View Full Version : Star Wars Episode 8
Spike Spiegel
01-16-2018, 03:17 PM
it wouldn't fit the men are evil agenda, and thus would be ignored.
Bruh, I don't particularly like online SJWs and Hollywood virtue signaling either, but I don't let it stop me from enjoying media on my own terms.
Nothing about TLJ is so bad that it's worth getting yourself all depressed over it. It's a guilty pleasure at the very worst. If you don't like it, buy some novels/download some games and choose-your-own-canon. Marvel's current comics are as good as any of the old Dark Horse stuff. My local Half Price Books has been stocking a lot of EU novels, and I've personally started a scavenger hunt of sorts for the ones I want to read. If anything, it's increased my love for the franchise overall.
The prequels, too. Hell, all three films are essentially about the rise of authoritarianism and a fascist government. With bombast, of course - it's still a space opera with laser swords, space dogfights and mystic powers - but some of it's really on the nose. Hell, at the time, some outlets in the news were flipping out about them because they were perceived as pointed shots at the then-ongoing Bush administration and the direction of the country at the time.
I've been thinking about the political aspects of the original six films and Clone Wars as well, and I would have to agree with this. I think Lucas made that part of the narrative something a little more subtle that the viewer has to internalize and think about on their own rather than overtly throwing it in our faces. It's ironic when you consider the stylistic choices within the prequels' storytelling.
Vegita-San
01-16-2018, 03:22 PM
I've been re reading the old eu novels from the start..to try and remember when i liked star wars.
It's amazing how bad the Kevin J Anderson novels read back. but it's still better than the newer books.
Vegita-San
01-16-2018, 03:23 PM
I was just thinking how both Lucas and Laird who were so protective of their creations ended up selling to someone who pretty much stepped on all their believes of what the franchise should be, it doesn't matter if you think it's for the better or the worse, it's still ironic.
that's because no one is a specific 'in charge' person.
IIRC, you have a Kevin Feige in charge of the entire marvel movie line. who SEEMS to be creative as well as an executive. a rare talent.
There is NO ONE like that in charge of the turtles empire now. Or Star Wars. or the DC Universe. which explains why all their new stuff is a big steaming patrick stewart (see what I did there? think about it)
CyberCubed
01-16-2018, 03:29 PM
There is NO ONE like that in charge of the turtles empire now. it)
Why should there be? It was never like that even when Mirage owned TMNT.
Spike Spiegel
01-16-2018, 03:33 PM
that's because no one is a specific 'in charge' person.
IIRC, you have a Kevin Feige in charge of the entire marvel movie line. who SEEMS to be creative as well as an executive. a rare talent.
There is NO ONE like that in charge of the turtles empire now. Or Star Wars. or the DC Universe. which explains why all their new stuff is a big steaming patrick stewart (see what I did there? think about it)
http://gif-finder.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Patrick-Stewart-That-is-EnoughDamn-it.gif
dl316bh
01-16-2018, 06:15 PM
I've been thinking about the political aspects of the original six films and Clone Wars as well, and I would have to agree with this. I think Lucas made that part of the narrative something a little more subtle that the viewer has to internalize and think about on their own rather than overtly throwing it in our faces. It's ironic when you consider the stylistic choices within the prequels' storytelling.
It's one of the things I appreciate about the prequels, actually. With movies, especially blockbusters, everything is done with bombast and explosiveness. You expect them to just take over by force (sort of like how the new trilogy has done things). But the prequels, for all their flaws, decided to show the slow decline of a republic into authoritarianism as a backdrop to the flashier things going on with the Jedi. It's a more realistic bent and one I think would have worked really well with a tighter script and a different or at least co-director.
I was just thinking how both Lucas and Laird who were so protective of their creations ended up selling to someone who pretty much stepped on all their believes of what the franchise should be
Well, in regards to Laird and the Turtles, whatever he (and Eastman, though KE's far more chill about the franchise) originally intended them to be, they morphed into something else pretty early even under his watch. I don't think the Turtles now are all too strikingly different from what was being made before he sold it off. The biggest difference is that now people can use things from the Fred Wolf series in new material and reinvent them, which Peter Laird seemed adamantly opposed to.
Shark_Blade
01-17-2018, 01:50 AM
https://i.imgur.com/6ZoLeuL.jpg
Okay, I'm appreciating what they've done with Luke now... sort of.
Utrommaniac
01-17-2018, 01:59 AM
I'm pretty sure most of the Jedi that survived Order 66 went into hiding - and those that tried to rise back up ended up getting killed.
If goddamn YODA is laying low in a desolate place, that's probably the best course of action to take.
Sumac
01-17-2018, 06:09 AM
Unless they're worded as eloquently as all the rape and death threats I've gotten over the years, I'd suggest you save the key strokes and not bother.
No need to engage into oppression olympics - everyone has hard lives, but it doesn't automatically imbues you with some kind of "moral superiority and righteousness".
ProphetofGanja
01-17-2018, 08:02 AM
I'm pretty sure most of the Jedi that survived Order 66 went into hiding - and those that tried to rise back up ended up getting killed.
If goddamn YODA is laying low in a desolate place, that's probably the best course of action to take.
Yoda was so sad and lonely (https://youtu.be/JXBZdIN1RhY)...
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 09:51 AM
Looks like word has gotten around about the No Ma'am Edit:
https://twitter.com/SidizenKane/status/953400413419548672
Andrew NDB
01-17-2018, 11:14 AM
https://i.imgur.com/6ZoLeuL.jpg
Okay, I'm appreciating what they've done with Luke now... sort of.
Not apples to apples at all. Obi-Wan (who keep in mind had been through a LOT more than Luke in TLJ at this point) jumped at the chance to help and go off-world when Leia sent him the message via R2-D2. Even while knocking on death's door, Yoda was immediately willing to train Luke (trouble is, Luke failed his first test and Obi-Wan's ghost had to convince Yoda to give him a shot anyway).
Luke in TLJ is just like, "No, no, no! I'm not training you and I'm not going ANYWHERE and THAT'S THAT!" He only grudgingly is like, "OK, I'll sort of train you a little bit... but not with a lightsaber, you've got to do that yourself."
And in regard to that "46 minute cut that cuts all the women out"... that has to be a FAKE thing. How would a fan even cut such a cut together? The movie isn't available yet to download or even pirate to be able to have footage to edit, unless this 46 minute cut is from the horrific quality theater cams that are probably on Pirate Bay or whatever.
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 11:35 AM
Judging by the article posted previously, the latter is true.
CyberCubed
01-17-2018, 12:11 PM
I've seen gifs of the movie all over the internet. Obviously it's pirated and in high quality too.
ProphetofGanja
01-17-2018, 12:16 PM
I've seen gifs of the movie all over the internet. Obviously it's pirated and in high quality too.
Could be from trailers
Andrew NDB
01-17-2018, 12:20 PM
Double-checked the torrents that are out there. It's definitely only available in horrible quality theater cam so far (i.e., versions of people sitting in the theater recording the whole movie poorly with their smartphone or camcorder). We're still probably a couple of months away from it popping up with Korean hard-coded subs before the official release.
newfan
01-17-2018, 12:22 PM
https://i.imgur.com/6ZoLeuL.jpg
Okay, I'm appreciating what they've done with Luke now... sort of.
I'm not sure what the odds were for Luke when things went south but for Yoda and Obi Wan, the odds were against them by the time they realised what was happening, so far as fighting back went.
There had to be another challenge or defeat to carry on the story (yes I know everyone gets that) but on the other side of that I can also see that after the triumph in Jedi we skip a lot of years and see... another Jedi Master turned into a sad old hermit after defeat... I suppose it depends on the view point you take, had they done the movies earlier when the original cast were a bit younger how different might it have been?
Also that "no women cut" was not made because of people hating women, it was made to get a rise out of feminists and the like and they took the bait. Even if it were real it wouldn't be any more stupid than the "no jar jar" cuts or the "I edited all the prequels into one 3 hour movie" or all those retarded edits that only sheep nerds keep blabbering about.
The only edit I can get behind on not being some "greater than thou" popularity contest edit is the despecialized edition, which at least is trying to re-create something that exists only in good quality.
https://i.imgur.com/6ZoLeuL.jpg
Okay, I'm appreciating what they've done with Luke now... sort of.
These are so retarded, there's also the one where they compare Snoke/palpatine rey/luke kylo/vader with the "SEE THEY"RE ALL THE SAME YOU JUST DON"T LIKE THE LAST JEDI TO BE COOL OR DON"T LIKE CHANGE"
Andrew NDB
01-17-2018, 12:48 PM
I'm not sure what the odds were for Luke when things went south but for Yoda and Obi Wan, the odds were against them by the time they realised what was happening, so far as fighting back went.
There had to be another challenge or defeat to carry on the story (yes I know everyone gets that) but on the other side of that I can also see that after the triumph in Jedi we skip a lot of years and see... another Jedi Master turned into a sad old hermit after defeat... I suppose it depends on the view point you take, had they done the movies earlier when the original cast were a bit younger how different might it have been?
I really don't have any problem, on principle, with Luke being a hermit like Yoda or Obi-Wan. But it's got to be for the right reasons.
On the run from a galactic-wide purge of all Jedis while you hide on a planet watching after the son of your padawan and waiting for a chance to help out a Rebellion (Obi-Wan)? That's valid.
On the run from a galactic-wide purge of all Jedis while you hide on a planet learning more about the Force while also waiting to help out anyone in need if/when a Rebellion gets going (Yoda)? That's valid.
During peacetime and not on the run from anybody or anything, just hiding on a planet upset that your little Jedi school failed when you thought about killing your Dark Side-leaning nephew for a split second before not even thinking that anymore (Luke)? Doesn't seem valid at all, at least not in terms of him not being willing to help anyone or leaving the planet to help. Especially with what was going on with the First Order, with Han, and the New Republic getting 5 planets destroyed.
I mean, look at Obi-Wan... by the time Alderaan was destroyed by the Empire, Obi-Wan was already on his way to join the Rebel Alliance and help out. By the time Rey is begging Luke for help, FIVE planets have already been destroyed by the First Order... and he STILL says no. That doesn't compute.
