The Technodrome Forums

Go Back   The Technodrome Forums > TMNT Universes > TMNT Movie Discussion

Notices

View Poll Results: Who should have won the fight?
Leo deserved to win 17 19.10%
Raph deserved to win 48 53.93%
It should have been a tie 9 10.11%
I wish those two would stop fighting 15 16.85%
Voters: 89. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 03-24-2007, 03:51 PM   #1
jezza
Foot Soldier
 
jezza's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Surrey, UK
Posts: 170
Leo vs Raph - Outcome

Just to cause contraversy I have decided to create a poll on to gather peoples opinions on the outcome of Leo and Raphs fight. Who do you think deserved to win? Who was in the right or wrong?

Go
__________________

"You fight as brothers"
jezza is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 03:55 PM   #2
triplexxx
Mad Scientist
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 1,823
They were both right and wrong. They were both too self-righteous, But they were both making good use of their year apart. It's just that simply being apart is what boosted their egos & provoked this fight in the first place. If splinter had never have separated them in the first place, this never would've happened.
__________________
Please don't shoot me Mr. Big Mike. I'm too young and good-looking to die, well too young. I got a father, I got a mother, I got a grandmother, I got a little sister...and a little brother this high (raises hand), and a little brother this high (lowers hand), and little brother this high (lowers hand), and a little brother this high (lowers hand), and a little brother this high (lowers hand) and then I got a great big brother this high (slaps gun and runs).
"Fright Night" - Three Stooges
triplexxx is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 04:08 PM   #3
CJStyles
Hench Mutant
 
CJStyles's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 277
Will you get off your Splinter's to blame theory lol
__________________
CJStyles is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 04:10 PM   #4
triplexxx
Mad Scientist
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 1,823
Quote:
Originally Posted by CJStyles View Post
Will you get off your Splinter's to blame theory lol
Why should I? I did the math, I applied the logic, and I've good reason to think he's to blame. Don't like it? Try and stop me.
__________________
Please don't shoot me Mr. Big Mike. I'm too young and good-looking to die, well too young. I got a father, I got a mother, I got a grandmother, I got a little sister...and a little brother this high (raises hand), and a little brother this high (lowers hand), and little brother this high (lowers hand), and a little brother this high (lowers hand), and a little brother this high (lowers hand) and then I got a great big brother this high (slaps gun and runs).
"Fright Night" - Three Stooges
triplexxx is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 04:16 PM   #5
Rooish
Devil's Advocate
 
Rooish's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Toronto, Ontario
Posts: 2,130
Quote:
Originally Posted by triplexxx View Post
Why should I? I did the math, I applied the logic, and I've good reason to think he's to blame. Don't like it? Try and stop me.
I agree with you, triplexxx, but fortunately Splinter seemed a bit more oblivious to his actions in this movie than in previous versions. He was just a jolly old man. He probably didn't understand fully the conflict it would cause.
__________________


Thanks evan2000 for the sig!
Rooish is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 04:19 PM   #6
johnnyblaze
Stone Warrior
 
johnnyblaze's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 677
he seemed convinced that they could work it out and just plain happy to have all of his sons back together again. plus he did realize that something was wrong with Raph, and kept pushing Leo to mend the team he is supposed to lead. I bet however that he didn't think it would get to the point where the 2 would beat each other up
johnnyblaze is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 04:13 PM   #7
jezza
Foot Soldier
 
jezza's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Surrey, UK
Posts: 170
For me I think Raph deserved to win as it would just put Leo in his place somewhat. After the comments Leo was putting forward, I thought they were a bit touchy for someone who is supposedly a leader.

I'm not usually as big fan of Raph losing his temper, it shows a form of weakness taking it out on other people. But in this case I felt it was more justified than it ever has been before.
__________________

"You fight as brothers"
jezza is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 07:50 PM   #8
raphael_is_cool
Mad Scientist
 
raphael_is_cool's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: England
Posts: 2,151
It was a fight they needed really. Leo needed to see he wasn't almighty and Raph needed to prove himself.

