PDA

View Full Version : New CGI movie


Pages : 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7

Galactus
03-19-2021, 05:58 PM
Well it's not much, but after roughly a year of no info at all, glad to at least hear some confirmation as to whether or not it's even still on the table. Was starting to have my doubts.

Wish we'd hear something more. If it's still slated to happen, surely after a year there is a little progress on this? So much of a 3D animated film, esp the initial parts of it, doesn't even need to be done colletively in the same office/studio these day.

I was hoping that no news meant the whole thing had been abandoned.

Who on Earth thinks another animated movie is creatively or commercially a good idea?!?

After the last attempt to make this TMNT work in movies failed and nearly killed the franchise an animated movie just screams cop out even we know it's going to deliberately stupid and contain all the things that turned people off from going to see the last one.

IndigoErth
03-19-2021, 06:28 PM
That's why I wish a year later we were hearing something more than just "oh hey, we're still doing it." Some hint of the general direction and tone would be nice.

Can't help but want to be optimistic about it, but if I'm just going to have my hopes dashed I'd rather just have that part confirmed already. As it is I'm not crazy about going all CGI. I far prefer live action for movies.


Though I'm kind of convinced that the film industry is probably terrified of fanbases these days and unlikely to even want to tell us anything for fear of having to go back and fix stupid choices that fans resent being made. LOL

And having to face this one... I'm sure the TMNT fanbase is somewhere within the top league of internet warriors who will tear you up should your production company commit some grave sin that goes too far. lol

Galactus
03-19-2021, 06:46 PM
I doubt we as a fanbase make much of difference to any TMNT product.

Sure, you could say we forced them to change the turtles back to mutants instead of aliens and Shredder being Japanese instead of William Fichtner but the outrage for those things stretched waaay beyond the TMNT fandom. Anyone who even had the remotest interest in the franchise were up in arms about those issues. Frankly if they'd listened to us in the first place they wouldn't have made those dumb decisions or any of the crap that led things caused the sequel to tank.

I don't think you have to be a genius to know were a cgi movie is headed. They are not going to make an semi serious animated movie, it's going to be a kiddy romp filled with lots of Fred Wolf characters and concepts. We don't need to be told this, you can see it coming off from miles away.

Rise1184
03-19-2021, 07:10 PM
I doubt we as a fanbase make much of difference to any TMNT product.

Sure, you could say we forced them to change the turtles back to mutants instead of aliens and Shredder being Japanese instead of William Fichtner but the outrage for those things stretched waaay beyond the TMNT fandom. Anyone who even had the remotest interest in the franchise were up in arms about those issues. Frankly if they'd listened to us in the first place they wouldn't have made those dumb decisions or any of the crap that led things caused the sequel to tank.

I don't think you have to be a genius to know were a cgi movie is headed. They are not going to make an semi serious animated movie, it's going to be a kiddy romp filled with lots of Fred Wolf characters and concepts. We don't need to be told this, you can see it coming off from miles away.

If it worked for Justice League and the fans pounding the studios, the Snyder cut would have never been released. If the fans didn’t cause an uproar regarding the original concept of Sonic The Hedgehog for the film, it would have never been redone. Never give up hope, we will be heard as a community :tgrin:

Andrew NDB
03-19-2021, 08:40 PM
If it worked for Justice League and the fans pounding the studios, the Snyder cut would have never been released.

Well, let's be clear about it. It was WB wanting to bring a lot of subscriptions to their new HBO Max and a lightbulb going on about "Seems to be demand for Snyder's cut... we need as many subscriptions as possible... we can make this happen!"

It wasn't like some gift to the fandom, or an altruistic reward.

sdp
03-19-2021, 08:51 PM
For better or worse studios do seem to be listening and with successful examples like Sonic the Hedgehog and the Snyder JL it might be happening more often until plenty of ideas tank because of asking fans. I personally think they do need to listen to feedback but not change their projects just because of that as well, Justice League 2017 is sort of another example of listening to people with the opposite results.

Not that I think fans can make a difference for this, TMNT is a kids property that they want to exploit as a kid brand to maximize profits. And I do think this CG film will aim for a fairly young audience, I'm thinking something like Big Hero Six for kids and enjoyable for "adults". It'll make us appreciate the 2007 movie for at least trying.

Galactus
03-19-2021, 08:58 PM
The whole thing with the 'Snyder Cut' is a fascinating look at a fandom flexing it's power but I don't think the TMNT fandom is anywhere near as big as that for the DC's main heroes. Plus it relied on a certain set of circumstances like the injustice of Snyder being taken off the project under the guise of helping him out during a family tragedy, not seeing the 'vision' that had been built up of over two movies come to fruition, the rivalry with the MCU and even at times taking on an almost pseudo political aspect. Finally there was HBO desperately needing something to attract attention and subscribers to their streaming service.

Wildcat
03-20-2021, 12:32 AM
Well it’s nice to know it’s still happening. Should be pretty cool at least.

A live action Loud House Christmas and a Nick Transformers sounds interesting.

I noticed Garfield was not listed. I guess they’re not doing that after all.

CyberCubed
03-20-2021, 11:25 AM
I honestly feel like this movie isn't going to happen. If they're thinking 2023 then it's obvious still early on and no animation has really been done so far.

neatoman
03-20-2021, 11:47 AM
I honestly feel like this movie isn't going to happen. If they're thinking 2023 then it's obvious still early on and no animation has really been done so far.

OH F%CKBALLS! TWO YEARS?!

My god, how the hell will they manage that?! Clearly they will give up before they get anywhere, no way they can keep it together for that long. It's not like anyone has ever done something similar before. It totally didn't take:

Boyhood 12 years
Eraserhead 6 years
Sleeping Beauty 7 years
Thief and the Cobbler 29 years


Clearly two years is just way too long... Oh wait, no... Two years is actually a fairly common production time. Raya, Disney's latest animated release, took three years from announcement to release. That is the same schedule as this movie. It's idiotic to assume this movie won't get made because it was announced less than a year ago and is scheduled for release in two.

Come back when there isn't even a trailer by 2023, then we can worry about this movie being canned.

sdp
03-20-2021, 12:17 PM
two years feels way optimistic, I don't see it happening and I'm sure it'll get stuck in development hell which is probably for the better, this will be a Incredibles/Big Hero 6 type of superhero movie and while it'll be "alright", it'll be a horrible tmnt movie since it'll just be another generic bland cg movie. It's best just to wait ten years or more for the next movie.

LeotheLateBloomer
03-20-2021, 12:34 PM
I honestly feel like this movie isn't going to happen. If they're thinking 2023 then it's obvious still early on and no animation has really been done so far.

I hope you're right. I have no hope in this turning out good.

CyberCubed
03-20-2021, 02:03 PM
Also keep in mind this movie was greenlit pre-covid pandemic. After that it probably made them re-think their approach to it with movie theaters being closed for over a year.

I don't think this will get made, or if it does, they'll just release it on Paramount+ digitally and it won't be a theater thing.

TigerClaw
03-20-2021, 02:21 PM
This movie will be released in theaters, Then it will be on Paramount+ after its 45 day theatrical release.

LeotheLateBloomer
03-20-2021, 03:39 PM
Also keep in mind this movie was greenlit pre-covid pandemic. After that it probably made them re-think their approach to it with movie theaters being closed for over a year.

I don't think this will get made, or if it does, they'll just release it on Paramount+ digitally and it won't be a theater thing.

Considering how the 2007 film did in theaters, maybe it's for the best that they'd release it on Paramount+ or any streaming service.

IndigoErth
03-20-2021, 05:07 PM
Also keep in mind this movie was greenlit pre-covid pandemic.
Actually, I'm pretty certain it was announced last spring, already during the pandemic. (edit: June I guess, going by articles that came out.) As if they'd almost kind of changed gears for a film because any remaining thought of a live action one would have had to be put aside anyhow thanks to Covid.


But the past year has felt more like two years, so... understandable to think we've known of this one longer than we really have.

Galactus
03-20-2021, 05:31 PM
^^^

Part of the reason that the Imagi movie under performed was because it was a cgi animated movie. The amount of people I saw writing it off as some Pixar wannabe kiddy romp and not something they'd want to see. The movie was better than that for sure but they weren't entirely wrong to dismiss it certainly there were aspects of it that absolutely were deliberately silly and those were all front and center in the marketing. Same with Into The Spider-verse. Generally considered to be a good animated movie but it didn't exactly break the box office because less people are interested in seeing a cartoon Spider-Man on the big screen.

TMNT is just uncomfortably caught between two different worlds. It's an action/adventure franchise much in the vein of many comic book properties that are killing it in movies right now but it's protagonists are anthropomorphic animals and that makes think it's more a childrens thing like Mighty Mouse or Samurai Pizza Cats or something.

Paramount only need look at their recent track record with property to see which direction is better. For all it's faults (and boy did it have many) TMNT 2014 was marketed along the lines of a movie for teenagers and young adults, had it's trailer premier before Captain America: The Winter Soldier and had at least some stylistic edge to it. It looked and sounded like a movie a movie for young adults. It turned out to be a bad movie for young adults but still one people wouldn't be too ashamed to buy tickets for. Contrast that to Out of the Shadows that despite it using all the nostalgia characters was aimed purely at pre-teens. Almost all the ads and marketing was aimed at kids and it tanked.

Leo656
03-20-2021, 05:43 PM
Yeah, like it or not any CGI animated movie is immediate visual shorthand for "Kids Movie". And right there you lose a sizeable chunk of the potential audience automatically. I know a ton of "adults" - even ones who love comic book movies - who absolutely refuse to watch cartoons or CGI animated movies of any kind. They'd watch a live-action TMNT movie if it was good or got good word-of-mouth - some of these people aren't even TMNT fans but just people who see pretty much "anything" that comes out - but they'd never watch an animated one. I'd go so far as to say that's MOST people over a certain age.

This is the problem they keep running into with TMNT. They see it as a "kids' thing" except that kids today DO NOT CARE about Ninja Turtles and so there will never be enough kids in the audience to make enough money back on any project. But they refuse to throw a bone to the audience that actually grew up with the brand over the last 30+ years, even though that would make a lot more sense if they actually want to make any money. They keep presenting projects that just automatically turn off a huge chunk of the potential audience by doing things like this.

It makes sense because CGI animation is cheaper than a live action movie, sure. The last two seriously under-performed, and so they don't want to take another risk. So they're aiming much lower and hoping they at least break even. Makes sense, but it's not actually gonna matter much. The brand needs the "credibility" that comes with having a successful live-action movie.

NinjaPug
03-21-2021, 08:40 AM
I don’t understand the thought process of ‘oh this isn’t coming out until 2023 - that means it isn’t going to happen’. Animated movies get announced 3-4 years in advance. Spiderverse was officially announced in early 2015 and was released in December 2018.

If anything, the fact that they included it in a press release detailing their tv animation for 2021-2022 and included a release date for the first time means it’s still moving forward

Viacom has made no secret that they’re going to exploit all of the IP for the near future. They’re not going to let a sleeping dog lie unfortunately.

neatoman
03-21-2021, 07:49 PM
I don’t understand the thought process of ‘oh this isn’t coming out until 2023 - that means it isn’t going to happen’. Animated movies get announced 3-4 years in advance. Spiderverse was officially announced in early 2015 and was released in December 2018.

If anything, the fact that they included it in a press release detailing their tv animation for 2021-2022 and included a release date for the first time means it’s still moving forward

Viacom has made no secret that they’re going to exploit all of the IP for the near future. They’re not going to let a sleeping dog lie unfortunately.

I don't know, Cubed is being weird. Two years from now really is nothing, maybe it'll get canned at some point but there really is no reason to think that'll be the case.

I think Cubed (and anyone who might agree with him) really just don't want this movie to happen, even if we really don't know anything relevant about it yet.

CyberCubed
03-21-2021, 08:22 PM
Movie projects can be abandoned. Imagi had a sequel movie planned that never got made with the Turtles de-mutated besides Michelangelo.

Since they also apparently have a live-action movie reboot coming, I don't think both that and a CG reboot coming out at roughly the same time is a good idea? This isn't like the Rise movie coming out on netflix which people know is based on the cartoon, this is a new CG movie with new rebooted Turtles. In addition to another movie reboot coming after.

Makes no sense to have two movie reboots coming.

neatoman
03-21-2021, 08:47 PM
The 2007 movie didn't get a sequel because Laird sold the franchise two years later, even if he hadn't it's doubtful the movie actually did well enough to justify it. It's also worth noting here that having unrelated adaptations run parallel is hardly unheard of, Sony made Spider-Verse alongside the MCU Spider-Man movies and they plan to keep both going as series. We also don't know for sure if the live-action project is still moving forward here, it's possible that one got cancelled for this CGI movie.

I don't understand why you think this movie, the one we just got an update on, isn't going to happen?

NinjaPug
03-21-2021, 09:05 PM
It seems pretty clear the live action reboot from Platinum Dunes isn’t happening.

Which option do you think Paramount is moving forward with? The one that they never officially commented was happening (one of the trades reported a writer had been hired for the Platinum Dunes reboot) or the one that they issued a full press release when it was announced last June and provided an update on last week?

CyberCubed
03-21-2021, 09:16 PM
I think they're both being shelved to be honest.

TigerClaw
03-21-2021, 09:17 PM
It seems pretty clear the live action reboot from Platinum Dunes isn’t happening.

Which option do you think Paramount is moving forward with? The one that they never officially commented was happening (one of the trades reported a writer had been hired for the Platinum Dunes reboot) or the one that they issued a full press release when it was announced last June and provided an update on last week?
Here's a theory. What if due to the success of the Sonic The Hedgehog movie, And they are currently working on the sequel. That one does well enough that Paramount hires the writers and producers of the movies to do the next TMNT live action reboot?

sdp
03-22-2021, 09:23 AM
Here is another theory, what if Sonic and TMNT team up in the next movie like they did in the archie comic and Ninjara is from the sonic universe and that way ninjara appears with the TMNT from the crossover to sonic's world and they can form a band.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DXG5QKwWAAEWhtt.jpg

Cyndaquilfan123
03-22-2021, 02:10 PM
I think they're both being shelved to be honest.

The PD one? Definitely. However, There's no reason to believe the CGI one is being shelved at this point in time. These things take a long time to produce. If there's nothing by say...mid 2022 there there would be cause for concern, but nothing to fret over at this point.

neatoman
03-22-2021, 09:47 PM
Again, we don't know if either project has been cancelled, there is just less reason to think the animated one has. The live-action project was announced in 2018 and last we heard of it was summer 2019. Now the fact the animated project was announced one year later could indicate it was replaced, that is true. On the other hand, the two projects would most likely aim to reach different audiences and 2019 isn't so far in the past we can really dismiss it yet.

Maybe we're getting multiple movies because Paramount isn't sure which direction is best for the franchise? Maybe the live-action movie is put on hold with the animated movie being a test to see if there's still interest in the franchise? Maybe the contract with PD states they need to make another movie? Maybe the animated movie is being made just because Seth Rogen begged for it?

Again yes, the live-action movie could have been shelved for the animated one, there's just not that much reason to think one or neither are still in development.

Andrew NDB
03-22-2021, 10:03 PM
The Rogen movie is for sure happening. He is white hot right now and if he already has the deal to make it, it's happening, period. We'd probably start seeing stuff from it late this year.

The "Rise" Netflix thing? I guess it's happening. Unfortunately.

The PD second reboot? No. I doubt it. It probably fell apart. And the deal for Rogen probably wouldn't have been on the table at all if PD was still actively working on it.

Slash-Dash
04-10-2021, 01:48 PM
Movie projects can be abandoned. Imagi had a sequel movie planned that never got made with the Turtles de-mutated besides Michelangelo.

Since they also apparently have a live-action movie reboot coming, I don't think both that and a CG reboot coming out at roughly the same time is a good idea? This isn't like the Rise movie coming out on netflix which people know is based on the cartoon, this is a new CG movie with new rebooted Turtles. In addition to another movie reboot coming after.

Makes no sense to have two movie reboots coming.

a new live action movie has never been confirmed. I'm sure it will happen one day but the cgi movie is most definitely arriving most likely next year.

FrederikWolferson
04-10-2021, 02:03 PM
The 2007 movie didn't get a sequel because Laird sold the franchise two years later, even if he hadn't it's doubtful the movie actually did well enough to justify it. It's also worth noting here that having unrelated adaptations run parallel is hardly unheard of, Sony made Spider-Verse alongside the MCU Spider-Man movies and they plan to keep both going as series. We also don't know for sure if the live-action project is still moving forward here, it's possible that one got cancelled for this CGI movie.

I don't understand why you think this movie, the one we just got an update on, isn't going to happen?

Wasn't it actually the #1 movie on its opening weekend,beating out 300? Thou,in retrospect,it was a pretty forgettable movie.

superstaff
04-10-2021, 07:01 PM
Wasn't it actually the #1 movie on its opening weekend,beating out 300? Thou,in retrospect,it was a pretty forgettable movie.

Yes, it was. However, it didn't have the best legs in the longrun.

Andrew NDB
04-10-2021, 07:05 PM
Wasn't it actually the #1 movie on its opening weekend,beating out 300? Thou,in retrospect,it was a pretty forgettable movie.

lol... 300 made 500 million, half of it domestic (shockingly only on a budget of twice TMNT 2007's 30 million dollar production budger). TMNT 2007 limped to 50 million domestic, not even hitting 100 million worldwide.

Leo656
04-10-2021, 07:08 PM
lol... 300 made 500 million, half of it domestic (shockingly only on a budget of twice TMNT 2007's 30 million dollar production budger). TMNT 2007 limped to 50 million domestic, not even hitting 100 million worldwide.

I'm starting to understand why so many TMNT fans have such a deep-rooted and borderline pathological hatred of Zack Snyder's movies. :lol: It all makes sense when viewed through the lens of history! :trazz:

Galactus
04-10-2021, 08:45 PM
I'm starting to understand why so many TMNT fans have such a deep-rooted and borderline pathological hatred of Zack Snyder's movies. :lol: It all makes sense when viewed through the lens of history! :trazz:

You've found us out. It's because 300 outdid a TMNT movie which most of us think is at best just okay.

On a serious note I doubt anyone expects a non Pixar cgi animated movie to be doing huge numbers. Better marketing and (let's be honest) better movie might have made TMNT '07 do a little better but it was never going to be a huge hit that would kickstart the revival of the franchise which is why it's so baffling to me that they are going that direction again.

Leo656
04-10-2021, 08:59 PM
Low Risk in hopes of at least a moderate reward.