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 12:50 PM
If the rise they were looking for was becoming even more of a punchline than they already are, then their achievement was definitely unlocked.
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 12:57 PM
Also that "no women cut" was not made because of people hating women, it was made to get a rise out of feminists and the like and they took the bait. Even if it were real it wouldn't be any more stupid than the "no jar jar" cuts or the "I edited all the prequels into one 3 hour movie" or all those retarded edits that only sheep nerds keep blabbering about.
These are so retarded, there's also the one where they compare Snoke/palpatine rey/luke kylo/vader with the "SEE THEY"RE ALL THE SAME YOU JUST DON"T LIKE THE LAST JEDI TO BE COOL OR DON"T LIKE CHANGE"
Yep.
And the sad part is there really IS no change. everything is STILL the same status quo it was in the last movie. it's just more smoke screen from the people who like bad movies or nu movies and want them to seem special, when they really are just retreading stuff that's been done better elsewhere.
As for the 'no women' cut....It had to be done as the ultimate trolling tactic. a way to fight back from the onslaught from the other side. and it worked...because it triggered all the same old responses and insults..
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 01:06 PM
You keep seeing trolling, and I keep seeing the Streisand Effect.
Pohtato/Pahtato.
https://i.imgur.com/4Mf6gzL.jpg
TigerClaw
01-17-2018, 01:54 PM
The reason The Last Jedi was pulled from theaters in China? cause the actors weren't pretty enough. :lol:
https://movieweb.com/last-jedi-reasons-chinese-theaters-pulled-actors-not-beautiful/
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 01:58 PM
and people wonder why old school nerds get so fed up with modern nerd culture these days. just look at that minefield of crazy political nonsense infesting our movies.
no wonder I hardly go to the theater anymore. I'll stick with what i've got.
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 02:02 PM
The reason The Last Jedi was pulled from theaters in China? cause the actors weren't pretty enough. :lol:
https://movieweb.com/last-jedi-reasons-chinese-theaters-pulled-actors-not-beautiful/
I know there's no accounting for taste but...THERE WAS SO MUCH HOTNESS IN THAT MOVIE!
TigerClaw
01-17-2018, 02:11 PM
I know there's no accounting for taste but...THERE WAS SO MUCH HOTNESS IN THAT MOVIE!
Not even shirtless Kylo Ren was pretty enough for China.
Sumac
01-17-2018, 02:21 PM
If the rise they were looking for was becoming even more of a punchline than they already are, then their achievement was definitely unlocked.
There is certain irony in this statement when it comes from you. :lol:
CyberCubed
01-17-2018, 02:22 PM
The Chinese don't find Rey good looking?
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 02:26 PM
Not even shirtless Kylo Ren was pretty enough for China.
All of China: Can you put on a cowl or something?
dl316bh
01-17-2018, 02:44 PM
I keep waiting for half this board to agree on some kind of meetup so they can all just get in a big fistfight with each other and get it over with.
Also that "no women cut" was not made because of people hating women, it was made to get a rise out of feminists and the like and they took the bait.
Or, occams razor, it's just s***ty people with s***ty personal beliefs wasting too much time making a s***ty cut of a movie. Not everything's just bait or a joke. I see this insistence every time anyone reacts to anything and it's borderline nihilistic thinking.
Andrew NDB
01-17-2018, 03:05 PM
I keep waiting for half this board to agree on some kind of meetup so they can all just get in a big fistfight with each other
I can't think of anyone active on the board right now that needs their ass kicked. Maybe pferreira, though even he has dialed his annoyance back a good amount of late.
dl316bh
01-17-2018, 03:08 PM
I can't think of anyone active on the board right now that needs their ass kicked. Maybe pferreira, though even he has dialed his annoyance back a good amount of late.
It's more that everyone just keeps taking shots at each other over the stupidest things or nothing outright and it's like, f***, just fight and get it over with already, you know?
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 03:11 PM
It's more that everyone just keeps taking shots at each other over the stupidest things or nothing outright and it's like, f***, just fight and get it over with already, you know?
I don't think "fight" is on most of their minds, to be honest.
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 04:29 PM
It's more that everyone just keeps taking shots at each other over the stupidest things or nothing outright and it's like, f***, just fight and get it over with already, you know?
first rule of technodrome fight club. you don't talk about technodrome fight club.
just learn to deal with the fact that pot shots are the ways of the internet. either ignore them, or address them, and move on.
95% of the time it's higher ground and easier to ignore 'em....
Allio
01-17-2018, 05:06 PM
I'm just glad I don't like people in general.
Unlike the people that fight for either the dumbass right side or the equality *uckwits on the left side, I can actually enjoy things.
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 05:50 PM
I'm just glad I don't like people in general.
pretty much my stance on things these days too.
I don't hate people, but I don't go out of my way to meet them, either.
sometimes I agree with people, sometimes I don't....
I just say what's on my mind, regardless of how people classify what's said, and move on to the next thing to talk about.
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 06:51 PM
one of the latest damage control articles.
That comment by 'kathy'... is this the brilliant successful producer that knows all and sees all seriously asking that question? You didn't see it because it was revealed in the LAST GD movie, you brainless twit. I mean, how do you answer that?
RIP Star Wars. The Jar Jars are in control now.
https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/star-wars-last-jedi-10-revelations-director-rian-johnson/
>>>
9. Luke and co.'s expanded Force powers had to compete with what we've seen before
"I feel like we still offered a modicum of restraint, because we didn't have anyone pulling Star Destroyers out of the sky. And believe me, it came up when Luke came out on to the field, I was, like, 'should he wave his hand and all the walkers blow off like dust?' The things that are in there that are Force moments largely came out of the dramatic moments. (OMG - CONSPIRACY THEORY ALERT) But the Leia thing is an interesting example. It's something that Kathy kept bringing up, which I thought was interesting. She said, 'I've always been intrigued by what Luke says to Leia in Jedi in that she has the power inside her also, and why haven't we seen that?'
>>>.
Leonardo_thebest
01-17-2018, 06:55 PM
The latest Star Wars film was simply too smart for most fans. It's too bad they didn't get it.
TigerClaw
01-17-2018, 07:02 PM
The latest Star Wars film was simply too smart for most fans. It's too bad they didn't get it.
The Last Jedi was made for more sophisticated fans.
Sumac
01-17-2018, 07:03 PM
I'm just glad I don't like people in general.
Unlike the people that fight for either the dumbass right side or the equality *uckwits on the left side, I can actually enjoy things.
Here-here.
There is nothing wrong with enjoying things and find some aspects of them problematic. But those problematic aspects, don't mean that your first priority in Internet is to scream at top of your lungs at other people: "stop liking what I don't like or you are all nazis".
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 07:17 PM
When the pro trilogy people just give up trying to defend it :).
Oh well. at least we can all more or less agree the new han solo movie looks to be a mess, right?
VVVVVVVV
The Last Jedi was made for more sophisticated fans.
Unlike the people that fight for either the dumbass right side or the equality *uckwits on the left side, I can actually enjoy things.
I wish I could go back to this, I don't like to get political contrary to many of my posts might lead someone to believe, I'm trying to tone it down for the most part, but it just seems that even when you try to avoid it everyone keeps slapping it in your face and bringing politics into everything.
I think a lot of the internet took notice before but I didn't really notice it until 2016, that's when people really went overboard and unavoidable IMHO.
The latest Star Wars film was simply too smart for most fans. It's too bad they didn't get it.
Well if:
Vegita-San : Plastron Cafe
mrmaczaps : Leonardo_The Best
?
I think I'm on to something
Vegita-San
01-17-2018, 07:27 PM
I
I think a lot of the internet took notice before but I didn't really notice it until 2016, that's when people really went overboard and unavoidable IMHO.
I didn't notice it before either, but thanks to feigbusters, it became UNAVOIDABLE to talk about it. try and talk about the movie, and people constantly brought it up. instantly putting you on one side because of THEIR beliefs...just because you didn't like the movie. and no pointing anything out for them would change their one set mind. that's the only reason I choose the anti SJW stance when I ignored it all before. I could have cared less about all that nonsense before. And I still really don't. But, I feel it's important to point out the crazy and the hypocrisy when it arises.
Well if:
Vegita-San : Plastron Cafe
mrmaczaps : Leonardo_The Best
?
I think I'm on to something
again with the insulting comparisons. :D come on dude.
dl316bh
01-17-2018, 08:03 PM
Oh well. at least we can all more or less agree the new han solo movie looks to be a mess, right?
That movie has all the signs of a dumpster fire in the making, yes. It has the potential to be the first Star Wars bomb, comparatively speaking. If it does, it will be interesting to see the reaction from Disney, who will have to deal with having made and released a turd in the most lucrative brand in the world and figure out how much damage that might do.
I'm looking forward to Solo more than Ep. IX. I don't know, I have a feeling that even though it seems like it'll suck, it could impress me, while I can't think of anything IX could do to change my mind.
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 09:31 PM
I've got to admit, I don't know where I stand on the Solo movie.
I don't really have a lot invested, so I think the only way I'll really be disappointed is if they add Nu Trek level visuals to what should really be a vintage looking production.
Leo656
01-17-2018, 10:48 PM
The Last Jedi was made for more sophisticated fans.
https://img.gawkerassets.com/img/19abcitz2f6t0jpg/original.jpg
CyberCubed
01-17-2018, 10:50 PM
This thread is why this section of the forums should be shut down. :lol:
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 11:03 PM
https://img.gawkerassets.com/img/19abcitz2f6t0jpg/original.jpg
Well well well, look what the cat dragged in!
Leo656
01-17-2018, 11:16 PM
Dude's batsh*t-crazy statement deserved an adequate response, nothing more.
I figure I may as well leave a review on my way out...
https://media.giphy.com/media/WtSlhmzhNwCju/giphy.gif
-Fin.
plastroncafe
01-17-2018, 11:21 PM
It's okay to miss us.
Andrew NDB
01-17-2018, 11:30 PM
I'm looking forward to Solo more than Ep. IX. I don't know, I have a feeling that even though it seems like it'll suck, it could impress me, while I can't think of anything IX could do to change my mind.
