Quote:
Originally Posted by TheSkeletonMan939
That's ridiculous. Just because someone doesn't have the talent to make good cinema doesn't mean they shouldn't give their thoughts on the film, and whether it was good or bad.
I'm not a good cook but I certainly know when the food I'm eating tastes bad, or good.
|
Food is not art. The comparison of food critique vs movie critique does not fit here. Most reviewers are people who went to film school, learned about making movies, and never actually made a movie. Or if they did, the movie sucked and they gave up. Then they bust out their thesaurus, and try and jam as many adjectives as they can down the readers throat. Their failure or lack of trying in the movie industry is vomited up each movie review they write. We get to see why these fools aren't writing movies with each review we read. Then there are the youtubers. They get in front of their bookshelf filled with toys and scream at the camera telling you how awful the movies are. They steal their reviews from the aforementioned critics, removing a lot of structure and a lot more cursing. They follow the formula of Youtube reviewers, quick jump cuts to make their nonsense seem like it's a steady stream of consciousness when it's really just an hour of them rambling on, and reading their notes. Lucky for them editing software is easy to get these days. All these reviews are the same every time. It's annoying. I avoid reviews until after I've seen a movie, and most of the time I roll my eyes at the things these people complain about.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZariusTwo
Some of my friends are pretty causal, did'nt know anything about the documented drama or cutting room floor edits, and guess what? They hated the movie also.
Just as I don't speak for you, nor should you speak for a particular group of people.
|
And that's fine, I don't expect everyone to like this movie. I just find it frustrating to read reviews that use "studio meddling" as a reason for a bad movie. There have been plenty of movies saved by studio meddling that you'll never hear about. But once these things get tossed in the rumor mill, it informs the critic or movie goer if they allow it. If your friends are just casual movie fans, or casual comic book movie fans, I can totally understand why they wouldn't like the movie. I'm merely attacking the people who bash movies based on reviews, or rumors and act like they KNOW the movie is bad because other people said so.