is good. Read, eat your vegetables. But there should be no prerequisite when it comes to enjoying a movie or tv adaption. It's entertainment.
It should be noted that I agree in the fact that adaptions are typically poorer than the source material. That's why I'm always hoping for more original stories with comicbook adaptions, as opposed to an attempt at recreating something that is special, in large part, because of the strengths of the medium it was created in. Different conversation.
Also, I highly recommend the Preacher comic to everyone. It is raunchy as hell, but it has one of the biggest hearts in all of comics. The last issue always gets me.
sgtfbomb
07-02-2020, 09:05 AM
You might be a philistine if you ONLY choose to watch movies but read no books, but if I spend all day studying politics and science, then sit down to watch The Boys, without having read the comics, I'll be damned if someone is going to call me a philistine. In conclusion: reading is good. Read, eat your vegetables. But there should be no prerequisite when it comes to enjoying a movie or tv adaption. It's entertainment.
I very much agree with this. Personally, the notion that "people who disagree with me about movies are intellectually flawed" is a bit daft. Like, if a scientist, doctor, engineer, architect, or psychologist enjoys a movie either better than the book or without reading the book at all, then they are *checks notes* dumb? Come on...
I had a historian friend who enjoyed all those Resident Evil movies, most of which I would classify as genuinely awful, and yet, without flinching, I'd say he's one of the most intelligent friends I have ever had. I'm not trying to downplay knowledge in entertainment. That's been my rabbit hole for 30+ years, that's for sure. All I'm trying to say is there are far more important traits for which we can judge people's character (and intelligence).
Leo656
07-02-2020, 09:15 AM
Those are some pretty deep reaches to pull from just to disagree with a broad point, cats. :lol:
I've moved labs, I've met tons of scientists. Very few of them sit down to read OR watch "The Killing Joke" or "Watchmen" or whatever after they get done with work. :lol: Not the same audience at all, but I do get what you're trying to say.
At some point I really wish people would kind of just accept that I'm judgmental as hell and look down on everyone who isn't me as a general rule. You'll have a lot more fun if you don't fight it.
I do agree that Preacher is amazing and everyone should read it.
AquaParade
07-02-2020, 09:42 AM
No, it is way more fun to fight it. You have strong, intelligent stances and are pretty bullish about them in ways which I disagree.
I'm not complaining, it helps keep this place interesting and the discussions dynamic.
Leo656
07-02-2020, 09:44 AM
Well that's pretty sweet. Thanks.
.....Do you have any pot? :lol: Not... y'know, not "in need", necessarily just... just curious.
I really should've gone to bed. Stupid Instagram.
AquaParade
07-02-2020, 09:57 AM
Well that's pretty sweet. Thanks.
.....Do you have any pot? :lol: Not... y'know, not "in need", necessarily just... just curious.
I really should've gone to bed. Stupid Instagram.
Yes, I do :D.
Redeemer
07-02-2020, 05:50 PM
The movie will be the direction that 2007 TMNT sequel with more jokes was going to be, it'll try to mimic Big Hero 6. It'll have a more cartoony look than say 2007/2012 designs, more pixar esque. It'll be aimed at a much younger audience than Out of the Shadows skewed. It'll be heavily inspired by Fred Wolf. It'll be more successful than the previous two movies.
The quicker you set your mind that this is what the project is going to be, the less disappointment you'll get when you see the designs and trailer eventually 2 years from today.
The eternal optimist I see...... :lol: I do agree we should not get our hopes up for a hardcore tent movie aimed at adults.
I rather get the FW universe. But set in 2020 and not the 80s/90s. Remove all the 80s/90s dressing and add the 2020 dressing. I would love to see how these character act in modern times rather then act like there in the 1980s.
As long as they got rid of the slapstick and had a tone more similar to the first 6 episodes of the original series I would definitely be interested. If its nothing about slapstick and over the top goofiness then I am out.
If this is anything like the 2007 movie, with a better script and villain then I would be all for it. I liked everything about the 2007 movie except the villain and the story surrounding him. I loved the Leo vs Raph sequence. I loved the designs, attitudes and voices for the turtle as well as splinter. Here is hoping!
PizzaPower1985
07-02-2020, 07:59 PM
So there's pretty much little to no Mirage influence on this project?
What's the point for TMNT comics fans to see this then?
neatoman
07-02-2020, 09:28 PM
So there's pretty much little to no Mirage influence on this project?
What's the point for TMNT comics fans to see this then?
We don't know anything about this project aside from who the director, writer, producer and the main tool to render it are. For all we know, it could be the most accurate adaptation to date or it could be the least accurate to date. We should probably wait a while for more details to surface to make such statements. Predicting using their previous works might be a good indicator but says very little about this particular project.
We should probably wait for more details that would suggest a direction. Like who are the villains of the movie? What stories, if any, will it use for a basis? What's the character design like?
D-ray
07-03-2020, 04:54 AM
If it as the same kind of CGI that the 2007 movie, I'm down with it!
Leo656
07-03-2020, 05:12 AM
I didn't really have much problem with the art style. For the Turtles, anyway. They were fine. The human characters, I was less enamored with.
The art style was probably the very best thing about the entire movie, honestly.
Realistically, though, it's a "new version" and they've even gone so far as to call it a "reimagining", so no. It'll be a brand-new art style completely. We'll just have to wait and see what they come up with.
For one thing, you know they'll likely have tons of "pieces of flair" all over them because that's what's hip and trendy, now - and maybe more importantly, far too many "nude" or "Vanilla" versions of the TMNT already exist in action figure form with them just wearing belts and pads. Just being "drawn" different won't be enough to stand out or get people to buy them when there's already the NECA Movie line, NECA FW line, and Super7 lines of toys that all have the "Just Belts and Pads" Turtles represented. So obviously they'll have some of the same stuff the PD Turtles had, like pants and sunglasses and stuff, just because they have to sell more toys that stand out in the market as being "unique" (especially for parents buying this stuff for their kids).
Hope not, I prefer the "simple" look the best by far, and think all the "flair" is pointless and dumb, but they probably will go that way. Just have to wait and see. But I don't think it's a very bold prediction at all. Donnie wearing glasses or goggles or both, for example, has become "standard", now, so you can pretty much put money down on at least that, as well as all the arm and calf wraps and what have you.
I really hope they avoid the temptation they keep caving in to on making Donnie a scrawny, lanky nerd and Raph being a roided-out giant Hulk. I don't even like them having dramatically different body types to begin with, it's very contrived and silly, but the way they go SO overboard with it in recent iterations is really irritating.
newfan
07-03-2020, 05:20 AM
The human characters, I was less enamored with.
.
Some of the human characters had a kinda Disney feel to me.
At least with a theatre release there is a good chance of decent CGI quality (hopes), as others have said, just a matter of waiting to see what they are going for and what designs come up.
Leo656
07-03-2020, 05:24 AM
Some of the human characters had a kinda Disney feel to me.
Little bit. Not sure I really liked it, though. I felt like it was a bit *too* stylized. Never been a huge fan of exaggerated proportions or Big Head/Skinny neck stuff. But that's just an opinion.
PizzaPower1985
07-03-2020, 06:11 AM
We don't know anything about this project aside from who the director, writer, producer and the main tool to render it are. For all we know, it could be the most accurate adaptation to date or it could be the least accurate to date. We should probably wait a while for more details to surface to make such statements. Predicting using their previous works might be a good indicator but says very little about this particular project.
We should probably wait for more details that would suggest a direction. Like who are the villains of the movie? What stories, if any, will it use for a basis? What's the character design like?
I'm sorry. I thought it was mentioned earlier that it was going to be similar to the 2007 film and be containing large bits of humor. If that's not a given, my mistake.
Leo656
07-03-2020, 06:37 AM
Every single news article reporting on it has a line containing some variation of, "It's Seth Rogen, so of course it's going to at least be funny." So nobody's wrong for making the assumption that it will have a lot of... "humor". Pretty much everyone who pays attention is saying that will inevitably be the case. To what degree, well, that we'll have to wait and see.
People hanging onto the fact that he worked on Preacher and The Boys and even entertaining the notion that it might be some semi-gritty, "dark", comics-based piece of work are seriously forgetting that those projects weren't being overseen by Nickelodeon, nor were they CGI (the very fact that it's CGI heavily implies it to be far more kid-centric than anything. CGI = Kids Movie as far as the general audience is concerned, there's honestly no reason at all to suspect this will be an outlier). Seth may or may not have his own preferences or level of "fandom" for TMNT - and I'm still very suspect of that idea, personally - but he's still just a Hired Gun, albeit one with some amount of stroke. But he's still not gonna be the one calling the BIG shots. And even if he was, well... he's still kind of an idiot so he probably shouldn't be the one calling the BIG shots, anyway.
It's Nick, it's CGI, it's gonna be a kid-focused movie with lots of humor with maybe some lowbrow stuff for the Dads and definitely, definitely some low-key stoner humor (probably involving Mikey). None of that is baseless speculation, it's merely a very educated guess based on every single thing we know. You can in fact assume quite a bit, just based on three factors: 1. Nick (= "Kids Movie"), 2. CGI (= "Kids Movie"), 3. Seth Rogen (= "Dumb Movie" :trazz:). You can pretty much guess what you're getting. It might not be literally like "Sausage Party", but it will definitely be a lot more like that than "Beowulf". You can't predict EVERYTHING based on those three key factors, but you can predict a lot. To say "You can't" or even "You shouldn't", well... that's a lie. You can, for sure... "should"? Eh, why not.
Here's a few of my other predictions, based more on gut instincts than anything else:
- Black April
- Prominent Bebop and Rocksteady
- Nerd Donnie and Hulk Raph (it's pretty much mandatory, nowadays)
But those are just based on current trends, both Real World and TMNT-related. They're not things I predict will happen because of Seth being involved, I just think they're pretty much a guarantee, anyway, and in truth his involvement does probably make all three of them more likely. Especially the first two.
If he comes out swinging with a PG-13 Mirage riff, I'll gladly eat a hat, but... there's really absolutely nothing to make a person suspect that will happen. But there's lots of reasons to suspect The Other Stuff.
But yeah, it'll be a "comedy". Will it be "funny"? That... will most likely depend on how each individual feels about Seth Rogen more than anything else.
AquaParade
07-03-2020, 08:36 AM
I guess somewhere along the line I stopped expecting a TMNT movie to be be the product directly aimed at me, were that ever to happen. If this is family-friendly, but still of great quality in the animation, writing, acting, action departments, I'll be pretty happy. I like an edge to my tmnt but can still have great character and drama without those, at least to the level of the 1990 film, which I admit is a tad edgy itself.
I sort of have my mind set on a streaming series when it comes to the ultimate tmnt adaption now. It just seems more viable, given the model.
As for designs, I'm also tired of "hulk raph" and "lanky don", or anything really that that further cements them, heavy-handidly, into one distinct personality type. I know that it is smart character design to bring out the personality however you can through physicality, clothing, etc, but I'd like a more subtle touch.
I do like the "flair" though. I've always loved the looks that Barron and McCarthy were cooking up for their abandoned tmnt sequel.
Leo656
07-03-2020, 09:04 AM
If this is family-friendly, but still of great quality in the animation, writing, acting, action departments, I'll be pretty happy.
To be blunt, that's a balancing act that they've yet to achieve even once for this franchise. 1990 film comes close, but apparently wasn't "family-friendly" enough and some people find the action subpar due to technical limitations. I think those criticisms are mostly bullsh*t and nonsense, but they're things people have said.
Most iterations excel in one or two of those areas. But all of them at once? Seth Rogen? Eh. I doubt he's that good of a puppet-master or juggler or whatever. if I shake my magic 8-Ball and ask it if "The Superbad Guy" is gonna be the one to finally "crack the code" for TMNT... "All Signs Point To No", says my heart and my gut.
Of course, "The sun even shines on a dog's ass some days," according to renowned prophet and scholar Wesley Snipes, but... I just can't see it. I really don't see anyone involved taking the project all that seriously, for a multitude of reasons. Those reasons aren't specifically about him but he's a factor in why I think that, sure. I just don't think anyone handling the brand gives a sh*t about anything except milking it like a tired mama cow, based on the last ten years and every new thing that comes out being worse than the one before it. They're gonna pull the nose up on it NOW? Why bother? They can spend $50 million on a "safe" little animated kids' movie, half-ass it A to Z, make 100 mil or so (which is doghs*t but better than nothing), break even or even make a small profit off of the merchandising, sit back for a couple years and do it again, rinse and repeat. They've shown they don't care what critics think, and they've shown they don't care what the fans think; as long as they break even, they'll just reshuffle the deck, reboot again, and do it every 5-10 years or so. And never once will they have to Try Hard because they know they have a built-in audience that's willing to settle for less. Once you know that for a fact, you're just Elvis playing Vegas. You're never going to reach your former glory and you're never gonna try... but mostly because, you don't have to.