They spent a lot of money on the last two live-action TMNT movies, and they sh*t the bed financially. Viacom sees TMNT in terms of a movie as a traditional "super-hero franchise" type of movie. That's NOT what TMNT actually is or what it should be, but that's what the people who own it and are developing it THINK that it is. And so there's no chance that they're going to ever do a smaller, more grounded (and less expensive) live-action film. It's going to be a big, bloated, expensive CGI-fest with lots of action set pieces, or else they're just not going to make the movie at all.

Since they did that twice in a row, and didn't do very well with it, they're stuck in "Just not going to make the movie at all" mode for the time being. They'll try again, eventually; but nothing anyone who was involved with the two BayTurtles movies has said out loud gives any indication that the people who made those movies understands what they did wrong. They THINK they made two really good TMNT movies and that the fans are just a bunch of whiny assholes. They don't understand they they got the entire concept wrong from the jump and that that's why the project failed. So rather than go back to the drawing board and reevaluate their entire approach, they're going to wait another 5+ years, let the heat cool off, and then do, basically, The Exact Same Thing all over again and hope it plays better.

In the meantime, they don't want the brand to get cold, so they do a low-risk animated project and hope to scrape in a little coin from that. If it under-performs, no big deal, they didn't spend $200 million on it so even if they only break even it wasn't a complete waste of time. Whereas if they did another big expensive live-action movie and failed, the repercussions across the board would be more serious.

FrederikWolferson
04-11-2021, 12:39 AM
lol... 300 made 500 million, half of it domestic (shockingly only on a budget of twice TMNT 2007's 30 million dollar production budger). TMNT 2007 limped to 50 million domestic, not even hitting 100 million worldwide.

In the opening weekend being the key here.

We did get a good TMNT animated movie recently. Batman vs the TMNT. And I'm looking forward to the sequel.

AlZarkovski
04-13-2021, 04:12 PM
Characters: https://www.theilluminerdi.com/2021/04/13/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-lds/

Andrew NDB
04-13-2021, 04:18 PM
Characters: https://www.theilluminerdi.com/2021/04/13/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-lds/

So...

Leo "is strictly business" and "Ralph" is stronger than him.

"Ralph" "likes to break sh**t."

Mikey "takes nothing seriously."

Don "feels like Matt Damon in Good Will Hunting." And "Donnie knows he’s smart, but his secret fear he’d never admit out loud is that if he was ever around people at his level, he worries he wouldn’t be able to keep up."

So... same caricatures (and a furthering of the "Raphael is the strongest Turtle" thing which seems as dumb as ever). The last one kind of reminds me of how Seth Rogen came off in the "Comedians in Cars" episode on Netflix where Jerry Seinfeld picked him up. He was downright scared sh**less.

NinjaPug
04-13-2021, 04:19 PM
Characters: https://www.theilluminerdi.com/2021/04/13/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-lds/

“Ralph”

That said this is probably legit as the only thing that website gets right is based off information from casting grids like that.

TigerClaw
04-13-2021, 04:22 PM
Characters: https://www.theilluminerdi.com/2021/04/13/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-lds/
I wouldn't trust a site like that. They and We Got This Covered are known for click bait articles, and posting about rumors without linking to a source.

Andrew NDB
04-13-2021, 04:25 PM
It sounds legit to me. But there are a LOT of typos and pretty obvious mistakes in that. The kind you might make if you were transcribing something you're reading into a Word document, or something.

Leo656
04-13-2021, 04:25 PM
I can buy Leo having a chip on his shoulder but I'm not a fan of him being supremely arrogant.

Also the whole "He needs Them more than they need Him" thing. That's... that's actually the inverse of how their dynamic usually works.

These are definitely some bad stereotypes masquerading as "characters". I can see the "illusion" of depth they're trying to project into each of them, but... doesn't quite wash.

Raph "with his hands in his pockets"... oh, GREAT, we're gonna get them wearing People Clothes again. Barf.

Yeah, I don't really like any of this, to be blunt.

It comes off as legit to me, because that reads exactly like what a room full of Hollywood hacks trying to "reinvent" these characters would come up with.

Andrew NDB
04-13-2021, 04:30 PM
I've listened to Rogen speak quite a bit and it does read "in his voice" very much.

Leo656
04-13-2021, 04:33 PM
And more "You can tell they're Teenagers because they'll be dressing in Teenage People Clothes" stuff.

"Yay."

Roseangelo
04-13-2021, 04:41 PM
Ralph has always been my favorite character.

:tsweatdr::tshifty:

Leo656
04-13-2021, 04:46 PM
I know, right? It's either ignorance or being too lazy to proofread, and both of those things, where I sit, are inexcusable.

I mean, I know that nowadays it's far more rare to find an article where there AREN'T any typos or spelling errors, but... I refuse to just roll over and go along with it. STANDARDS, people.

IndigoErth
04-13-2021, 04:58 PM
I don't even know what to think, it sounds like nonsense... it aught to be nonsense... but lord knows Nick & Co. are perfectly capable of nonsense.

hands in his pockets, crossed arms
Well there's an interesting way to sulk... stop being weird, Ralph.

Though I can't decide if they mean pockets literately or just figuratively.

All killer no filler? Eegh. Can we just... not? Leo being the serious guy is good. But that line someone thought was clever sounds more like a wannabe serial killer, not the sometimes morally conflicted boy scout who at times even sees the better potential in an enemy if they'd only change their ways.



Age: 13-16, Any ethnicity, (V.O.) LEAD
If there is any validity to this stuff at all... sounds like it might be pulled from casting info then. Basic descriptions for those looking to read for the parts.

Galactus
04-13-2021, 07:07 PM
Those character descriptions sound awful. Also I loath it whenever press releases about new versions of TMNT say they are going to focus on the teenage aspect of the characters. It's usually an excuse to show them skate boarding and acting obnoxious. The turtles being teenagers is the least relevant part the characters. TMNT is not a 'coming of age' story in any of its iterations.

Andrew NDB
04-13-2021, 07:11 PM
I suspect it'll be like a pie chart with like... 50% committed to the Teenage, 25% to the ninja, and the rest in service of a plot that will probably try to tug at the heartstrings in the manner of something between your average Pixar movie and a Judd Apatow movie.

IndigoErth
04-13-2021, 07:23 PM
TMNT is not a 'coming of age' story in any of its iterations.
Nick/Rogen: "Challenge accepted."

Andrew NDB
04-13-2021, 07:26 PM
It kind of is, if you take TMNT Vol. 1, #1-11, #19-21, and #48-62 as an overall arc. That is definitely a "coming of age" story, or at least it ends up being during CAW.

Galactus
04-13-2021, 08:02 PM
It kind of is, if you take TMNT Vol. 1, #1-11, #19-21, and #48-62 as an overall arc. That is definitely a "coming of age" story, or at least it ends up being during CAW.

I don't know. The first issue opens with Splinter pronouncing them as ready for their mission to take on the Shredder. We don't really see the journey they go on to get there.

After that they battle robots, find out a previously unknown aspect to their origin and go to other planets. None of that affects the characters in any meaningful way.

Focusing on the Vol. 1 Foot related stories the turtles (particularly Leo) suffer their first defeat and go on a journey to build their confidence back to the point they take on Shredder and the Foot a third time and win. That's not really a coming of age story. I would argue neither is City At War, I mean it's kinda suggested that perpetuating their war with the Foot out of a sense of vengeance, honour or simply because their bad guys is a quaint childish notion but I'm not sure that's a huge theme of the story.

IMJ
04-13-2021, 08:58 PM
The entire farmhouse sequence and decision to man up and return to New York without Splinter is a direct example of the coming of age elements....

Galactus
04-13-2021, 09:12 PM
The entire farmhouse sequence and decision to man up and return to New York without Splinter is a direct example of the coming of age elements....

Like?

Characters go on emotional journeys but we don't always say they are coming of age. I feel if the turtles were not teenagers no one would think the Mirage turtles vs Foot story as a coming of age one. The turtles don't really 'man up' in Return To New York. Raphael forces them to follow him and strangely Splinter isn't even mentioned or even featured in the story. It's all about their own personal honour.

LeotheLateBloomer
04-13-2021, 09:21 PM
I wouldn't trust a site like that. They and We Got This Covered are known for click bait articles, and posting about rumors without linking to a source.

I hope you're right because I'm not liking anything that I've read of the turtles descriptions.

All killer no filler? Eegh. Can we just... not? Leo being the serious guy is good. But that line someone thought was clever sounds more like a wannabe serial killer, not the sometimes morally conflicted boy scout who at times even sees the better potential in an enemy if they'd only change their ways.

They just can't seem to stop attempting to "reinvent the wheel for Leo.":roll:

TigerClaw
04-13-2021, 09:36 PM
I hope you're right because I'm not liking anything that I've read of the turtles descriptions.



They just can't seem to stop attempting to "reinvent the wheel for Leo.":roll:
Articles from that site got banned from the Power Rangers Reddit.
https://www.reddit.com/r/powerrangers/comments/jneqis/theilluminerdicom_has_been_banned_on/

They would usually post click bait articles with exclusive without mentioning any sources.

Andrew NDB
04-13-2021, 11:39 PM
I don't know. The first issue opens with Splinter pronouncing them as ready for their mission to take on the Shredder. We don't really see the journey they go on to get there.

It's not about getting to that point. They're still blank slates by that point. The "coming of age" in my mind is, they were raised all of their lives to one day kill Shredder... they DID, and now are kind of like, "Well, now what?" and have to figure that out. In CAW.

I'm leery to say either way whether the Rogen version will have Turtles doing legit ninja stuff and killing bad guys or if it'll just be a glorified "Kung Fu Panda" level of violence. He could deliver the goods.

newfan
04-14-2021, 02:41 AM
All killer no filler? Eegh. Can we just... not?


Yeah I'm not feeling that personality description.

Taking with a pinch of Salt until something more official comes out though.

AquaParade
04-14-2021, 03:28 AM
That's just the type of silly attempt at appearing vaguely realistic derail that makes me think it is fake - "all killer, no filler." That's rich. Good for a chuckle.
In other words, I don't think this is real. But I'm resigning myself to the fact that the movie could be something like this.

CyberCubed
04-14-2021, 07:37 AM
I just hope they keep their designs looking "normal" this time.

No huge Hulk Turtles with nostrils wearing clothing like the previous movies, and no major changes to designs like Rise did with Raph being bigger than all the others, Don's head being more square, etc.

Can't the Turtles just look normal again instead of trying to reinvent their look each time? That's all I ask for.

neatoman
04-14-2021, 09:35 AM
What do mean by normal exactly?

If you mean "cartoony" I don't think that's going to be a problem, given that it is an animated movie. If you mean they won't have any distinguishing features beyond the masks and weapons, I'm not sure they're gonna go back to that. That was correctly deemed to be a major flaw with how they traditionally looked, characters should be easier to tell apart visually than what we were usually given. Rise is obviously an absurd overcorrection, but I don't think we'll ever see another animated adaptation where they all basically look the same ever again.

IndigoErth
04-14-2021, 02:03 PM
I hope it's "normal" in a good design that isn't weird. Something akin to 2003 would be decent, but still without trying to be 2003. I'm afraid if they aim for a spacific version, FW or 1990 esp, it will never be quite right enough and be off putting...the way 2012's CGI FW Turtles kind of are, imo.

That's just the type of silly attempt at appearing vaguely realistic derail that makes me think it is fake - "all killer, no filler." That's rich. Good for a chuckle.
In other words, I don't think this is real. But I'm resigning myself to the fact that the movie could be something like this.
Yeah, that and some other parts feel as if they're written by a 17-year-old gamer.... but I'm not real familiar enough with Seth Rogen other than knowing he did Sausage Party, so I'm conflicted on if it would come from a grownass man like him or not. :tconfuse: (Though even if fake I guess a grown man still wrote it.)



Guess I'm too "old" and out of a particular loop to have known that "all killer no filler" has been around a while... but still sounds gross applied to Leo, so just no, please. Sounds like something the Rise version would say because it sounds "cool" to him.

Andrew NDB
04-14-2021, 03:03 PM
If there is no "ninja violence" in this up to and including killing... they're doing this:

XaOsX-vwKLw

neatoman
04-15-2021, 06:28 AM
If there is no "ninja violence" in this up to and including killing... they're doing this:

XaOsX-vwKLw

Was this inspired by the David Reimer case?

80gmrp
04-15-2021, 09:52 AM
I wouldn't trust a site like that. They and We Got This Covered are known for click bait articles, and posting about rumors without linking to a source.

Sorry I took so long to see the link of concern, but agreed. I certainly hadn’t heard of the site before (then again, I don’t regularly look up info about upcoming movies and games in the first place), combined with the typo for Raph others pointed out.

IndigoErth
04-15-2021, 01:33 PM
A couple days later and it doesn't really seem to be carried by any other sites with much more credibility, and what few there are just pulling it from this same one and still no sources about where it supposedly came from otherwise... Just fine by me if it's utter hogwash.

Who would make that "Ralph" typo though and not notice. Maybe some amateur media journalist who isn't enough of a fan to be a stickler about it wouldn't notice, but the article presumably wants us to believe that the descriptions are copy/pasted from somewhere... and I have a hard time accepting that any filmmaker or writer trying to come up with this film wouldn't have read over those descriptions enough times to catch it.

neatoman
04-15-2021, 04:54 PM
Anybody else find it a little weird that all of the Turtles in this movie will allegedly be defined by their insecurities? I'm not knocking any writer or director here, giving the characters some defined weakness is a good thing and insecurites are just as good as any, I just find it a little strange that it needs to be front and centre for all of them.

Anyway, if Don is going to be Will Hunting, can we get a psycho Splinter scene?
"If you ever disrespect Master Yoshi again, I will f%cking end you!"

https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-2x6f80WKHI8/XwXYzzluAkI/AAAAAAAAuhI/Zlzs59NGF0kjgtOD4FTUjyTt50YwMyOnwCLcBGAsYHQ/s1600/source.gif

Leo656
04-15-2021, 05:10 PM
The "N" in "TMNT" now stands for "Neurotic". :lol:

Slash-Dash
04-16-2021, 10:38 AM
not sure if we should believe the leak or not...

I just hope the character designs are decent.

Zulithe
04-16-2021, 11:58 PM
I hope this doesn't turn out like the Preacher adaptation Seth was involved in... it felt like it ripped out so much of what made the property unique and told a totally different story with characters halfway modeled after the originals. Sigh.

I will say... the Matt Damon inspiration could be a step-up for Donnie. They need to find a way to get the nerd angle while still cool.

Leo656
04-17-2021, 04:43 AM
The 11th Commandment is "Thou Shalt Not Adapt The Works Of Garth Ennis".

AquaParade
04-17-2021, 06:51 AM
I stopped caring for this movie the way you forget about your ex when a wonderful new partner enters your life. I guess “The Last Ronin” was the bone I needed thrown to me. I’m not calling the book perfect, two issues in, but it’s at least serving me my flavor of TMNT, which I’ve been starved of for too long.

I’m not looking to this movie to give me what I need anymore, on even that small level. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still quite curious and I’m not calling it a trash fire, without concrete details. I’m just content with this movie most likely being aimed at children. Another cartoon reboot I can more or less ignore without hesitation.

Slash-Dash
04-17-2021, 02:59 PM
when do y'all think we will se character designs? hopefully sometime this year.

srmff
04-18-2021, 08:49 AM
I can buy Leo having a chip on his shoulder but I'm not a fan of him being supremely arrogant.

Also the whole "He needs Them more than they need Him" thing. That's... that's actually the inverse of how their dynamic usually works.

It reminds me a bit of the angle that Rise used for Leo. In the 'Portal Jacked' episode, Leo said:
I will not be fine! There’s no team with just a faceman. I need my brainy guy, and my smashing guy and eats peanut butter with his fingers guy. I’m nothing without them

He was also quite arrogant in Rise. However, he wasn't the leader in that version and wasn't dedicated in trying to improve his abilities so he really didn't bring much to the team in that version except for coming up with ideas for the team now and again rather than Raph.

I've only seen the story posted on CBR and MOVIEWEB with both citing Illuminerdi as the source so it doesn't seem very reliable. The typos and Ralph further make it seem like it's probably fake.

IndigoErth
04-18-2021, 01:53 PM
I hope they don't keep trying to continue that angle. Playing on his common themes of sometimes losing his confidence and struggling a little to find it again is one thing, but twisting that into "deep down Leo is actually just useless/nothing without the rest" is terrible. Sure, they all bring different strengths and talents to the team which is an assent, but none of them should be nothing without the rest. They've all got the training and survival skills to go it on their own if they have to.

Not to leave the others out though, most discrptions aren't all that flattering for any of them.

Sure, play on their flaws, but lets not keep trying to dumb them down with it, huh, and fix some of the damage already done like that.

Along with called Raph "Ralph," I find the use of "turtle boy" also feels a bit awkwardly out of place and lends more of a fanfic feel to it... Hm.

ZariusTwo
05-10-2021, 12:36 PM
Rogen recently had an interview with The Times (although it is pay walled). Nothing about TMNT in it, but he does talk a bit about how dated some of his earlier films are.

FrederikWolferson
05-10-2021, 12:57 PM
Rogen recently had an interview with The Times (although it is pay walled). Nothing about TMNT in it, but he does talk a bit about how dated some of his earlier films are.

Apology tour, when? ????

Galactus
05-11-2021, 07:21 PM
Unlikely but I hope it's cancelled. A kids cgi movie that is not what the franchise needs right now.

Honestly I'm not sure TMNT can bounce back as a movie series anytime soon. The failure of Out Of The Shadows still taints the brand when it comes to live action and to be honest a big part of the 'success' of the 2014 movie was that it was the first time seeing these characters in a big blockbuster setting with modern effects. Even I who who followed the movies production and knew it was going to suck got a pang of excitement of seeing Leo jump from that water tower in the teaser trailer and though "wow this is actually happening". That is gone. Paramount is never going to replicate that excitement again.

TigerClaw
05-11-2021, 08:33 PM
Unlikely but I hope it's cancelled. A kids cgi movie that is not what the franchise needs right now.

Honestly I'm not sure TMNT can bounce back as a movie series anytime soon. The failure of Out Of The Shadows still taints the brand when it comes to live action and to be honest a big part of the 'success' of the 2014 movie was that it was the first time seeing these characters in a big blockbuster setting with modern effects. Even I who who followed the movies production and knew it was going to suck got a pang of excitement of seeing Leo jump from that water tower in the teaser trailer and though "wow this is actually happening". That is gone. Paramount is never going to replicate that excitement again.
I don't know about that, But TMNT is due for a new CGI animated movie since 2007.