You know, in spite of TLJ doing its darnedest to make me not be excited or interested in IX (and keep in mind, I am of the "I liked TLJ... but man it has problems" camp)... it's a fascinating thing. JJ rightfully got so much sh** about TFA there is no way he is not aware of it... and now he gets the chance to redeem himself and justify this whole kind of empty, questionable trilogy. I am really interested in what he's going to do (and with JJ throwing his hat in for this, 2 out of the 3 sequel trilogy movies... he surely must know no matter what, he will either get all of the credit or all of the blame, depending on how it goes down). I can't even speculate what it will be.
Solo? It may be good or bad. Howard won't deliver a turd... but what it won't be is overly interesting or inspired. It will be a fill in the box next to a bunch of checkboxes from the OT and all seem very familiar. Kessel Run, Chewie rescue, Lando, winning the Falcon, probably him learning to say "I have a bad feeling about this" from Woody Harrelson or something, the origin of that chess board... we'll needlessly see all of that, I'm certain.
snake
01-17-2018, 11:52 PM
The no girls allowed cut is probably better than the actual movie. :lol:
Leo656
01-18-2018, 12:23 AM
It's okay to miss us.
https://media.giphy.com/media/f31X5xnGIxsMU/giphy.gif
Leonardo_thebest
01-18-2018, 12:29 AM
It goes like this:
Empire
The Force Awakens
The Last Jedi
Return of the Jedi
A New Hope
Revenge of the Sith
Rogue One
Clone Wars
Phantom Menace
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 12:35 AM
https://media.giphy.com/media/f31X5xnGIxsMU/giphy.gif
Stick around, foo.
Leo656
01-18-2018, 12:39 AM
Stick around, foo.
https://media.giphy.com/media/OBtguzj1bcgX6/giphy.gif
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:42 AM
You know, in spite of TLJ doing its darnedest to make me not be excited or interested in IX (and keep in mind, I am of the "I liked TLJ... but man it has problems" camp)... it's a fascinating thing. JJ rightfully got so much sh** about TFA there is no way he is not aware of it... and now he gets the chance to redeem himself and justify this whole kind of empty, questionable trilogy. I am really interested in what he's going to do (and with JJ throwing his hat in for this, 2 out of the 3 sequel trilogy movies... he surely must know no matter what, he will either get all of the credit or all of the blame, depending on how it goes down). I can't even speculate what it will be.
I guess we'll see. I've seen enough Abrams films that I'm not super optimistic. It doesn't help that this new trilogy was put together in the most slapdash manner. They decided to farm all three films out to three different directors, initially, and Abrams only came back in when Book of Henry seemed to make them think twice about Trevarrow, so the whole thing just felt kind of sloppy and put together just to get the three films out like an assembly line with no delays. It's never felt like this trilogy was going to have some consistent vision.
I'm hoping he puts something out that makes for an alright cap, but I'm not expecting amazing things. I think the worst case scenario is another Force Awakens thing where it's just nothing. Another negative possibility is another film like Star Trek Into Darkness, which got a little too cute and felt like it thought it was a bit more clever than it actually was.
There's also whatever happens with Solo to consider, too. If that film bombs in some way - critically or commercially (by the standards of Star Wars, of course) - Disney might want Episode IX to play it safe to try and win people back or encourage them to forget the most recent film.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 12:58 AM
There's also whatever happens with Solo to consider, too. If that film bombs in some way - critically or commercially (by the standards of Star Wars, of course) - Disney might want Episode IX to play it safe to try and win people back or encourage them to forget the most recent film.
There's two sides to it (though I don't foresee any side where "Solo" doesn't pull at least Rogue One numbers). Solo does great, look forward to IG-88: The Movie. It's received badly... maybe no more looking in the rearview, which wouldn't be the worst thing at all.
Neither of which, I think, will impact IX. Won't it basically begin principal photography by the time Solo comes out?
*Disclaimer: We know Kathleen Kennedy has no problem shooting the same movie twice, so... anything goes.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 01:19 AM
There's two sides to it (though I don't foresee any side where "Solo" doesn't pull at least Rogue One numbers).
That's why I mean comparatively for Star Wars. It'll make bank, but if it's bad, word of mouth will slow it. It's also a side film with a lot of publicly noted problems going in and bad early buzz has hobbled more than one movie. Also worth noting that it's coming out five months after the last in the franchise. People will have barely processed The Last Jedi before the next film comes along, marketing and all.
I don't think they're at the point where they could lose money on a Star Wars film yet, but I can forsee it making around, quite possibly less, than Rogue One. It has elements that are not in their favor at all.
Solo does great, look forward to IG-88: The Movie. It's received badly... maybe no more looking in the rearview, which wouldn't be the worst thing at all.
I'd be fine with that. The latter, I mean. F*** IG-88.
Neither of which, I think, will impact IX. Won't it basically begin principal photography by the time Solo comes out?
June. A month after Solo hits. That's assuming no delays. A lot can change in that time, especially if they're worried. Hell, last I heard, they're still hammering out what Episode IX is even going to be now, since they've had to alter what plans they did have. Hell, they could even throw money at reshoots if they feel it necessary.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 01:36 AM
That's why I mean comparatively for Star Wars. It'll make bank, but if it's bad, word of mouth will slow it. It's also a side film with a lot of publicly noted problems going in and bad early buzz has hobbled more than one movie. Also worth noting that it's coming out five months after the last in the franchise. People will have barely processed The Last Jedi before the next film comes along, marketing and all.
I don't think they're at the point where they could lose money on a Star Wars film yet, but I can forsee it making around, quite possibly less, than Rogue One. It has elements that are not in their favor at all.
I'd be fine with that. The latter, I mean. F*** IG-88.
June. A month after Solo hits. That's assuming no delays. A lot can change in that time, especially if they're worried. Hell, last I heard, they're still hammering out what Episode IX is even going to be now, since they've had to alter what plans they did have. Hell, they could even throw money at reshoots if they feel it necessary.
I dunno... everyone, especially Kathleen Kennedy, seem to really, really revere JJ. I seem to remember it was a bit of a begging game to even get him to do TFA... if I recall, it came down to a phone call from Spielberg (JJ's admitted and obvious idol) telling him to do it that moved the needle with JJ. I'm certain whatever negotiations that happened with JJ in the Speed Force when Trevorrow was shown the door gave him similar carte blanche as before... possibly more so, since TFA did better box office than any SW movie ever.
I feel like whatever deal JJ signed under duress for IX, it would be one that would be sure and insulate him from being the next Gareth Edwards or those two directors on Solo. 100%.
Not saying that great things will come of this, I'm just saying that we've never seen JJ with his back against the wall like this, with a ton to prove.
Vegita-San
01-18-2018, 06:41 AM
I wish I knew where this was from. but the place I saw it in didn't post a link.
If true, it wouldn't be shocking. RT's protecting the interest of disney and not letting the film score fall below a certain extent.
we all know the critics are afraid of disney anyway.
>>>I believe I can show that the current audience score of 49% which RT displays for the Last Jedi is false. I can only speculate as to why they are lying but they clearly are. I did a statistical analysis of all of the audience reviews I was allowed to view. There are nearly 2000 pages of reviews and I was able to access 46 of them. This is a perfectly reasonable sample size which I believe represents an accurate reflection of the overall audience opinion. A five star rating system translated to a scale of 1 to 100 means that each star is worth 20 points. A half star is 10 points etc. Here are my results...
.5 stars - 339
1 star - 173
1.5 stars - 66
2 stars - 90
2.5 stars - 23
3 stars - 19
3.5 stars- 12
4 stars - 26
4.5 stars 25
5 stars 95
A sample size of 868 audience reviewers awarded a total of 23390 points for an average user score of 33.8594. Less than 34%.
I don't know why RT is lying to the public, but they are clearly preventing the audience score from falling below a certain level. If RT is protecting Disney's interests then this is a conflict of interest of the highest order and this site cannot be trusted. Again, the true audience score for this film is well, WELL below 40. >>>
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 08:22 AM
It's about ethics in film criticism journalism.
NinjaPug
01-18-2018, 10:19 AM
I know it went through massive reshoots but I'm still shocked we have seen absolutely nothing official released from Disney for Solo and the movie comes out in 4 months. No images, no behind the scenes reel. Nothing. Not even the planted articles from Lucasfilm on EW doing damage control and trying to reassure fans that the movie will be great great and all the negative production problems are overblown like they did for Rogue One after all of those reshoots.
Vegita-San
01-18-2018, 10:21 AM
man..this one must really suck..
and it mostly stars men, so it's OK to say it sucks by everyone. YAY!
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 10:23 AM
Okay, but only because you said so.
Spike Spiegel
01-18-2018, 11:46 AM
man..this one must really suck..
and it mostly stars men, so it's OK to say it sucks by everyone. YAY!
You are on this forum...but we do not grant you the rank of sh*tposter.
http://memecrunch.com/meme/BEWEG/take-a-seat/image.jpg
ZariusTwo
01-18-2018, 11:57 AM
The Last Jedi was made for more sophisticated fans.
You like milking tits too?
Spike Spiegel
01-18-2018, 12:00 PM
You like milking tits too?
https://i.pinimg.com/474x/05/ee/a5/05eea55b5b7918a0ce5eb57b127418f4--teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-want-you.jpg
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:05 PM
You are on this forum...but we do not grant you the rank of sh*tposter.
http://memecrunch.com/meme/BEWEG/take-a-seat/image.jpg
http://robocoparchive.com/old/duffy.JPG
"Officer Duffy, take a seat."
It might be sad that my first thought when I saw "take a seat" is Robocop 2.
newfan
01-18-2018, 12:23 PM
http://robocoparchive.com/old/duffy.JPG
"Officer Duffy, take a seat."
It might be sad that my first thought when I saw "take a seat" is Robocop 2.
Robo is one of my guilty pleasures (not everything they did with it)
You like milking tits too?
:lol: thanks ZariousTwo, that response made me laugh.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 12:26 PM
Not entirely related, but one of my strongest and fondest RoboCop memories is from the Marvel Comics' "RoboCop" comic that lasted about 23 issues.