They know they have no incentive to make it "good", so why would they even break a sweat trying? Pride in their work? Pssssssssshhhhhhh. :lol:
Frankly I think they brought Seth onto the project solely to attach a "name" to the project who appeals to a large section of the TMNT audience, and bring along a little "goodwill and reassurance" in the sense that he's everything Michael Bay is not. Also, brownie points for them in the sense that he's been on the news very recently for telling "certain people" that he doesn't want them to watch his films anymore, and is being touted as heroic for doing so. So that gets them a little more attention by putting someone "super-woke" in charge of the project at a time when that's apparently the most important thing in getting your project started.
But ultimately, to put it simply and harshly, I think it's all smoke and mirrors and people are falling for it because they have Battered Wives Syndrome. Maybe I'll be proven wrong, but again, that's genuinely what my gut says. But hey, if not, then good. I suppose I could be wrong... eventually. Certainly hasn't happened YET but I guess maybe that just means I'm due.
PizzaPower1985
07-03-2020, 09:48 AM
To be blunt, that's a balancing act that they've yet to achieve even once for this franchise. 1990 film comes close, but apparently wasn't "family-friendly" enough and some people find the action subpar due to technical limitations. I think those criticisms are mostly bullsh*t and nonsense, but they're things people have said.
Most iterations excel in one or two of those areas. But all of them at once? Seth Rogen? Eh. I doubt he's that good of a puppet-master or juggler or whatever. if I shake my magic 8-Ball and ask it if "The Superbad Guy" is gonna be the one to finally "crack the code" for TMNT... "All Signs Point To No", says my heart and my gut.
Of course, "The sun even shines on a dog's ass some days," according to renowned profit and scholar Wesley Snipes, but... I just can't see it. I really don't see anyone involved taking the project all that seriously, for a multitude of reasons. Those reasons aren't specifically about him but he's a factor in why I think that, sure. I just don't think anyone handling the brand gives a sh*t about anything except milking it like a tired mama cow, based on the last ten years and every new thing that comes out being worse than the one before it. They're gonna pull the nose up on it NOW? Why bother? They can spend $50 million on a "safe" little animated kids' movie, half-ass it A to Z, make 100 mil or so (which is doghs*t but better than nothing), break even or even make a small profit off of the merchandising, sit back for a couple years and do it again, rinse and repeat. They've shown they don't care what critics think, and they've shown they don't care what the fans think; as long as they break even, they'll just reshuffle the deck, reboot again, and do it every 5-10 years or so. And never once will they have to Try Hard because they know they have a built-in audience that's willing to settle for less. Once you know that for a fact, you're just Elvis playing Vegas. You're never going to reach your former glory and you're never gonna try... but mostly because, you don't have to.
They know they have no incentive to make it "good", so why would they even break a sweat trying? Pride in their work? Pssssssssshhhhhhh. :lol:
Frankly I think they brought Seth onto the project solely to attach a "name" to the project who appeals to a large section of the TMNT audience, and bring along a little "goodwill and reassurance" in the sense that he's everything Michael Bay is not. Also, brownie points for them in the sense that he's been on the news very recently for telling "certain people" that he doesn't want them to watch his films anymore, and is being touted as heroic for doing so. So that gets them a little more attention by putting someone "super-woke" in charge of the project at a time when that's apparently the most important thing in getting your project started.
But ultimately, to put it simply and harshly, I think it's all smoke and mirrors and people are falling for it because they have Battered Wives Syndrome. Maybe I'll be proven wrong, but again, that's genuinely what my gut says. But hey, if not, then good. I suppose I could be wrong... eventually. Certainly hasn't happened YET but I guess maybe that just means I'm due.
Why must you ALWAYS say what I'm thinking? You save me a lot of typing. Thanks!
ProphetofGanja
07-03-2020, 09:59 AM
If Into the Spiderverse is any kind of inspiration for this flick, it could be good
Leo656
07-03-2020, 10:09 AM
Why must you ALWAYS say what I'm thinking? You save me a lot of typing. Thanks!
:lol: I just call 'em like I see 'em, brother. All Observe and Report, all deductive reasoning, very little emotion. Never, ever "I hope" or "I wish". That's a sucker's game! What I want them to do or would like them to do... that ain't what they're gonna do so I'm not even gonna pretend it's a factor. I just look at what's In Play, take the current cultural temperature and viola.
Anybody can do it. Anybody can be right all the time if they feel like it. They just gotta get rid of those pesky little emotions that interfere with their objective reasoning skills. "Forecasting" is very, very easy when you realize that nobody cares at all about What You Want. When that's no longer a factor, even hypothetically, all you can do is weigh the evidence that exists and go from there.
I don't claim to speak for other people, but it's cool when I accidentally do anyway. Makes me feel like John Nada in "They Live" and I've just found another ally who's hip to the game. "Put the glasses on!" :lol:
If Into the Spiderverse is any kind of inspiration for this flick, it could be good
The people who own Spider-Man give a sh*t about Spider-Man. That's kind of a huge differentiating factor between Spider-Man and Ninja Turtles. In the eyes of their respective owners, Spider-Man is a cash cow, TMNT is just a cheap whore. That makes all the difference in the world.
AquaParade
07-03-2020, 10:12 AM
To be blunt, that's a balancing act that they've yet to achieve even once for this franchise. 1990 film comes close, but apparently wasn't "family-friendly" enough and some people find the action subpar due to technical limitations. I think those criticisms are mostly bullsh*t and nonsense, but they're things people have said.
Most iterations excel in one or two of those areas. But all of them at once? Seth Rogen? Eh. I doubt he's that good of a puppet-master or juggler or whatever. if I shake my magic 8-Ball and ask it if "The Superbad Guy" is gonna be the one to finally "crack the code" for TMNT... "All Signs Point To No", says my heart and my gut.
Of course, "The sun even shines on a dog's ass some days," according to renowned prophet and scholar Wesley Snipes, but... I just can't see it. I really don't see anyone involved taking the project all that seriously, for a multitude of reasons. Those reasons aren't specifically about him but he's a factor in why I think that, sure. I just don't think anyone handling the brand gives a sh*t about anything except milking it like a tired mama cow, based on the last ten years and every new thing that comes out being worse than the one before it. They're gonna pull the nose up on it NOW? Why bother? They can spend $50 million on a "safe" little animated kids' movie, half-ass it A to Z, make 100 mil or so (which is doghs*t but better than nothing), break even or even make a small profit off of the merchandising, sit back for a couple years and do it again, rinse and repeat. They've shown they don't care what critics think, and they've shown they don't care what the fans think; as long as they break even, they'll just reshuffle the deck, reboot again, and do it every 5-10 years or so. And never once will they have to Try Hard because they know they have a built-in audience that's willing to settle for less. Once you know that for a fact, you're just Elvis playing Vegas. You're never going to reach your former glory and you're never gonna try... but mostly because, you don't have to.
They know they have no incentive to make it "good", so why would they even break a sweat trying? Pride in their work? Pssssssssshhhhhhh. :lol:
Frankly I think they brought Seth onto the project solely to attach a "name" to the project who appeals to a large section of the TMNT audience, and bring along a little "goodwill and reassurance" in the sense that he's everything Michael Bay is not. Also, brownie points for them in the sense that he's been on the news very recently for telling "certain people" that he doesn't want them to watch his films anymore, and is being touted as heroic for doing so. So that gets them a little more attention by putting someone "super-woke" in charge of the project at a time when that's apparently the most important thing in getting your project started.
But ultimately, to put it simply and harshly, I think it's all smoke and mirrors and people are falling for it because they have Battered Wives Syndrome. Maybe I'll be proven wrong, but again, that's genuinely what my gut says. But hey, if not, then good. I suppose I could be wrong... eventually. Certainly hasn't happened YET but I guess maybe that just means I'm due.
Sure, but if you asked your magic 8-ball if the director of the Hangover would direct Joker to the highest-grossing R-rated film of all time, what do you think it would have said? "LMAO. No". How about if Michael Keaton is a good choice for casting Batman, back in the 80's? "You fool."
I think the easiest mistake to make, especially when it comes to those of us who follow movies online, is to put someone into a box. It's the same with the egregious casting blow-back we saw with Heath Ledger, Ben Affleck, etc...
That's why I'm willing to give Seth Rogen a chance. Simply because people break out of the preconceived notions people place on them all the time in the entertainment industry. It's not rare at all and ignoring that is like the CLASSIC mistake you see people making all the time online. I could be wrong in this case, but I think it's a better mindset to adopt and it often serves me well.
I don't think it's at all battered-wife syndrome. I think that implication says more about how you feel about the franchise, quite honestly. Again, I don't see a bad tmnt movie as a "battering". It ain't that serious. At least to me, at this point in the franchise life.
I'll enjoy the comics, the 90's movie stuff, and when a Seth Rogen produced film comes along, I'll shrug and follow along to see what happens. I don't need to be pessimistic, because if it sucks, I'm not going to blow my brains out all over the forum, tbqh. Not saying you will, but I think "battered wife" syndrome implies that it may be more dire for you than it is for me. But who's to say.
Leo656
07-03-2020, 10:34 AM
But you're still gonna care. And you're still gonna hope the next time will be better. That's silly. People need to stop doing that. The term "Battered Wives Syndrome" applies better to this franchise than just about any that I can think of, because for some reason, in spite of ALL evidence and objective reasoning... some people actually think that there'e ever gonna be another good movie. They think Nick actually cares about this property. They're happy whenever a new Nick TMNT project is announced. They keep getting black eyes, but they don't leave. "Battered wives", the whole lot'a ya. If it weren't true, I wouldn't say it. It's painful to watch. And t'were it up to me you all wouldn't suffer needlessly, you'd smarten up and get wise.
Nobody needs to "blow their brains out", but I do care about TMNT and I do care about movies. I think the brand deserves better, and I think Movies Should Always Be Good. They cost a lot of money, and when they suck, it's a waste of resources and a waste of everyone's time who worked on or watched them. And it's vulgar to waste time and it's vulgar to waste money. And it's not necessary; most movies are only Good or Bad because of the care involved in their crafting. Literally ALL you have to do is care sincerely about the results and not the money, and things will generally turn out alright. Start counting the money before you put pen to paper, you're gonna turn out a piece of sh*t, every time. It's something you notice after a while when you really pay attention to this sh*t.
Meanwhile, it's a good brand (or was) that deserves a lot more than it's been given recently. And it's not gonna improve because Nick Doesn't Get It. They only bought the property so they could make it stupid and give kids something to drool over in between Spongebob. It ought to be worth more than that. Never, ever again, though. "You shouldn't care so much." Well, I do. Boo-hoo. I can't help but die a little bit inside when I see things that once had at least a little bit of genuine integrity in their DNA become just another jetski payment for some suit.
Expecting people to Always Aim High and giving them sh*t for not trying isn't a crime. It's what most people should be doing. Nobody has any standards anymore, and it's quite frankly because people aren't anywhere near as judgmental as they should be. People who haven't earned the benefit of the doubt don't deserve it. Simple as that.
I get the point you're trying to make about the other stuff, really. I will say, though, that the way you can tell "The Hangover" and "Joker" were made by the same guy, is that neither one is anywhere near as good or as clever as they each want you to think. ;) So that's the one bit of consistency between them. :trazz:
Anyway. Stop implying, be it subtly or otherwise, I have an attitude problem for telling the truth. Rather, a lot of other people should just admit this brand is being run into the ground and start fighting back instead of saying "Eh, I'll wait and see." No. Don't wait and see. The "Sausage Party" guy is running the ship for the next movie, for f*ck's sake. That's a red flag with skulls and crossbones on it, but people are acting like it's a life raft. Stop it. Y'all ain't gonna be happy until TMNT is literally f*cking Barney or some sh*t, with how it keeps getting dumber and you people keep passively going along with it. And you're gonna cry and wonder how it got like that. And I'll laugh and say I f*ckin' warned ya. If you're all perfectly fine with Less Than Mediocre out of something you used to love, something that used to be Good, then I can't help ya. But I'm not the one with the incorrect attitude.
I might be a pessimist. There's nothing wrong with that. Optimism Kills. But sure, I'm a pessimist, and proudly so. At least I'm not bleeding from the ass, which is more than most TMNT fans can say. I can spot sh*t from a mile away, which is why I can sit just fine. Don't ask me to apologize for speaking Impolite and Inconvenient Truths. I ain't here to make friends, I'm here to set people straight. Somebody gotta do it.
IndigoErth
07-03-2020, 10:39 AM
I hope they go with designs that are more like the Injustice game ones, but less identical. Not too different from each other, but enough variation that you could tell them apart sans gear. To the degree that you could tell who is who if looking at a black and white head shot of the 1990/91 movie Turtles.