Galactus
05-12-2021, 01:40 PM
I don't know about that, But TMNT is due for a new CGI animated movie since 2007.

Due for another CGI animated movie? That implies that people were waiting for another one after the Imagi movie...they were not.

AquaParade
05-12-2021, 02:38 PM
Seth Rogen is involved with the tv show adaptions of Invincible, The Boys, and Preacher.
It's actually not a bad track record for comic book adaptions.

It will probably be for kids, but there is a chance he mimics the source material to an extent. He definitely at least tries to take from the source material with the other three projects. Maybe Robert Kirkman was able to steer him in the right direction while they collaborated on Invincible. Wishful thinking.

neatoman
05-12-2021, 02:59 PM
Kirkman isn't involved with this movie is he?

TigerClaw
05-12-2021, 04:20 PM
Seth Rogen is involved with the tv show adaptions of Invincible, The Boys, and Preacher.
It's actually not a bad track record for comic book adaptions.

It will probably be for kids, but there is a chance he mimics the source material to an extent. He definitely at least tries to take from the source material with the other three projects. Maybe Robert Kirkman was able to steer him in the right direction while they collaborated on Invincible. Wishful thinking.
The question is, What will he used for the source material, He could either look at the mirage comics and go from that. But given how mainstream FW was back in the days. I wouldn't be surprise if he used that as the source material, But also look into some of the IDW stuff, He did emphasize the teenage part on one of the interviews. So we could see the Turtles with a lot more teenage angsts then we seen from previous movies.

Galactus
05-12-2021, 04:59 PM
The most likely route they'll go down is using the Fred Wolf show as their primary inspiration even though the last movie was basically that in live action and is so far the only TMNT movie to actually fail and almost finish the franchise.

There's a few lessons you can learn from that, one of which is that kids today are not interested in a version of TMNT that is based on a show they've never seen and have little interest in.

Leo656
05-12-2021, 07:48 PM
The "Preacher" show is generally despised by fans of the book, and while "The Boys" is generally better-received it also has very little in common with the books outside of costumes and character names, so it's a bit of a stretch to say that Rogen's involvement in these licensed properties implies any sort of "fidelity" to the source material. I haven't seen or read "Invincible" so I can't speak to that.

It's all more like "Kinda-sorta resembles the source material if you squint really hard", which is really no better or worse than any other "adaptations" out there from Marvel or DC or otherwise. Rogen's involvement in and of itself promises nothing.

Based on Rogen's age and general style of "humor" and priority, one can safely assume it'll be a FW-inspired take that maybe ages them up slightly to be about 17 or something. He's the same age as the group of fans who came into the franchise with the FW cartoon, and his type of "humor" is the sort of goofy stoner sh*t that makes Kevin Smith look like Quentin Tarantino. So you can already guess what he'd put together, and it will probably be dreadful.

AquaParade
05-13-2021, 07:56 AM
Yup, Preacher is generally despised by hardcore fans. I love the comics but never gave the show a real try, so I can't say. I definitely picked up on the disdain however.

The Boys and Invincible were generally very well received, and generally faithful adaptions. No, they may not be 100% exactly like the source material all the time (you can read the books for that), but they are very clearly revere the source material. Especially Invincible, I mean damn. If you can get the TMNT that close to the source material in the 21st century, that'd be a complete and utter win.

So, yeah, I'd say it's a pretty solid track record of adaptions, all things considered. If Mirage still owned TMNT and handed it over to this production team, I'd be damn excited. With Nick at the helm, odds are they skew a different direction.

FrederikWolferson
05-14-2021, 02:42 PM
With Nick at the helm, odds are they skew a different direction.
We saw their direction so far,it went from sometimes passable to- wtf is this Teen Titans Go ripoff. I doubt adding dick jokes will help.

Slime State Alumni
05-15-2021, 01:52 PM
I have a close friend who's an industry type in LA and the info he's feeding me about the new movie does not make me too excited. I'm going in with EXTREMELY low expectations.

TigerClaw
05-15-2021, 02:48 PM
I have a close friend who's an industry type in LA and the info he's me feeding me about the new movie does not make me too excited. I'm going in with EXTREMELY low expectations.
What can you tell us?

IndigoErth
05-15-2021, 02:56 PM
Surely there are character designs by now that we could see...? That might give us some sense of the vibe they're going with?

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/fe/aa/26/feaa260b7a8f4819539c38b8c5ba9855.gif


I guess they didn't get the memo that me being away from the computer and internet for several days due to work is the perfect time when they should finally put something out there so I'm made to be late to the discussion... Was kind of hoping that would happen. lol

Slime State Alumni
05-15-2021, 06:38 PM
What can you tell us?

Let's just say whatever you were hoping for, you're not gonna get it :lol:

TigerClaw
05-15-2021, 06:57 PM
Let's just say whatever you were hoping for, you're not gonna get it :lol:
That really depends.

IndigoErth
05-15-2021, 10:56 PM
Let's just say whatever you were hoping for, you're not gonna get it :lol:
I dunno, he sometimes wants the opposite of some of the general consensus around here, so he might be the only one that gets what he wants.

Andrew NDB
05-15-2021, 11:04 PM
I have a close friend who's an industry type in LA and the info he's feeding me about the new movie does not make me too excited. I'm going in with EXTREMELY low expectations.

Your avatar makes me wonder if you're the best judge on what "the fandom" wants.

But I mean... what? Are you talking the "take" on the TMNT? Is it kind of poised to be corny? Or are you just thinking there isn't enough Fred Wolf crap in there? Something else?

superstaff
05-16-2021, 07:30 AM
Your avatar makes me wonder if you're the best judge on what "the fandom" wants.

But I mean... what? Are you talking the "take" on the TMNT? Is it kind of poised to be corny? Or are you just thinking there isn't enough Fred Wolf crap in there? Something else?

If he had a real insider feeding him morsels, he'd reveal more details instead of being cryptic. I'm gonna assume he's lying or exaggerating.

Sumac
05-16-2021, 08:08 AM
As if any expectations regrading TMNT movies can be any lower...lol

CyberCubed
05-16-2021, 03:26 PM
After the two Michael Bay movies, and then Rise after that, I'm really not sure what other odd expectations I can have at this point.

Going full "Family Guy" humor with TMNT isn't what I expect either, since Nick will want kids to watch this and they're not going to go all adult comedy with it limiting sales to younger kids.

sdp
05-16-2021, 03:47 PM
It's going to be a comedy/action aimed at kids, think The Incredibles or Big Hero 6.

Andrew NDB
05-16-2021, 03:56 PM
If he had a real insider feeding him morsels, he'd reveal more details instead of being cryptic. I'm gonna assume he's lying or exaggerating.

I was just humoring the thought.

Galactus
05-16-2021, 03:59 PM
It's going to be a comedy/action aimed at kids, think The Incredibles or Big Hero 6.

I think this is the most likely rout the take regarding tone they will strive for. I also think that the Fred Wolf animated series will be the basis for the story and plot. I also think that it will just about break even because cgi animated movies that aren't Disney/Pixar joints rarely ever do well. I also think the regular suspects will treat not flopping as a huge success.

If he had a real insider feeding him morsels, he'd reveal more details instead of being cryptic. I'm gonna assume he's lying or exaggerating.

I'd take anything I read with a grain of salt but I am curious nontheless.

Slime State Alumni
05-17-2021, 02:04 PM
That really depends.

It's pretty bad. And I can't get into details because it could cost my bud his gigs, so pardon me for not wanting to delve too deeper for a TMNT message board.

Slime State Alumni
05-17-2021, 02:04 PM
Your avatar makes me wonder if you're the best judge on what "the fandom" wants.

But I mean... what? Are you talking the "take" on the TMNT? Is it kind of poised to be corny? Or are you just thinking there isn't enough Fred Wolf crap in there? Something else?

You're totally right, a screaming man in his 40's is definitely more indicative of the fandom. My mistake!

shredder orokusaki
05-17-2021, 02:47 PM
What he dont want to tell us is that it will be another very bad and and funny movie similar to rise of the teenage mutant ninja turtles series. That what he DONT WANT to tell us because he knows that evryone will be angry and dissapointed.

sdp
05-17-2021, 02:56 PM
https://media1.giphy.com/media/DWSTQMPMGHs8Z4fOMH/giphy.gif?cid=6c09b952uaaoqwtyrvvd1r47tm1govinu8tm f5yifjp7jgtc&rid=giphy.gif

CyberCubed
05-17-2021, 02:56 PM
It's pretty bad. And I can't get into details because it could cost my bud his gigs, so pardon me for not wanting to delve too deeper for a TMNT message board.

Do you think it's worse than the designs or tone seen in the Michael Bay movies or Rise of the TMNT for example?

AquaParade
05-17-2021, 03:50 PM
You're totally right, a screaming man in his 40's is definitely more indicative of the fandom. My mistake!

At the end of the day, Andrew's point is that a fan of the Fred Wolf cartoon may have no love for the darker tone of the Mirage books and vis versa.

So, if you love the Fred Wolf stuff, like Bebop & Rocksteady, and your buddy tells you "dude, this new tmnt movie is super dreary. There's no pizza, no Krang, and Rat King is in the movie but he doesn't even fight the turtles. Plus the turtles are like 30 years old"...well that could be one man's trash and another man's treasure.

Andrew NDB
05-17-2021, 03:52 PM
You're totally right, a screaming man in his 40's is definitely more indicative of the fandom. My mistake!

At least I'm not hiding behind a sh** children's character. Or hiding at all, really.

Leo656
05-17-2021, 05:24 PM
I'm always in favor of giving people the benefit of the doubt, but we've had so many people over the years come through here whose Dad totally worked for Nintendo, you guys, that I don't think anyone's ever offsides for being skeptical when anyone makes such claims.

That said, I do expect the movie to be terrible, but more because any non-Last Ronin, non-action figure TMNT stuff nowadays promises to be terrible as a general rule. So one needn't be Kreskin to make that prediction and have it turn out to be true.

IMJ
05-17-2021, 05:42 PM
Napolean Dynamite Dromers say:

"Yeah, Right. Who's The One That Knows Illegal Ninja Moves From The Government?"

Slime State Alumni
05-17-2021, 06:17 PM
Do you think it's worse than the designs or tone seen in the Michael Bay movies or Rise of the TMNT for example?

It's definitely more about tone since no pre production designs have leaked.

Slime State Alumni
05-17-2021, 06:19 PM
At the end of the day, Andrew's point is that a fan of the Fred Wolf cartoon may have no love for the darker tone of the Mirage books and vis versa.

So, if you love the Fred Wolf stuff, like Bebop & Rocksteady, and your buddy tells you "dude, this new tmnt movie is super dreary. There's no pizza, no Krang, and Rat King is in the movie but he doesn't even fight the turtles. Plus the turtles are like 30 years old"...well that could be one man's trash and another man's treasure.

Myself and my friend both agree that each iteration has it's strengths and weaknesses, and we definitely disagree on some things. For example, I thought Rise was a nice change of pace and the animation is above and beyond anything in the contemporary market. He, like many dromers, hates it and I understand why. It's a shame too because Andy deserves way more credit than he gets. That guy is one of the hardest working creatives in the industry and I wish the collective response wasn't overshadowed by a hardcore vocal minority.

Slime State Alumni
05-17-2021, 06:20 PM
I'm always in favor of giving people the benefit of the doubt, but we've had so many people over the years come through here whose Dad totally worked for Nintendo, you guys, that I don't think anyone's ever offsides for being skeptical when anyone makes such claims.

That said, I do expect the movie to be terrible, but more because any non-Last Ronin, non-action figure TMNT stuff nowadays promises to be terrible as a general rule. So one needn't be Kreskin to make that prediction and have it turn out to be true.

I don't doubt that. And as I mentioned before, I personally enjoyed Rise of the TMNT even though most users here seem to have some sort of irrational hateful attitude about it.

I rarely use these forums anymore as I've been a user for almost 2 decades (my old account was Donatello02) but I'll hop on every now and then just to see where the TMNT fandom is at or look at toy updates/debates. It definitely seems the fandom in general has grown more and more bitter/disillusioned as they've gotten older and it's a sad state of affairs if you ask me. That being said, Rogen's involvement coupled with what I was told about the concept for his film seems like a huge step back and says more about Nickelodeon as a company now than anything else.

Leo656
05-17-2021, 08:22 PM
Nick definitely is the sh*ts in its current incarnation. I think enough bad TMNT products have come out over the last decade that it's safe to say the wrong company bought the franchise. That isn't even a "hot take" anymore, it's just an obvious "no sh*t" statement.

It might be "evergreen" in the sense that Nick will fart out another mediocre-to-terrible reboot every few years to make another fast million or two in toy sales, but if it's all gonna be terrible I really don't see that "evergreen" status as a "good" thing.

Like let's be honest: Nobody's happy that Kurt Cobain killed himself, but everyone's happy that he never had a "Fat Elvis" phase.

AquaParade
05-17-2021, 09:46 PM
I don't doubt that. And as I mentioned before, I personally enjoyed Rise of the TMNT even though most users here seem to have some sort of deathcult attitude about it.

I rarely use these forums anymore as I've been a user for almost 2 decades (my old account was Donatello02) but I'll hop on every now and then just to see where the TMNT fandom is at or look at toy updates/debates. It definitely seems the fandom in general has grown more and more bitter/disillusioned as they've gotten older and it's a sad state of affairs if you ask me. That being said, Rogen's involvement coupled with what I was told about the concept for his film seems like a huge step back and says more about Nickelodeon as a company now than anything else.

Interesting. What would you ideally want in a Tmnt film? Just curious because it sounds like we aren’t getting that.

Slime State Alumni
05-18-2021, 02:49 AM
Interesting. What would you ideally want in a Tmnt film? Just curious because it sounds like we aren’t getting that.

I would like to see either a return to the Mirage roots similar to the 1990 film or something entirely different that keeps the basic fundamentals: they're teens, they're mutated turtles, they're ninjas, and they're brothers. Everything else is flexible. Again, this is why I was all for Rise. It kept the core idea of what TMNT is but played around with everything in between. What I do not want is a teen comedy that's just 2 hours of fart and dick jokes in a setting that has nothing to do with TMNT.

Slime State Alumni
05-18-2021, 02:53 AM
Nick definitely is the sh*ts in its current incarnation. I think enough bad TMNT products have come out over the last decade that it's safe to say the wrong company bought the franchise. That isn't even a "hot take" anymore, it's just an obvious "no sh*t" statement.

It might be "evergreen" in the sense that Nick will fart out another mediocre-to-terrible reboot every few years to make another fast million or two in toy sales, but if it's all gonna be terrible I really don't see that "evergreen" status as a "good" thing.

Like let's be honest: Nobody's happy that Kurt Cobain killed himself, but everyone's happy that he never had a "Fat Elvis" phase.

Nick has been a mixed bag. Ciro's TMNT was a homerun, Rise was great but pissed off the hardcore crowd, the Bay movies were surprisingly boring for a movie about teenaged mutant ninja turtles, and this new movie is just... I don't even know what to call it. And don't get me started on the recent IDW titles. That stuff is so phenomenally tedious and clearly pandering to the YA demo to the point of parody.

If you look at other evergreen properties, they all have their highs and lows. TMNT has had plenty of both. TBH I'm not too concerned because no matter what happens, whether it be the same tired formula or just a wildly off the mark take, we'll still have our preferred versions available.

Slime State Alumni
05-18-2021, 02:58 AM
At least I'm not hiding behind a sh** children's character. Or hiding at all, really.

You have my pity. What a sad, dreary life you must lead.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 08:31 AM
Nick has been a mixed bag. Ciro's TMNT was a homerun, Rise was great but pissed off the hardcore crowd, the Bay movies were surprisingly boring for a movie about teenaged mutant ninja turtles, and this new movie is just... I don't even know what to call it. And don't get me started on the recent IDW titles. That stuff is so phenomenally tedious and clearly pandering to the YA demo to the point of parody.

If you look at other evergreen properties, they all have their highs and lows. TMNT has had plenty of both. TBH I'm not too concerned because no matter what happens, whether it be the same tired formula or just a wildly off the mark take, we'll still have our preferred versions available.
2012 was a homerun? Really now?

AquaParade
05-18-2021, 08:59 AM
I think 2012 was a win. Granted, it's not my ideal representation of TMNT, I accept the parameters in which it was created, as a vehicle for selling toys, funding the brand, and indoctrinating children to the brand.

It did all that crud and still managed to be a solid TMNT show for kids. It's not like every episode I've seen is a win, but when they get it right, it's a great version of TMNT for kids. It's funnier, more visually striking, and better choreographed than any of the other TMNT shows we had up until that point.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 09:19 AM
I think 2012 was a win. Granted, it's not my ideal representation of TMNT, I accept the parameters in which it was created, as a vehicle for selling toys, funding the brand, and indoctrinating children to the brand.

It did all that crud and still managed to be a solid TMNT show for kids. It's not like every episode I've seen is a win, but when they get it right, it's a great version of TMNT for kids. It's funnier, more visually striking, and better choreographed than any of the other TMNT shows we had up until that point.
For me it was a whole lot of wasted potential. It had neither the story of 2003 version nor the humor of the original cartoon (which,granted was mostly so bad it's good type of thing). Writing was repetative and full of ass jokes,and the whole thing being CGI meant we only had 4 places to work with. So the whole thing is mostly turtles fighting Fishface in the same alley while being agresively unfunny.

newfan
05-18-2021, 09:35 AM
All personal tastes. 2012 will likely remain my favourite as I don't imagine there will ever be on older/adult version for TV media. I can't see myself caring about another kids show or kiddy movie (lets argue that this new one is going to be that) as much as it, but we never know.

I don't know what to expect with this movie but I'm taking a guess of it trying to hit a 'family' all ages mark but swaying a little on the goofy side. I'll check it out if it looks watchable and just not bother and stick with the versions I like if it looks like something I'm really not going to be interested in.
..well, unless my son wants to see it, then I will be off to the theatre if I am interested or not :).

sdp
05-18-2021, 09:54 AM
All personal tastes. 2012 will likely remain my favourite as I don't imagine there will ever be on older/adult version for TV media. I can't see myself caring about another kids show or kiddy movie (lets argue that this new one is going to be that) as much as it, but we never know.


well it was your first show, so to you that's how most of those characters should be, it's a good interpretation too even if not my favorite so yeah it'll likely remain your favorite take. I have no faith on anything TMNT related in the short term. I don't see viacom too convinced either.