I was just a bit letdown that they didn't actually 'pay off' the idea so much, as it seemed Raph became the leader and did pretty good while Leo became the damsel in distress. I guess I kinda like the idea as it doesn't follow cheesy cliches and that theme will probably run through sequels if they're made.
raphael_is_cool is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 09:41 PM   #9
twopinacoladas
Stone Warrior
 
twopinacoladas's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 717
Normally I would want Leo to win and normally I would have thought he would have won. It reminds me of me and one of my younger bros, who is quite a bit more built then me (has about 60 lbs on me) he could toss me around pretty good now if he wanted to. With that said Leo was way to smug saying "cause Im better than you" I thought it was almost out of character but Raph showing Leo up surprised me. I like all the turtles I would normally lean slightly towards Mikey and Leo being favs but I dont really have a fav. I liked Raph in that movie you couldnt help but feel for him at certain points in the flick.
twopinacoladas is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-24-2007, 09:53 PM   #10
Warhorse
Emperor
 
Warhorse's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Florida
Posts: 5,544
Quote:
Originally Posted by twopinacoladas View Post
Normally I would want Leo to win and normally I would have thought he would have won. It reminds me of me and one of my younger bros, who is quite a bit more built then me (has about 60 lbs on me) he could toss me around pretty good now if he wanted to. With that said Leo was way to smug saying "cause Im better than you" I thought it was almost out of character but Raph showing Leo up surprised me. I like all the turtles I would normally lean slightly towards Mikey and Leo being favs but I dont really have a fav. I liked Raph in that movie you couldnt help but feel for him at certain points in the flick.

I really loved Raph in here. Sure, he has his problems like everyone else, but he's certaintly not a bad guy.

And he is such the protector. Liked how he used his body as a shield for Casey when they were being shot at. I felt really sad seeing Raph fight off the tranquelizers all he could.
And then he had just had that mind blowing fight with Leo. I can imagine he would have had that out of body type of experience, which is pribably whu he ran and was confused, but the second he heard Leo scream, Raph was out to help Leo the best he could, but was too late, and Raph's scream towards the van that took Leo reminds me alot of the scream Raph bellowed when they realized Splinter had been kidnapped in the first movie.

Raph owned this movie. I feel bad that the others keep getting shafted, but I wonder, would Mikey and Don they have what it takes to carry a full length feature film? I definitely agree that they are much underused in this film. But Raph and Leo, they attract your attention because they just do.

I dunno, I feel glad that my favorite Turtle shined like a beacon in the night sky in this movie, but guilty that the other two didn't get the justification that was needed.

But I do think this Leo is far better than the Leo I have seen in the other movies, and about equal to the Leo portrayed in the 2k3 toon.
Warhorse is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 12:52 AM   #11
Masked Ninja
Doodles TMNT for fun
 
Masked Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: sploshin' through some sewer...
Posts: 2,137
To put things in context first:

Leonardo was once my favorite turtle... before I stopped being able to choose. But since his personality is a lot like mine, I'll probably always favor him a little over Raph. I just understand his motivations a bit more. I'm also the eldest of three, so I've even shared his role a bit in my life.

That said, this fight was great because I think both Turtles were justified. Raph thinks Leo is being cocky because he just got back from intensive training and is being pretty pushy about gathering his family back around him. Leo thinks Raph is being irrational and selfish by disobeying Splinter's orders just to go out and be a "showboating vigilante." He also is peeved because he sacrificed a lot of his time in order to better himself and his leadership for the team, and Raph doesn't seem to appreciate that. Of course, Leo got a little self-absorbed himself (as we saw in the beginning of the film).

And that's what I loved about it. They were BOTH right, and I understood both of their motivations. They also were BOTH wrong in certain ways. This is why I think this was probably the best Leonardo to date, because unlike the previous movies and even the old 'toon, he had a strong enough personality. I honestly think he's just as stubborn as Raph, but has better self-control. But unlike the 2k3 toon, he was shown to have serious faults (though his season 4 freakout was very appreciated by yours truly). Even on a good day, Leo is a little arrogant. It'd be hard not to be, when you are the most dedicated to training and explicitly selected as leader over the others. (which I don't think has ever been directly acknowledged in any other medium... he leads in the old toon, but is there evidence that Splinter directly appointed him? The movies and new toon have Leo as the unofficial leader - the others joke/whine about it but he seems to lead because he naturally does so. I don't know enough about the comics, maybe he leads officially there?)

*cough* Anyways. I keep getting sidetracked. I'll get to the meat of this.