Maybe I'm in a minority, I dunno, but never been fond of the 2007 designs. Have always found the design style of the characters (Turtle, human, and otherwise) kind of bland; don't really like the proportions of the Turtles, the head shape, or how the mask sits. I'd rather they avoided anything too stylized in an attempt to be "new." Nor trying to do a total copy of the original films (that's sacred ground there lol)... but the Injustice Turtles are a nice in between.
And please don't reuse or mimic the 2012 FW crossover 3D designs...
PizzaPower1985
07-03-2020, 10:53 AM
Based on these posts, is it fair to say that MOST OF US here want a less cartoon influenced TMNT project, whether it be a full film, mini-series, new tv show etc.????
How adult is YOUR vision compared to what the brand usually offers?
Leo656
07-03-2020, 10:59 AM
I hope they go with designs that are more like the Injustice game ones, but less identical. Not too different from each other, but enough variation that you could tell them apart sans gear. To the degree that you could tell who is who if looking at a black and white head shot of the 1990/91 movie Turtles.
Maybe I'm in a minority, I dunno, but never been fond of the 2007 designs. Have always found the design style of the characters (Turtle, human, and otherwise) kind of bland; don't really like the proportions of the Turtles, the head shape, or how the mask sits. I'd rather they avoided anything too stylized in an attempt to be "new." Nor trying to do a total copy of the original films (that's sacred ground there lol)... but the Injustice Turtles are a nice in between.
And please don't reuse or mimic the 2012 FW crossover 3D designs...
I do love me some Injustice TMNT.
--------------
As for what I'd do if I were booking it? I've said it before: 1990 movie all the way. Obviously technology is better now and people are less pussified about "violence" in movies kids might watch. Even those MCU live-action cartoons have fight scenes in 'em and nobody cries about The Children.
Something done in the exact same aesthetic as the first film with a similar tone, just with the advantages of modern technology. Guys in suits, CGI to the absolute minimum. They never, EVER should have deviated from that in the first place. We should be on our fifth or sixth "true" sequel to The Only Good TMNT Movie by now, not the fourth or fifth reboot project. They've gotta be drooling morons, over there, making such simple sh*t complicated for no reason.
When you've made ONE good movie out of six, don't keep trying to reinvent the wheel or build a better mousetrap. Just go back to what worked, pay attention to WHY it worked, and the rest takes care of itself.
newfan
07-03-2020, 11:23 AM
Maybe I'm in a minority, I dunno, but never been fond of the 2007 designs.
.
In the minority with you there, well, I didn't dislike their over all design, but their faces weren't my favourite. wouldn't be the end of the world though if the movie was decent and they looked like that I guess, could be worse. Can't remember if they had the flatter shells or not, I prefer those to very bulky shells, not a design deal breaker, just a preference. Obviously that's a minor thing to concern about over all :)
PizzaPower1985
07-03-2020, 11:23 AM
I hope they go with designs that are more like the Injustice game ones, but less identical. Not too different from each other, but enough variation that you could tell them apart sans gear. To the degree that you could tell who is who if looking at a black and white head shot of the 1990/91 movie Turtles.
Maybe I'm in a minority, I dunno, but never been fond of the 2007 designs. Have always found the design style of the characters (Turtle, human, and otherwise) kind of bland; don't really like the proportions of the Turtles, the head shape, or how the mask sits. I'd rather they avoided anything too stylized in an attempt to be "new." Nor trying to do a total copy of the original films (that's sacred ground there lol)... but the Injustice Turtles are a nice in between.
And please don't reuse or mimic the 2012 FW crossover 3D designs...
I NEVER liked that either. The entire look of that movie was like a Pixar version of TMNT. It made it feel like it was a kids film. Not good at all. The story wasnt that great either. Plus, having grown up in the 90s I heard A LOT of familiar cartoon voices from kids shows back then voicing minor characters. Jim Cummings anyone? Yeah, that movie stunk. Still, not nearly as bad as the abortion that was PD.
IndigoErth
07-03-2020, 11:33 AM
Can't remember if they had the flatter shells or not, I prefer those to very bulky shells, not a design deal breaker, just a preference.
Yeah, I think they were moderately flatter? Definitely agree on keeping the shells a bit flatter like that of red-eared sliders, not so bulky. The 2012 series seems to be one of the only ones to have gotten that right.
AquaParade
07-03-2020, 11:37 AM
But you're still gonna care. And you're still gonna hope the next time will be better. That's silly. People need to stop doing that. The term "Battered Wives Syndrome" applies better to this franchise than just about any that I can think of, because for some reason, in spite of ALL evidence and objective reasoning... some people actually think that there'e ever gonna be another good movie. They think Nick actually cares about this property. They're happy whenever a new Nick TMNT project is announced. They keep getting black eyes, but they don't leave. "Battered wives", the whole lot'a ya. If it weren't true, I wouldn't say it. It's painful to watch. And t'were it up to me you all wouldn't suffer needlessly, you'd smarten up and get wise.
Nobody needs to "blow their brains out", but I do care about TMNT and I do care about movies. I think the brand deserves better, and I think Movies Should Always Be Good. They cost a lot of money, and when they suck, it's a waste of resources and a waste of everyone's time who worked on or watched them. And it's vulgar to waste time and it's vulgar to waste money. And it's not necessary; most movies are only Good or Bad because of the care involved in their crafting. Literally ALL you have to do is care sincerely about the results and not the money, and things will generally turn out alright. Start counting the money before you put pen to paper, you're gonna turn out a piece of sh*t, every time. It's something you notice after a while when you really pay attention to this sh*t.
Meanwhile, it's a good brand (or was) that deserves a lot more than it's been given recently. And it's not gonna improve because Nick Doesn't Get It. They only bought the property so they could make it stupid and give kids something to drool over in between Spongebob. It ought to be worth more than that. Never, ever again, though. "You shouldn't care so much." Well, I do. Boo-hoo. I can't help but die a little bit inside when I see things that once had at least a little bit of genuine integrity in their DNA become just another jetski payment for some suit.
Expecting people to Always Aim High and giving them sh*t for not trying isn't a crime. It's what most people should be doing. Nobody has any standards anymore, and it's quite frankly because people aren't anywhere near as judgmental as they should be. People who haven't earned the benefit of the doubt don't deserve it. Simple as that.
I get the point you're trying to make about the other stuff, really. I will say, though, that the way you can tell "The Hangover" and "Joker" were made by the same guy, is that neither one is anywhere near as good or as clever as they each want you to think. ;) So that's the one bit of consistency between them. :trazz:
Anyway. Stop implying, be it subtly or otherwise, I have an attitude problem for telling the truth. Rather, a lot of other people should just admit this brand is being run into the ground and start fighting back instead of saying "Eh, I'll wait and see." No. Don't wait and see. The "Sausage Party" guy is running the ship for the next movie, for f*ck's sake. That's a red flag with skulls and crossbones on it, but people are acting like it's a life raft. Stop it. Y'all ain't gonna be happy until TMNT is literally f*cking Barney or some sh*t, with how it keeps getting dumber and you people keep passively going along with it. And you're gonna cry and wonder how it got like that. And I'll laugh and say I f*ckin' warned ya. If you're all perfectly fine with Less Than Mediocre out of something you used to love, something that used to be Good, then I can't help ya. But I'm not the one with the incorrect attitude.
I might be a pessimist. There's nothing wrong with that. Optimism Kills. But sure, I'm a pessimist, and proudly so. At least I'm not bleeding from the ass, which is more than most TMNT fans can say. I can spot sh*t from a mile away, which is why I can sit just fine. Don't ask me to apologize for speaking Impolite and Inconvenient Truths. I ain't here to make friends, I'm here to set people straight. Somebody gotta do it.
I'll still care? Not really. I'll just hope for it to be good and if it's not, that's too bad. I don't think it's fair to say I'd care any more than you would, seeing as we are both willing to discuss it to such great lengths. It's just not an "end of the world" scenario if I give it a chance and it disappoints, which it seems to be to you. You always talk about being a realist to avoid disappointment, and that's fair, but I don't necessarily wear that brand of armor.
Yeah, I do think it's possible that there are more good TMNT stories told. I don't think that's crazy. Franchises go through up's and down's. Even at great lengths. And it doesn't hurt to keep an open mind. I don't feel battered at all, I just ignore the stuff I don't like. It's really not a big deal.
And I thought Nick 2012 was good for the first few seasons. Really quality stuff for "all-ages". It captured the lighter side of the Mirage books pretty well.
Viacom/Nick also just recently greenlit an ending to the Urban Legends series. Do you think they did that strictly to sell toys to kids or to throw a bone to fans? It's a dirty, violent book that doesn't line up with the kiddy TMNT brand that makes big dollars. It's a cool move.
Than there is The Last Ronin and all of the awesome IDW covers we've been getting for years. Good stuff.
Batman Vs TMNT was a step in the right direction.
They've also opened up the license for collector market figures.
Those are all decisions that Nickelodeon made or approved of. If they didn't create it themselves, they handed it off to someone who would.
Sure, if you think everything TMNT since Nickelodeon took over sucks, that might be a different scenario.
I don't feel that way, so the battered wife scenario doesn't apply to me.
I'm not happy with everything that has happened with TMNT since the buyout (PD - obviously, Rise.., the handholding in the IDW comic, etc). I ignore the majority of the content (and obviously merch $$$) that has been produced since then. But they've done some good and in franchise terms, they really haven't owned it for that long. They have room to grow.
So that's my case for not automatically believing anything Nickelodeon produces under the TMNT banner will be utter ****. Not to step on your opinion, that's just where I'm coming from. Nick could be doing better with the franchise, but there has been some good stuff.
I disagree with the bolded. It is fine to "wait and see". In fact, it's more intelligent than making an assumption. That's really the crux of the discussion here for me all else be damned. If the movie appears to be crap, I won't give it any money. That's all you can really do, unless you're going to Snyder-Cut the **** out of the entire TMNT franchise and actually make something happen. Which, in that case, be my guest.
newfan
07-03-2020, 11:37 AM
Yeah, I think they were moderately flatter? Definitely agree on keeping the shells a bit flatter like that of red-eared sliders, not so bulky. The 2012 series seems to be one of the only ones to have gotten that right.
I noticed Henson's were less bulky too when I was last watching the 1990 movie.
IndigoErth
07-03-2020, 11:46 AM
I noticed Henson's were less bulky too when I was last watching the 1990 movie.
True, you're right.
God knows why those PD films thought all Turtle shells are bulky like tortoises. Would have helped a little at least has they skipped going so bulky.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-03-2020, 04:07 PM
I'll still care? Not really. I'll just hope for it to be good and if it's not, that's too bad. I don't think it's fair to say I'd care any more than you would, seeing as we are both willing to discuss it to such great lengths. It's just not an "end of the world" scenario if I give it a chance and it disappoints, which it seems to be to you. You always talk about being a realist to avoid disappointment, and that's fair, but I don't necessarily wear that brand of armor.
Yeah, I do think it's possible that there are more good TMNT stories told. I don't think that's crazy. Franchises go through up's and down's. Even at great lengths. And it doesn't hurt to keep an open mind. I don't feel battered at all, I just ignore the stuff I don't like. It's really not a big deal.
And I thought Nick 2012 was good for the first few seasons. Really quality stuff for "all-ages". It captured the lighter side of the Mirage books pretty well.
Viacom/Nick also just recently greenlit an ending to the Urban Legends series. Do you think they did that strictly to sell toys to kids or to throw a bone to fans? It's a dirty, violent book that doesn't line up with the kiddy TMNT brand that makes big dollars. It's a cool move.
Than there is The Last Ronin and all of the awesome IDW covers we've been getting for years. Good stuff.
Batman Vs TMNT was a step in the right direction.
They've also opened up the license for collector market figures.
Those are all decisions that Nickelodeon made or approved of. If they didn't create it themselves, they handed it off to someone who would.
Sure, if you think everything TMNT since Nickelodeon took over sucks, that might be a different scenario.
I don't feel that way, so the battered wife scenario doesn't apply to me.
I'm not happy with everything that has happened with TMNT since the buyout (PD - obviously, Rise.., the handholding in the IDW comic, etc). I ignore the majority of the content (and obviously merch $$$) that has been produced since then. But they've done some good and in franchise terms, they really haven't owned it for that long. They have room to grow.
So that's my case for not automatically believing anything Nickelodeon produces under the TMNT banner will be utter ****. Not to step on your opinion, that's just where I'm coming from. Nick could be doing better with the franchise, but there has been some good stuff.
I disagree with the bolded. It is fine to "wait and see". In fact, it's more intelligent than making an assumption. That's really the crux of the discussion here for me all else be damned. If the movie appears to be crap, I won't give it any money. That's all you can really do, unless you're going to Snyder-Cut the **** out of the entire TMNT franchise and actually make something happen. Which, in that case, be my guest.