Sumac
05-18-2021, 10:15 AM
TMNT 2012 was a wasted potential in my opinion as well.
First season was very solid and I thought that show had a potential, but season 2 was very weak and when season 3 ended up being cheap rip-offs of good movies I've abandoned the series. IMO, it was worse than Red Sky and Fast Forward.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 10:19 AM
All personal tastes. 2012 will likely remain my favourite as I don't imagine there will ever be on older/adult version for TV media.
That might be true. Considering Nick went for a Teen Titans Go ripoff after that,I doubt they will actually TRY anymore.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 10:22 AM
TMNT 2012 was a wasted potential in my opinion as well.
First season was very solid and I thought that show had a potential, but season 2 was very weak and when season 3 ended up being cheap rip-offs of good movies I've abandoned the series. IMO, it was worse than Red Sky and Fast Forward.
Not like they even homaged the movies,like say Simpsons did with Twilight Zone episodes,they went and reenacted the movies but with turtles. And I guess the got away with that kind of laziness because kids are not familiar with Nightmare on Elm Street or Friday the 13th.

NinjaPug
05-18-2021, 10:27 AM
Season 1 of the 2012 series is solid and still holds up for me. Everything after that is a mixed bag with the majority of it being pretty bad. I tried doing a rewatch recently and lost complete interest somewhere in Season 3. The change in writers after Season 1 hurt the show IMO. I'm sure there was a mandate to continue going with the monster (toy) of the week episodes but they lost focus with the overall narrative especially with the Kraang/April and the humor got more juvenile.

sdp
05-18-2021, 10:34 AM
That might be true. Considering Nick went for a Teen Titans Go ripoff after that,I doubt they will actually TRY anymore.

But they didn't go for a TTG rip-off, Rise is just something else. I think a TTG rip-off might've actually worked.

Slime State Alumni
05-18-2021, 10:38 AM
2012 was a homerun? Really now?

Yeah I know what I said. It was genuinely funny when it wanted to be, it was filled with references I never thought I'd see in a TMNT show, and the tail end of the last season was some of the best I'd seen from the license on a mainstream stage. The turtles are such a visual variety that made each one stand out much more than any previous version (great silhouettes so you'd be able to tell who is who even without color), Splinter was an actual threat and felt like a real presence that could hold his own unlike previous iterations, Shredder felt similar to the 2003 version minus the Utrom angle, and April was no longer a passive bystander.

I actually didn't care for the show initially as I thought the first few episodes were kind of uninteresting but that quickly changed by the end of the season. And I agree with previous comments about the middle seasons, but it picked back up again. All things considered, it was a solid show for a brand new license holder and Ciro was perfect for the job in terms of knowing what he wanted out of the characters, mythos, and art direction. My other criticism would be that NYC always felt nearly empty, but that's understandable considering the budget they were working with for the first few seasons.

While I did like the 2003 show, I always felt it was a little dry at times. I don't think TMNT should take itself that seriously considering its roots as a parody. Also the comedy was unbearable. Just the corniest cringe stuff.

Slime State Alumni
05-18-2021, 10:43 AM
But they didn't go for a TTG rip-off, Rise is just something else. I think a TTG rip-off might've actually worked.

Yeah I don't really understand that comparison at all.

IMJ
05-18-2021, 11:33 AM
I thought TMNT '12 was a home run - maybe not a grand slam, but it was solid. It was a rare example of a significant I.P. shift that still maintained the heart of TMNT very well, and brought a lot of fans back into the fold - myself included.

I will say that I was more forgiving of the show while it was airing, although now in hindsight some of the criticisms here on the forums are somewhat credible - the outer space season season for example. At those times during broadcast I just figured my interest was waning a bit, but in hindsight there may have been a few narrative mis-steps. But that show did everything it was supposed to and there were several moments where you could actually laugh out loud watching it, which although the goal of a lot of animation, almost never actually happens in real life.

TMNT '12 was overall very solid. I'd say that it's biggest weaknesses were some of the character designs, which didn't always meet with my nerd-approval. But c'mon already - that show with it's continuity, the Michelangelo moments, the repetition of Leatherhead pulling on Donatello's nose, the quirkiness of the character traits juxtaposed with the moments of great "ninja coolness" was all executed perfectly.

Some of the criticisms here have merit, sure. But overall that was a great show.

AquaParade
05-18-2021, 11:36 AM
But that show did everything it was supposed to and there were several moments where you could actually laugh out loud watching it, which although the goal of a lot of animation, almost never actually happens in real life.

TMNT was overall very solid. I'd say that it's biggest weaknesses were some of the character designs, which didn't always meet with my nerd-approval. But c'mon already - that show with it's continuity, the Michelangelo moments, the repetition of Leatherhead pulling on Donatello's nose, the quirkiness of the character traits juxtaposed with the moments of great "ninja coolness" was all executed perfectly.

Some of the criticisms here have merit, sure. But overall that was a great show.

Lol so true. The fact that the show actually got me to chuckle a few times was a big accomplishment, for me, watching a Nick cartoon, in 2012.

I always give major credit to any videogame that makes me laugh out loud, because it's so dang rare.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 11:50 AM
Oh yeah,Ralph with a beard in some Mad Max (see my point about lazy writing) pastiche. Groundbreaking stuff.

Zog The Magnificent
05-18-2021, 12:03 PM
I personally consider the 2012 show a win. It's my favorite of the bunch. The stupid finale notwithstanding, the 2012 show has solid characterization, a well though out plot that for the most part builds on what came before and answers most loose ends, consistent and measured character development, good humor, and some of the best action we've seen in the franchise. Plus, it's one of the only versions where April actually remains relevant. Also Splinter is especially good in this one.

As for the rest, I don't even hate Rise or the Bay movies. They all have their flaws, but when it comes to the TMNT franchise, I tend to like every version for different reasons. There's no one "correct" way to do it as far as I'm concerned, and as long as the core ideas are maintained, why not play around with it? It's one of the most diverse and adaptable franchises in existence.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 12:19 PM
It didn't have plot. It's status quo never changed and the characters never developed. They end up same as they started in season 1,just without Splinter.

Zog The Magnificent
05-18-2021, 12:29 PM
It didn't have plot. It's status quo never changed and the characters never developed. They end up same as they started in season 1,just without Splinter.

I beg to differ. The first season had the Krang invasion plot, which indirectly led to most of the mutants, as well as the turtle's origin. The Krang served as overarching villains for the first 3 seasons, along with Shredder, with many efforts focused on beating them. The fourth season had them go into space to track down pieces of a machine to avert the distruction of the Earth, followed by building up a final battle with Shredder. The only season that didn't really have a plot was the 5th one, which they decided to make after they had already wrapped up the story. Multiple characters died throughout, they actually took care of their villains definitively. There's also Karai, and her change from enemy to ally to family member, as well as her relationship to Splinter. April goes from being a regular teenager to a powerful ninja and true family member. Leonardo goes from an insecure teen to a solid leader. Raph learns to soften his approach to life and be a better brother. Even Donatello learns to let go of April eventually. Shredder experiences a series wide breakdown as he sacrifices more and more to achive his goal of killing Splinter. Michaelangelo doesn't really change a lot, I'll give you that. But to say that there is no plot and that the characters don't change just isn't true.

newfan
05-18-2021, 12:45 PM
I do feel there was some growth of characters by the end compared with season 1, sure they are still them but for example Leo was not that same inexperienced boyish hero wanna be from season one by the time they'd got to the end and had more experience.

Anyway, I feel like we are steering far from topic ...though while there is no news I guess we can can only go around in circles with speculation over the new movie anyway.

Zog The Magnificent
05-18-2021, 12:52 PM
Y'know, whatever it is, I'm fairly confident that I'll enjoy most of it, and then I'll come here and most everyone else will be complaining about how it's not Mirage. And then we'll do the same thing all over again when another TMNT comes out.

FrederikWolferson
05-18-2021, 12:56 PM
I beg to differ. The first season had the Krang invasion plot, which indirectly led to most of the mutants, as well as the turtle's origin. The Krang served as overarching villains for the first 3 seasons, along with Shredder, with many efforts focused on beating them. The fourth season had them go into space to track down pieces of a machine to avert the distruction of the Earth, followed by building up a final battle with Shredder. The only season that didn't really have a plot was the 5th one, which they decided to make after they had already wrapped up the story. Multiple characters died throughout, they actually took care of their villains definitively. There's also Karai, and her change from enemy to ally to family member, as well as her relationship to Splinter. April goes from being a regular teenager to a powerful ninja and true family member. Leonardo goes from an insecure teen to a solid leader. Raph learns to soften his approach to life and be a better brother. Even Donatello learns to let go of April eventually. Shredder experiences a series wide breakdown as he sacrifices more and more to achive his goal of killing Splinter. Michaelangelo doesn't really change a lot, I'll give you that. But to say that there is no plot and that the characters don't change just isn't true.
Krang invasion happens every 4 episodes in this cartoon. So they can recycle the Krang compound set.

sdp
05-18-2021, 12:58 PM
here are my thoughts on the 2012 ninja turtles (http://miscrave.com/articles/tmnt-2012), I agree it's great show and it was very well received, it's not my cup of tea in many decisions though. I have tons of problems with it and how they handled characters and not a fan in general, but it's still not a bad show, just not my preferred vision. I still prefer 2k3 and even the 1987 show.

The biggest weakness of 2012 was when it tried to adapt 1987/2k3 show characters, it was better when it was trying to do its own thing.

CyberCubed
05-18-2021, 01:39 PM
It didn't have plot. It's status quo never changed and the characters never developed. They end up same as they started in season 1,just without Splinter.

You can say that for almost any TMNT incarnation outside maybe Mirage. The Turtles all revert back to their archetypes in every series no matter what happens to them.

AquaParade
05-18-2021, 01:59 PM
I'm trying to say this without negating valid complaints, but I feel like expectations play a huge role in something like this. I just don't know how much you can expect from a series that needs to "serve as many masters" as TMNT 2k12. It's always a slight miracle when a children's cartoon can truly stand the test of time, like Batman: TAS.

For a show like this, if it can hold my attention for the entire runtime, it's probably doing something right. I never went into this show expecting to be wowed, so I came away impressed with what they were able to come up with and by the bits that are rather reverent of the original concept.

And before you think I'm someone who just accepts anything with a "TMNT" sticker on it, it simply isn't the case.

IMJ
05-18-2021, 02:01 PM
It didn't have plot. It's status quo never changed and the characters never developed. They end up same as they started in season 1,just without Splinter.

Yeah man... Um. Basically everything you put forth as a criticism here was the exact opposite of what actually happened on the show.

The seasons were all completely plot driven. They were so much so that the plots informed where the Turtles would be the next season.

The status quo changed from a "street level New York City action show" to an "out in the country mystery show" to a "dimension hopping sci-fi space show" and then came back full circle in the end.

Ending up where they started is a classic visitation to the roots in any storytelling. As for the characters developing? You answered your own question - throughout the show the brothers grew to the point where Splinter was ultimately gone, and although they missed him they evolved to where they didn't need him anymore. They grew autonomous.

LMAO... give me a break man. It's one thing completely if you didn't like the show for personal psychology XYZ, but quite literally everything you've said in the post I quoted is literally, demonstrably 100% wrong. When you do that it wreaks of phony intellectualism, rotten eggs, or just that you are trying to sound informed and never watched the show. I mean it's literally the exact opposite of what you've said here.

I'm trying to say this without negating valid complaints, but I feel like expectations play a huge role in something like this.

And see, at least this makes sense. I'd be more inviting of a long-term fan simply saying "TMNT '12 didn't give me what I've been looking for out of the franchise for 25 years now - I want a straight up, non-stop ninja show". And something like that would be credible. Not that other phony BS.

TigerClaw
05-18-2021, 04:14 PM
I thought TMNT '12 was a home run - maybe not a grand slam, but it was solid. It was a rare example of a significant I.P. shift that still maintained the heart of TMNT very well, and brought a lot of fans back into the fold - myself included.

I will say that I was more forgiving of the show while it was airing, although now in hindsight some of the criticisms here on the forums are somewhat credible - the outer space season season for example. At those times during broadcast I just figured my interest was waning a bit, but in hindsight there may have been a few narrative mis-steps. But that show did everything it was supposed to and there were several moments where you could actually laugh out loud watching it, which although the goal of a lot of animation, almost never actually happens in real life.

TMNT '12 was overall very solid. I'd say that it's biggest weaknesses were some of the character designs, which didn't always meet with my nerd-approval. But c'mon already - that show with it's continuity, the Michelangelo moments, the repetition of Leatherhead pulling on Donatello's nose, the quirkiness of the character traits juxtaposed with the moments of great "ninja coolness" was all executed perfectly.

Some of the criticisms here have merit, sure. But overall that was a great show.
TMNT 12 was pretty good, Except when they create new characters, and then slap the names of classic characters on them, So they are just characters in name only, and nothing like the originals.

Im not really happy with how they treated the Nutrinos and Wingnut and Screwloose, Such wasted opportunities.

CyberCubed
05-19-2021, 09:30 AM
Maybe this movie will be canceled now since Seth Rogen is being canceled.

FrederikWolferson
05-23-2021, 12:26 AM
2012 version was just wasted potential. Rise is just generic CalArts crap.

CyberCubed
05-23-2021, 10:52 AM
2012 version was just wasted potential.

They covered what they wanted to do for 5 seasons and 124 episodes.

sdp
05-23-2021, 11:12 AM
They covered what they wanted to do for 5 seasons and 124 episodes.

yes, horror tributes.

neatoman
05-23-2021, 12:35 PM
They covered what they wanted to do for 5 seasons and 124 episodes.

124 episodes and the show still got plenty of unresolved cliffhangers, how does that even happen?

sdp
05-23-2021, 12:38 PM
124 episodes and the show still got plenty of unresolved cliffhangers, how does that even happen?

what show doesn't end with a bunch of cliffhangers?

CyberCubed
05-23-2021, 12:50 PM
124 episodes and the show still got plenty of unresolved cliffhangers, how does that even happen?

I mean not counting the 20 (?) year time skip in the last 3 eps, everything was resolved. We know April's mother was dead, see see Mutagen Man's container at the bottom of the sea in the future.

Whatever mutants were running loose around the city like Snakeweed/Spiderbitez or whomever don't really matter because there's always random mutants out there and the whole planet becomes mutant world in 5 years time or whatever.

neatoman
05-23-2021, 01:00 PM
what show doesn't end with a bunch of cliffhangers?

Ones that can focus on the main story without intentionally leaving a bunch of open plot threads and/or gets more than enough episodes to reseolve them. If the show had not been so obsessed with introducing new characters and teasing their return, maybe this wouldn't have been the case, but they did tease the return of the Fugitoid and despite having 32 episodes left never touched on that. And then there is just weird horseshit like revealing Dregg was a robot and just ignoring it.

This would have been so easy to fix too:

Don't tease the return of characters you have no plans for.
Follow up on teasers within two seasons.
Make sure side plots are resolved within the season they're introduced.


I get that it could be hard in some cases, Spectacular Spider-Man only got 26 episodes spread out over two seasons, but this show got 124 and should have been able to resolve everything.

I mean not counting the 20 (?) year time skip in the last 3 eps, everything was resolved. We know April's mother was dead, see see Mutagen Man's container at the bottom of the sea in the future.

Whatever mutants were running loose around the city like Snakeweed/Spiderbitez or whomever don't really matter because there's always random mutants out there and the whole planet becomes mutant world in 5 years time or whatever.

Being told on twitter that April's mom was dead all along and seeing a container without context are not conclusions. One is the writer trying to handwave away a question and the other is ambigious. One sucks because the show itself never gave us an answer and the second one sucks because it's barely an answer that fails to explain anything important.

As for the random mutants running around, you do realise a major population center having an infestation of monsters hiding in the shadows isn't something that can just be ignored, right? That is arguably even worse than the first two because it should have major implications about what's going on.

Lame but proper explainations would have been to show mom's skeleton in a lab, have Don demutate Mutagen Man when Mike made anti-mutagen by accident and say that the EPF scooped up mutants to freeze until they could be demutated. Lame because the cliffhangers and teases might as well not even have been there if they weren't going to tell actual stories building on them, but actual explainations still.

Zog The Magnificent
05-23-2021, 02:33 PM
None of these things are cliffhangers. Even Fugitoid is just a sequel hook, but that one did annoy me. But anyways, all of these are just background details that got elaborated on sometimes. They were never subplots. April's mom was never a subplot, and the episode answered it: she's dead. All the actual plot points and character arcs got resolved by the end of the show.

IMJ
05-23-2021, 03:21 PM
How do you guys by and large feel about the character design and art direction? I thought TMNT '12 started off great on each; but as the show went on I can't help but feel that there were too many "Large animals" and fewer "mutants" that made for a cool hybrid of "man and animal".

I also didn't think that many of the character models were as attractive as I would have liked for "cool characters". For example, Slash with the exaggerated "pea-head" - I hated that character design. Wasn't a fan of "kid Casey" with the gap in his teeth although that design did, at least, suit the character as presented in the show. Maybe with the exception of Leatherhead, I wasn't a fan of anytime a mutant was simply a regular animal walking upright (Pigeon Pete, for example). Thought that the Rat King was a novel approach - I respect it, but didn't like it.

Thought the main 6 character designs were good, as well as Shredder and the Krangs. I really wouldn't mind watching this show again beginning to end and seeing how I feel about it now. Back when it was release it was anticipated TV for me as a show that drew me back into "something on TV" for the first time in years.

TigerClaw
05-23-2021, 03:33 PM
How do you guys by and large feel about the character design and art direction? I thought TMNT '12 started off great on each; but as the show went on I can't help but feel that there were too many "Large animals" and fewer "mutants" that made for a cool hybrid of "man and animal".

I also didn't think that many of the character models were as attractive as I would have liked for "cool characters". For example, Slash with the exaggerated "pea-head" - I hated that character design. Wasn't a fan of "kid Casey" with the gap in his teeth although that design did, at least, suit the character as presented in the show. Maybe with the exception of Leatherhead, I wasn't a fan of anytime a mutant was simply a regular animal walking upright (Pigeon Pete, for example). Thought that the Rat King was a novel approach - I respect it, but didn't like it.

Thought the main 6 character designs were good, as well as Shredder and the Krangs. I really wouldn't mind watching this show again beginning to end and seeing how I feel about it now. Back when it was release it was anticipated TV for me as a show that drew me back into "something on TV" for the first time in years.
I wasn't a fan of the Mona Lisa design, Since they made her a Space Salamander instead of a mutant from Earth.

newfan
05-23-2021, 03:44 PM
How do you guys by and large feel about the character design and art direction? I thought TMNT '12 started off great on each; but as the show went on I can't help but feel that there were too many "Large animals" and fewer "mutants" that made for a cool hybrid of "man and animal".