There's a scene with RoboCop busting into a club looking for a perp, and RoboCop shouts "Everybody get down! Now!" This hippy looking dude is dancing and grooving on the dancefloor and walks up to RoboCop with a smile saying, "Yeah, man! Let's all get down! Boogie!" And then the guy gets shot up by the perp, caught in the crossfire.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:30 PM
Robo is one of my guilty pleasures (not everything they did with it)
Yeah, not everything Robocop 2 did was great. But I still think it's a pretty okay movie and it had some good ideas. It's not Robocop 3, at least. I can rewatch R2 and find things to enjoy. Can't say the same for the third.
Not entirely related, but one of my strongest and fondest RoboCop memories is from the Marvel Comics' "RoboCop" comic that lasted about 23 issues.
There's a scene with RoboCop busting into a club looking for a perp, and RoboCop shouts "Everybody get down! Now!" This hippy looking dude is dancing and grooving on the dancefloor and walks up to RoboCop with a smile saying, "Yeah, man! Let's all get down! Boogie!" And then the guy gets shot up by the perp, caught in the crossfire.
Robocop vs Terminator aside, I haven't read nearly as many Robocop comics as I'd like to have. I've never really been sure which are worth reading. There have been plenty of miniseries and ongoings over the last thirty years and I'm sure they're all of varying quality.
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 12:30 PM
I've never actually seen RoboCop, so...my question for the folks wot love it:
Does it hold up?
Is it worth checking out?
And what peripheries would you recommend?
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 12:33 PM
I've never actually seen RoboCop, so...my question for the folks wot love it:
Does it hold up?
Is it worth checking out?
And what peripheries would you recommend?
You haven't seen RoboCop? Oh, you must. It's aged fine beyond some of the ED-209 shots.
RoboCop 2 is not great, but worth watching to decide for yourself. RoboCop 3 is probably best avoided but there is good... moments in it.
You can avoid the TV show but I'd strongly recommend the "RoboCop: Prime Directives" mini-series that's out on like, 4 different DVDs. It was really, really good.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:35 PM
I've never actually seen RoboCop, so...my question for the folks wot love it:
Does it hold up?
Is it worth checking out?
And what peripheries would you recommend?
The original Robocop is still shockingly relevant to today in regards to its satire and holds up great as a story. Yes, it's absolutely worth checking out. Robocop 2 is a pretty alright movie if you want more, but it's not quite as good. Avoid 3.
For stuff outside the movies, I've read Robocop vs Terminator and it's pretty great. Frank Miller and Walt Simonson in their prime. Outside of that, I don't have a ton of experience.
It's aged fine beyond some of the ED-209 shots.
Yeah, and even those aren't really that bad either. The effects hold up quite well.
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 12:36 PM
T
For stuff outside the movies, I've read Robocop vs Terminator and it's pretty great. Frank Miller and Walt Simonson in their prime. Outside of that, I don't have a ton of experience.
Is this Miller before or after he started drinking his own kool-aid?
Vegita-San
01-18-2018, 12:36 PM
You are on this forum...but we do not grant you the rank of sh*tposter.
It's nice to know someone cares about post integrity.
but in this case, i couldn't resist an obvious dig, cause we all know it'll be ok to trash the solo movie :).
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 12:37 PM
It's nice to know someone cares about post integrity.
but in this case, i couldn't resist an obvious dig, cause we all know it'll be ok to trash the solo movie :).
But only because you gave us permission.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:39 PM
Is this Miller before or after he started drinking his own kool-aid?
Before. It's 80's/90's Miller. He's always had a weird streak, but he didn't get bad until somewhere around the aughts.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 12:39 PM
For stuff outside the movies, I've read Robocop vs Terminator and it's pretty great. Frank Miller and Walt Simonson in their prime. Outside of that, I don't have a ton of experience.
I mentioned the Marvel RoboCop comic but I can't really recommend it. I recall it did try some pretty interesting things (like a rival company to OCP called "Nixco," that makes android "Nixcops") and go to some dark places, though. Pretty sure his wife and son got murdered in the last issue.
Yeah, RoboCop vs. Terminator is pretty great. It's pretty clear it was written before Frank Miller had seen Terminator 2, though.
I remember reading that Frank Miller did a Dark Horse "RoboCop" comic or two that was supposed to reflect the RoboCop 2 or 3 he actually envisioned... I think. Pretty sure I remember reading about that. Anyway, that's out there somewhere and is probably worth a look, too.
Robocop 2 is a pretty alright movie if you want more, but it's not quite as good. Avoid 3.
For stuff outside the movies, I've read Robocop vs Terminator and it's pretty great. Frank Miller and Walt Simonson in their prime.
Is this Miller before or after he started drinking his own kool-aid?
Do you know that Frank Miller wrote the screenplays for both RoboCop 2 and RoboCop 3? He also has a cameo in 2. As "Frank."
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:45 PM
I mentioned the Marvel RoboCop comic but I can't really recommend it. I recall it did try some pretty interesting things (like a rival company to OCP called "Nixco," that makes android "Nixcops") and go to some dark places, though. Pretty sure his wife and son got murdered in the last issue.
Probably be a bitch to find even if I wanted to check it out now. I don't know if it's on Comixology.
Yeah, RoboCop vs. Terminator is pretty great. It's pretty clear it was written before Frank Miller had seen Terminator 2, though.
Didn't they come out around the same time? I think both were '91. It would explain it.
Oh, also, that reminds me, the Robocop vs Terminator Sega Genesis game? It rocks. Worth emulating (because there will never be another legal way to play that s*** again unless you want to spend time tracking a physical copy down).
I remember reading that Frank Miller did a Dark Horse "RoboCop" comic or two that was supposed to reflect the RoboCop 2 or 3 he actually envisioned... I think. Pretty sure I remember reading about that. Anyway, that's out there somewhere and is probably worth a look, too.
Oh yeah, I remember hearing about that. I heard it was pretty good, but also clear that Robocop 2 did actually keep a fair amount of Millers script, or more than he made it seem. I should track it down. It's recent enough that it's probably in trade or on Comixology.
Do you know that Frank Miller wrote the screenplays for both RoboCop 2 and RoboCop 3?
He did 3? I thought it was just 2.
newfan
01-18-2018, 12:48 PM
You haven't seen RoboCop? Oh, you must. It's aged fine beyond some of the ED-209 shots.
RoboCop 2 is not great, but worth watching to decide for yourself. RoboCop 3 is probably best avoided but there is good... moments in it.
You can avoid the TV show but I'd strongly recommend the "RoboCop: Prime Directives" mini-series that's out on like, 4 different DVDs. It was really, really good.
Yes the first one is the best and worth a watch, the .... 2 I watch still, (alternative script for that is on-line) ... 3 not so much. I didn't take to Prime directives...I remember thinking 'noo.. there are 3 more disks to go' :) Didn't like his portrayal.
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 12:48 PM
Do you know that Frank Miller wrote the screenplays for both RoboCop 2 and RoboCop 3? He also has a cameo in 2. As "Frank."
So long as it's before his kool-aid period, that'll be fine.
I love his early stuff, back when it seemed to me he knew he was writing porn.
It's his later stuff I avoid like the plague.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 12:51 PM
Probably be a bitch to find even if I wanted to check it out now. I don't know if it's on Comixology.
A quick search turned this up:
http://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Robocop-1990
Didn't they come out around the same time? I think both were '91. It would explain it.
Yeah, I remember it came out right when the Marvel series ended. It was a bittersweet thing.
He did 3? I thought it was just 2.
Both. Though lots of complaining from him about the studio ruining his RoboCop 3 script.
I remember playing the SNES Robocop vs. Terminator and it not being terrible.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 12:52 PM
It's his later stuff I avoid like the plague.
You're doing yourself a big favor. I've read some of his aughts and beyond work out of morbid "can't look away from the train derailment" curiosity. It's bad.
A quick search turned this up:
Thanks man. I think I'll at least skim a few issues.
Both. Though lots of complaining about the studio ruining his RoboCop 3 script.
I remember playing the SNES Robocop vs. Terminator and it not being terrible.
I can believe it. Robocop 3 is not great. I thought it was just them pulling stuff from 2 for 3, though, I didn't realize he actually wrote any of it. I must have remembered incorrectly.
SNES RvsT was pretty good too. It's the one you should play if you want the comic story interspersed with the action. I love the graphics and gameplay of the Genesis version better though.
newfan
01-18-2018, 01:01 PM
I'm sure I looked at the comics for Millers 2 and 3 on-line, his story differs a little from what was then done in the actual movies. Not entirely certain but I don't think he was happy about it.
3 was downgraded I think to try and make it appeal to a younger audience (so the fans have complained) but I don't think 2 was very sucessful and that was an 18 (R rating).
As far as comics, I only read one or two (so I actually have read a comic... just doesn't really count so much as real comic franchise :)) but there seem to be a few who have had a try at the franchise.
Anyway, a derailed thread but at least we have few posts without arguing... unless any Robocop haters are on their way :lol:
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 01:03 PM
I'm sure I looked at the comics for Millers 2 and 3 on-line, his story differs a little from what was then done in the actual movies.
As far as comics, I only read one or two (so I actually have read a comic... just doesn't really count so much as real comic franchise :)) but there seem to be a few who have had a try at the franchise.
Anyway, a derailed thread but at least we have few posts without arguing... unless any Robocop haters are on their way :lol:
Well I'm here, which means we're at least a comment or two away from someone getting buttmad, having their panties twisted, or continuing their efforts to neg me into some sort of submission.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 01:05 PM
Anyway, a derailed thread but at least we have few posts without arguing...
We should just make this a Robocop thread from now on. ;)
unless any Robocop haters are on their way :lol:
...
I will fight them.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 01:09 PM
Thanks man. I think I'll at least skim a few issues.
I just skimmed over a few myself, reminiscing. You know, I take it back... these are pretty good, maybe I didn't appreciate them as a kid. I also had no idea they were written by Alan Grant and Simon Furman.
I've also never seen Robocop, I had an old toy that shot powder I think and I once watched the cartoon but while I knew who he was I guess it was just before my time.