Comic books aren't that mainstream despite the success of Comic book movies (just look at modern Comic Book sales for proof) so having a violent TMNT comic makes sense for Nick. If the comic tanks, then it's only a small part of the franchise and they wouldn't make as much money from that as say, a movie.
A dark TMNT movie will never happen (not officially anyway) because movies are mainstream and could possibly attract millions of people. If a TMNT movie tanks, it's a noticable loss compared to the comic books. Same goes for toy sales and TV ratings. It's where Nick's majority of revenue comes from
AquaParade
07-03-2020, 08:37 PM
Comic books aren't that mainstream despite the success of Comic book movies (just look at modern Comic Book sales for proof) so having a violent TMNT comic makes sense for Nick. If the comic tanks, then it's only a small part of the franchise and they wouldn't make as much money from that as say, a movie.
A dark TMNT movie will never happen (not officially anyway) because movies are mainstream and could possibly attract millions of people. If a TMNT movie tanks, it's a noticable loss compared to the comic books. Same goes for toy sales and TV ratings. It's where Nick's majority of revenue comes from
My point was not that the movie could end up being dark like the comic. My point was that Nickelodeon has done some good stuff since acquiring the license so I don’t feel like I’m being pummeled over and over again for being interested in modern TMNT products.
I don’t think a movie will be any darker than the first movie was, and that’s if we’re lucky. If we are going to get a gritty live-action representation, our best bet is a streaming show. That’s really my dream product for the franchise at this point.
Leo656
07-03-2020, 08:48 PM
If I were gonna do anything with the franchise I wouldn't "Snyder Cut" it, I'd kill it off once and for all, frankly. Let the Good Stuff remain encased in amber so that it could remain unsullied by any future fumbling attempts which will only diminish the overall reputation of the brand. Better to let things die while they're More Good Than Bad. Doesn't mean you can't go back and still watch those things, but it's nice to remember things as being pristine.
Stuff like Star Wars and Toy Story and Jurassic Park all turned to sh*t because people didn't know when to stop milking the cow. They all shouldn't have ever been brought back just to sell more toys, it's not gonna be the same. At one point, these things were all "perfect"; now look at it. You can't say Star Wars without it being, "Three Good Movies and six crummy ones". Toy Story? Three "perfect" movies and one lousy one. Jurassic Park might be the worst offender, with ONE good movie and a lot of crap afterwards.
Wouldn't it be great to remember these things as still pristine and untouchable? Wouldn't it be great if there were no "Godfather III"? Wouldn't it be awesome to remember Elvis thin? I mean let's be real, if Kurt Cobain hadn't shot himself, Nirvana would probably be slumming it at Six Flags by now. He's only legendary because he went out at his peak, long before settling into being a parody of himself.
TMNT was great once. ONCE. And it should have stayed there so it could always be great. Now, when people say "TMNT", it's ALL crap except for "the one or two or maaaaaaybe three times when it wasn't." And that's a goddamn shame.
I say this all the time, but we don't NEED constant subpar reinventions that dilute and bastardize the greatness of any original work. No, they don't ERASE that work from existence, but they do hurt the overall reputation of A Thing once there's officially more bad than good associated with it. All anyone or anything really has is a Legacy, how we're remembered after the fact. TMNT once had a great and mostly-bulletproof "legacy". Now it's all junk except for a couple things. It's gonna go down in history as something that was Officially Stupid, except for once or twice. Boooooooo.
And it's an easily avoidable problem: Don't Be Greedy, and know when it's a good time to pull the plug before the body starts to smell.
I knowwwwwwww, not popular. "We want more toys! We love nostalgia! We've never learned how to move on and let things rest peacefully in the past where they belong because our lives lack purpose and so we seek the familiar comforts of youth!" Believe me, I get it completely.
But like the man said: "Sometimes, Dead is Bettah."
Leo656
07-03-2020, 08:54 PM
I don?t think a movie will be any darker than the first movie was, and that?s if we?re lucky. If we are going to get a gritty live-action representation, our best bet is a streaming show. That?s really my dream product for the franchise at this point.
Never happen, but it'd be our best bet for anything "good" anytime soon, for sure. Someone would have to be really, really desperate for content and very sure that such a project could push a streaming service's subscriptions, though, or else they'd never be able to justify the exorbitant expense.
Snyder's JL is only happening because WB has nothing else to push HBO Max with and nobody wants HBO Max. They've already blown $300 million on JL, another $20-30 million is peanuts at this point, they've got nothing to lose on it, and if even one million people get HBO Max then whatever they put into Snyder's JL is now justified with profit.
A TMNT series would have to be in a similar "We NEED this and we're definitely gonna make money on it" position to ever get the green light, at least a live action one. Because it would inevitably be expensive. But IF? Yeah, that's the one and only chance for anything "good" to come along again.
I think a streaming show will happen at some point but I rather think it'll be another CGI or animated thing, personally. I can't see a ton of people buying any streaming service just for a TMNT show and if it's live action it'll cost too much to be worth it. But I guess it's a nice dream. I'd theoretically support the idea.
AquaParade
07-03-2020, 10:36 PM
I actually don’t think the Snyder-cut is a wise investment for HBO Max, but I’m glad it is happening. I just don’t think the demand and revenue brought in by people driven to the service primarily by the Snyder cut will make up for the expenses.
I think a live action streaming series is possible for TMNT. It nearly happened on Hallmark when the TMNT were at a low point in the public eye, and big budget television series are ten times more common than they were then. Lots of shifting parts in the steaming world right now and companies all want to have premium content going straight into our homes. A lot of possibilities right now so we will see.
Andrew NDB
07-04-2020, 12:23 AM
I actually don?t think the Snyder-cut is a wise investment for HBO Max
How could it possibly not be? It's this thing of 90% of footage never seen.
Leo656
07-04-2020, 02:25 AM
Plus, I forget what the service supposedly costs per month, but all they need is a little over one million subscribers and they automatically made back their $20 million investment in that one project within a month. They'll get one million subscribers easily; not exclusively because of Justice League, but it'll help. It's one of the smartest business decisions they've ever made, frankly. This is easy money in the bank.
AquaParade
07-04-2020, 11:41 AM
Right, but if they don't get the subscribers because of Justice League, than you can't write off the expenses of Justice League with those subscribers. Those said subscribers would be coming for other projects that have their own expenses to make up for. That's not my rule, it's just math.
The more unseen footage there is, the more post production expenses there will be. Everyone involved has made it clear: there is work to be done. That is why this thing is not releasing until next year, despite how desperate MAX is for content right now. This is more ambitious than his original vision.
So "90% unseen footage" sounds good, but it's a double-edged sword in this respect.
My feeling comes from the fact that
Snyder's vision for DC wasn't accepted on a large scale by the public, so they are banking on general curiosity when it comes to non-fans. People feel burned by Zack Snyder. I think it will be one of the most pirated projects over the last few years as well, with people justifying that they already paid for this movie and were ripped off, whether that is true or not.
On the other hand, there is the possibility that this earns them some goodwill with the fans, but some of that credit will be too little too late, seeing as they've already bailed on a lot of the projects these stars were involved in.
Again, it's a unanimous win for Zach, the fans, myself included. I'm just not convinced it will be worth the expensive undertaking.
An HBO max exec even let it slip a few months ago that this thing was more expensive than the number that was making the rounds. He said something to the effect of "I WISH it cost that much".
PizzaPower1985
07-04-2020, 11:54 AM
Right, but if they don't get the subscribers because of Justice League, than you can't write off the expenses of Justice League with those subscribers. Those said subscribers would be coming for other projects that have their own expenses to make up for. That's not my rule, it's just math.
The more unseen footage there is, the more post production expenses there will be. Everyone involved has made it clear: there is work to be done. This is seemingly more ambitious than his original vision.
So "90% unseen footage" sounds good, but it's a double-edged sword in this respect.
My feeling comes from the fact that
Snyder's version wasn't accepted on a large scale by the public, so they are banking on general curiosity when it comes to non-fans. I think it will be one of the most pirated projects over the last few years as well, with people justifying that they already paid for this movie and were ripped off, whether that is true or not.
On the other hand, there is the possibility that this earns them some goodwill with the fans, but some of that credit will be too little too late, seeing as they've already bailed on a lot of the projects these stars were involved in.
Again, it's a unanimous win for Zach, the fans, myself included. I'm just not convinced it will be worth the expensive undertaking.
An HBO ma. Exec even let it slip a few months ago that this thing was more expensive than the number that was making the rounds. He said something to the effect of "I WISH it cost that much".
What about those of us who are big superhero fans but generally find superhero movies, particularly in the last decade, to be not worth the celluloid they're printed on? I've watched all the DCU and Marvel films, unfortunately. Are we supposed to get excited over a new cut of a film that generally was awful but had some decent acting? If it's 90% new footage (and it won't be) that doesn't change the fact that the film was miscast, had pacing and plot issues and presented the Justice League in name only.
I guess if they hype it up tho, droves of superhero fans will flock to the theater because of loyalty and battered wife syndrome.
Chris
07-05-2020, 03:51 AM
At this point I'm going to be optimistic and hope for the best. If it's good, great. If it's bad then I'll just ignore it like the PD movies and Rise series. I still have the IDW series I'm enjoying and the old stuff I like isn't going anywhere. At this point I've accepted most of what they do isn't going to be aimed at me and I've made peace with that.
On the Snyder JL thing it makes sense as HBO Max badly needs original content. It's a big, iconic brand and can be mostly completed whilst Hollywood is shut down. I do believe the Snyder Cut fanbase is more vocal than it is large, not saying it's small but reading some comments online you'd think this was the second coming of Snyder's DCEU, people seem to have forgotten that the general audience rejecting his vision is what led to the JL mess in the first place. In terms of publicity for HBO Max it's probably already justified the expense and I can see him getting a season 2 to complete his intended arc on HBO Max but I don't believe he will get any influence on the future direction of the universe on the big screen.
AquaParade
07-05-2020, 07:39 PM
Regarding cost of Zack Snyder's JL:
https://www.google.com/amp/s/observer.com/2020/05/snyder-cut-budget-hbo-max-bob-greenblat-cost-justice-league/amp/
"Greenblatt described the process as 'a radical rethinking of that movie' and 'complicated and wildly expensive. Which is, of course, a number I won't quote...I'll just say I wish it was $30 million and stop there.'"
This isn't going to be easy to make back, especially after the reception Zack Snyder's previous work received from the general audience.
Aside from that, It sure has gotten a lot of publicity lately so hopefully that helps it out. I'm very much looking forward to watching this from my couch. What a treat.
Leo656
07-05-2020, 08:11 PM
Well either they sincerely think they'll make their money back or somebody got a BJ, I'unno what to tell you. :lol: Things like this don't happen if they think they're gonna LOSE money, that's all I know. It wasn't a knee-jerk decision after all. People don't just do the exact opposite of what they spend years saying they're gonna do (or not do). Not unless someone expects big returns.
The fact that the entire narrative for the last few years was "No... no... no... no... NO.... oh, wait... Yes." kinda makes me think someone must've looked at the math before committing to the idea. There was no "creative" reason to push forward since they did all they could to bury it. To do a complete flip, someone sees bank. Nothing else makes sense.
Unless, of course, someone got a BJ. :lol: That too can change a lot of things. But I don't count on that being the answer.
AquaParade
07-05-2020, 08:15 PM
Well, no one ever plans to lose money in Hollywood, but we see it happen anyway. I don't see why this project would be shielded from that reality.
Leo656
07-05-2020, 08:40 PM
I just feel like very few projects have had to "fight to be seen" as much as that one has, and that if they didn't see a slam dunk they wouldn't even bother with it. It's just weird. They did everything they could to discourage it. Greed is King; if they thought there was any chance of taking another loss, they'd leave it buried.
I just think that when a risk-averse company like WB, who can't take a sh*t without asking people if it's okay that they wipe too, suddenly changes their mind so completely, the only possible reason can be that Profits Are Inevitable.
There's Desperate and there's Crazy, after all. Obviously they're desperate, but taking on another sinkhole would be lunacy. I'unno, I'm inclined to think there's gotta be something about the whole thing that They Know and We Don't. Because it just doesn't make a lot of sense for them to even be doing it on any level, but they are.
If I were the guy in the office booking it, I wouldn't press ahead unless some suit showed me in black and white how we were 99% guaranteed to profit before taking on such a risky venture after years of burying it outright. Kinda feel like whoever did make the decision feels the same. WB is generally incompetent but I have to feel like someone counted ALL the beans before they committed to this.
At least, one would think/hope. :lol:
sgtfbomb
07-10-2020, 05:43 PM
I actually don?t think the Snyder-cut is a wise investment for HBO Max.
I can see why you think that, but I kinda disagree. With everything that's going on right now, studios/streaming platforms/etc. will probably be looking for ways to bring audiences "new" content in a cost effective way. Personally, I think releasing alternate cuts isn't a bad way to go.