I also didn't think that many of the character models were as attractive as I would have liked for "cool characters". For example, Slash with the exaggerated "pea-head" - I hated that character design. Wasn't a fan of "kid Casey" with the gap in his teeth although that design did, at least, suit the character as presented in the show. Maybe with the exception of Leatherhead, I wasn't a fan of anytime a mutant was simply a regular animal walking upright (Pigeon Pete, for example). Thought that the Rat King was a novel approach - I respect it, but didn't like it.

Thought the main 6 character designs were good, as well as Shredder and the Krangs. I really wouldn't mind watching this show again beginning to end and seeing how I feel about it now. Back when it was release it was anticipated TV for me as a show that drew me back into "something on TV" for the first time in years.

It was mostly just spare/random humans that I didn't care for, found them plain/dull (guessing budget issues?) I'd not really thought too much about the ratios of human and animal in the mutants before, I did like Leatherheads design though. Agreed with Casey, both about the look but also that it went with the characterisation.

neatoman
05-23-2021, 04:10 PM
None of these things are cliffhangers. Even Fugitoid is just a sequel hook, but that one did annoy me. But anyways, all of these are just background details that got elaborated on sometimes. They were never subplots. April's mom was never a subplot, and the episode answered it: she's dead. All the actual plot points and character arcs got resolved by the end of the show.

Fine, sequel hooks, whatever. The point still stands, if they had no intention of making a continuation they might as well not even have bothered. Like seriously, if you get more than twice as many episodes as most cartoons, why not follow up on them?

Oh and no, the episode about April's mom did not answer it. April wonders if she might still be alive by the end and Leo tells her she shouldn't give up hope. So I am calling oxshit on that one, the show never established she was actually dead for sure, they implied they might follow up on it, they never did and the writer confirming it online is literally the only confirmation we got. Just because they never did an episode where they actively went out to look for her, that doesn't mean this wasn't an idea they threw out there and just ignored.

It's not even like the main plot of the show was even that good, it falls apart pretty quickly if you try to analyse it, and coupled with nonsense like this I don't really understand why anyone felt satisfied with the story.

I wasn't a fan of the Mona Lisa design, Since they made her a Space Salamander instead of a mutant from Earth.

I'm confused, is your problem the design or the backstory? Because I would say both are an improvement in some sense.

TigerClaw
05-23-2021, 04:21 PM
I'm confused, is your problem the design or the backstory? Because I would say both are an improvement in some sense.
The problem has more to do with the characters, They like creating new characters, and then slapping the name of a classic character, and pretend that its one of the classic characters.
Also her name wasn't really Mona Lisa, It was a name Raph gave to her.

One of the things this show did was have Michelangelo giving all the mutants a name.

I wouldn't say the backstory is any improvement when its nothing like the original character, Fortunately IDW stayed true the original in some way.

IndigoErth
05-23-2021, 04:40 PM
then slapping the name of a classic character, and pretend that its one of the classic characters.
The 2012 Neutrinos is probably one of the worst offenses imo in that regard, reusing the name on something else that is completely unrelated. They weren't necessarily a bad concept, but the naming seems lazy and would have been better off with one that was original.

I feel that doing that sort of thing also handicaps a potential reuse of a character/concept that might have been a decent one to bring back elsewhere in the franchise later (talking in general in the franchise, not 2012 Neutrinos specifically), but since it's just a "new" version of something else that will probably go back to a more recognizable form later if seen again... the new idea might not make a return.

Mona Lisa 2012 at least stayed a salamander-like being and already had an established (even if unseen) population/race of characters to make the alien angle make sense.

Zog The Magnificent
05-23-2021, 05:25 PM
Fine, sequel hooks, whatever. The point still stands, if they had no intention of making a continuation they might as well not even have bothered. Like seriously, if you get more than twice as many episodes as most cartoons, why not follow up on them?

Oh and no, the episode about April's mom did not answer it. April wonders if she might still be alive by the end and Leo tells her she shouldn't give up hope. So I am calling oxshit on that one, the show never established she was actually dead for sure, they implied they might follow up on it, they never did and the writer confirming it online is literally the only confirmation we got. Just because they never did an episode where they actively went out to look for her, that doesn't mean this wasn't an idea they threw out there and just ignored.

It's not even like the main plot of the show was even that good, it falls apart pretty quickly if you try to analyse it, and coupled with nonsense like this I don't really understand why anyone felt satisfied with the story.

Posing an idea is not the same thing as implying that there will be followup. It's just world building. The only two examples of subplots that they set up and then never finished that I can think of are Timothy, which had three episodes dedicated to it before it stopped appearing, and the potential return of Fugitoid. That one annoyed me because it undercuts his sacrifice, but then they never used him again so it was for nothing. But other details, like Arpil's mom, was never a subplot. It was simply a background detail that was part of the lore, and they decided to explore it for an episode. I had no expectations that it would ever be "answered" because the question was never really posed.

As for how I could be satisfied with the story, I guess I'll explain why I personally liked it. I felt that this show had very strong continuity, both in terms of the overall villain plots, minor events, and the character arcs. All of the primary characters had definitive arcs that had them progress from immature teenagers at the start of the show to full-fleged independant ninjas by the end. April stayed relevent the whole time, the stakes were high, characters actually died from time to time, Shredder has a pretty epic breakdown across the whole show, not to mention all of the various ways they implemented past elements from other incarnations. The plot moved foward, the status quo changed, the characters developed, the action was very good, and the show wrapped up basically all of its plots and ribbons, except for the ones I mentioned. It would have been better if it had stopped 16 episodes sooner, because yeah, the mad max finale was a terrible finale. But no one really considers it canon anyways. If anything, I think this show's main weakness was the same as the 2003 show: continuing past its natural conclusion. Other than that, I can't really understand why people who don't like it don't like it very much. The reasons always seem to be the same; "It has no plot, there are no stakes or character development, the plot falls apart if you think about it, it's just wasted potential," etc. These reasons always seem to be vague, in the case of "wasted potential," or flat out untrue, in the case of "the status quo never changes." What is it specifically that you don't like about this show? Is it just the percieved lack of general followup, or are there other things that you don't care for?

neatoman
05-23-2021, 05:31 PM
Sure it was a weird tendency of the show to effectively just create new characters with the names of old ones, but I'm not sure most of the characters they did take the names of were especially interesting ones in the first place. In the case of Mona Lisa in particular, there really isn't much to her character in all honesty. She gets gooped which randomly turned her into a lizard and then she crashes a party to stop a pirate, she never showed up again and I think the only reason anyone remembered her is because they like the idea of the character but not actually the character herself. Likewise, I really can't say I really care about the changes made to the Neutrinos, Tokka, Rahzar, Traag, Granitor, Armaggon, Wyrm, Wingnut, Antrax or Scumbug because I don't think any of them were good characters in the first place. In fact, I'm pretty sure the orignal Neutrinos, Tokka and Rahzar are actually hated for being bad characters.

The changes made to Bishop and Alopex bothers me a bit but those characters were actually... You know... Not annoying and worthless in their original forms.

I think it's a bit ironic that the one character they didn't want to change anything about, be it design, backstory or personality, is Muckman. You know, the literal pile of waste. I think making his eyeball a sidekick instead of a co-worker and giving him power of trash were the only changes made.

CyberCubed
05-23-2021, 09:25 PM
As for the random mutants running around, you do realise a major population center having an infestation of monsters hiding in the shadows isn't something that can just be ignored, right? That is arguably even worse than the first two because it should have major implications about what's going on.
l.

There's always random mutants just running around loose in every TMNT incarnation. It doesn't always need to be wrapped up especially for minor characters.

IMJ
05-23-2021, 09:53 PM
LOL... most I.P.'s that can be revisited over time receive new adaptations or updates. Reinventing or reimagining a character is what you do in new iterations of these I.P.'s. And doing so is not entirely the same (or as mundane) as the observation that TMNT '12 "slapped old names on new characters".

I mean... in that case, anyone who follows that very simplistic POV should by all rights only want to see a continuation of whatever past version of the intellectual property they liked the most because that's the only way you are going to get those characters without "slapping an old name on a new one".

Slash-Dash
05-31-2021, 06:52 AM
I wonder if we will see the character designs sometime this year?

CyberCubed
05-31-2021, 10:45 AM
I just hope a few things:

- The character designs aren't too cartoony or "out there" like the Rise of the TMNT designs

- The character designs don't look like Family Guy or other adult comedies

- The character designs don't look like the 2014 movie where they're all muscle bound nostril monster looking Hulks.


I mean how hard is it to just use "standard" designs for the Turtles. Even the 4th movie from 2007 got it mostly right.

Papenbrook
06-01-2021, 08:54 AM
I think that the upcoming TMNT project should try to observe and draw influence from both modern, comic-centric media and its own indie, action-thriller comic origins.

You know, from something like modern shounen ( My Hero Academia, Jujustu Kaisen, Chainsaw Man ) and darker, character-retrospective shows ( Invincible, The Boys ) - they are all sort of similar in tone to Mirage-TMNT.

I feel like that would be the best way to adapt the TMNT for the modern age.

Andrew NDB
06-01-2021, 09:05 AM
I think that the upcoming TMNT project should try to observe and draw influence from both modern, comic-centric media and its own indie-action comic origins.

You know, from something like modern shounen ( My Hero Academia, Jujustu Kaisen, Chainsaw Man ) and darker, character-retrospective shows ( Invincible, The Boys ) - they are all sort of similar in tone to Mirage-TMNT.

I feel like that would be the best way to adapt the TMNT for the modern age.

Anime crap? Absolutely not.

AquaParade
06-01-2021, 11:48 AM
I think that the upcoming TMNT project should try to observe and draw influence from both modern, comic-centric media and its own indie, action-thriller comic origins.

You know, from something like modern shounen ( My Hero Academia, Jujustu Kaisen, Chainsaw Man ) and darker, character-retrospective shows ( Invincible, The Boys ) - they are all sort of similar in tone to Mirage-TMNT.

I feel like that would be the best way to adapt the TMNT for the modern age.

It could be an interesting take. Not my cup of tea, necessarily, but more interesting than what they likely have cooking up.

NinjaPug
06-01-2021, 12:32 PM
I think this was just given an August 11, 2023 release date per Rogen's twitter.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E20BhPjVIAUR3KI?format=jpg

Vicky82
06-01-2021, 12:39 PM
I wonder if the voice cast will be announced soon.

AquaParade
06-01-2021, 12:50 PM
Holy crap, are they putting them in school?

In fact, call me crazy, but I think Baxter Stockman may be the teacher.

TheJ-manTurtleMan
06-01-2021, 01:34 PM
I think this was just given an August 11, 2023 release date per Rogen's twitter.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E20BhPjVIAUR3KI?format=jpg

Could the turtles be starting out as humans? Is that why they are in school? Is that drawing on the top left corner supposed to be what Leo thinks he looks like? Maybe some insight to his character design?

CyberCubed
06-01-2021, 01:41 PM
If the Turtles are human teenagers in school than I'm done. This is the biggest jump the shark moment in TMNT history since the days of Eric Sachs white man Shredder.

I knew it was too good to be true. I am sick to my stomach.

Sumac
06-01-2021, 02:06 PM
If the Turtles are human teenagers in school than I'm done. This is the biggest jump the shark moment in TMNT history since the days of Eric Sachs white man Shredder.

I knew it was too good to be true. I am sick to my stomach.
Agreed.
I am, kinda-sorta OK with idea that Turtles are reincarnations of humans, but making them humans in the beginning is as absurd as making them aliens.

AquaParade
06-01-2021, 02:30 PM
Maybe but I don't think so. Look at the little blurb that says "who am i?", and that drawing looks like a turtle to me.

I wouldn't be shocked at this point though.
They need to try something new with the franchise and they seem dead set against doing the obvious thing, like following the MCU's approach and adapting the comics, so where else can they go? Might as well make a damn mess and see what comes out.

CyberCubed
06-01-2021, 02:37 PM
Seth Rogen says Leonardo is "learning lessons" in school. Granted it could just be Splinter setting up his teaching of the Turtles when they were younger in a school-like setting in the lair, but that might be reaching.

Papenbrook
06-01-2021, 03:09 PM
So, this film will be scheduled for release in about two years.

I wonder if it'll be delayed.

Edit: Here's some additional info. (https://variety.com/2021/film/news/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-reboot-seth-rogen-1234985667/amp/?__twitter_impression=true)



Also producing from Rogen’s Point Grey Pictures production banner are co-founder Evan Goldberg and president James Weaver. Brendan O’Brien will write the reboot. He previously co-wrote the scripts for the comedies “Neighbors” and “Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising,” both of which Rogen starred in and produced with Goldberg and Weaver. Jeff Rowe, who co-directed and wrote the recent Netflix animated movie “The Mitchells vs. the Machines,” will helm the film. Paramount is handling the global distribution for the reboot.

TigerClaw
06-01-2021, 03:51 PM
Seth Rogen posted this image on his twitter.
https://twitter.com/Sethrogen/status/1399776734946357251

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E20BhPjVIAUR3KI.jpg:medium

Leo656
06-01-2021, 04:01 PM
D'you not read threads before you reply to them?

TigerClaw
06-01-2021, 04:11 PM
Could the turtles be starting out as humans? Is that why they are in school? Is that drawing on the top left corner supposed to be what Leo thinks he looks like? Maybe some insight to his character design?
I doubt it, But they were humans in the IDW comics via reincarnation.

Leo656
06-01-2021, 04:49 PM
I will take that as a "No."

Galactus
06-01-2021, 04:57 PM
Cue the usual suspects saying that we shouldn't pre-judge or panic at abitrary changes to the mythos...or at least it would if I felt even most of those guys hadn't moved on. This is a dead franchise.

sdp
06-01-2021, 04:58 PM
2023 is so far away that this could get stuck in development hell and cancelled. And if it isn't we won't be getting any info until SDCC 2022 with a teaser poster or teaser trailer.
Also those notes look like they came from a casual fan, this movie is going to suck if it does come out.

IndigoErth
06-01-2021, 06:03 PM
What am I even looking at... This is supposed to be Leo's school work? What.... Because not enough s*** has been thrown at the fan yet in recent years?

To be honest, my initial thought was that this mess was just Rogen's notes and needs to lay off the smoking of stuff... It as might well have been.

Galactus
06-01-2021, 06:38 PM
It could just be nothing or even an attempt to mess with us and create some buzz. I remember that when the 2012 series was in development there was a rumour the turtles were going to be in school and they were in high school with April in of those shorts Nickledeon did a few years ago which felt like idea test kitchens for future TMNT projects.

CyberCubed
06-01-2021, 07:33 PM
The guy who posted his "leaks" said most fans would be disgusted with the Turtles, I guess making them human teens before mutation was what he was talking about.

Andrew NDB
06-01-2021, 08:17 PM
I doubt it, But they were humans in the IDW comics via reincarnation.

That's not really the way reincarnation works. If you were a mouse in a previous life that doesn't make you any more mouse-like now than "not at all."

But yeah... if Rogen wants to make the TMNT into normal human boys before their mutation... yeesh. Count me out. That isn't TMNT or anything I'd be interested in seeing. And right away we could guess that "ninja" would be taking a major league backseat.

Leo656
06-01-2021, 08:20 PM
Now you got me curious as to how you know so much about reincarnation, sir. :lol:

Who/What did YOU used to be, "allegedly"?" :trazz: Tell us what you know!

CyberCubed
06-01-2021, 10:44 PM
I was just thinking if the Turtles are humans they can make them different ethnic groups since they don't have to be related by blood (and become "brothers" after training with Splinter), so they can say how racially diverse they are.

Leonardo will probably be Asian/Japanese because he's the most interested in martial arts. Donatello will probably be the geeky black kid, Raphael will probably be hispanic like Puerto Rican or something, and Michelangelo will be the white teen like spicoli or whatever. That way they can all be a racially diverse group before being mutated.

There was that thread a while back calling Donatello, "the black turtle" after all.

sdp
06-01-2021, 10:58 PM
There was that thread a while back calling Donatello, "the black turtle" after all.

He has the largest weapon of the four.

does that mean Raphael is asian?

Andrew NDB
06-02-2021, 12:57 AM
Now you got me curious as to how you know so much about reincarnation, sir.

Well, the whole thing about reincarnation is that you don't actively remember anything from your previous life... but who we are is the sum of our memories. So it is all fairly meaningless, even if it's real and we subscribe to it. Yes, you can maybe visit a psychic and they can tell you stuff or a medicine man can tell you about how the life you lived as a pigeon, allegedly... but it might as well be anyone else's memories or experiences, no?

Wildcat
06-02-2021, 01:06 AM
I think making them mutated humans is kind of cool for a reinterpretation. A lot of the other mutants were humans first. I don’t see why it would be a problem.

Could be friends in martial arts school who think they’re ready to fight. They mistake a situation involving the ooze for a common crime and they come in contact with it.

It’s really not that absurd. There’s a lot of sci-fi/horror stories with characters accidentally getting involved in or messing with something that changes them.

It would make they’re relationship with April easier too. Instead of doing the same - she discovers them and they all become friends.

Not sure about Splinter but he’s either been a rat that learned from watching or a human that also came in contact with mutagen. Whatever they come up with must be better than him learning from a book in PD...IF this is what they’re doing.

Leo656
06-02-2021, 02:17 AM
Once you change everything about a character or a concept but the name... it is no longer That Thing, anymore.

AquaParade
06-02-2021, 02:31 AM
To me, if you break down the core elements of tmnt, you have:

- family with some degree of dysfunction
- family has deep-seeded legacy that involves revenge or someone wanting vengeance on them
- outcasts
- ninja, samurai, fantasy, sci-fi elements

Do they need to be born as mutants for it to work for me? I'm not sure.
I'm pretty uncomfortable with the idea of them ever being human, but that doesn't mean it can't be done in a cool way. To be frank, my first reaction is to say "hell no."

Mind you, I'm not defending that direction, it just makes you think.

Wildcat
06-02-2021, 02:56 AM
Ya. I know people don’t like reimaginings, or just don’t like certain things changed, in long running franchises...but it’s 1 version after 30+ years. Human-to-Turtles TMNT can’t be a thing once?

Surely there’s wiggle room to try out a different origin this far down the line. Most things in pop culture have different versions that operate separately. Until they decide to do crossovers but that’s not the point.