Now I feel like I need to watch it...
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 01:11 PM
I just skimmed over a few myself, reminiscing. You know, I take it back... these are pretty good, maybe I didn't appreciate them as a kid. I also had no idea they were written by Alan Grant and Simon Furman.
Oh, that's a good writing pedigree. I like Furmans Transformers comics a lot and Alan Grants written more than his fair share of enjoyable Batman comics.
Sumac
01-18-2018, 01:16 PM
I remember Terminator vs RoboCop comic book. It was weird and the whole time travel angle was really...complicated? More like complete non-sense, but there were few nice moments.
Miller has written scripts for both Robo 2 and 3, AFAIK, but Robo 3 script was butchered for the sake of making RoboCop more "accessible for children", which complete idiocy, considering the roots of the franchise.
RoboCop 1 is an awesome movie - an immortal classic, still relevant and funny today. Aside from couple of moments it's still looking fairly good.
RoboCop 2 is good, but it tries to be too edgy for the sake of being edgy and misses nuanced approach of the first movie. Though, it has one of the best motion-capture battles in the history of 80-s movies. And it was directed by Kirshner who was director of The Empire Strikes Back.
RoboCop 3 is trash. There is a good idea somewhere, but it's marred by desire of producers to make movie kid friendly. Also, special effects in it are awful and it was released after Terminator 2.
RoboCop (2014) is also quite mediocre. It has a good first half and bad second. Once again producers tried to make movie for kids.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 01:21 PM
Has nobody else seen "RoboCop: Prime Directives"? It's the best RoboCop I've ever seen outside of the original movie.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 01:23 PM
I remember Terminator vs RoboCop comic book. It was weird and the whole time travel angle was really...complicated? More like complete non-sense, but there were few nice moments.
I thought it made sense, but there's no question that you're right. It was a bit complicated.
Miller has written scripts for both Robo 2 and 3, AFAIK, but Robo 3 script was butchered for the sake of making RoboCop more "accessible for children", which complete idiocy, considering the roots of the franchise.
It's beyond stupid. It still amazes me that they tried things like that back then. Stuff was thrown out for kids no matter what the source material. They made Robocop and Rambo cartoons. Unbelievable. There were Aliens toys at one point. Great movie - and I had a few of the toys, there were some really cool ones in those lines - but not one you'd expect kids to see, especially at the time when even the notion of kids seeing R-rated films made mom groups faint.
RoboCop (2014) is also quite mediocre. It has a good first half and bad second. Once again producers tried to make movie for kids.
I actually haven't seen this one. Worth even bothering with, or just skip it?
Has nobody else seen "RoboCop: Prime Directives"? It's the best RoboCop I've ever seen outside of the original movie.
I know of it, but I've never seen it. It was super limited release, right?
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 01:29 PM
I know of it, but I've never seen it. It was super limited release, right?
It was a full-on mini-series event on the Sci-Fi Channel around 2001. Then it went to DVD.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 01:32 PM
It was a full-on mini-series event on the Sci-Fi Channel around 2001. Then it went to DVD.
I never watched the Sci-Fi Channel with any regularity, which probably explains why I missed it. I doubt it would be too hard to find it on the internet now, though, so I might go digging later.
Spike Spiegel
01-18-2018, 01:40 PM
Has nobody else seen "RoboCop: Prime Directives"? It's the best RoboCop I've ever seen outside of the original movie.
I watched it on Netflix about four years ago...
The only flaw it really has is the low-budget effects. I remember some parts looking like something out of Power Rangers.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 01:42 PM
I watched it on Netflix about four years ago...
The only flaw it really has is the low-budget effects. I remember some parts looking like something out of Power Rangers.
Yeah, and there's one guy that looks like Bonesteel from Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation. But the story and character performances is really, really good.
Candy Kappa
01-18-2018, 01:48 PM
I remember Terminator vs RoboCop comic book. It was weird and the whole time travel angle was really...complicated? More like complete non-sense, but there were few nice moments.
NECA recently came out with some figures based off that, they look really nifty.
I actually haven't seen this one. Worth even bothering with, or just skip it?
I liked it, but I also kept my expectation low when I saw it on Netflix. It's really hampered about the "no gore" even though in some regards it's kinda more gruesome in some places. It's worth a watch if you're invested in Robocop as the themes of the original movie is still present, but honestly the in-world commercials they ran on Facebook for the Omnicorp products are way better and more engaging, I highly recommend seeing those on YouTube or something.
newfan
01-18-2018, 02:01 PM
I couldn't take to the look and effects of Robocop, sounds, movement etc. in Prime Directives... it's at the bottom of my DVD box. Not sure what the training was for this one but Weller trained with a mime artist to get the movement right.
Anyway, if anyone wants to carry on the topic (though it looks like we are done?) shall we have a 'Robocop general discussion' thread?
Well I might as well...at the risk of having 0 replies :)
Sumac
01-18-2018, 02:26 PM
I moved this post to the thread about RoboCop.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 02:34 PM
I mean, we can always go back to Star Wars, I guess, though do we really want to go back to constant fights over it?
I guess it's been derailed long enough, though.
Sumac, I'll reply to you in the new thread.
Candy Kappa
01-18-2018, 02:54 PM
Back to SW, so... I'm curious if the old Jedi books will have any bearing to ep9
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 02:57 PM
I can't imagine they won't?
I mean, they went out of their way to a) introduce them, b) make us thing they were destroyed, to c) show us that they weren't.
What happens with the Jedi Teachings now, is one of the things I'm most curious about regarding the next movie.
That and how they're going to handle Leia.
(perhaps she'll die of a broken heart now that Luke is gone...)
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 03:00 PM
I'm expecting a bit of a time skip. They need time to pass for the rebellion to regroup and recruit anyway. Perfect excuse to have a "she passed away recently" thing. Not ideal or great, but there aren't a lot of options at this point anyway.
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
01-18-2018, 03:03 PM
I can't imagine they won't?
I mean, they went out of their way to a) introduce them, b) make us thing they were destroyed, to c) show us that they weren't.
What happens with the Jedi Teachings now, is one of the things I'm most curious about regarding the next movie.
That and how they're going to handle Leia.
(perhaps she'll die of a broken heart now that Luke is gone...)
Maybe they Paul Walker her, without CGI...
"Hey, guys, so Leia retired... I think she's on that Gamorrean spa planet? Yeah, she's not taking our calls anymore."
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 03:11 PM
Back to SW, so... I'm curious if the old Jedi books will have any bearing to ep9
I am almost 200% certain the "blink and you'll miss it" glimpse of the books on the Falcon was a reshoot thing for IX. Not in a sense of there actually being a script or even a story in place for IX that VIII needed to adhere to, but someone (probably Kennedy) almost undoubtedly went at some point... "Wait... dammit, Rian, you have to leave whoever's doing IX SOMETHING to follow up on/recreate more Jedi from."
There's no way that was always the plan. It retroactively robs any weight from Luke trying to burn the temple with the books in it and Yoda doing it anyway (makes Yoda's dialogue meaningless, too).
oldmanwinters
01-18-2018, 03:17 PM
I'd favor opening Episode IX with Leia's funeral/memorial service. It would be a nice way to honor the character and Carrie Fisher, and provide an immediate sense of gravitas to the film.
A time skip makes some sense too. I don't know how long a gap there was supposed to be between Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi, but RotJ's opening just feels like a lot more time has transpired between the two movies than between New Hope and Empire. Luke has obviously made rapid progress in his Jedi training with Yoda and the two clearly have more of a bond at the latter's deathbed than was apparent in a movie that would take place soon after Empire.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 03:28 PM
I'd favor opening Episode IX with Leia's funeral/memorial service. It would be a nice way to honor the character and Carrie Fisher, and provide an immediate sense of gravitas to the film.
A time skip makes some sense too.
Yeah, 100% chance of a big time lapse. 5 years, maybe. By the start of the movie, I bet there's already Padawans (or whatever) in training. Conversely, Kylo and his Knights of Ren are doing evil stuff.
They'll probably have Leia die in the years between in some random First Order attack and "tune into the books to read about it!" Which is chickenshit.
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 03:28 PM
I'd favor opening Episode IX with Leia's funeral/memorial service. It would be a nice way to honor the character and Carrie Fisher, and provide an immediate sense of gravitas to the film.
This is what I'm hoping they do as well.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 03:32 PM
This is what I'm hoping they do as well.
Can't have a time lapse with a memorial... I'm not seeing it. What we might get is some kind of big nod to her, though. Think, Henry Jones' statue in Indy IV, or something like that. Maybe some plan she hatched before dying bears fruit at a critical moment (fleet of ships arrives, "We're here on orders of General Leia," etc.).
I wonder if we'll finally get to see any of the existing Star Wars planets again. That Abrams interview about "I'm tying it all together, all the trilogies" is comforting.
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 03:37 PM
I disagree.
They could do the time jump in the crawl, and have the movie start at her memorial service.
But hey, there's plenty of time to speculate.
Andrew NDB
01-18-2018, 03:47 PM
I disagree.
They could do the time jump in the crawl, and have the movie start at her memorial service.
But hey, there's plenty of time to speculate.
What do you mean a time jump in the crawl? Say it's been 5 years, then show the memorial service, then actually move the movie 5 years? It's possible, but there's never been a Star Wars movie that skips ahead time like that mid-movie. Then again, there wasn't ever flashbacks in Star Wars movies until TLJ (the "Force Visions" thing in TFA wasn't really that).
It might begin with Kylo having a tense reunion with Rey at Leia's gravestone. Or something. "I can't believe it's been 5 years already since she passed," etc.. That would kind of accomplish the same thing.
dl316bh
01-18-2018, 03:52 PM
It might begin with Kylo having a tense reunion at Leia's gravestone. "I can't believe it's been 5 years already," etc..
That might actually work with or without Rey. He was clearly conflicted about his mother in The Last Jedi. Much as he seems to want to escape his families shadow, his feelings on his family seem really complicated and I could see him visiting a memorial.