Now keeping it exclusive to HBO Max, yeah I'm not sure about that. Maybe after some time, they can release it on physical and digital markets to keep the investment worth it.
There's also a movement to get the extended cut of Batman Forever released as well. I'm not sure if all the footage still exists. WB allegedly planned to include the 170-minute cut with the 2005 special edition DVD release, but only offered some of the footage as a separate feature. But hey, if it is somehow feasible, I'm all for it. Give me all the alternate cuts! I eat that stuff up.
mikey0
07-11-2020, 12:15 PM
This new CGI movie will most likely be a number-one movie at the box office for a week or two like the Bayverse movies, but I doubt it will be as good as TMNT The Movie from 1990. I think TMNT The Movie will go down in history as the greatest TMNT film. Still, it?s good to hear that there will be more TMNT movies. It would be nice if they touched on the original Playmates toyline universe. I don?t think they will, but I would love that.
Vicky82
07-11-2020, 01:08 PM
This new CGI movie will most likely be a number-one movie at the box office for a week or two like the Bayverse movies, but I doubt it will be as good as TMNT The Movie from 1990. I think TMNT The Movie will go down in history as the greatest TMNT film. Still, it?s good to hear that there will be more TMNT movies. It would be nice if they touched on the original Playmates toyline universe. I don?t think they will, but I would love that.
That depends if there are any bigger movies being released at the same time. The 2007 movie was only at number 1 for a week and went down to 4 in it's 2nd week in the US. In the UK it only got to number 2 because the 300 got to number 1 because it came out at the same time.
I found this, it could be the release date. Untitled Paramount Animation July 22nd 2022.
(Under spoilers due to pic being big)
https://66.media.tumblr.com/7b784d708233e18f29d8a12ee714c4f2/b58685c34fddfec4-55/s540x810/cb31087e065b96574be236a6d2ccb8da00018f82.png
https://pro.imdb.com/company/co0023400/boxoffice/?view=releases&ref_=mojo_rs_table_4&rf=mojo_rs_table_4
But I expect it will change to a later date due to the virus and other movie release dates being delayed.
NinjaPug
07-12-2020, 08:42 PM
Doubtful. Animation development takes longer than 2 years. The director has been working on another movie set to release this October so it's unlikely much, if any, work has been done on this.
snake
07-13-2020, 07:06 AM
I can't wait for this to either not pan out or come out and suck.
AquaParade
07-13-2020, 09:23 AM
I've been trained to enjoy following the development of a TMNT movie more than the movie itself, so I'm just patiently waiting for more info to discuss here. :P
Coola Yagami
07-18-2020, 11:45 AM
I'm gonna treat this like the Sonic movie and Bill and Ted 3. With caution and not much interest until we finally see a trailer.
IndigoErth
07-18-2020, 12:06 PM
Was just thinking... with all the time they ignore it except for posting images and gifs on Twitter or whatever, I'd heart it so much, at least the idea of it, if this ended up being finally Nick's first step into giving the 2003 TMNT some love, while making it their own with CGI.
80gmrp
07-18-2020, 12:27 PM
Was just thinking... with all the time they ignore it except for posting images and gifs on Twitter or whatever, I'd heart it so much, at least the idea of it, if this ended up being finally Nick's first step into giving the 2003 TMNT some love, while making it their own with CGI.
Fully agreed. For that matter, if such a scenario involves Leatherhead appearing in a movie for the first time, I'd be more than willing to watch.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 03:05 PM
They can't even mention or remind people of 2K3, because all it does is showcase how everything Nick has done with TMNT is piss by comparison. That's why they bury it.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-18-2020, 03:26 PM
They can't even mention or remind people of 2K3, because all it does is showcase how everything Nick has done with TMNT is piss by comparison. That's why they bury it.
The North remembers.
We shall never see their like again.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 03:29 PM
We really need you to chime in more often. I can't f*cking do everything. I mean I'm witty and handsome and well-hung but I'm still only One Guy. I need my team!
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-18-2020, 03:37 PM
We really need you to chime in more often. I can't f*cking do everything. I mean I'm witty and handsome and well-hung but I'm still only One Guy. I need my team!
$hit, man, leave a good point for the rest of us to make. You've been on a fvcking roll lately! :tlol:
AquaParade
07-18-2020, 04:08 PM
2k3 is just diet-mirage though. I want to like it, but it's a dull impersonation.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 04:24 PM
At least it's in color. And April isn't a goddamn drawing. And no time-travel roach-f*cking! That's all Win by default. :trazz:
"Diet Mirage" is a bit harsh. TMNT 2K3 more like Crystal Pepsi. Like The Man said, "In many ways, it's superior! But will never be AS recognized as the original." :lol:
Kidding aside, I do admit that 2K3 probably plays a lot better if you're not in romantic love with Mirage. I didn't read it until like, 1999 and I was almost out of school; Mirage TMNT is kinda just like Star Wars, if you get into it as an older guy, it's Just Okay for a lot of folks. Like, you see the appeal of it but it's not entrancing, it's Merely Fine. So seeing some of the elements of it be taken in very different directions for the cartoon never bothered me. I was more happy that they even bothered at all. If they tried to be 1:1 with Mirage, they would have run out of plot after about 8 episodes, anyway. There was more than enough "Mirage Flavor" in it for my tastes. Some things could've been better, sure, but altogether I think it was a really good take on TMNT. Definitely one of the best ones, easily.
I mean... it was a cartoon, y'know? Much of Mirage is as dry as rice cakes, and the rest was some LSD-inspired filler lunacy. At least they mostly aped the best stuff for the cartoon, and gave it a little Razzmatazz. That's all I ever asked for or expected and I got more than I would have settled for. 2K3 was "dynamic" in ways that Mirage could never hope to be, since the two mediums had totally different limitations. 2K3 was "toyetic" but also just plain a lot more fun.
They could've done "City At War" better, though. That was kind of not a great attempt at imitation. As for the rest, I stand by my stance. It's good. :trazz:
d_osborn
07-18-2020, 04:33 PM
Like The Man said, "In many ways, it's superior! But will never be AS recognized as the original." :lol:
Star Trek: The Next Generation!
Leo656
07-18-2020, 05:03 PM
^^^ Gets It.
I needed that, pal. All day yesterday I was posting the "Do you like Huey Lewis and The News...?" monologue from "American Psycho" in various places and I think like two people got it. So I needed some faith in humanity restored, today. Thanks!
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-18-2020, 05:13 PM
I never had the sense that the City was at War in 2k3. It always seemed like maybe a few blocks at most.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 05:16 PM
It's tough to create a sense of "scale" with TMNT cartoons, on account of everyone's inside all the time and the streets are always barren. :lol:
Like seriously, man, cartoon shows just can't present "cities" very well. Stock footage of skylines, sure, but that's about it. Kinda drags the whole thing down, makes you wonder why so many fictional stories insist on being set there. Your cartoon's gonna be terrible! :trazz:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-18-2020, 05:23 PM
Post-Apocalyptic Mutant Ninja Turtles.
THAT should be a new TMNT comic series. The streets would be mostly empty, except for hordes of monsters or bands of ninjas and gangs, which would be perfect for animation. :tlol:
TigerClaw
07-18-2020, 05:35 PM
Post-Apocalyptic Mutant Ninja Turtles.
THAT should be a new TMNT comic series. The streets would be mostly empty, except for hordes of monsters or bands of ninjas and gangs, which would be perfect for animation. :tlol:
I have this vision in my head for a TMNT Movie set a couple years after the bomb in Mutant Town.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 05:46 PM
Yes, yes, mutants everywhere. Mutants on top of mutants, of every color and flavor in the rainbow. Just make it "Zootopia, Guest Starring the TMNT", since they'd be the exact opposite of special in such a world. Supremely interesting stuff, that'd be.
Wait, no, that's not the word. What was... ah, yeah, "Supremely Pointless", that's the word I wanted to use. :lol:
Just like those Superman stories where there's a million other Kryptonians flying around and the only difference between Him and Them is he wears blue. It always sounds great on paper and is f*cking terrible in execution because the entire premise of Superman is "This Guy's Special". If he ain't special, there's no more story.
Ninja Turtles, same thing. There's no pathos or drama in a world where everyone is Just Like Them. Might as well be Care Bears, at that point. Boooooooooo.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-18-2020, 05:52 PM
Yes, yes, mutants everywhere. Mutants on top of mutants, of every color and flavor in the rainbow. Just make it "Zootopia, Guest Starring the TMNT", since they'd be the exact opposite of special in such a world. Supremely interesting stuff, that'd be.
Wait, no, that's not the word. What was... ah, yeah, "Supremely Pointless", that's the word I wanted to use. :lol:
Just like those Superman stories where there's a million other Kryptonians flying around and the only difference between Him and Them is he wears blue. It always sounds great on paper and is f*cking terrible in execution because the entire premise of Superman is "This Guy's Special". If he ain't special, there's no more story.
Ninja Turtles, same thing. There's no pathos or drama in a world where everyone is Just Like Them. Might as well be Care Bears, at that point. Boooooooooo.
This is largely the reason why I've always preferred that the only mutants are the four turtles and Splinter. Being outcasts is the main appeal with them. It's harder to be outcasts if there's other mutants kicking about
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-18-2020, 06:03 PM
Yes, yes, mutants everywhere. Mutants on top of mutants, of every color and flavor in the rainbow. Just make it "Zootopia, Guest Starring the TMNT", since they'd be the exact opposite of special in such a world. Supremely interesting stuff, that'd be
...
Ninja Turtles, same thing. There's no pathos or drama in a world where everyone is Just Like Them. Might as well be Care Bears, at that point. Boooooooooo.
Exactly. We should be able to count the number of mutants EVER, in an entire TMNT series, on both hands. No more.
Leo, Don, Raph, Mike, Splinter. That's 5. Add in Leatherhead, for 6. That's all the Mirage series had.
Now because I'm generous, add in Slash and Old Hob (most everybody loves those two characters).
Finally, just for the possible theoretical maximum even though we already have enough, you can add two more mutants AS LONG AS THEY AREN'T BEBOP AND ROCKSTEADY. Just for argument's sake, and to round it out.
Let's say Bloodsucker and some Rahzar type mutant. Because wolves are cool. Or $hit, to get REALLY wild, let's even say Venus can be one of the ten. Because inclusion!
There. You're done. That's more than enough mutants, and the special uniqueness that IS mutants can be retained.
No Bopsteady and Rerock, no Mutanimals, no Mona Lisa, no Playmates aren't-these-cool-look-it's-a-samurai-seaslug!
TigerClaw
07-18-2020, 06:06 PM
a movie set in Mutant Town would look really cool on the big screen. The designs of the mutants all would be CGI of course.
As to how I approach this movie? It would be set a couple of years after Old Hob dropped that bomb that turn half of the NY population into mutants.
But years has passed since the event. And some company is working on some retromutagen to change these mutants back into humans. However they wanna monetize it. So there is this groups of people that are get this retromutagen to become normal again. But then we have this other group that wants to destroy it. Because being turned into a mutant cured them of some diseases and and also gave them abilities that they didn't have as humans.
The Turtles will be out there patrolling the streets and so on and they hear about this. So they will fit against those that want to destroy the only that might change people back to normal.
As for the Mutants that should appear? The usual ones. I would love to see Alopex and Mona Lisa in supporting roles.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 06:18 PM
This is largely the reason why I've always preferred that the only mutants are the four turtles and Splinter. Being outcasts is the main appeal with them. It's harder to be outcasts if there's other mutants kicking about
Exactly. We should be able to count the number of mutants EVER, in an entire TMNT series, on both hands. No more.
Leo, Don, Raph, Mike, Splinter. That's 5. Add in Leatherhead, for 6. That's all the Mirage series had.
Now because I'm generous, add in Slash and Old Hob (most everybody loves those two characters).
Finally, just for the possible theoretical maximum even though we already have enough, you can add two more mutants AS LONG AS THEY AREN'T BEBOP AND ROCKSTEADY. Just for argument's sake, and to round it out.
Let's say Bloodsucker and some Rahzar type mutant. Because wolves are cool. Or $hit, to get REALLY wild, let's even say Venus can be one of the ten. Because inclusion!
There. You're done. That's more than enough mutants, and the special uniqueness that IS mutants can be retained.
No Bopsteady and Rerock, no Mutanimals, no Mona Lisa, no Playmates aren't-these-cool-look-it's-a-samurai-seaslug!
I'm a little more forgiving, so maybe a dozen? Introduced very gradually over the duration of an entire series, that'd be alright. But yeah, more than that and the Turtles are not only guest stars in their own story, they're not even "weird" anymore. The one thing the TMNT should never be is Mundane.
But I mean... y'gotta have Ace Duck. Although sometimes he can be an alien, I guess. But you gotta have Ace Duck!
