![]() |
|
|
#11 | |
|
Stone Warrior
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Southern California
Posts: 912
|
Quote:
The one area I credit for being similar to 4Kids' show is that the status quo doesn't stay still in this show. A lot of characters change their appearance, roles, etc, and all of that is nice, but it never seems like the priority of the plot. We're basically getting a light repeat of the problem from the start of the first season; in that April loses her father, it's portrayed as something very dramatic, and then it gets ignored in many subsequent episodes. The episode with Casey, they didn't even bother to have April sad and neurotic over the loss. Now that we're talking about April, I'd like to address Ciro's point about how when there's a female character in a show, she runs the risk of being too powerful. I agree that's happened sometimes as of late. In earlier shows, like the Fred Wolf series, females were usually barred from action roles, and this has created a situation of resentment where we've gone the opposite direction. For example, The Powerpuff Girls and Kim Possible, where it seems the importance of feminism alone is enough to make girls invincible, which actually makes them less relatable to actual women. Naturally, those are comedies, but there's also Transformers Animated, which gave Sari Sumdac way too much power without providing any explanation, and to an extent, even the 4Kids show, which gave April just a bit too many talents. It's really not often you get somebody who can function as a brainy computer nerd, a ninja, and a jungle warrior, all in one. I mean; Batman can, but he's the star of his series. So there really is a risk of female characters becoming Mary Sues. I do have to criticize Nielli on a lot of his other related points, though. First of all, I don't think his Teen Titans show made Starfire and Raven too powerful; given the source. Starfire was, if anything, underpowered next to her graphic novel origin; there she was from a race of catlike warriors, while the show made her more of a ditz who had a lot of physical strength, but little finesse. Cartoon Raven was a better fighter than her graphic novel origin; both in terms of hand-to-hand combat and having gained telekinetic powers, but her most cosmic, demonic, dangerous abilities were, in fact, taken from the original. Secondly, how could Nielli be worried about creating a Mary Sue in terms of abilities, yet think doing so in terms of popularity and plot-centricism is fine. I wonder just how close we came to a Ninja Turtles show that was mostly about April, with all of the Turtles having crushes on her. Third and finally, though there is, in fact, the risk of making females too powerful, it's far from inevitable, and I don't think it's right to use that as an excuse not to have females.
__________________
![]()
|
|
|
|
|
| Tags |
| ciro nieli |
|
|