CyberCubed
01-18-2018, 05:46 PM
Saw the movie, again before it left theaters, really great. I do wish the Canto Blight segment was a bit shorter, but no complaints. I even liked Rose and the Codebreaker guy a bit more this time around.
Love that Snoke and Phasma are dead. Love that Rey's parents are nobody. Mark Hammil and Adam Driver were fantastic the whole movie, easily the two standout actors. Also the ship battles are probably the best we've had in a Star Wars movie especially at the beginning. Some really great action scenes too in the throne room scene and Luke's training with Rey was good.
Hux is still terrible, worst new character by far. Purple Hair was boring too, but she's dead too so who cares. Also what's with that old woman with the ridiculously long nose?
I also hope Carrie Fisher's real life daughter gets a bigger role in the next movie, I liked her in this one even if she didn't do much. I also think the climax is one of the best of the series on Krait, although I wish the final shot wasn't on those slave kids, the main boy reminded me of Anakin.
Humor was on point too.
Katie
01-18-2018, 07:22 PM
But...but the next trilogy is about those kids. How can we ever GET it if they don’t show them?!
It was alright. I thought it could have been shaved down about 45 min. I still haven’t gotten the awe and amazement I felt ftom the original trilogy, but I guess some people will.
I want to really love it, cause I really loved those movies when I was a kid, but I just haven’t felt it from these new ones.
Vegita-San
01-18-2018, 07:34 PM
That might actually work with or without Rey. He was clearly conflicted about his mother in The Last Jedi. Much as he seems to want to escape his families shadow, his feelings on his family seem really complicated and I could see him visiting a memorial.
See, if they actually EXPLAINED why he was mad at his parents, rather than let the audience guess, or state the obvious (he blamed them for sending him off to murdering uncle school)....something like him showing up at a memorial for his mother could be an interesting character conflict.
But, these new movies don't seem interested in that. Setup interesting ideas...next director doesn't like those ideas....give him permission to throw them out, wash, rinse, repeat.
I am AMAZED Disney is letting kennedy do these important movies WITHOUT a clear gameplan in mind.
it would have been hard enough to do 9 with carrie fisher gone. But, not knowing how 9 ends when you're almost done with 1? Bush-league stuff.
plastroncafe
01-18-2018, 08:04 PM
I'd rather them show us Ben split from his family, then just have it come up in some sort of a monologue or opening crawl.
And that's only if it's an absolute necessity, because I'll be honest his backstory is far less interesting to me when compared to the Future of the Jedi.
Mom and Dad agreed to send him to live as a Hermit with his crazy uncle who tried to kill him one night.
ProactiveMan
01-19-2018, 02:56 AM
I wish the final shot wasn't on those slave kids, the main boy reminded me of Anakin.
They looked like kids in a school production of Oliver Twist. Like the casting director picked them up from a local Pokemon League and rubbed some dirt on their faces.
Vegita-San
01-20-2018, 06:23 PM
Doomed.......worlds is doommmed!
https://www.cbr.com/star-wars-handmaids-tale-director-reed-morano/
Autbot_Benz
01-20-2018, 06:25 PM
Doomed.......worlds is doommmed!
https://www.cbr.com/star-wars-handmaids-tale-director-reed-morano/
The **** is wrong with you why don't you want female directors?
Spike Spiegel
01-20-2018, 06:56 PM
So after five movies with white men at the helm, Kathleen Kennedy is finally considering following through on her promise to have a woman in the director's chair?
I'd imagine that it's for one of the spinoffs, since Johnson's trilogy will probably be X-XII, and Abrams is doing IX.
Vegita-San
01-20-2018, 07:00 PM
I'm more concerned about what this new director has worked on previously.
has she worked on ANYTHING close to the level of Star wars before?
Something like the Hand Maidens tale doesn't scream star wars worthy.
Andrew NDB
01-20-2018, 07:26 PM
I'm more concerned about what this new director has worked on previously.
has she worked on ANYTHING close to the level of Star wars before?
Something like the Hand Maidens tale doesn't scream star wars worthy.
I just hope she holds them to the same level of scrutiny as the male directors. She's had two Star Wars movies almost entirely reshot so far and fired another two others before they even began.
Vegita-San
01-20-2018, 07:40 PM
i seriously doubt it. in that case, if she doesn't like it and is afraid to fire this director for whatever reason, watch it be an even worse mess because her first choice was again another bad choice.
NinjaPug
01-20-2018, 09:19 PM
What's the problem? She did good work on The Handmaid's Tale. I think she even won an Emmy for it.
For all we know she could've met with KK to discuss the live action TV series that's coming in 2019.
CyberCubed
01-20-2018, 09:44 PM
Vegita-san goes through mental breakdowns whenever anything relating to women is going on. His act has gotten really tired, I don't know how he doesn't get banned for this.
Autbot_Benz
01-20-2018, 09:50 PM
Vegita-san goes through mental breakdowns whenever anything relating to women is going on. His act has gotten really tired, I don't know how he doesn't get banned for this.
Vegita-San in a nutshell
https://i.imgur.com/0s445HI.gif
Allio
01-20-2018, 09:58 PM
has she done anything sci-fy related?
dl316bh
01-20-2018, 10:23 PM
has she done anything sci-fy related?
Not that I'm aware of, but that's not a great indicator of anything. James Gunn hadn't done anything with superheroes or the like prior to Guardians. Hell, George Lucas himself had only done a Phillip K. Dick esque sci-fi story and a comedy before he did the swashbuckling adventure in space that's Star Wars.
For all we know she could've met with KK to discuss the live action TV series that's coming in 2019.
It's certainly possible. Even likely, I'd say. Most of her work, after a quick wiki, seems to be in TV, so Kennedy might be looking into her to at least direct some episodes.
Vegita-San
01-21-2018, 09:15 AM
Not that I'm aware of, but that's not a great indicator of anything. James Gunn hadn't done anything with superheroes or the like prior to Guardians. Hell, George Lucas himself had only done a Phillip K. Dick esque sci-fi story and a comedy before he did the swashbuckling adventure in space that's Star Wars.
Sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.
and it looks like she's done TV mostly, and some shorts. NOTHING to the scale of a Star Wars movie, or even a TV show.
Lucasfilm seems to be targeting unknown or new directors cause they are easier to control and get what lucasfilm wants done.
JJ seems to be the biggest name chosen so far.
plastroncafe
01-21-2018, 09:58 AM
Well that may be the case, I'm hopeful that they're choosing lesser-known directors to get a fresh voice on the property. We wouldn't have the MCU now had it not been for Jon Favreau getting to direct Iron Man. And it's not exactly like he had any experience directing an action movie before.
And I would say that it's arguably still the best comic book movie ever made.
Jester
01-21-2018, 09:58 AM
Lucasfilm seems to be targeting unknown or new directors cause they are easier to control and get what lucasfilm wants done.
JJ seems to be the biggest name chosen so far.
Ron Freakin' Howard, man.
NinjaPug
01-21-2018, 10:23 AM
Sometimes it works, and sometimes it doesn't.
and it looks like she's done TV mostly, and some shorts. NOTHING to the scale of a Star Wars movie, or even a TV show.
Lucasfilm seems to be targeting unknown or new directors cause they are easier to control and get what lucasfilm wants done.
JJ seems to be the biggest name chosen so far.
Why are you putting Star Wars on such a pedestal? A good director is a good director. These big budget movies have teams that handle the FX and action staging that I assume you think a TV director can't handle.
Look at the Russo brothers filmography before being tapped to make what many believe to be the best MCU movie so far.
Spike Spiegel
01-21-2018, 10:29 AM
I don't care who they get at this point, as long as they give us something new that doesn't bastardize established characters. I think the best parts of the ST are the aspects that don't depend on the originals.
Vegita-San
01-21-2018, 10:59 AM
Ron Freakin' Howard, man.
true. I forgot about him.
can you tell i could care less about the solo movie?
And I think they only brought him in is because the movie needs a desperate save.
CyberCubed
01-21-2018, 12:58 PM
I don't care who they get at this point, as long as they give us something new that doesn't bastardize established characters.
They didn't bastardize Luke, if that's what you're implying. Episode 8 is the most interesting Luke has ever been.
Spike Spiegel
01-21-2018, 04:24 PM
Episode 8 is the most interesting Luke has ever been.
https://i.imgur.com/pFxqbGz.gif
I think they bastardized Han and Leia, too. It's like they had no development after the romantic bits of ESB. If anything, they regressed by the time of TFA.
The idea that mouse-canon Leia was never properly trained in the Force makes me a sad panda.
CyberCubed
01-21-2018, 04:27 PM
Luke had the best characterisation he ever had in the series, and it's generally agreed upon on most online communities I've been to. He's a man who was betrayed by his nephew and everything he did about the Jedi religion failed him. Given there is also a 30 year gap here, of course people change from when they're 20 to 60 something.
AT-Man
01-21-2018, 06:08 PM
Luke had the best characterisation he ever had in the series, and it's generally agreed upon on most online communities I've been to. He's a man who was betrayed by his nephew and everything he did about the Jedi religion failed him. Given there is also a 30 year gap here, of course people change from when they're 20 to 60 something.
https://i.imgur.com/7ECCQyz.gif
Vegita-San
01-21-2018, 07:05 PM
https://i.imgur.com/pFxqbGz.gif
I think they bastardized Han and Leia, too. It's like they had no development after the romantic bits of ESB. If anything, they regressed by the time of TFA.
They ALL regressed.
Han went back to doing what he did. leia went back to doing what she did. Luke just gave up.
That's not character development. that's character assassination.
Leonardo_thebest
01-21-2018, 07:18 PM
Did anyone see this film theory, um, film theory? I agree with the first half of what he says, but not his counterpoint about why theory matters.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aB-UKwO367s
Could someone explain how I fix this so it plays?
CyberCubed
01-21-2018, 07:18 PM
All of Luke's scenes were the most powerful in the movie, along with the Kylo Ren and Rey scenes. Luke is a disenchanted war hero who saw all his hard work had gone to naught, and training Kylo Ren his own bloodline turned on him and burned down the Jedi temple. Besides the 30 year gap of other stuff where we don't know what happened, Luke was definitely in the place he needed to be.