------------
Everything about that "pitch" would suffice as a single episode of a cartoon show at best. There's nothing there to support a 90-minute movie, that's entirely masturbatory self-indulgence. Nick could'a done something with that, maybe. A movie? Again, that's not "TMNT", that's "Zootopia, Guest Starring The TMNT".
Right after that we can get started on the Superman movie where he decides to spend all afternoon waiting on line at the DMV. :lol:
neatoman
07-18-2020, 07:27 PM
The more I think about it, the more I think the Space Arc might be the most suitable story arc for this movie. It would justify being all CGI and it's a classic storyline we have yet to see on the big screen.
LeotheLateBloomer
07-18-2020, 07:48 PM
2k3 is just diet-mirage though. I want to like it, but it's a dull impersonation.
It was still a good cartoon and better than all the other TMNT cartoons we've gotten. It was my Batman TAS for a while when I was younger. Sure we can do better but I appreciate what we got.
PizzaPower1985
07-18-2020, 07:54 PM
It was still a good cartoon and better than all the other TMNT cartoons we've gotten. It was my Batman TAS for a while when I was younger. Sure we can do better but I appreciate what we got.
Everything here I'll agree with BUT... can we do better? Well, technically it is possible to make a better cartoon than 2K3, BUT... no. No. It will never happen. It's not going to ever be better than 2K3 as long as Nickelodeon owns this franchise.
LeotheLateBloomer
07-18-2020, 08:12 PM
Everything here I'll agree with BUT... can we do better? Well, technically it is possible to make a better cartoon than 2K3, BUT... no. No. It will never happen. It's not going to ever be better than 2K3 as long as Nickelodeon owns this franchise.
Sadly you're right.
80gmrp
07-18-2020, 08:16 PM
This is largely the reason why I've always preferred that the only mutants are the four turtles and Splinter. Being outcasts is the main appeal with them. It's harder to be outcasts if there's other mutants kicking about
I mean, technically, even in the original Mirage comics, Leatherhead was proof that the turtles weren't supposed to be the only mutants in existence, so I do feel that the turtles and Splinter being the only mutants in an entire era may be a pipedream.
As for what else I missed, 2003 was relative gold, yes (my favorite series at that), but I wouldn't necessarily assume the worst about the future of the franchise as a whole. The 2012 cartoon, while it was focused more on humor, certainly felt like it had some elements of seriousness to it like 2003 did, at least to me.
IndigoErth
07-18-2020, 09:11 PM
It's not going to ever be better than 2K3 as long as Nickelodeon owns this franchise.
Why I just keep hoping they remain open to letting others have the license to do with them what Nick doesn't want to. I could kinda live with that, for now. The existence of that Batman vs TMNT keeps me hopeful. This CGI movie that doesn't sound like it's only going to be purely Nick, maybe that too, if we're lucky.
on account of everyone's inside all the time and the streets are always barren. :lol:
See now, that's one of the unspoken secrets of these cartoons, they all happen during a pandemic lock down. Relatable! lol
as dry as rice cakes
And no knocking the rice cakes, I just "accidentally" ate half a bag of the tomato and basil flavor, they're awesome. :trazz: If Mirage is race cakes then they're obviously the tomato and basil.
neatoman
07-18-2020, 09:22 PM
a movie set in Mutant Town would look really cool on the big screen.
Hwz7YN1AQmQ
Leo656
07-18-2020, 09:25 PM
And no knocking the rice cakes, I just "accidentally" ate half a bag of the tomato and basil flavor, they're awesome. :trazz: If Mirage is race cakes then they're obviously the tomato and basil.
Hm? Hm. Hmmmm.
0iAuw5dxQFg
Hmm.
TigerClaw
07-18-2020, 09:30 PM
Hwz7YN1AQmQ
Yes actually. Its better then anything that's out there at the moment.
Andrew NDB
07-18-2020, 09:34 PM
I mean, technically, even in the original Mirage comics, Leatherhead was proof that the turtles weren't supposed to be the only mutants in existence, so I do feel that the turtles and Splinter being the only mutants in an entire era may be a pipedream.
But we know TPTB's intention was always to limit the mutants running around to just those. We know this because they've told us.
IndigoErth
07-18-2020, 09:38 PM
Hm? Hm. Hmmmm.
Hmm.
Your loss, your stores can send the good flavors here, you can keep the bland ones.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 09:49 PM
Your loss, your stores can send the good flavors here, you can keep the bland ones.
I got like three Heinekens left, I'm doin' fine. :lol:
Yes actually. Its better then anything that's out there at the moment.
You're silly. :lol:
Y'know what? Thanks to you, I've got a really, really good idea that's gonna make a LOT of people here very, very happy. Turn around for a second, buddy?
((Deep breaths; adjusts tie, turns the volume on the stereo way, way up))
So, TigerClaw... You like Huey Lewis and the News?
Their early work was a little too "New Wave" for my tastes, but when "Sports" came out in '83, I think they really came into their own, commercially and artistically. The whole album has a clear, crisp sound, and a new sheen of consummate professionalism that really gives the songs a big boost. He's been compared to Elvis Costello, but I think Huey has a far more bitter, cynical sense of humor.
In '87, Huey released "Fore!", their most accomplished album. I think their undisputed masterpiece is "Hip to be Square", a song so catchy, most people probably don't listen to the lyrics. But they should, because it's not just about the pleasures of conformity, and the importance of trends, it's also a personal statement about the band itself!
HEY, TIGERCLAW......!!!
-------------------
......Whew, that was messy, but damn, do I feel a LOT better already. :lol: Try getting a reservation at Dorsia NOW. :lol:
PizzaPower1985
07-18-2020, 09:52 PM
:oops:Your loss, your stores can send the good flavors here, you can keep the bland ones.
I love those tomato basil rice cakes too... Good stuff.
But Indigo... important Q: How goes the Mirage reading... are you enjoying it?
neatoman
07-18-2020, 09:54 PM
Yes actually. Its better then anything that's out there at the moment.
Mutant Town is a dumb idea for a primary setting and was clearly only ever thought of as a cheap way to introduce new mutant characters, without the need for labs or explainations for more spills. If you think the various possible futures that depict the world occupied by Utroms and/or full of mutants is meant to be where the world is going, rather than some nightmare scenario that the heroes will try to prevent, you really don't understand storytelling.
Mutant Town itself does not work as a long time setting because it is a small quarantined area in poverty that will eventually run out potential rather quickly. TMNT is largely about exploring a huge insane world with a variety of concept, coupled with the lonliness of being unique creatures, something you can't have if you force the stories to take place in a small area where the turtles blend in.
Once enough mutant characters have been introduced, the series will keep the interesting ones and find a way to discard the majority of mutants who did not get any focus. Either by curing them, exiling them to another world or in a straight up massacre. There is no way it'll last forever because that would be really boring.
And yes, even for a single movie, Mutant Town would be bad choice because the only point of it is set-up for other stories!
PizzaPower1985
07-18-2020, 09:55 PM
I got like three Heinekens left, I'm doin' fine. :lol:
You're silly. :lol:
Y'know what? Thanks to you, I've got a really, really good idea that's gonna make a LOT of people here very, very happy. Turn around for a second, buddy?
((Deep breaths; adjusts tie, turns the volume on the stereo way, way up))
So, TigerClaw... You like Huey Lewis and the News?
Their early work was a little too "New Wave" for my tastes, but when "Sports" came out in '83, I think they really came into their own, commercially and artistically. The whole album has a clear, crisp sound, and a new sheen of consummate professionalism that really gives the songs a big boost. He's been compared to Elvis Costello, but I think Huey has a far more bitter, cynical sense of humor.
In '87, Huey released "Fore!", their most accomplished album. I think their undisputed masterpiece is "Hip to be Square", a song so catchy, most people probably don't listen to the lyrics. But they should, because it's not just about the pleasures of conformity, and the importance of trends, it's also a personal statement about the band itself!
HEY, TIGERCLAW......!!!
-------------------
......Whew, that was messy, but damn, do I feel a LOT better already. :lol: Try getting a reservation at Dorsia NOW. :lol:
Leo wins the night's thread award for the Amer. Psycho reference.
He has to return some video tapes because he wants to fit in!
TigerClaw
07-18-2020, 09:56 PM
I got like three Heinekens left, I'm doin' fine. :lol:
You're silly. :lol:
Y'know what? Thanks to you, I've got a really, really good idea that's gonna make a LOT of people here very, very happy. Turn around for a second, buddy?
((Deep breaths; adjusts tie, turns the volume on the stereo way, way up))
So, TigerClaw... You like Huey Lewis and the News?
Their early work was a little too "New Wave" for my tastes, but when "Sports" came out in '83, I think they really came into their own, commercially and artistically. The whole album has a clear, crisp sound, and a new sheen of consummate professionalism that really gives the songs a big boost. He's been compared to Elvis Costello, but I think Huey has a far more bitter, cynical sense of humor.
In '87, Huey released "Fore!", their most accomplished album. I think their undisputed masterpiece is "Hip to be Square", a song so catchy, most people probably don't listen to the lyrics. But they should, because it's not just about the pleasures of conformity, and the importance of trends, it's also a personal statement about the band itself!
HEY, TIGERCLAW......!!!
-------------------
......Whew, that was messy, but damn, do I feel a LOT better already. :lol: Try getting a reservation at Dorsia NOW. :lol:
Well my idea is better then anything you pull out. The filmmakers will do a movie that will appeal to all ages and not cater to a specific group of fans.
Mutant Town is a dumb idea for a primary setting and was clearly only ever thought of as a cheap way to introduce new mutant characters, without the need for labs or explainations for more spills. If you think the various possible futures that depict the world occupied by Utroms and/or full of mutants is meant to be where the world is going, rather than some nightmare scenario that the heroes will try to prevent, you really don't understand storytelling.
Mutant Town itself does not work as a long time setting because it is a small quarantined area in poverty that will eventually run out potential rather quickly. TMNT is largely about exploring a huge insane world with a variety of concept, coupled with the lonliness of being unique creatures, something you can't have if you force the stories to take place in a small area where the turtles blend in.
Once enough mutant characters have been introduced, the series will keep the interesting ones and find a way to discard the majority of mutants who did not get any focus. Either by curing them, exiling them to another world or in a straight up massacre. There is no way it'll last forever because that would be really boring.
Its better then most ideas seen around here. Lots of fans act like there entitled these days.
You can do a movie without doing the origin. Just sprinkle the origin as a series of flashbacks.
neatoman
07-18-2020, 10:08 PM
Well my idea is better then anything you pull out. The filmmakers will do a movie that will appeal to all ages and not cater to a specific group of fans.
Its better then most ideas seen around here. Lots of fans act like there entitled these days.
You can do a movie without doing the origin. Just sprinkle the origin as a series of flashbacks.
Well first off, what other ideas are you talking about and can you give a concrete reason why they suck beyond thinking the people behind them seem entitled?
Secondly, your idea doesn't even describe a real plot, just a general idea with barely direction.
Thirdly, like I said, Mutant Town exists for set-up and has no real purpose to tell stories in it's own right. The only places I can see your idea going is that the mutants get cured or stay in the quarantine zone as mutants and the plot is back to square one or two, either case makes for a really lame story because nothing interesting came out of it.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 10:09 PM
Leo wins the night's thread award for the Amer. Psycho reference.
He has to return some video tapes because he wants to fit in!
See, my material plays a lot better when the person reading it has seen movies that aren't all cartoons. :lol: This guy gets it!
https://www.relatably.com/m/img/american-psycho-meme-tumblr/634213e5cf69ebec2260a4b35025568f.jpg
Some people don't get it, though. They get this card, instead (NSFW):
https://40.media.tumblr.com/cf4c7e23d02487d46f67aa04644d53f0/tumblr_mzvh1lbt2e1r390ndo1_250.png
Either way, everybody gets a card. Because I'm just that kinda guy.
https://img.cinemablend.com/cb/0/9/3/3/b/c/0933bce3a13c8447ccd5a71265a5c46e0017ca6e964044bf99 97b4a653a7faeb.jpg
TigerClaw
07-18-2020, 10:15 PM
Well first off, what other ideas are you talking about and can you give a concrete reason why they suck beyond thinking the people behind them seem entitled?
Secondly, your idea doesn't even describe a real plot, just a general idea with barely direction.
Thirdly, like I said, Mutant Town exists for set-up and has no real purpose to tell stories in it's own right. The only places I can see your idea going is that the mutants get cured or stay in the quarantine zone as mutants and the plot is back to square one or two, either case makes for a really lame story because nothing interesting came out of it.
I just rather see something new that isn't the same tired old cliche. How many times are we gonna tell the same story over and over. Its getting old.
neatoman
07-18-2020, 11:08 PM
I just rather see something new that isn't the same tired old cliche. How many times are we gonna tell the same story over and over. Its getting old.