While both Turtles (IMO) had good reasons to be ticked off, I think Raph winning was the best way to solve their problem. Coming back to his senses as he was crouched over his brother and ready to strike a killing blow was a wakeup call. He may be a disagreeable SOB at times, but Raph is no brother-killer, and what he was about to do slapped his major flaw in his face...hard. He also understood why Leo was more suited to lead, because allowing yourself to become blind like that is no help to anyone. Leo's line "you're not ready!" made sense to him then.

Consider what would have happened if Leo had won. Since he's great at keeping his cool, there would have been no "oh crud, what have I done?!" moment because he would merely have got Raph where he obviously couldn't continue the fight. MAYBE if he accidentally hurt Raph pretty bad it would be there (and in any case he would probably deal with some guilt internally) but my imagination sees Leo standing over Raph with a smug "I told you so" smile on his face. I love Leo, but I can see him being smug like that, no problem. And how would that have helped anything? Raph would just be humiliated, which would make him angrier, and any continued superiority from his big brother would certainly not make him any more inclined to follow, as it would inspire NO respect.

Raph winning is the only way it would have worked out, and I was glad to see it happen.

One last point I want to make: watch the "Who said I wanted to be led?" clip again. Notice how Leo sounds heated in his accusations right until he's about to drop the bomb, and he gets creepily calm. I think until that point his complaints were wholehearted, and then he was gathering for something hurtful. Not because he really meant it, but because he wanted to show Raph how ticked off his was about the situation and finally get a reaction. I've done the same thing (sad to say) in arguments with my own siblings back in the day. When your real accusations don't seem to sway them, you get mad enough to shoot off something that might be close to the truth but is really meant to get a reaction, because at that point your anger has reached its peak and you feel like provoking your opponent into a physical fight to drain off that anger.

It was probably a blessing for Leo to have been asleep in the cage, because the regret would have come fast and it would have hurt. He'll still have to suffer that, but luckily Raph had already forgiven him by the time he was rescued.

Dang, I should shut up. Hope that drivel was interesting to someone.
Masked Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 12:54 AM   #12
Fledermaus
Mad Scientist
 
Fledermaus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: SoCal
Posts: 1,115
It was interesting to me, MN! Another great analysis!
__________________
We're calling it a freeway. Eight lanes of shimmering cement running from here to Pasadena. Smooth, safe, fast. Traffic jams will be a thing of the past. I see a place where people get on and off the freeway. On and off, off and on all day, all night! Soon there will be a string of gas stations, inexpensive motels, restaurants that serve rapidly prepared food! Tire salons, automobile dealerships and wonderful, wonderful billboards reaching as far as the eye can see! My God... It'll be beautiful.
Fledermaus is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 01:04 AM   #13
Kunoichi_Haruko
A shell of a good hit!
 
Kunoichi_Haruko's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Richmond, Va.
Posts: 1,685
Quote:
Originally Posted by Masked Ninja View Post
Dang, I should shut up. Hope that drivel was interesting to someone.
Do go on, Masked Ninja. Your analyses are always insightful and thought-provoking. They're never a dull read.
__________________

Last edited by Kunoichi_Haruko; 03-25-2007 at 01:22 AM.
Kunoichi_Haruko is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 02:25 AM   #14
Willis
Thug
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 64
Very well written, Masked Ninja.

I can respect if this did have some secret message delt from Leo to Raph. I'd have to hear it from the horses mouth to accept it, I suppose. It may have finished that way but I don't think it started that way.

See lets take two steps backwards and remember when Leo came into the scene. Through the entire movie Leo is talking smack about the NightWatcher. And when they finally meet up, what does Leonardo do? Lecture and talk smack. When Raph is revealed, what does Leo do? Begin to lecture..again.. But Raphael shuts him up for a second using his fist. Giving Raph the chance to talk.

That whole argument between Leonardo an Raphael - Never once does Raph make a comment on why he is or is not the leader of a team. But Raph wanting to be allowed to make his own decisions about what he can and cannot do.

This I see as best when Leonardo cries out "I was training to be a better leader.. for you! Why do you hate me for that?" Does Raph say "yeah, I hate you!" , or does he say "well why do YOU have to be the leader?".. no.. he argues about why HE even has to have a leader.

Thats when Leo chimes in about Raph's weaknesses and the famous "I'm better." Comment. I just can't see that being about ANYTHING but who was the stronger fighter.
Willis is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 08:13 AM   #15
jenna
Mad Scientist
 
jenna's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Cambridge, UK
Posts: 1,190
Hi there! I am new here and scared because I am technically inept and not sure if I'm posting correctly, but here goes...