Andrew NDB
06-02-2021, 03:12 AM
Ya. I know people don’t like reimaginings, or just don’t like certain things changed, in long running franchises...but it’s 1 version after 30+ years. Human-to-Turtles TMNT can’t be a thing once?

No. It can't. Maybe in a "What If?" comic or something. In a big budget movie this could irreparably harm TMNT at large in the worst possible way.

The Turtles aren't humans. It would be like making a Batman movie where he is a real giant bat, or where Spider-Man is a spider.

frank_one
06-02-2021, 04:08 AM
I was just thinking if the Turtles are humans they can make them different ethnic groups since they don't have to be related by blood (and become "brothers" after training with Splinter), so they can say how racially diverse they are.

Leonardo will probably be Asian/Japanese because he's the most interested in martial arts. Donatello will probably be the geeky black kid, Raphael will probably be hispanic like Puerto Rican or something, and Michelangelo will be the white teen like spicoli or whatever. That way they can all be a racially diverse group before being mutated.Perfect. And April and Casey are a gay couple.

Wildcat
06-02-2021, 04:26 AM
No. It can't. Maybe in a "What If?" comic or something. In a big budget movie this could irreparably harm TMNT at large in the worst possible way.

The Turtles aren't humans. It would be like making a Batman movie where he is a real giant bat, or where Spider-Man is a spider.
I think in the context of TMNT it would be fine because the result would still be their usual forms (assuming being human first is all they’d change about them)

We all already consider the turtles “human-like”. Don’t we? We view them as individuals with personal feelings and emotions regardless of appearance.

To be clear I prefer they be turtles all along but I think being humans is an interesting idea. A little surprised it hasn’t been tried yet.

Andrew NDB
06-02-2021, 05:18 AM
The Turtles were fundamentally created as mutated petshop turtles who grew up in a sewer to kill a man who have no idea about mankind beyond what they see on TV or happen to glance at as they scurry about in the shadows. They look outwards inwardly at a society they have no part in and have never have a part in. Until... April and Casey start to ease into their lives a little. And that becomes the interesting thing. As they begin to experience this thing they had no idea about.

Humans who become turtles radically changes everything. And removes -- for me -- like the only interesting part of the equation beyond the Japanese clan intrigue... which kind of has to be drastically reduced in a former human TMNT. Because what? Now some kids in a NY high school get mutated, meet "Splinter" and he sells them on some grand cause and invites them down into the sewer? That's stupid. That has nothing to do with TMNT.

0 interest in such a thing. And why should we hold TMNT at such a lower standard than other big properties?

Wildcat
06-02-2021, 06:14 AM
The Turtles were fundamentally created as mutated petshop turtles who grew up in a sewer to kill a man who have no idea about mankind beyond what they see on TV or happen to glance at as they scurry about in the shadows. They look outwards inwardly at a society they have no part in and have never have a part in. Until... April and Casey start to ease into their lives a little. And that becomes the interesting thing. As they begin to experience this thing they had no idea about.But have they ever been portrayed with such mystery from there standpoint? Maybe in the comics, I don’t know, but I mean in the cartoons and movies. They’re usually portrayed as typical “people” who have lived sheltered lives.

Humans who become turtles radically changes everything. And removes -- for me -- like the only interesting part of the equation beyond the Japanese clan intrigue... which kind of has to be drastically reduced in a former human TMNT. Because what? Now some kids in a NY high school get mutated, meet "Splinter" and he sells them on some grand cause and invites them down into the sewer? That's stupid. That has nothing to do with TMNT.

0 interest in such a thing. And why should we hold TMNT at such a lower standard than other big properties?Put that way it sounds dumb but being human first can definitely be interesting. For one they’d have family and friends. People who may not accept them after mutation. Hiding means relatives or the police could be looking for them. Characters besides villains. They don’t have to live in the sewers.

The Splinter/Shredder feud might have to be reworked a little but it’s not like he just uses them to get revenge. Being human first could actually introduce there own personal feuds. Not other teenagers. People who did there family wrong.

Andrew NDB
06-02-2021, 07:55 AM
But have they ever been portrayed with such mystery from there standpoint? Maybe in the comics

Oh by "the comics" you mean that pesky Source Material. Yes. It is there. And kind of stings a bit for folks who project their own nonsense into things. The 1990 movie (now 31 years removed from the equation) did a... fairly OK job of that. And that's like the only movie fans and audiences agree was fairly OK. So now let's radically reexamine that? Why? Why change the few things that universally always worked?

NinjaPug
06-02-2021, 09:09 AM
With Mirage Studios/Laird no longer having any creative input in the property things like their designs and their origins will likely continue to further move away from the source material.

TheJ-manTurtleMan
06-02-2021, 10:17 AM
Another terrifying thought I had was that if they do make the turtles human first (which I sincerely hope they DO NOT do) then a potential plot point could be them trying to find a way to turn back to human. I hate that idea.

AquaParade
06-02-2021, 10:32 AM
If that is the direction, I have to admit being surprised at the gall of Nickelodeon. "Rise..." seemingly failed because it was so "off brand", it doesn't even feel like TMNT.

I'd think that would nudge them in the opposite direction to try and be more faithful to the source material. Instead, it's like their attempt at "left turn" didn't work, so now they're just going for a full on backflip.
Just turn right, damnit. The end of the rainbow is two feet away.

That said, even if it sounds like the polar opposite of what I'd like to see, I am curious, and I suppose that's a reason to be alive.

CyberCubed
06-02-2021, 01:50 PM
We've seen some drastic changes from IDW/Nick already:

- Turtles reincarnated from Yoshi's sons in Japan. If it was just Yoshi and Saki reincarnated that'd be a different story, but they also technically had the Turtles past lives as humans

- April named the Turtles in IDW, not Splinter. I think people have forgotten this over time

- Raphael technically didn't grow up with his brothers for 1 year in IDW due to Old Hob snatching him away when he just got mutated

- In the 2012 cartoon of course Casey and April were made teens for the first time to grow up with the Turtles instead of being adults


Obviously villain origins get changed all the time, but the Turtles origins did get a shake-up already since 2011.

sdp
06-02-2021, 02:20 PM
IDW was never good and luckily since it's a comic book it'll be ignored by nick forever and once it's cancelled it'll fade to obscurity of the fandom.

frank_one
06-02-2021, 02:24 PM
Huge fan of Mirage here but I'm done playing the grumpy old 30+ fan who spits on everything that deviates from the source material. They can do whatever they think will work, I'm fine. Obviously I won't bother watching it, like I've never bother watching the Bay movies.
New versions and reinterpretations won't make the original material less important or less accessible and that's all I care about.
Even during the Laird/Eastman era we have seen new versions of the Turtles, like the FW cartoon or the Archie comics. Damn, Laird himself produced a series where Shredder is an alien, beat that! And you know what? That series is quite good.

TigerClaw
06-02-2021, 03:41 PM
Well I am looking forward to it and I'm a huge fans, I'm interested to see what Seth Rogen will bring to the table.

IndigoErth
06-02-2021, 05:20 PM
Can I just get a good, solid, normal TMNT in film (and in animated series) again before I'm frigging old?

Why are people so desperate to totally reinvent them and turn them into something they aren't, rather than, you know... let the TMNT be the TMNT and focus on exciting new stories instead of effing up the general foundation. I get that people get bored of the same stories retold over and over, and sure, most of us do, but new stories doesn't have to mean also changing who they are as characters. :tconfuse:

He has the largest weapon of the four.

does that mean Raphael is asian?

Great, thanks for the nightmare fuel, now I know what Leo actually meant by "my swords" when talking about mutation.

https://i.imgur.com/yRLLs3c.jpg



edit: How is it that this film was announced nearly a year ago and...this is where we're at and it's still over 2 years away. I know there has been a pandemic and all, but so much of an animated movie these days, esp the early stages, is totally distance/telecommute friendly. A year later and we see scribbles on paper.

Galactus
06-02-2021, 05:24 PM
Maybe we shouldn't jump to conclusions based on a piece of art but it would certainly fit the reports that Rogen wants to focus on the teenage aspect of the franchise. The flaw with that approach is the only reason the characters are even teenagers to begin with is Peter Laird thought that adding in Teenage Mutant made a catchier title than simply 'Ninja Turtles'.

Whenever the various cartoons and movies want to emphasise the teenage aspect they have them skateboard and eat pizza and so forth but that's as far as it usually goes because the characters have never acted like typical teenagers because the world they inhabit is so far removed from the typical teenage experience of curfews, homework, meeting girls etc. The only way to make them seem more like actual teenagers would be put them in high school. Being a animated movie they could try it that they are in disguise and the human kids and faculty are too dumb to notice or have them as humans who turn into Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Both approaches are ********.

The idea that the turtles are isolated from society has actually been consistent underlying theme in almost every version of TMNT. Whether it's played for laughs like in the '87 cartoon or more serious like in the comics it's always been there.

Heck one version that had this at the forefront was Nickelodeons own TMNT: Out of the Shadows and I hate to say to say anything positive about any of the Platinum Dunes productions but that was one of the better parts of that movie. I can't say that the exploration of whether the turtles should be human or not was something I ever wanted to see but it was actually handled pretty well, it had shades of X-Men: First Class handling of a similar theme. I actually would have liked more screen time devoted to that debate rather than the groan worthy sneaking into the Police station or the Planetarium stuff. Of course the reason why it worked is because they didn't pull the trigger and make the turtles human, not as a test to see what it was like or even as a gag like in the crappy 2000s Fantastic Four sequel were they had a sequence were they kept swapping powers.

Having them start out as humans is not only worse but it would probably be the most significant change anyone has ever made to the mythos even moreso than than Michael Bay's aborted plans to make them aliens and fight Col. Schrader. What would their relationship with Splinter be? Biological father? Gym coach? Karate instructor? Why would he train them (presumably) to fight Shredder and the Foot?

Every successful version of the property has had the Hamato Yoshi vs Oroku Saki rivalry at their core it's bizarre that they keep sidelining and jetison the central theme of the property. For all their faults the Mirage comics got it, the 80s cartoon got it, Archie comics got it, the 90s live action movies got it, the 2003 animated series got it, the IDW comics got it, the 2012 cartoon got it...even Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation got it. I have nothing against him but if he does away with this aspect then Seth Rogen doesn't get it.

CyberCubed
06-02-2021, 05:53 PM
Maybe we shouldn't jump to conclusions based on a piece of art but it would certainly fit the reports that Rogen wants to focus on the teenage aspect of the franchise.

I haven't checked since yesterday, but from memory one of the notes said the Turtles used to have 5 fingers and now they're down to 3...which implies going from a human hand of 5 fingers to the mutant turtle hand of 3 figures.

I don't know if these notes are what he actually plans to do, but if so, it's hard to not think he's going for human teenagers mutated to turtles.

Galactus
06-02-2021, 06:07 PM
Nickelodeon have probably had this as a plan for a while.

While I stand by that it was reasonably well done aspect in an otherwise terribly executed movie the fact that the turtles could potentially become human was such a random subplot to even have in Out of the Shadows. Then there is that crappy short were the turtles have become human and go to high school with April and all those shorts seemed like test pitches for future TMNT projects.

If Nickelodeon and/or Seth Rogen really think a movie about high school kids who moonlight as crime fighters is a good idea have them do Power Rangers. If they must change into anthropomorphic animals do Street Sharks. Just don't do TMNT.

Leo656
06-02-2021, 06:25 PM
I'm like thisclose to just making it my headcanon that the TMNT franchise ended entirely with "Turtles Forever".

Fact is we'd all be better off.

IndigoErth
06-02-2021, 06:50 PM
While I stand by that it was reasonably well done aspect in an otherwise terribly executed movie the fact that the turtles could potentially become human was such a random subplot to even have in Out of the Shadows.
Even there, at least they let the Turtles have differing opinions on it (okay it was just Leo who objected and for which I was grateful he did) and eventually change their minds as if they learned something somehow.

the notes said the Turtles used to have 5 fingers and now they're down to 3...which implies going from a human hand of 5 fingers to the mutant turtle hand of 3 figures.
It doesn't say they ever had 5 and even if easy to assume it still wouldn't mean much since most turtle species also have 5 digits on each, so it could go either way.

Considering the impacts of mutation is reasonable to touch on, and we've already talked about those things here before so goodness knows some of it could have served as inspiration (I know I've brought up the wonky nature of mutation and the losing of fingers myself once or twice), though it's not much of a detail to bother with for a plotline.

AquaParade
06-02-2021, 07:58 PM
Alien-turtles don’t sound half bad, now that I think about it.

frank_one
06-02-2021, 08:14 PM
If they start as teenage humans this imply we will see their parents and they will interact with them after the mutation. It's not like a teenager can go living in the sewer and leave his family without a reason. Unless all their parents die or are already dead. Maybe they start as orphans and happily accept Splinter (who will start as a rat maybe) as their father after the mutation.

IndigoErth
06-02-2021, 09:17 PM
Splinter is probably a science class pet...or the would-be dissected one that Mikey couldn't bare to hurt so he smuggled him out and escaped from his backpack when he went to karate practice after school. From that point the rat lived in the dojo and picked up some moves.

LeotheLateBloomer
06-02-2021, 09:36 PM
We've seen some drastic changes from IDW/Nick already:

- Turtles reincarnated from Yoshi's sons in Japan. If it was just Yoshi and Saki reincarnated that'd be a different story, but they also technically had the Turtles past lives as humans

- April named the Turtles in IDW, not Splinter. I think people have forgotten this over time

- Raphael technically didn't grow up with his brothers for 1 year in IDW due to Old Hob snatching him away when he just got mutated

- In the 2012 cartoon of course Casey and April were made teens for the first time to grow up with the Turtles instead of being adults


Obviously villain origins get changed all the time, but the Turtles origins did get a shake-up already since 2011.

You could make the argument if any of those aspects are actually good regardless if you like the material.

Can I just get a good, solid, normal TMNT in film (and in animated series) again before I'm frigging old?

Why are people so desperate to totally reinvent them and turn them into something they aren't, rather than, you know... let the TMNT be the TMNT and focus on exciting new stories instead of effing up the general foundation. I get that people get bored of the same stories retold over and over, and sure, most of us do, but new stories doesn't have to mean also changing who they are as characters. :tconfuse:

edit: How is it that this film was announced nearly a year ago and...this is where we're at and it's still over 2 years away. I know there has been a pandemic and all, but so much of an animated movie these days, esp the early stages, is totally distance/telecommute friendly. A year later and we see scribbles on paper.

If people are bored of the same stories told over and over, they haven't experienced Batman. That's a franchise that tells the same stories over to the point of regurgitation and yet they still manage to tell a multitude of different takes from Zur En Arrh to Gotham by Gaslight. He's arguably the most popular comic book superhero. TMNT aren't nearly big enough and hardly at that point where people can do radically drastic versions that stray from what it initially was. You have to build a base before you get ambitious because sometimes ambition can almost kill a franchise.

They either try to milk nostalgia from FW or try something unnecessary as opposed to a somewhat reasonable change. This company is very out of touch with what the fans want.

Nickelodeon have probably had this as a plan for a while.

While I stand by that it was reasonably well done aspect in an otherwise terribly executed movie the fact that the turtles could potentially become human was such a random subplot to even have in Out of the Shadows. Then there is that crappy short were the turtles have become human and go to high school with April and all those shorts seemed like test pitches for future TMNT projects.

If Nickelodeon and/or Seth Rogen really think a movie about high school kids who moonlight as crime fighters is a good idea have them do Power Rangers. If they must change into anthropomorphic animals do Street Sharks. Just don't do TMNT.

Now that I think about it, the concept origin for this kinda matches the origin for Battletoads where they started off as humans.

Either way, it's as though as if Nick is trying to find the worst possible people to run a film incarnation. First a guy known for explosions and now a guy known for stoner and sophomore jokes that can't stop getting high.

Andrew NDB
06-02-2021, 11:16 PM
I haven't checked since yesterday, but from memory one of the notes said the Turtles used to have 5 fingers and now they're down to 3...which implies going from a human hand of 5 fingers to the mutant turtle hand of 3 figures.

Or it could just be going from a normal turtle hand of 5 fingers.

AquaParade
06-03-2021, 09:04 AM
Makes me think of these figures:

http://img4.imagetitan.com/img4/small/24/24_abc.jpg (http://img4.imagetitan.com/img.php?image=24_abc.jpg)

Wildcat
06-04-2021, 12:50 AM
People talking about sticking to the source material, which is important if that’s what you’re going for but just trying something different does not mean you’re against it or don’t understand it.

Are we saying every adaptation of everything has to stick 100% to the original source material with no exception? I know there’s various levels of change but why can’t someone do human-turtles?

This might not be what Seth is doing but after many adaptations how is this one 30 years later forbidden?

People like to think change ups or reboots will do drastic harm and knock things out but that’s just not the case at all. How many times have fans said...”oh no, [this thing] will ruin the franchise”?

TMNT, Terminator, Ghostbusters, Transformers, Sonic (redesign helped the movie) and many others.

Cowa
06-04-2021, 06:36 AM
So we have come from "the turtles are aliens from outterspace that came to Earth to help Casey" to maybe "the turtles were humans before becoming turtles"? It seems they never learn.

Leo656
06-04-2021, 11:56 AM
Your point completely fails when the TMNT, Terminator, Ghostbusters and Transformers movies that people were worried about being terrible WERE all terrible, though. People said "That sh*t's gonna suck" and then that turned out to be the case.

On some level, your whole "Just give things a chance!" gimmick is admirable, to a point. But on the other hand... no. Not when most things DON'T actually deserve the benefit of the doubt.

AquaParade
06-04-2021, 01:45 PM
You can reinvent things and still make them work. Everyone will have a different line in the sand, in regards to how far you can take it.

There isn't typically one definitive thing you can point to that makes a franchise like this special. Certain elements resonate with certain people.

It's almost like the Ship of Theseus - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus

the ship of Theseus is a thought experiment that raises the question of whether an object that has had all of its components replaced remains fundamentally the same object. The concept is one of the oldest in Western philosophy, having been discussed by the likes of Heraclitus and Plato by c. 500–400 BC.

It is supposed that the famous ship sailed by the hero Theseus in a great battle was kept in a harbor as a museum piece, and as the years went by some of the wooden parts began to rot and were replaced by new ones; then, after a century or so, every part had been replaced. The question then is whether the "restored" ship is still the same object as the original.

That said... changing the turtles to humans is a pretty extreme example. I always say Batman is nigh-unbreakable character - you can reinvent him in many ways and still have a great concept.
But I'm not sure it'd work if your version of Bruce Wayne is a Golden Retriever (hmmm). I'd say at that point, even if it's cool, it's going to be unrecognizable as "Batman".