Are you talking about what the movies decide to adapt? Sure, meybe telling the origin story several times over is lame, but there's really only two movies that does that. Still, Mutant Town itself is meant for set-up and not pay-off, it simply doesn't make for a good story to use it as a setting, which is why I see it as a dumb waste to make a movie about it.
There are still way more compelling for the movies to adapt than Mutant Town, such as:
The MOUSER attack
The Space Arc
The Don Micro
The First Savanti/Renet story
The Second Savanti/Renet story
The Passing
The C.R.A.P. story
The Doctor Dome story
Distractions
A version of Return to New York that actually uses Zog and the Shredder Monsters
City at War
The People's Choice
Dreams of Stone
Sons of the Silent Age
Egyptian Adventure
The Ring
Twilight of the Ring
Halls of Lost Legends
I, Monster
Soul's Winter
And probably a lot more that haven't made it to the big screen but are still better choices than Mutant Town. Let's be clear here, Mutant Town sucks because (like I already said) the point is to set up game pieces for other stories, it cannot tell compelling stories on it's own because it's too limited (or at the very least limited for long term use).
TigerClaw
07-18-2020, 11:18 PM
Are you talking about what the movies decide to adapt? Sure, meybe telling the origin story several times over is lame, but there's really only two movies that does that. Still, Mutant Town itself is meant for set-up and not pay-off, it simply doesn't make for a good story to use it as a setting, which is why I see it as a dumb waste to make a movie about it.
There are still way more compelling for the movies to adapt than Mutant Town, such as:
The MOUSER attack
The Space Arc
The Don Micro
The First Savanti/Renet story
The Second Savanti/Renet story
The Passing
The C.R.A.P. story
The Doctor Dome story
Distractions
A version of Return to New York that actually uses Zog and the Shredder Monsters
City at War
The People's Choice
Dreams of Stone
Sons of the Silent Age
Egyptian Adventure
The Ring
Twilight of the Ring
Halls of Lost Legends
I, Monster
Soul's Winter
And probably a lot more that haven't made it to the big screen but are still better choices than Mutant Town. Let's be clear here, Mutant Town sucks because (like I already said) the point is to set up game pieces for other stories, it cannot tell compelling stories on it's own because it's too limited (or at the very least limited for long term use).
I prefer Mutant Town over any of that stuff. Because I think its the most fantastical element that the comics have created. Its new. It brings up a world of possibilities to open up the world even more.
Leo656
07-18-2020, 11:26 PM
Anybody wanna play "Guess Who's The Furry?" :lol:
KIDDING, kidding. I'm just kidding.
Mostly. :trazz:
neatoman
07-18-2020, 11:50 PM
I prefer Mutant Town over any of that stuff. Because I think its the most fantastical element that the comics have created. Its new. It brings up a world of possibilities to open up the world even more.
In what sense? From where I'm sitting, all it really does is make the introduction of more mutants a little easier than it was before. That is worthwhile if you want to introduce a shitton of mutants all at the same time, if you only want a couple (which is what I would recommend) you're better off sticking to isolated chemical spills and labs.
And you don't really offer any argument as to why the Mutant Town is a good setting. When used as a primary setting, it draws attention away from crime fighting, mysticism, outer space, time travel, alternate realities, etc. and instead forces the characters to hang out in a quarantine zone.
Because that's all Mutant Town really is, a quarantine zone. That sucks and the longer it goes on, the more people will agree that it sucks.
Anybody wanna play "Guess Who's The Furry?" :lol:
KIDDING, kidding. I'm just kidding.
Mostly. :trazz:
Yeah, in a less joking way of putting it, having a giant crowd of humanoid animals eat up pages is pretty much the only interest anyone would have in the Mutant Town long term. Which is a really shallow and idiotic reason to want it around for more than a few issues. Not that we hate humanoid animals around here, but having a ton of them around just because is kind of dumb.
Leo656
07-19-2020, 12:03 AM
Yeah, in a less joking way of putting it, having a giant crowd of humanoid animals eat up pages is pretty much the only interest anyone would have in the Mutant Town long term. Which is a really shallow and idiotic reason to want it around for more than a few issues. Not that we hate humanoid animals around here, but having a ton of them around just because is kind of dumb.
Agreed. And I'm mostly a "Hey, boobs are boobs" kinda guy, myself. But that book doesn't even lean into that very much, so there's not even that to look forward to. :lol:
I mean if Spaziante were drawing it, a whole Mutant Town might at least have some eye candy.
F*ck, I either need'a stop drinking right now or have three more, I really don't know yet. :lol:
LeotheLateBloomer
07-19-2020, 12:14 AM
In what sense? From where I'm sitting, all it really does is make the introduction of more mutants a little easier than it was before. That is worthwhile if you want to introduce a shitton of mutants all at the same time, if you only want a couple (which is what I would recommend) you're better off sticking to isolated chemical spills and labs.
And you don't really offer any argument as to why the Mutant Town is a good setting. When used as a primary setting, it draws attention away from crime fighting, mysticism, outer space, time travel, alternate realities, etc. and instead forces the characters to hang out in a quarantine zone.
Because that's all Mutant Town really is, a quarantine zone. That sucks and the longer it goes on, the more people will agree that it sucks.
TigerClaw just wants everything akin to the OT and a Mutant Town is just an excuse so he can see the same old mutants like Bebop and Rocksteady.
IndigoErth
07-19-2020, 12:18 AM
Can I just say I'd kind of love to see a space arc for live action one day? Could be fun. And that kind of setting with other worlds and Dimension X would give these studios like PD and whatnot that have a bad tendency to overdo things room to go as big and fantastical as they want without looking like it's going overboard, so long as they leave any Earth scenes feeling like the real world.
:oops:
I love those tomato basil rice cakes too... Good stuff.
At least somebody knows! lol
But Indigo... important Q: How goes the Mirage reading... are you enjoying it?
Still need to read the last one in the second volume I have. Have the next volume but been putting it off, trying to decide weather to just go into that one or try to catch the missing ones between first.
edit: Mutant town... One angle of that I do think would be interesting would be if it's only temporary. The TMNT get a dose of "normal" before all those people are eventually turned back to human. So the guys go back to being unique again. But...now you also have a new dynamic with a portion of the community that now knows them; a scattering of people who are now sympathetic instead fearful or rejecting. (Will the comic do this?) A bit complex for a movie though, imo. Needs more time to devote to it, like the comics.
Leo656
07-19-2020, 12:42 AM
I mean, it can kinda only go one of four ways:
- All the "New Mutants" (is it even legal to say that, or am I gonna get a letter from Disney?) stick around forever, cluttering up the book and tripping over each other. Meh.
- Most/All of them somehow revert back to human form.
- Most/All of them die.
- A combination of Two and Three.
It's very reminiscent of the "World of New Krypton" arc in the Superman books back in 2009 or so. It was an intriguing premise - a few thousand Kryptonians turn up and settle on a growing world on the other side of Earth's Sun, so now there's suddenly a few thousand "Supermen" and Super-Women zipping around, and all the tension that goes with that. How's it gonna affect Superman? Can Earth and New Krypton co-exist? The Earthlings are afraid of the Kryptonians, with something of good reason because the Kryptonians mostly want to invade and take over because they're "superior" to humans. This is really gonna screw with things!
And it did, kinda, but then it was over. And the ending was something of a foregone conclusion (Spoiler: Most everyone died, everyone else went back to the Phantom Zone), and everyone saw it coming before the first issue was over, simply because the premise was not sustainable. They weren't gonna keep thousands of super-people hanging around, and everyone knew that, it's not practical. So it was an interesting story, but out of necessity, it all had to be tied up SO neatly, that once it was over, it was like the entire story never even happened at all. That's like, the biggest criticism of it: Everyone called the ending before the story came out, because it could ONLY end that way, and then the entire thing may well as never even happened. Because when you do these kinds of Big Concept Stories, you're either gonna lean into the "collateral damage" at the end OR sweep it all under the rug. Guess what I expect this book to do?
So that's the story I see this concept of Mutant Town being the most reminiscent of, and I see quite a few thematic similarities between them so it's not a bad bet that the ending will turn out the same, either. Everyone's either gonna die or de-mutate, and there'll be some contrivance to smooth out the edges of the story's ending, and afterwards, it'll be like it never happened. Because there's just not much else you can DO with it, really. Like it might be referenced in future stories as A Thing That Happened, but no way do the setting or 90% or more of the characters that go with it stick around for the long haul.
TigerClaw just wants everything akin to the OT and a Mutant Town is just an excuse so he can see the same old mutants like Bebop and Rocksteady.
Stiff, but accurate enough, probably. That's certainly an observation that one could be forgiven for making with the available information, sure.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
07-19-2020, 05:35 AM
Having countless mutants running around just makes the Turtles (y'know, the characters that the franchise is named after) pretty much 'ordinary'. That's why I've always been against having endless 'mutants of the week' running around.
Have Splinter and the four turtles around. Maybe Leatherhead at a stretch. But that should be it.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 07:31 AM
Having countless mutants running around just makes the Turtles (y'know, the characters that the franchise is named after) pretty much 'ordinary'. That's why I've always been against having endless 'mutants of the week' running around.
Have Splinter and the four turtles around. Maybe Leatherhead at a stretch. But that should be it.
And that's exactly what the IDW books are doing. They have turned the TMNT into guest stars. Nobody wants it in a movie but in a comic it's okay? Is that because it's serial fiction and the story has more time to explore that kind of thing or what? IDW, I'm giving notice now... KILL OFF like 60% of the current characters in your story and I'll keep giving you $$$.
AquaParade
07-19-2020, 10:45 AM
To be fair, Mirage was crawling with other super powered types as well. I?d say the issue with IDW is the idea that they focus on these other characters as much as they do the turtles.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 11:00 AM
To be fair, Mirage was crawling with other super powered types as well. I?d say the issue with IDW is the idea that they focus on these other characters as much as they do the turtles.
Nailed it! Even tho you're like the millionth person to say this. I've said it myself. So has Cubed... a bunch of us.
IDW has just never figured out how to make the TMNT shine in their own book while also balancing a giant number of characters. Admittedly it's a damn near impossible feat. To balance that kind of writing... to write a decent story like that... takes a masterful skill that no comic book writer has ever had.
And no matter how many times IDW's main audience tells them to kill off some of the side characters or cool it with all these side characters, they either pile on even more or just ignore the TMNT altogether in favor o Jenika, Allie, the Mutanimals, LH etc.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 12:11 PM
Nailed it! Even tho you're like the millionth person to say this. I've said it myself. So has Cubed... a bunch of us.
IDW has just never figured out how to make the TMNT shine in their own book while also balancing a giant number of characters. Admittedly it's a damn near impossible feat. To balance that kind of writing... to write a decent story like that... takes a masterful skill that no comic book writer has ever had.
And no matter how many times IDW's main audience tells them to kill off some of the side characters or cool it with all these side characters, they either pile on even more or just ignore the TMNT altogether in favor o Jenika, Allie, the Mutanimals, LH etc.
I love that Jennika got her own series. This is the kind of thing I wanna see done for a TMNT Cinematic Universe.
IndigoErth
07-19-2020, 01:12 PM
Would be funny if this turned out to be a 2012 movie... but with new grown up, more refined/detailed designs. lol Might not mesh with that apocalypse arc existing but...I think they only called it a "possible" future anyhow. I wouldn't mind an alternate one.
Not really want I want for a TMNT movie, but I wouldn't hate that. (I doubt that's it though if they are pulling in another company to do it.)
Jennika... I honestly don't mind her as an addition to the Turtle clan, but I don't want her taking over either. No movies please, not unless it's was a really successful run of films and she came much later.
I?d say the issue with IDW is the idea that they focus on these other characters as much as they do the turtles.
IDW has just never figured out how to make the TMNT shine in their own book while also balancing a giant number of characters.
Fact aside that I just didn't grow up a comic reader in general and has never really been a go-to hobby for me, that's the main turn off for me with IDW. I know it has done some good things and many enjoy it, so I'm glad it has been a decent long running comic for the TMNT, and I've seen portions of it that I do like a lot...however of what I've come across there's also sometimes been multiple pages devoted to anyone and everyone else but the TMNT, often droning on with a lot of dialogue, and to be honest that usually ends up losing my interest.
Difference with Mirage, imo, of what I'm familiar with (so far), is not so much that they do or don't have additional characters or however many, but that for the majority of it they generally seem to keep telling the story from the Turtles' perspective. It doesn't tend to lose sight of the fact that it's a TMNT comic and generally follows their experience of events, keeping any necessary side stuff without them relatively brief.
Look a those last movies, they made the same mistake, particularly with 2014; too much non-TMNT focus and the human-only parts get incredibly boring pretty fast. Who the hell wants to sit through that long Eric Sacks speech/conversation with April scene every time? The whole thing only exists for the simplest of reasons that didn't need all that screen time to explain and few people are going to care about this interaction focused on the background and connection of these side characters.