Also I don't know what else people expected of Leia? She's defending the Rebels like she should, what else did you expect?
Leonardo_thebest
01-21-2018, 07:22 PM
All of Luke's scenes were the most powerful in the movie, along with the Kylo Ren and Rey scenes. Luke is a disenchanted war hero who saw all his hard work had gone to naught, and training Kylo Ren his own bloodline turned on him and burned down the Jedi temple. Besides the 30 year gap of other stuff where we don't know what happened, Luke was definitely in the place he needed to be.
Also I don't know what else people expected of Leia? She's defending the Rebels like she should, what else did you expect?
I think that's right, loathe as I am to agree with you.
Old people are often just fed up. Yoda certainly was.
Luke could've been a lot better, there was a lot of potential, but even then, he was absolutely fantastic in the film.
Vegita-San
01-22-2018, 07:40 AM
mark hamil knows how to act, even with crap. that's why.
Put a SJW in their place in another ep 8 thread elsewhere. they came back with a lame butt reply that wasn't even trying anymore and totally ignored what I wrote.
rewarding when it works that way.
plastroncafe
01-22-2018, 09:32 AM
I think that's right, loathe as I am to agree with you.
Old people are often just fed up. Yoda certainly was.
People had similar complaints about Toph and Katara in Legends of Korra.
That there's no way the top and Katara we saw in Last Airbender would give up. But what I think they're neglecting to realize is how long those characters have been fighting. Stuff like that takes its toll. Grief takes its toll.
I thought a lot about an aging and close to dying Aang as I left the Last Jedi.
The balance between light and dark is not a singular battle that's going to be won by a singular person, and I think the realization of that when one is dedicated their entire life to that balance, it's got to be world wearying.
CyberCubed
01-22-2018, 02:01 PM
Put a SJW in their place in another ep 8 thread elsewhere. they came back with a lame butt reply that wasn't even trying anymore and totally ignored what I wrote.
Is this your only enjoyment in life? You think "putting SJW's in their place" on the internet is some sort of big accomplishment?
Leonardo_thebest
01-22-2018, 07:46 PM
The hostility here is off the charts. Somebody should take a break from the internet and get themselves sorted.
I thought bullying wasn't tolerated.
Andrew NDB
01-22-2018, 08:02 PM
The idea that mouse-canon Leia was never properly trained in the Force makes me a sad panda.
You would think more women would be upset about it when you consider the real reason that is. Fisher didn't want a huge role, that's true... that didn't mean she couldn't be an experienced Jedi. She was rendered a non-Jedi because making her a full-fledged Jedi would make Luke less special and the race to find him (this is what the opening crawl of TFA says) less meaningful in the story. If that doesn't make the Bechdel people fired up, I'm not sure what would, and it's absolutely true.
Vegita-San
01-22-2018, 08:04 PM
You would think more women would be upset about it when you consider the real reason that is. Fisher didn't want a huge role, that's true... that didn't mean she couldn't be an experienced Jedi. She was rendered a non-Jedi because making her a full-fledged Jedi would make Luke less special and the race to find him (this is what the opening crawl of TFA says) less meaningful.
i don't think they even thought that much about it.
Leia lead the rebellion in the OT, thus, that was her role here. they ALL had the same roles, except luke who regressed further.
plastroncafe
01-22-2018, 08:09 PM
You would think more women would be upset about it when you consider the real reason that is. Fisher didn't want a huge role, that's true... that didn't mean she couldn't be an experienced Jedi. She was rendered a non-Jedi because making her a full-fledged Jedi would make Luke less special and the race to find him (this is what the opening crawl of TFA says) less meaningful in the story. If that doesn't make the Bechdel people fired up, I'm not sure what would, and it's absolutely true.
So you still don't know what the Bechdel test is, huh?
Andrew NDB
01-22-2018, 08:13 PM
So you still don't know what the Bechdel test is, huh?
I do. Why?
Spike Spiegel
01-22-2018, 08:26 PM
I do. Why?
I guess that for some gender critical fans, having female-female relationships on display that are affirming/"realistic" (i.e. Leia/Holdo) > the idea of Leia kicking ass as a fully trained Jedi. Apparently Holdo appears in a current tie-in novel as a friend Leia meets years before TFA.
I still don't see why we couldn't have had both, though. Maybe Han could have become the Rebel leader, completing his character's change from mercenary to selfless leader, and Leia would have taken over the new Jedi order after Luke lost his mojo. Maybe that change would be what eventually drove them apart and estranged them further from Ben/Kylo.
Sumac
01-22-2018, 08:53 PM
I kind of agree that characters sort of "froze" into roles they had back in the OT. Which what usually happens when someone tries to make a continuation pandering to the fans of original work.
In that light, prequels, for all their shortcomings don't look so bad now.
CyberCubed
01-23-2018, 05:22 PM
Most sequel series have that problem though. For Dragonball fans they can look at Super, Goku and Vegeta regressed to their pre-Buu saga personalities just to keep the series going.
I think that happens with any continuation of a franchise that ended a long time ago, so it's not only Star Wars here. Probably doesn't help matters the current people writing were the original kid/teen fans who grew up with it, so it sort of has a "published fanfiction" mentality to it.
TigerClaw
01-23-2018, 05:53 PM
The Last Jedi got 4 nominations for the 2018 Oscars, these are the categories that you can always expect a Star Wars movie to get nominated for.
Best Original Score
Best Sound Editing
Best Sound Mixing
Best Visual FX
ProactiveMan
01-23-2018, 07:14 PM
Makes sense. All that stuff was good.
Vegita-San
01-23-2018, 07:19 PM
last three maybe.
but not really the first one.
then again, modern movie scores are so bland, maybe it was the least bland and somehow stood out.
although I AM glad they actually g ave Wonder woman an actual theme. that alone should have gotten a nod.
Vegita-San
01-23-2018, 07:21 PM
I kind of agree that characters sort of "froze" into roles they had back in the OT. Which what usually happens when someone tries to make a continuation pandering to the fans of original work.
In that light, prequels, for all their shortcomings don't look so bad now.
not in the EU books.
Everyone evolved. and responded to the challenges in interesting ways. I especially liked the side detour they gave han, after Anakin was killed (IIRC) where he kind of went rogue for a while to get away from it all. if i'm remembering right, it was a fun side venture.
Sumac
01-23-2018, 07:38 PM
Most sequel series have that problem though. For Dragonball fans they can look at Super, Goku and Vegeta regressed to their pre-Buu saga personalities just to keep the series going.
I think that happens with any continuation of a franchise that ended a long time ago, so it's not only Star Wars here. Probably doesn't help matters the current people writing were the original kid/teen fans who grew up with it, so it sort of has a "published fanfiction" mentality to it.
Definitely.
But SW had an Extended Universe which took characters in various directions.
I am not saying Sequels should have followed those directions, but at least creators could do something more creative than basically bringing characters 20 years later and doesn't change them from OT one bit.
With the seemingly exception for Luke, which still had repeated they way of Obi-Wan and Yoda.
I mean, they were so many ideas and things that could be used and they opted for the least exciting and least creative option possible. It's really disappointing.
dl316bh
01-23-2018, 07:40 PM
that's character assassination.
Character assassination is deliberately and falsely trying to harm someones good reputation.
Whatever your opinion on the direction of fictional characters, it's not character assassination.
Also I don't know what else people expected of Leia? She's defending the Rebels like she should, what else did you expect?
It's also what she's always been doing in any form of post-RotJ fiction. The only thing I can remember her stepping up for force training over other duties was in an Infinities comic where Luke died during Empire Strikes Back and someone had to carry the torch. In the EU and such, she chose to be a politician and work on establishing the New Republic, which is absolutely a choice she would make, especially given she already had experience. Aside from her blood family history, which she didn't even know until Return, the Jedi didn't mean much to her. She'd been more involved in the political life led by her adopted father, who was once a senator.
I kind of agree that characters sort of "froze" into roles they had back in the OT.
I think that's definitely true of Han and it's something I did not like about Force Awakens. It seems too stupidly simple to just have him be a smuggler again rather than redefine his role in the universe after becoming a damn general and a war hero.
Andrew NDB
01-23-2018, 08:43 PM
If they didn't want to have Han be General Han Solo, old war hero of the Republic (like he was in the EU) they could have done something else, anything else but make him a damn smuggler again. Maybe he goes all Jane Goodall on Kashyyyk, tending to sick Wookiees or something, or in some kind of New Republic Intelligence.
Vegita-San
01-23-2018, 08:50 PM
Character assassination is deliberately and falsely trying to harm someones good reputation.
Whatever your opinion on the direction of fictional characters, it's not character assassination.
it may be a fictional character, but I think the description fits PERFECTLY.
they ruined lukes destiny so rey could be special.
dl316bh
01-23-2018, 09:01 PM
it may be a fictional character, but I think the description fits PERFECTLY.
they ruined lukes destiny so rey could be special.
The movie literally ends with Luke Skywalker inspiring the galaxy one more time in a way no single person in this universe has before. Children are enacting his last stand with homemade figures. He's a legend.
His reputation could not possibly be higher.
If they didn't want to have Han be General Han Solo, old war hero of the Republic (like he was in the EU) they could have done something else, anything else but make him a damn smuggler again. Maybe he goes all Jane Goodall on Kashyyyk, tending to sick Wookiees or something, or in some kind of New Republic Intelligence.
Yeah, Hans situation was absolutely the laziest thing done in the new trilogy. It also ended up making Han look kind of pathetic. Taking what we've learned and saw in all the films into account, Han's a pretty garbage smuggler.
Vegita-San
01-23-2018, 09:03 PM
Not really.
There is ZERO way that anyone would even have even heard of his accomplishments. ESPECIALLY that fast.
That ending was so badly tacked on, it made zero sense.
plastroncafe
01-23-2018, 09:07 PM
Yeah, Hans situation was absolutely the laziest thing done in the new trilogy. It also ended up making Han look kind of pathetic. Taking what we've learned and saw in all the films into account, Han's a pretty garbage smuggler.
I was always under the assumption that was entirely the point.