Short story long: I always leave a little room for subjectivity when it comes to what the "core elements" of a franchise are. I am also tickled by seeing concepts refreshed in exciting ways. Buuuut, when you're going this deep into reinvention, I can't blame fans for having an averse reaction. It's hard to imagine the turtles as humans without forgoing so many of the elements that made TMNT special in the first place.

Personally, if they do turn the turtles into humans, I can say this would never be the direction I'd choose for the franchise and it's not something that excites me. But I can't deny that bold ideas intrigue me and I'm curious to see what they do.

Leo656
06-04-2021, 02:10 PM
I actually don't think that's the concept they're going with, or at least I think people might be jumping the gun a bit to make such assumptions.

Then again, they almost made them aliens at one point, so if they DID make the Turtles into mutated humans it would in no way shock me. It is VERY clear to me that they have NO goddamn idea what to do with this property and are in full "Throw Sh*t At The Wall" mode.

But if they DID do that... no. Absolutely "no".

One thing that kills me about the very concept of "reinvention" is that most of the time even the "proper" versions of A Thing or A Property don't even get a satisfying resolution; they just fizzle out. And yet when we can't even move the story forward in any meaningful or satisfying way (or god forbid provide a proper ending) for any of the GOOD versions of a property, you have a bunch of people celebrating a completely off-brand "reinvention" or "reimagining", saying it's "good" just because it's "different".

At the end of the day, it's just because it's easier to just make up your own dumb sh*t than try and work within what's already been established. And if people say your dumb ideas are dumb, you get to say "They're not 'dumb'... they're NEW!" and all the criticism slides right off of you the second you call someone a "boomer".

I don't believe that ANY of these properties require (or would significantly benefit from) "reimagining" or "reinvention". The pieces are already on the board, and they work. Just arrange them in a way that doesn't insult your audience (or the property) and stop trying to reinvent the damn wheel.

Stan Lee once "reinvented" Batman, and it was the goddamn drizzling sh*ts. If that doesn't just about say it all on the subject, I don't know what would.

IndigoErth
06-04-2021, 02:58 PM
The franchise may not have done it before, but a "human version" seems quite common in fan art and fic, which makes the whole idea incredibly unoriginal to start with. Personally, I already find it boring in most cases when fans do it (no offense to anyone here who has) and isn't what I want the actual franchise doing.

Not entirely into the reincarnation angle either, but it's at least decently done and it works without too blatantly intruding on the normal foundation of the TMNT.

Making them humans to start with just takes away some of what's special about the Turtles. And how do I even say it so it isn't too awkward... The fact that these guys are a type of being and a skin tone that no human is or has lets them be openly relatable too all fans across the board since they are not any part of those demographics us humans stupidly divide ourselves into, and I'd rather that remain intact rather than force it to have to establish human race(s) for them. Let them stay that unique "other," which is also part of their own long established isolation from humans.



Again, I'm fine with new adventures for them. I'm even fine with new enemies and new friends. I'm not fine with taking away and fundamentally changing who the Turtles are as individuals, as a group, and as a family. Changing that up and making them out-of-character is ground zero of HELL NO for me. 'Rise' already chose to step in that pile and that show bombed.


edit: If they want to suggest mutation makes them a little bit human via human DNA getting involved, then fine, I have no issue with that, so long as they start out as regular turtles. That's an old thought that has been around or suggested already in various places for a long time, and a small enough detail that those who don't like that can ignore it.

Wildcat
06-05-2021, 12:35 AM
Your point completely fails when the TMNT, Terminator, Ghostbusters and Transformers movies that people were worried about being terrible WERE all terrible, though. People said "That sh*t's gonna suck" and then that turned out to be the case.

On some level, your whole "Just give things a chance!" gimmick is admirable, to a point. But on the other hand... no. Not when most things DON'T actually deserve the benefit of the doubt.
How the movies themselves turn out is a different question. My point was every time they happen fans claim they’ll damage the franchise for years to come.

That just does not happen. Off the top of my head I cannot think of any popular franchise that was doomed by a reboot, new version or even questionable sequel. They either have some success or it carries on and disregards them.

One thing that kills me about the very concept of "reinvention" is that most of the time even the "proper" versions of A Thing or A Property don't even get a satisfying resolution; they just fizzle out. And yet when we can't even move the story forward in any meaningful or satisfying way (or god forbid provide a proper ending) for any of the GOOD versions of a property, you have a bunch of people celebrating a completely off-brand "reinvention" or "reimagining", saying it's "good" just because it's "different".

At the end of the day, it's just because it's easier to just make up your own dumb sh*t than try and work within what's already been established. And if people say your dumb ideas are dumb, you get to say "They're not 'dumb'... they're NEW!" and all the criticism slides right off of you the second you call someone a "boomer".

I don't believe that ANY of these properties require (or would significantly benefit from) "reimagining" or "reinvention". The pieces are already on the board, and they work. Just arrange them in a way that doesn't insult your audience (or the property) and stop trying to reinvent the damn wheel.

Stan Lee once "reinvented" Batman, and it was the goddamn drizzling sh*ts. If that doesn't just about say it all on the subject, I don't know what would. Would reimaginings be ok as long as proper adaptations get their fair share first? Or doing anything out of the norm is never an acceptable idea just because it’s different?

There’s been many adaptations. Fred Wolf, 90s movie(s), 4kids, 2007 if you consider it separate, Platinum Dunes and Nick ‘12. To me these are the major ones. They were high profile or lasted awhile.

I’m not sure how any could have a “proper” ending though. The 90s movies had closure even if Soto was silly and part 3 did it’s own thing.

It’s not like the source material has been ignored. It’s been the base of each version. Personal opinions on them aside. I know PD reluctantly wrote it in.

Making them humans to start with just takes away some of what's special about the Turtles. And how do I even say it so it isn't too awkward... The fact that these guys are a type of being and a skin tone that no human is or has lets them be openly relatable too all fans across the board since they are not any part of those demographics us humans stupidly divide ourselves into, and I'd rather that remain intact rather than force it to have to establish human race(s) for them. Let them stay that unique "other," which is also part of their own long established isolation from humans.I like how you described this. I agree it’s part of their appeal. I just think there’s room for other interpretations now that everything about them is well established.

Leo656
06-05-2021, 12:44 AM
Transformers Movies = All Dogsh*t

Every Terminator movie after "Salvation" was garbage (and "Salvation" itself was well-intentioned but very flawed).

Both of the Bay TMNT movies were worthless.

Ghostbusters 2016 was complete f*cking trash, and "Afterlife" still very well might suck, we don't know. We have some baby Stay-Pufts and some footage of kids driving a car around a field; we know NOTHING of substance yet.

So if we're being honest, what we see is "When people say 'This is going to destroy the franchise'...", it turns out that they're RIGHT and that is indeed what happens.

Just like most of the time when you try and refute the points I'm trying to make, you accidentally prove them, instead. This has been One Of Those Times.
------------

With regard to the TMNT movie franchise, the Right thing to do is so simple that nobody will ever do it.

The 1990 movie was the only good one, and it did everything more or less "right" (even if some people wanted it to be more Turtle-focused). The origin, the characters, the lore, the tone, was all what it needed to be. It never had a proper sequel ("Secret of the Ooze" went so far off the reservation you can't even say with a straight face that it's a "real" sequel), there are still stories that can be told in that universe, and there's nothing anyone can or WILL ever do that would objectively be "better" than what that movie did.

So what you do, is pretend everything after that movie never happened, and just do a PROPER sequel set in that "universe". Obviously you have to update the cast and special effects, and probably fudge the timeline, but keep everything else the same and then just move the story forward from the end of the 1990 movie.

When it comes to making a TMNT movie, they got it right the first time and every attempt since then has just been different flavors of Failure.

SO. Don't "reinvent". Don't fix what isn't broken. Go back to the only thing that ever WORKED, and build on it.

That's the Right thing to do. Every other option is the Wrong thing to do.

It's not rocket science.

The Powers-That-Be immediately f*cking ruined the TMNT film franchise back in 1991, when they looked at the overwhelming success of the first movie and said, "Y'know what would be even BETTER? If we did everything COMPLETELY different, next time!" :roll:

That's what fixing sh*t until it breaks gets you. Vanilla Ice and Combat Cold Cuts. That's what happens when you favor "reinvention" over just plain doing sh*t the right way.

And there is a "Right Way". There IS a blueprint. It's called "TMNT 1990". Every bit of effort spent on "reinvention" instead of just going back to the source is a colossal waste of time and resources.

Wildcat
06-05-2021, 01:01 AM
Transformers Movies = All Dogsh*t

Every Terminator movie after "Salvation" was garbage (and "Salvation" itself was well-intentioned but very flawed).

Both of the Bay TMNT movies were worthless.

Ghostbusters 2016 was complete f*cking trash, and "Afterlife" still very well might suck, we don't know. We have some baby Stay-Pufts and some footage of kids driving a car around a field; we know NOTHING of substance yet.

So if we're being honest, what we see is "When people say 'This is going to destroy the franchise'...", it turns out that they're RIGHT and that is indeed what happens.

Just like most of the time when you try and refute the points I'm trying to make, you accidentally prove them, instead. This has been One Of Those Times.How does any of that equal the destruction of the franchise when they keep going?

As big a deal that people made over GB16 they greenlit a GB3 like 2 years later. Whenever it was.

Transformers exists beyond the movies but these were actually successful. In terms of profit and toys. Enough people liked liked them. It’s supposed to get a Beast Wars adaptation next.

Terminator keeps getting movies as surprising as it might seem. There’s an animated series in the works isn’t there?

If the PD movies did such damage to the TMNT we would not be having this conversation. Nobody would be working on anything.

Leo656
06-05-2021, 01:14 AM
The fact that they keep making bad movies everyone hates doesn't mean those series are "alive". They're alive the way zombies are "alive". Do I really need to explain this?

Terminator was one of the most beloved action movie franchises of all time... when it was only two movies. Now everyone hates it and wishes they'd stop making movies. Except you, for some damn reason. You're the ONE person I've ever seen say they want more Terminator movies; the rest of humanity wishes they stopped forever four movies ago. They will make another "Terminator" one day, yes... but NOBODY wants that anymore.

The Transformers movies made money but are "respected' the same way "Sharknado" is. "Stupid Sh*t For Morons". That's what's called a "Living Death", when your only function is as a punchline about just how dumb a movie (or series) can possibly be.

These things only keep existing because they are Brand Names and Hollywood thinks they are "safe bets". But they're trash now, and everyone knows it. Even the last couple Transformers movies under-performed, because the secret's out that they're no good. You can only force-feed people the same garbage so many times before they stop swallowing it. That's why the last few X-Men movies tanked. No direction, no consistency, just "People like this brand, they'll come see it even if we half-ass the movies." Turns out, you can't pull that trick on people more than once or twice, before they get smart to it and stop coming. X-Men was HUGE; by the end, nobody even WANTED any more of them, and the Disney sale/merger was a mercy-killing.

This is the sh*t I'm talking about; this is what the difference is between what YOU call "success", and ACTUAL success.

If you think "success" for a franchise means "It's easier to make 'Transformers 12' than make up a new franchise; even if it's a piece of sh*t at least someone will go see it", then I'm glad you're not part of the decision-making process. Those franchises are DEAD, with the exception of Ghostbusters which MIGHT not suck but is definitely limping after the 2016 disaster. And if "Afterlife" sucks, then guess what? Franchise is Dead. Even if they make another movie in 10 or 20 years, the brand will be a joke forevermore if they screw up One More Time. So we'll see.

Yes, they keep making movies based on familiar brand names. But if you think those brands are actually doing WELL...

El. Oh. El.

Companies who paid a lot of money for an IP want to capitalize on that IP. Obviously they try and make more product with that brand name, otherwise they don't get paid for it. It's called "return on investment". That doesn't mean they're "successful", it means they have a contractual and financial obligation to exploit that brand name or else they lose it to someone else who might accidentally do it better than them.

If the PD TMNT movies weren't failures, then we'd be talking about BayTurtles 3, and not "Stupid TMNT Reboot #121".

Make no mistake: the PD movies were failures. The only reason we're even getting this stupid CGI thing - Or ANY thing - is because Viacom wants return-on-investment. They think the name still has value, they want to squeeze a buck if they can. That's all it is.

But if they fail AGAIN... well, this franchise is already a bad joke. But if THIS one fails, then we likely won't see ANY TMNT movies of any kind for a very, very long time.

Wildcat
06-05-2021, 02:15 AM
No these franchises are not at peak popularity but they’re not zombies either.

There’s going to be point where everything settles into position and continues from there. It does not mean it’s struggling to stay around. Nothing exists in a constant form of “Whatever-Mania”.

Ghostbusters as a whole was stuck in the mud for decades for other reasons.

Transformers will always be successful on cartoons and toys alone. The Beast Wars adaptation is not from the same people. Neither was Bumblebee.

Terminator is kind of an oddball but it keeps going. I want War movies not just “T7”. I thought you did too.

TMNT will keep getting movies and cartoons as other long running properties do. That doesn’t equal dragging on.

I understand IP holders want brands to be relevant so they keep producing but the way you describe it makes it sound like every franchise is just a looping ploy.

I think every long running property has some level of staying-power or they would have been forgotten years ago. Nobody is going to keep wasting resources if literally nobody is paying attention.

So I see you’d accept a continuation of the 90s movie that ignores the others. That would definitely be cool to see. I wouldn’t even say it’s impossible.

Leo656
06-05-2021, 05:06 AM
Terminator is kind of an oddball but it keeps going. I want War movies not just “T7”. I thought you did too.



I'd want a Terminator movie that ignores everything after T2 - maybe some vague "some of it happened, but differently" elements of T3 can remain, but some of that movie is trash, too (not all or even a lot of it; but some) - and moves the story forward into the Future War storyline that was teased from the beginning but never adequately delivered on film.

Point of fact - and it's easy to overlook this because some people weren't around for it - but before Terminator was "a franchise", before T2 even existed and the entire plot of the series became a self-referential time-travel circle-jerk, the only thing that existed besides the first movie was the comics published by NOW Comics such as "The Burning Earth" and so on. For almost five years, before T2 came out, "Terminator" was depicted as a story set in the future about John Connor and his soldiers fighting a guerrilla war against the machines. The time travel subplot was like the Endgame of that, something they needed to do to ensure that humanity even had a chance to win, but it wasn't this constantly repeating thing that happened over and over. But The Story itself was The War.

It was good stuff, and it was interesting.

Then T2 came out, and it was amazing. But I hate to admit that in it's awesomeness, it kind of ruined the franchise forever, because not only will there N-E-V-E-R be a better Terminator movie, it also changed the entire thing into a story that's a constant loop of Killer Time Travel Robots. All but ONE of the six Terminator movies now has, essentially, the same exact plot with different details - "Bad stuff happens in the future, and a Hero and a Villain each come back in time to serve their own specific agenda, to either Ensure or Prevent that future." We've SEEN it, now. T1 was good, T2 was better, T3 was a flawed-but-necessary piece in moving the story forward into the Future War... but then "Salvation" fumbled, and so they panicked and went back to recycling the plot of the first two movies, because those were the only two movies that were universally accepted so they THINK that's the right thing to do. But it isn't. It's 100% the WRONG thing to do.

We've watched them try to "Fight The Future" for five f*cking movies. It's tired. If they MUST keep making Terminator movies, they don't need to do that again, and they don't need to "reboot" and do the first movie over with more CGI, which is probably what they'll do next. The only INTERESTING stories left to be told in the Terminator universe are the ones we've only seen hinted at, the actual Future War. "Salvation" was flawed, it ultimately was not the movie it should have been... but it's the ONLY Terminator movie in the last 20 years that was at least in the ballpark of what they should be doing. When it under-performed, the LAST thing they needed to do was more time-travel plot retreads and T2 fanservice. But Hollywood lacks imagination, so that's what we got ever since, and will likely continue to get.

Now, would I theoretically be accepting of another Terminator movie, or even two or three more, IF they actually executed on the Future War premise? Sure. It's why I defend "Salvation" even though I see it's problems; for all its flaws, it had the right idea, fundamentally. The war with Skynet is the ONLY stuff we EVER need to see from another Terminator movie, from now until the end of time. IF they decided to pursue that angle, I would support them in it.

BUT, all they want to do is recycle the plot of the first two movies, it seems. Last rumor I heard was a full reboot. So you can imagine how THAT's gonna go: They'll recycle T1 and the time travel plot, AGAIN. The "reinvention" angle of it will be more CGI, Sarah Conner will be non-white and Kyle Reese will be a woman named "Kylie Reese", probably. Sarah will still have a kid who grows up to fight Skynet in the future, but it'll be "Jane Connor" and not John Connor. And for these reasons it will be called a "Bold New Vision" and they'll squeeze a few more bucks out of it, but it will still just be the same basic plot we've seen in 5 out of 6 movies with "Terminator" in the title.

And in that case... yeah, since THAT is a million times more likely to happen than them actually making movies set in the future that move the story forward and aren't just recycled time-travel wank... yeah, I'd honestly, sincerely prefer that they just stop making Terminator movies entirely.
-------------

And if stuff like BayTurtles, or the TMNT being aliens or mutated humans is all we can ever expect from any future TMNT movies... then I'd honestly be fine if they never made another TMNT movie again, too.

If everything they can potentially do with a brand promises to be sh*t, then I don't need any more of it. The stains can be ignored, but they don't ever come off. No, I don't have to watch BayTurtles, but I can't deny its existence, or how it hurt the brand. I don't have to watch any Terminator movies after T2, but I can't pretend they didn't happen. "Our Scars remind us, that the Past is Real."

Let's put it like this: I don't have kids, but if I did, I would rather see them die young than suffer a lifetime of rape and abuse.

That's what it's like, when you REALLY care about these franchises - not "care" in that you want them to keep existing, but that you want them to be GOOD and remain pristine. You don't want them to simply "endure", you only want the very very BEST for them. Watching people make movies like BayTurtles or Transformers or the last few Terminators... it's like watching someone molest your f*cking kids.

And I'm not into that, and I'd honestly rather see things go away than be abused and perverted beyond all recognition. That is sincerely how I feel.

Wildcat
06-05-2021, 06:21 AM
Ya I give Salvation a lot of credit for giving us a war movie. I know it went through problems but I think it definitely tried to be creative. It’s cool seeing the other machine models, Skynet and John Connor running the resistance. I think people’s criticism is mostly because it does not match up to some 80s or 90s version in their mind. I’ve said this on other boards but those bits in the first 2 movies are so brief. I remember you mentioning the comics too.