Luckily I can't really see a CGI movie making too much of that mistake unless something goes really wrong. Not with the time and cost it takes to devote to the whole design and animation process.
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 01:21 PM
Would be funny if this turned out to be a 2012 movie... but with new grown up, more refined/detailed designs. lol Might not mesh with that apocalypse arc existing but...I think they only called it a "possible" future anyhow. I wouldn't mind an alternate one.
Not really want I want for a TMNT movie, but I wouldn't hate that. (I doubt that's it though if they are pulling in another company to do it.)
Jennika... I honestly don't mind her as an addition to the Turtle clan, but I don't want her taking over either. No movies please, not unless it's was a really successful run of films and she came much later.
Fact aside that I just didn't grow up a comic reader in general and has never really been a go-to hobby for me, that's the main turn off for me with IDW. I know it has done some good things and many enjoy it, so I'm glad it has been a decent long running comic for the TMNT, and I've seen portions of it that I do like a lot...however of what I've come across there's also sometimes been multiple pages devoted to anyone and everyone else but the TMNT, often droning on with a lot of dialogue, and to be honest that usually ends up losing my interest.
Difference with Mirage, imo, of what I'm familiar with (so far), is not so much that they do or don't have additional characters or however many, but that for the majority of it they generally seem to keep telling the story from the Turtles' perspective. It doesn't tend to lose sight of the fact that it's a TMNT comic and generally follows their experience of events, keeping any necessary side stuff without them relatively brief.
Look a those last movies, they made the same mistake, particularly with 2014; too much non-TMNT focus and the human-only parts get incredibly boring pretty fast. Who the hell wants to sit through that long Eric Sacks speech/conversation with April scene every time? The whole thing only exists for the simplest of reasons that didn't need all that screen time to explain and few people are going to care about this interaction focused on the background and connection of these side characters.
Luckily I can't really see a CGI movie making too much of that mistake unless something goes really wrong. Not with the time and cost it takes to devote to the whole design and animation process.
That is probably the best comparison regarding side characters of IDW vs Mirage I have ever seen. Excellent points, and as someone who wrote a blog on comparing the two, I'm kind of ashamed that I didn't put it so succinctly and to the point. Nailed it! Simply nailed it!
And you're also right about the recent movies. They lost focus on the TMNT too much for their own good.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 01:23 PM
Would be funny if this turned out to be a 2012 movie... but with new grown up, more refined/detailed designs. lol Might not mesh with that apocalypse arc existing but...I think they only called it a "possible" future anyhow. I wouldn't mind an alternate one.
Not really want I want for a TMNT movie, but I wouldn't hate that. (I doubt that's it though if they are pulling in another company to do it.)
Jennika... I honestly don't mind her as an addition to the Turtle clan, but I don't want her taking over either. No movies please, not unless it's was a really successful run of films and she came much later.
Fact aside that I just didn't grow up a comic reader in general and has never really been a go-to hobby for me, that's the main turn off for me with IDW. I know it has done some good things and many enjoy it, so I'm glad it has been a decent long running comic for the TMNT, and I've seen portions of it that I do like a lot...however of what I've come across there's also sometimes been multiple pages devoted to anyone and everyone else but the TMNT, often droning on with a lot of dialogue, and to be honest that usually ends up losing my interest.
Difference with Mirage, imo, of what I'm familiar with (so far), is not so much that they do or don't have additional characters or however many, but that for the majority of it they generally seem to keep telling the story from the Turtles' perspective. It doesn't tend to lose sight of the fact that it's a TMNT comic and generally follows their experience of events, keeping any necessary side stuff without them relatively brief.
Look a those last movies, they made the same mistake, particularly with 2014; too much non-TMNT focus and the human-only parts get incredibly boring pretty fast. Who the hell wants to sit through that long Eric Sacks speech/conversation with April scene every time? The whole thing only exists for the simplest of reasons that didn't need all that screen time to explain and few people are going to care about this interaction focused on the background and connection of these side characters.
Luckily I can't really see a CGI movie making too much of that mistake unless something goes really wrong. Not with the time and cost it takes to devote to the whole design and animation process.
I wanna see Jennika appear in the movies. a TMNTCU.
neatoman
07-19-2020, 02:20 PM
I love that Jennika got her own series. This is the kind of thing I wanna see done for a TMNT Cinematic Universe.
I wanna see Jennika appear in the movies. a TMNTCU.
Jennika sucks too, she's been around for years and is still somewhat bland and ill-defined. Having her mutate into a copy of the main characters and presented as one of them is just a lazy move to make us care about her without ever having earned it. Much like the Mutant Town, I'm not sure she's actually meant to stick around for too long either.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
07-19-2020, 02:24 PM
Jennika sucks too, she's been around for years and is still somewhat bland and ill-defined. Having her mutate into a copy of the main characters and presented as one of them is just a lazy move to make us care about her without ever having earned it. Much like the Mutant Town, I'm not sure she's actually meant to stick around for too long either.
You're kidding yourself, brah. Jennika is in it for the long haul. Maybe if we're lucky, Stockman cures Mutant Town at least.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 02:37 PM
You're kidding yourself, brah. Jennika is in it for the long haul. Maybe if we're lucky, Stockman cures Mutant Town at least.
Yep Jennika is here to stay. I think some people have a problem that she's female. They attempted a female Turtle in the past and it didn't work out. Jennika on the other hand seems like a character will grow over time.
As for Stockman curing the people of Mutant Town? Don't bet on it. I don't think he has good intentions. Like come on! Baxter Stockman has always been a villain. Sure it looks like he has good intention to find a cure. But he probably has a hidden agenda and will use this to his own advantage for something sinister.
neatoman
07-19-2020, 02:38 PM
You're kidding yourself, brah. Jennika is in it for the long haul. Maybe if we're lucky, Stockman cures Mutant Town at least.
I don't know. Her question about wheter or not the mutation is permanent, as well as the factor or her mutation being different, might imply she'll be the first successful test subject of a cure. Or she could be written out as staying with the remaining mutants when that whole arc ends. Or... Well, let's be honest here, her very nature makes her more "expendable" than the "real" turtles, so she might be written out in a way that allows for quick drama.
I think some people have a problem that she's female.
That is not the reason, it's the most drain-dead and lazy excuse you could come up with. I already laid out the real reason.
She has been around for about four years already and nobody paid any attention to her until last year when she turned into a turtle, that's kind of the thing her defenders ignore about her. If she had not already devloped into something interesting before, what makes you think turning her into a turtle would? Having this character transform into a copy of the main characters does not suddenly make her a good character.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 02:40 PM
As for finding a cure for the mutation. I doubt some people want to change back to normal due to the mutation curing there ailments. Such as maybe someone was suffering some diseases and being turned into a mutant cured that person of the disease. Or people dealing with arthritis.
Think of all the abilities one would have being a mutant. Being a lot more agile. Able to move faster, and most animals they mutate into have night vision.
neatoman
07-19-2020, 02:48 PM
As for finding a cure for the mutation. I doubt some people want to change back to normal due to the mutation curing there ailments. Such as maybe someone was suffering some diseases and being turned into a mutant cured that person of the disease. Or people dealing with arthritis.
Think of all the abilities one would have being a mutant. Being a lot more agile. Able to move faster, and most animals they mutate into have night vision.
"Aw geez, being turned into a giraffe sure has made my life better! Sure, I can't go inside, my family is freaked out by me, scientist might want to experiment on me and there's virtually no benefits I can reap from this... But at least my joints don't hurt anymore, so I might as well stay like this forever!"
Do notice how idiotic this sounds?
PizzaPower1985
07-19-2020, 02:59 PM
I see Neatoman is being his usual self. Good, because I agree with him. Except that I loved the Jenika/Splinter relationship. Loved her as his apprentice/chunin. Thought she was a neat character.
But then she became a Mutant... Ninja... Turtle. And I read City At War and... I really enjoyed it. A great finale to THE ENTIRE SERIES! But Jenika becoming VENUS was a BAD IDEA! Then... I started hearing buzzing, rumblings of MUTANT TOWN... and you're doubling down and tripling down... throwing your entire series on MORE MUTANTS?
Glad I'm done! Glad they ended #100 without any MAJOR cliffhangers.
MikeandRaph87
07-19-2020, 03:05 PM
You're kidding yourself, brah. Jennika is in it for the long haul. Maybe if we're lucky, Stockman cures Mutant Town at least.
Honestly, I believe that there is an out if fan reception is leaning negative. If she is well received Jennika will decide she was fated to be a mutant and embrace the change. However, if readership opposes it for the long run she will decide to accept the cure along with the rest of Mutant Town whenever that plotbeat is finished. Will it be after Campbell's 16-20 issue run is over or will Tom do his own plot with Mutant Town is something that will not be known for awhile.
How long can Baxter hold on to the mayorship?
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 03:12 PM
"Aw geez, being turned into a giraffe sure has made my life better! Sure, I can't go inside, my family is freaked out by me, scientist might want to experiment on me and there's virtually no benefits I can reap from this... But at least my joints don't hurt anymore, so I might as well stay like this forever!"
Do notice how idiotic this sounds?
Someone could have been dealing with cancer. and turning into a mutant could have cured them of that disease. What if changing back makes that disease come back.
TigerClaw
07-19-2020, 03:13 PM
I see Neatoman is being his usual self. Good, because I agree with him. Except that I loved the Jenika/Splinter relationship. Loved her as his apprentice/chunin. Thought she was a neat character.
But then she became a Mutant... Ninja... Turtle. And I read City At War and... I really enjoyed it. A great finale to THE ENTIRE SERIES! But Jenika becoming VENUS was a BAD IDEA! Then... I started hearing buzzing, rumblings of MUTANT TOWN... and you're doubling down and tripling down... throwing your entire series on MORE MUTANTS?
Glad I'm done! Glad they ended #100 without any MAJOR cliffhangers.
I guess some people don't like change. The series has a new status quo and its gonna be like that for the foreseeable future in the IDW comics. I'm glad they went with this direction. Because I don't want another rehash. I want things to move forward and into the future with no looking back. This universe continues to evolve and I love that about the comics.
neatoman
07-19-2020, 03:20 PM
Honestly, I believe that there is an out if fan reception is leaning negative. If she is well received Jennika will decide she was fated to be a mutant and embrace the change. However, if readership opposes it for the long run she will decide to accept the cure along with the rest of Mutant Town whenever that plotbeat is finished. Will it be after Campbell's 16-20 issue run is over or will Tom do his own plot with Mutant Town is something that will not be known for awhile.
How long can Baxter hold on to the mayorship?
Well he'll probably be forced resign or something when his villainy goes public, that's just how the "Supervillain gets elected" stories tend to go. Much like Hob, just because he's been on the heroes' side for some time now, that just means he's doing what's beneficial, not that he isn't still evil. If you're asking about how long he's actually allowed to be mayor, eight years. The NYC mayor is allowed a maximum of two terms lasting four years each.
Someone could have been dealing with cancer. and turning into a mutant could have cured them of that disease. What if changing back makes that disease come back.
And how many of them do you think were dealing with something that serious?
I guess some people don't like change. The series has a new status quo and its gonna be like that for the foreseeable future in the IDW comics. I'm glad they went with this direction. Because I don't want another rehash. I want things to move forward and into the future with no looking back. This universe continues to evolve and I love that about the comics.
Just because something is different does not mean it's good. Again, I pointed out why this direction is not going to work out in the long run. On the topic of disease, if you had a type of medicine to treat some condition you have and you don't experience a lot of problem with it, but then it's discontinued and you're forced to use something causing more side-effects, are you going to go "This is good because it's a new experience for me, I was tired of my old medication!"?
MikeandRaph87
07-19-2020, 03:27 PM
Well he'll probably be forced resign or something when his villainy goes public, that's just how the "Supervillain gets elected" stories tend to go. Much like Hob, just because he's been on the heroes' side for some time now, that just means he's doing what's beneficial, not that he isn't still evil. If you're asking about how long he's actually allowed to be mayor, eight years. The NYC mayor is allowed a maximum of two terms lasting four years each.
I know its 8 years in NYC, I meant the political office held by a villain angle. It never last long. Be it Luthor as president or Kingpin as mayor of NYC among others. It appears that Baxter's beginning of the end is already starting with the mousers wandering around Mutant Town to spy on activities and April set to quit as his assistant by the end of only the second arc in this direction. While I am among those bored out of my mind with Mutant Town and want a quick fix for it and Jennika I also wonder if the Mutant Town angle ends so does Baxter's run as mayor. To see the corrupt politics he can be up to and what his deal with Null is would be an interesting focus, but his downfall will likely be tied to what he does with Mutant Town and of course it is to fit his own egotistical agenda.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.