I agree with Masked Ninja and would like to add a thought:

Leo and Raph are fighting about more than just leadership. Raphael is resentful of Leonardo for going away and feels rejected that he stayed away and forgot about his family - he moved on whilst the others had to stay and this has increased his anger with Leo. Splinter knows this and even said to Leo that his absence had been hard for Raph and that Leo should take steps to mend the damage. Leo, however, takes no action to talk to him, buckles at the first sign of hostility (which if he knows his brother at all, should tell him something is wrong) and then tries to place blame when Splinter challenges him on it. As Raph overheard Splinter's conversation with Leo, he is angry that Leo doesn't make an effort with him and this fuels his anger in the fight.

With regards to the leadership issue, it's an easy excuse to fight over it because Raph doesn't like to take orders, especially from the brother he historically competed with for the role of leader, but the real problem (in my opinion) is that Raphael has never been able to distinguish between Splinter the teacher and Splinter the father. He doesn't say to Splinter "I know why you picked him, why he's the leader and I'm not", he says: "I know why you picked him, why he's the BETTER SON and I'm not." Raph's resentment of Leo's leadership is a perversion of the original resentment born by having perceived that by selecting Leo as the leader, Splinter was declaring him the favourite.... more cause for anger: rejection.

I think this is why Leo's "I'm better than you" comment touches a nerve which makes Raph attack. He then runs away when he realises how close he was to killing his brother whom, despite the fact that he is displacing all of his hatred onto him, Raphael loves. He cannot face Leo whilst he recognises this. When he speaks to Splinter later, saying "I know why you picked him", I do not think this is a comment on Leo's appropriateness for leader, moreover Raphael's inappropriateness.
jenna is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 08:35 AM   #16
Brandatello
Hench Mutant
 
Brandatello's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: CNY
Posts: 364
yeah...like in the episode tales of leo raph says "i always thought i would be leader, i was toughest, bravest..."and it fades to the flash back were leo saves raph from an alligator. then he starts to cry. so i think raph really loves his brothers but hides it with anger..like the time were he almost kills mikey with a pipe.
__________________
Brandatello is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-25-2007, 12:46 PM   #17
Rooish
Devil's Advocate
 
Rooish's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Toronto, Ontario
Posts: 2,130
Quote:
Originally Posted by jenna View Post
Hi there! I am new here and scared because I am technically inept and not sure if I'm posting correctly, but here goes...

I agree with Masked Ninja and would like to add a thought:

Leo and Raph are fighting about more than just leadership. Raphael is resentful of Leonardo for going away and feels rejected that he stayed away and forgot about his family - he moved on whilst the others had to stay and this has increased his anger with Leo. Splinter knows this and even said to Leo that his absence had been hard for Raph and that Leo should take steps to mend the damage. Leo, however, takes no action to talk to him, buckles at the first sign of hostility (which if he knows his brother at all, should tell him something is wrong) and then tries to place blame when Splinter challenges him on it. As Raph overheard Splinter's conversation with Leo, he is angry that Leo doesn't make an effort with him and this fuels his anger in the fight.

With regards to the leadership issue, it's an easy excuse to fight over it because Raph doesn't like to take orders, especially from the brother he historically competed with for the role of leader, but the real problem (in my opinion) is that Raphael has never been able to distinguish between Splinter the teacher and Splinter the father. He doesn't say to Splinter "I know why you picked him, why he's the leader and I'm not", he says: "I know why you picked him, why he's the BETTER SON and I'm not." Raph's resentment of Leo's leadership is a perversion of the original resentment born by having perceived that by selecting Leo as the leader, Splinter was declaring him the favourite.... more cause for anger: rejection.

I think this is why Leo's "I'm better than you" comment touches a nerve which makes Raph attack. He then runs away when he realises how close he was to killing his brother whom, despite the fact that he is displacing all of his hatred onto him, Raphael loves. He cannot face Leo whilst he recognises this. When he speaks to Splinter later, saying "I know why you picked him", I do not think this is a comment on Leo's appropriateness for leader, moreover Raphael's inappropriateness.
Very good point there. I think Leo was less sensitive than he could have been. He basically just got defensive right away. In the novelization, Leo did try to talk to Raph.
__________________


Thanks evan2000 for the sig!
Rooish is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:59 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.