Anyway I think we all want our favorite franchises to keep turning out good stuff but unfortunately we have to go through less appealing or bad versions in between. Every so often something worthwhile comes out of it imo. No franchise is always good.

It’s no surprise I personally like seeing different ideas and also how long something can go from one starting point. How big and far can you keep going. I just find both sides fun. I know that sounds like I don’t understand quality control but I do. I just think a lot of things happen to fit. Even if whatever it is becomes more extravagant than others prefer. It’s hard to put into words.

AquaParade
06-05-2021, 06:37 AM
To be fair Adam West Batman was nearly as perverted version of that character as you could make. And it didnt kill the character. Far from it. It may have kept him relevant long enough for us to eventually get our Neal Adams version, our Dark Knight Returns (another semi-reinvention), or Burton's Batman.

So reinvention doesn't always kill a franchise. Regardless of quality. It can be a mixed bag.

The Transformers movies may have driven themselves into the ground...but the movies also were the thing that put the franchise at their peak of popularity. Brand was laying pretty low before then.
Again, not great quality, but not really an example of a "reinvention killing the franchise."
The reinvention by Bay made the franchise huge. It was the lack of care and quality control that drove it back into the ground.

This could be the TMNT movie that keeps the brand alive another ten years, when we do eventually get the Mirage reinvention, instead of puttering out in five years.
Just one of many possibilities. Not saying it's the ideal path to take.

Leo656
06-05-2021, 06:58 AM
The 1966 Batman TV show accurately reflected the comics of its era. Hardly a "reinvention" so much as adherence to a "Anything super-hero related in this era must be completely toothless and palatable for 4-year olds" mandate. The comics of the day were stupid, ergo the show was stupid in turn. Credit where it's due, before the TV show the comics were about to be cancelled. So it probably is thanks to that show there even still is a Batman character in any form. But the fact is, by contemporary standards they were 100% "playing it straight".

Transformers is profitable and well-known, but it will never be respected again (if it ever was; I don't know about that but if there was ever a chance it MIGHT be that chance is gone forever now, certainly). Its only true legacy is as an example of "How dumb can we actually make a movie/series and still turn massive profits?". Proof that the general public really IS that stupid, and that they really will pay for and sit through anything. Seriously, it's the answer to a Trivial Pursuit question: "What movie franchise made over $5 billion dollars while conclusively proving that movie audiences have no standards or taste?" "Michael Bay's Transformers." That's not trumpet-worthy.

Put bluntly, that franchise is a busted whore.

Now, some people don't think there's anything inherently wrong with being a busted whore, and they think that it's a perfectly valid way to make a living. I don't fully agree, and I damn well wouldn't want anyone I love or care about to go down that path. And if they did, I sure wouldn't brag about it.

Meanwhile, "Reinvention" is only a few entries removed from "Rape" in the dictionary. You say "Tomato", etc. etc. etc.

Slash-Dash
06-05-2021, 07:55 AM
still over 2 years away... bummer. was hoping for a 2022 release.

I wonder if thats our first look at Leo on the top left. notice the L on his clothing.

Sumac
06-05-2021, 08:07 AM
Cue the usual suspects saying that we shouldn't pre-judge or panic at abitrary changes to the mythos...or at least it would if I felt even most of those guys hadn't moved on. This is a dead franchise.
It is much worse - it is a zombie franchise. Gutted from meaning and soul it exists as a shambling corpse puppeteered by greedy idiots, who don't really know what to do with it.

To me, if you break down the core elements of tmnt, you have:

- family with some degree of dysfunction
- family has deep-seeded legacy that involves revenge or someone wanting vengeance on them
- outcasts
- ninja, samurai, fantasy, sci-fi element

Do they need to be born as mutants for it to work for me? I'm not sure.
I'm pretty uncomfortable with the idea of them ever being human, but that doesn't mean it can't be done in a cool way. To be frank, my first reaction is to say "hell no."

Mind you, I'm not defending that direction, it just makes you think.
At this point it is easier to create a new franchise all together, rather than mutilate existing thing to fit whatever you want to do out of it.

Put that way it sounds dumb but being human first can definitely be interesting. For one they’d have family and friends. People who may not accept them after mutation. Hiding means relatives or the police could be looking for them. Characters besides villains. They don’t have to live in the sewers.
At this point it is a different story, not TMNT.
Words have meaning. Ideas have meaning.
And they are not interchangeable.

If you want to see something like this, why not to propose some sort of spinoff? TMNT'verse has plenty of characters that can fit the bill for your scenario.

Huge fan of Mirage here but I'm done playing the grumpy old 30+ fan who spits on everything that deviates from the source material. They can do whatever they think will work, I'm fine. Obviously I won't bother watching it, like I've never bother watching the Bay movies.
Which obviously means you are not fine with it. :D

Damn, Laird himself produced a series where Shredder is an alien, beat that! And you know what? That series is quite good.
And then he backpedaled on this decision and introduced human Shredder.

I'm like thisclose to just making it my headcanon that the TMNT franchise ended entirely with "Turtles Forever".

Fact is we'd all be better off.
I am getting closer and closer to this mindset, with every new iteration of the franchise.

People talking about sticking to the source material, which is important if that’s what you’re going for but just trying something different does not mean you’re against it or don’t understand it.

Are we saying every adaptation of everything has to stick 100% to the original source material with no exception? I know there’s various levels of change but why can’t someone do human-turtles?
Because, if they want to strip TMNT of one of their main defining traits, they DO NOT understand what it is about.

How does any of that equal the destruction of the franchise when they keep going?

As big a deal that people made over GB16 they greenlit a GB3 like 2 years later. Whenever it was.

Transformers exists beyond the movies but these were actually successful. In terms of profit and toys. Enough people liked liked them. It’s supposed to get a Beast Wars adaptation next.

Terminator keeps getting movies as surprising as it might seem. There’s an animated series in the works isn’t there?

If the PD movies did such damage to the TMNT we would not be having this conversation. Nobody would be working on anything.
All of your examples are hilariously bad, because, none of them are made due to the "fan demands", but, because, corporations are trying to milk famous properties, due to their creative impotency.

Also, I am not sure, how the **** all of this didn't damaged their respective franchises. TMNT was always a shadow of its 90s glory, past Fred Wolf days, but others like Terminator and Ghostbusters went from beloved series to "just shot them in the head and stop their suffering, please!".

Transformers movies are pretty much expected to be ****, thanks to stigma of Bay movies and Sonic having one successful movie, doesn't really mean anything.

No these franchises are not at peak popularity but they’re not zombies either.
When corporations produces new **** movies solely to capitalize on the famous name it is very definition of the zombie franchise.

Unless you consider something like Terminator: Dark Fate to be a "good movie".

AquaParade
06-05-2021, 08:26 AM
Leo, you make good point about Adam West Batman, sort of, reflecting the comics of those times.
They were both pretty damn goofy, so it's hard to argue. But it felt like the show was laughing at itself more than the comic was.

Either way, I'd have to say that even that goofy version of Batman, whether from the comics or show, was still a reinvention of Bob Kane's Batman, which was quite different from that era.

Thing about TMNT is, Mirage Volume 1 really set the table by showing how malleable the concept truly is. Issue #1 works, Soul's Winter works, City at War works.
Those three have as many differences as they do things in common.
It's one of my favorite things about TMNT.

Similarly, I enjoy musicians who switch their sound up from album to album. You know it's them, but they are going somewhere new. I believe that's what a lot of people want, but draw different lines in the sand.

Then again, some people do seem to complain if they don't get the same exact thing over and over. To me, at some point that starts to border on parody. If you want the original thing so bad, go appreciate it. On the contrary, when I love source material, I don't really need to see it replicated. I feel like I have it already. Let's take the concept and see if we can try something new with it now. Offen you get great results. That's how I think.
Let alone when taking something from one medium and translating it to another. Way too many complications there.

But I think I understand what you're saying. I agree that the examples you listed all screwed things up pretty badly. And maybe turning the tmnt into humans is a bridge too far for even me. Honestly, I do want to see the tmnt movie that is more faithful to the source material. Not the same exact story, by any means, but it's been way too far gone for my tastes.

Technogeek29
06-05-2021, 12:02 PM
I'm not seeing signs of Yoshi, Saki or Shen in this story and the last movie that ditch does elements bombed. I'm looking at this like a gift wrapped present with every warning label and red flag possible decorating it.:ohwell::tconfuse:

DragonSoul
06-05-2021, 02:19 PM
Looks like the teaser from Seth Rogen shows that the turtles will be taught formal education--the question is by who? The man with the flies above his head yelling "pay attention" maybe a Baxter Stockman nod. So it seems that the turtles are again intentional experiments in a lab instead of an accident. The turtles being humans is a huge leap to make from a simple teaser but it is understandable as past TMNT creators did terrible fan service in their reboots.

The writing capability of Leo is horrible--this maybe a nod that they are still animals and not humans. Leo also indicates his mutated animal features in his science notes. The one thing I find interesting is Leo writing down his brothers names with a subject like Mikey with drama or Raph with math. Does this mean that those subjects are their favorites? or the subjects they struggle in the most? I doubt Mikey struggles in drama though so it might be their favorite subject. Raph liking math is an interesting take on Raph. Leo trying to be cool is also an interesting take on Leo's character. Overall the teaser is interesting but there isn't much to make huge assumptions.

IndigoErth
06-05-2021, 03:45 PM
The one thing I find interesting is Leo writing down his brothers names with a subject like Mikey with drama or Raph with math. Does this mean that those subjects are their favorites? or the subjects they struggle in the most?
I assumed they were probably just the subjects his brothers were siting in while he was in science class, and Donnie's whereabouts unknown.

Yeah, also thought the writing would seem a bit too messy for Leo... although that's hard to fake so that's just the penmanship of Rogen himself (or whoever did this). lol


The drawing yelling "pay attention!" actually kinda looks more like Bishop with the short hair and what look to be sunglasses rather than regular glasses. :tconfuse:

Leo656
06-05-2021, 03:52 PM
Either way, I'd have to say that even that goofy version of Batman, whether from the comics or show, was still a reinvention of Bob Kane's Batman, which was quite different from that era.

The key thing to remember is that specific "reinvention" away from the original source material was more or less mandated by the United States government after comic books were accused of turning kids into juvenile delinquents. Overnight super-hero comics were faced with the dilemma of "Start pandering to preschoolers OR you won't be allowed to stay in print."

So it's not like such "reinvention" was an organic shift based on consumer demand; it was quite literally forced.

It's also worth noting that some of the things people get irrationally angry about with characters like Batman and Superman - such as the "No-Kill Rule" and the idea that above all they MUST always be presented in a way that's appropriate for young children - came from that same mandate. Before "Seduction of the Innocent" and all the courtroom ballyhoo, you had stuff like Batman shooting bad guys and Superman throwing villains in front of their own bullets, and nobody cried foul. Not until that Wertham idiot came along screaming about how comics were turning America's youth into hoodlums.

So yeah, it's not like the "reinvention" of super-hero comics into strictly-kiddie fare was ever a populist decision in the first place, it was a pragmatic reaction to government overreach. So it's kind of a dubious example to cite.

Credit must be given for how the characters and concepts managed to adapt and survive for so long despite the creative handcuffs, but it would simply be false to say "Batman and Superman became kiddie cartoons specifically because people asked for that." That's not at all what happened.

Galactus
06-05-2021, 06:17 PM
I would argue that the TMNT franchise has been ruined by bad adaptions. The franchise itself is not in a good place right now; a huge commercial flop like Out Of The Shadows followed by a flop animated series has put a lot of taint on the brand.

If the franchise was in a healthy place I have little doubt we'd be getting another live action movie. For a franchise which has had a string of live action movies to be reduced to a cgi animated movie shows that Paramount has very little faith in the brand. You could argue that we're lucky to be getting anything at all - but if what we do get is going to taint the brand even further then it shouldn't be done. It likely wouldn't kill the franchise completely but it would significantly damage it even more than it has been.

Comparisons to Batman are a little silly. No matter how Batman has been altered he's still always been Bruce Wayne who as a child saw his parents murdered, raised by his family butler Alfred he trained to become an expert detective and fighter and donned a bat themed costume to fight crime in Gotham City. It's always been the same. The fact that he's so consistent is a large part of the reason he's been so consistently successful.

Frankly TMNT has already been messed with far too much for my liking and that's part of the reason why people find the franchise so confusing and now it seems they want to change it again into something so fundamentally alters the characters. If it's true it's a disaster waiting to happen.

Leo656
06-05-2021, 06:28 PM
^^^On this, we agree.

Wildcat
06-05-2021, 11:27 PM
At this point it is a different story, not TMNT.
Words have meaning. Ideas have meaning.
And they are not interchangeable.

If you want to see something like this, why not to propose some sort of spinoff? TMNT'verse has plenty of characters that can fit the bill for your scenario. and closer to this mindset, with every new iteration of the franchise.

That’s a fair alternative. It’s surprising there’s never been a fully functioning TMNT spinoff of any kind.

All of your examples are hilariously bad, because, none of them are made due to the "fan demands", but, because, corporations are trying to milk famous properties, due to their creative impotency.

Also, I am not sure, how the **** all of this didn't damaged their respective franchises. TMNT was always a shadow of its 90s glory, past Fred Wolf days, but others like Terminator and Ghostbusters went from beloved series to "just shot them in the head and stop their suffering, please!".

When corporations produces new **** movies solely to capitalize on the famous name it is very definition of the zombie franchise.My examples show that at the very least they only do momentary damage. Their time/resources from start to finish if they end up failing to meet expectations.

Calling them Zombie Franchises is an exaggeration. Plenty of things come and go with various results. Like I said nothing exists in a constant state of peak performance. Things level out.

Also important to keep in mind each franchise has it’s own circumstances. It’s easy to say “Hollywood sucks” but each thing is where it is for different reasons and sometimes needs to work itself out.

Then again, some people do seem to complain if they don't get the same exact thing over and over. To me, at some point that starts to border on parody. If you want the original thing so bad, go appreciate it. On the contrary, when I love source material, I don't really need to see it replicated. I feel like I have it already. Let's take the concept and see if we can try something new with it now. Offen you get great results. That's how I think.
Let alone when taking something from one medium and translating it to another. Way too many complications there.Ya my original point was it should be ok to try a different take because we’re so far in. If changing the source material was done in the 90s movie that’s too soon. FW was the only other adaptation.
———

The current state of TMNT is nothing special but everything goes through slumps, hiatus’s or peaks and valleys. This is normal. It should not be defined as zombie or milking a brand.

frank_one
06-06-2021, 01:57 AM
The funny thing is that for the average tmnt fan the FW cartoon IS the source material while the Mirage comics is just a failed "early attempt".

AquaParade
06-06-2021, 11:05 AM
Comparisons to Batman are a little silly. No matter how Batman has been altered he's still always been Bruce Wayne who as a child saw his parents murdered, raised by his family butler Alfred he trained to become an expert detective and fighter and donned a bat themed costume to fight crime in Gotham City. It's always been the same. The fact that he's so consistent is a large part of the reason he's been so consistently successful.

Comparisons to Batman are pretty appropriate. You have legions of fans who believe that either the character should kill or shouldn't, which is pretty fundamental when you think about it.

Then you have the turtles who go from being raised as assassins to just...being raised, yet both versions have worked before.

But again, I'm not saying it's the same as turning the turtles into humans. It's easy too early to say that. It will probably veer pretty far off the source material and become unrecognizable to it, if I'm a betting man.

Leo, that's true about censorship & Batman comics, but the the question wasn't "what brought Batman comics to the point?", the point was whether or not Batman survived being turned into something he arguably wasn't.

IndigoErth
06-06-2021, 12:12 PM
The funny thing is that for the average tmnt fan the FW cartoon IS the source material while the Mirage comics is just a failed "early attempt".
Some fans, but even more-so the casual viewer who watched that show as a kid and might remember it fondly, but was never a favorite thing and may have no clue Mirage even existed before it. And sadly, they outnumber us...

It would be nice if some of those people could be shown through a good modern film and/or series that there is more to it and get them interested in finding out what else exists, and maybe help draw TMNT back a bit to that particular side of itself, instead of leaving people always expecting dumb kid stuff.


Saw a question the other day elsewhere online asking of TMNT comics are childish. Which of course sounds absurd to anyone with even a least a little knowledge. I can't even think of what might actually be childish outside of maybe issues related to Nick's shows. But people just assume these things, which is sad.

Wish the people who grew up with the 2003 series were a bigger, louder force of nostalgia that the makers of these things could see as a viable target. That at least would get it going in a better direction.

Jephael
06-06-2021, 05:06 PM
I'd been giving it a lot of thought what I feel constitutes a proper adaptation of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and I've come to this conclusion:

As long as the story includes Leonardo, Donatello, Raphael and Michelangelo with their signature color coded bandanas and weapons, being raised and trained by Splinter, befriended by April 'O Neil and on a never ending battle against Shredder and his forces, that's all that truly matters in my personal opinion. You can do whatever you like with the backstory and throw in whatever supporting cast you want, just so long as it makes for a good compelling story. The Archie comics I loved as a kid did that extremely well back in the day, and I often wish people would give them more credit for that. Then again I understand why some people didn't care much for that iteration, but to each their own.

Whatever Seth Rogen's team comes up with for the next film, it will either be a hit and people will love it, or it'll flop just like the Michael Bay nonsense that came prior. Until then, we'll all just have to wait with baited breath.

LeotheLateBloomer
06-06-2021, 05:31 PM
Some fans, but even more-so the casual viewer who watched that show as a kid and might remember it fondly, but was never a favorite thing and may have no clue Mirage even existed before it. And sadly, they outnumber us...

It would be nice if some of those people could be shown through a good modern film and/or series that there is more to it and get them interested in finding out what else exists, and maybe help draw TMNT back a bit to that particular side of itself, instead of leaving people always expecting dumb kid stuff.


Saw a question the other day elsewhere online asking of TMNT comics are childish. Which of course sounds absurd to anyone with even a least a little knowledge. I can't even think of what might actually be childish outside of maybe issues related to Nick's shows. But people just assume these things, which is sad.

Wish the people who grew up with the 2003 series were a bigger, louder force of nostalgia that the makers of these things could see as a viable target. That at least would get it going in a better direction.

Considering even FW fans enjoyed the 1990 film, I can't see why they wouldn't enjoy another Mirage style film. If they do, that would be very ironic and confusing.

Regarding 2k3 fans, I'm not sure how much Viacom/Nickelodeon will listen to them sadly. I guess we could try but it usually never works out.