Maybe that's why I don't see Han and Chewie returning to their old line of work in the wake of the loss of his son to be that unsurprising a character turn.
dl316bh
01-23-2018, 09:12 PM
Not really.
There is ZERO way that anyone would even have even heard of his accomplishments. ESPECIALLY that fast.
That ending was so badly tacked on, it made zero sense.
Okay, now you're just straight up trying to negate what we actually saw in the film because it does not fit your views and coming up with any excuse for why it's not valid.
It was in the film. That denouement could also have been months later. If you don't like the film, fine - I don't think any Star Wars film has been universally loved since A New Hope - but let's not pretend the film didn't do things it actually did because it's inconvenient to your argument.
Utrommaniac
01-23-2018, 10:09 PM
I assumed that particular kid knew because he's Force Sensitive and "felt" it.
dl316bh
01-23-2018, 10:39 PM
I assumed that particular kid knew because he's Force Sensitive and "felt" it.
That's a good possible explanation. I assumed it was simply weeks or months later, after whispers spread about the last stand of the resistance and Luke's role.
Andrew NDB
01-23-2018, 11:14 PM
Okay, now you're just straight up trying to negate what we actually saw in the film because it does not fit your views and coming up with any excuse for why it's not valid.
It was in the film. That denouement could also have been months later. If you don't like the film, fine - I don't think any Star Wars film has been universally loved since A New Hope - but let's not pretend the film didn't do things it actually did because it's inconvenient to your argument.
Ehh... I liked the film, but that scene wasn't remotely even presented as some kind Of, "Luke made this sacrifice, the word is out galaxy wide about it, even to child slaves on casino planets!" That's a reach. It seemed like Johnson was going for some kind of symmetry there, or simultaneous "The Force finding balance, somehow" thing, but watching the movie there is no way I'd come to the conclusion the end is stemming directly from some kind of public knowledge of Luke's Force projection sacrifice. Plus, no one even really knows he's dead yet. Think about it. WE saw him die... but if you're Rey, or anyone else... you go to Ach'to and he isn't there, can you even be certain he's dead at all?
plastroncafe
01-23-2018, 11:20 PM
I think it's pretty safe to say that Leia knows.
As does Ray, and probably Kylo.
Andrew NDB
01-23-2018, 11:24 PM
I think it's pretty safe to say that Leia knows.
As does Ray, and probably Kylo.
I'll give you Leia, probably, but it seems like the "I know so-and-so died because of the Force" so far in Star Wars seems to be limited to direct blood relatives, people you've had kids with, or entire planets of people dying. Unless it does, in fact, turn out Rey is a Skywalker.
Though how much stock would most folk put in Leia have in telling the galaxy Luke died, sight-unseen through the Force which she isn't even supposed to know much about? Particularly just having recovered from a vacuum near-death in space an hour beforehand at an elderly age? I think most people would think she's full of sh**, and this mystery about "Luke is still out there, somewhere!" would continue.
plastroncafe
01-23-2018, 11:26 PM
That's the beauty of these movies, the force can pretty much be anything you want it to be.
Andrew NDB
01-23-2018, 11:28 PM
That's the beauty of these movies, the force can pretty much be anything you want it to be.
In the latest trilogy, it'd appear you're correct. Anything goes.
:roll:
plastroncafe
01-23-2018, 11:34 PM
Yeah, because if there's one thing Lucas had it was an ironclad story Bible that he adhered to religiously.
*cough*Hanshotfirst*cough*
Andrew NDB
01-23-2018, 11:36 PM
Yeah, because if there's one thing Lucas had it was an ironclad story Bible that he adhered to religiously.
*cough*Hanshotfirst*cough*
He actually did, as far as the Force goes. We can talk about midichlorians (there seems to have grown a huge misconception that's fed into itself about what they actually are since TPM came out), but what we saw in 4-6 was perfectly consistent with what we saw in 1-3.
And who even cares who shot first. That stuff is so boring and geek bait. If his finger hit the trigger 5 milliseconds before or during when Greedo hit his, who cares? He was still gonna do it.
plastroncafe
01-23-2018, 11:44 PM
Is there anything in this conversation that is not geek bait?
What is boring to you, was to me a character defining moment that was changed because the guy who made it decided there was a car coming and got a do over.
But fair is fair, there are a whole bunch of really boring conversation surrounding the newer movies as well.
Andrew NDB
01-23-2018, 11:50 PM
Is there anything in this conversation that is not geek bait?
What is boring to you, was to me a character defining moment that was changed because the guy who made it decided there was a car coming and got a do over.
But fair is fair, there are a whole bunch of really boring conversation surrounding the newer movies as well.
Not really of equivalent nature. In 20 years, I am reasonably certain we will not be sitting in theaters watching "The Last Jedi: Kathleen Kennedy Special Edition" where Luke actually visits the salt planet. Or whatever. Less people will care, the whole "WOW! Star Wars is this big event, these special editions are the first things new we're seeing of Star Wars ever!!!" won't be a thing. The big event has passed. For new generations, TFA and TLJ will just be remembered about the same as the latest "Maze Runner" movie, possibly even less favorably.
plastroncafe
01-23-2018, 11:56 PM
I guess we'll find out won't we.
Personally? I think that was always going to be the case anyways. The original trilogy was lightning in a bottle.
I don't think anything will ever top their greatness, but then again I say that as someone who could not have been less impressed with the prequels. I saw each of them opening night, and I haven't seen them since.
I think it's okay if the current Trilogy of movies doesn't reach the same height as the previous 6.... Which again in my estimation is still debatable because I didn't like the prequels.
The nature of media is completely different now, and I don't see the rapidly changing face of media entertainment slowing down anytime soon.
dl316bh
01-24-2018, 12:11 AM
Ehh... I liked the film, but that scene wasn't remotely even presented as some kind Of, "Luke made this sacrifice, the word is out galaxy wide about it, even to child slaves on casino planets!" That's a reach.
It really had no other significance than "kid talks about Lukes last stand, as Luke has become myth and folktale passed from person to person", so I don't think it's a reach. Like I said, I just assumed it took place weeks or months later. If that's not what they were going for, there wasn't much point in the scene. Besides, it ties very much in with the way the film focuses on heroes, legends, myths and everything that comes with them.
In the latest trilogy, it'd appear you're correct. Anything goes.
:roll:
To be fair, Lucas wasn't even super consistent with that. We got an explanation for what the Force was from Yoda. Then the prequels muddies the waters with midichlorians and such. The whole saga, Lucas onward, was made up as they went along.
And who even cares who shot first.
I've been saying that for years. It never goes over well.
The big event has passed.
To be fair, that was always going to be the case whatever the merits of the films. You can't really fully recapture the hype and wave that came with the prequels, the first Star Wars films in twenty years when the franchise could still "do no wrong". The yearly schedule isn't helping, I think.
Star Wars could've continued to be "an event" if Disney had wanted and make as much money from the franchise as they wanted. Instead they went the route of milking it. Sure Lucas also milked it but not in movie form, only to the fans through comics/books/figures, here we're getting at least one movie a year if not more and people will get tired of it eventually. Short Term vs Long Term money and Disney went for Short.
I think a lot of the backlash in TLJ is people realizing this and they're getting off their Star Wars high and being a bit more selective. The flaws of Disney Star Wars are becoming more apparent and being bombarded by more and more movies isn't feeling right for a lot of people. The movie Solo will likely do a lot more damage to the character of Han than Greedo shooting first ever did.
I was a little kid when the Special Editions came out, I had actually accidentally discovered Star Wars only a bout a year before and to me they were awesome. I loved all the changes, now as an adult I can see some of the annoying changes but in the end there's a reason Disney hasn't sold the unaltered versions on BR yet, the majority of the people don't care, only whiny fans. The prequel trilogy as criticized as it was, was always an "event".
Vegita-San
01-24-2018, 01:30 AM
Okay, now you're just straight up trying to negate what we actually saw in the film because it does not fit your views and coming up with any excuse for why it's not valid.
It was in the film. That denouement could also have been months later. If you don't like the film, fine - I don't think any Star Wars film has been universally loved since A New Hope - but let's not pretend the film didn't do things it actually did because it's inconvenient to your argument.
what exactly did the film do? other than keep things in the status quo and waste 2 hours with back and forth nonsense?
I sense andrew getting a plant graphic ready :D
CyberCubed
01-24-2018, 03:34 AM
what exactly did the film do? other than keep things in the status quo and waste 2 hours with back and forth nonsense?
I sense andrew getting a plant graphic ready :D
Go away, troll.
Sumac
01-24-2018, 06:50 AM
I was always under the assumption that was entirely the point.
I love when people start to justify ****** writing, by doing stuff like "this was plan all along".
That's the beauty of these movies, the force can pretty much be anything you want it to be.
In another words - as long as they support (your) agenda everything goes. Yay!:roll:
Vegita-San
01-24-2018, 06:54 AM
Ehh... I liked the film, but that scene wasn't remotely even presented as some kind Of, "Luke made this sacrifice, the word is out galaxy wide about it, even to child slaves on casino planets!" That's a reach. It seemed like Johnson was going for some kind of symmetry there, or simultaneous "The Force finding balance, somehow" thing, but watching the movie there is no way I'd come to the conclusion the end is stemming directly from some kind of public knowledge of Luke's Force projection sacrifice. Plus, no one even really knows he's dead yet. Think about it. WE saw him die... but if you're Rey, or anyone else... you go to Ach'to and he isn't there, can you even be certain he's dead at all?
Exactly.
especially since after 30 years of 'winning the war', People like Rey STILL thought he was a freakin' myth. how can a SLAVE KID with no media access know what just went on, from our POV, no more than 10 minutes ago?
just crap writing.
He actually did, as far as the Force goes. We can talk about midichlorians (there seems to have grown a huge misconception that's fed into itself about what they actually are since TPM came out), but what we saw in 4-6 was perfectly consistent with what we saw in 1-3.
And who even cares who shot first. That stuff is so boring and geek bait. If his finger hit the trigger 5 milliseconds before or during when Greedo hit his, who cares? He was still gonna do it.
'Han shot first' happened because lucas softened a bit in his old age. he didn't want han to be seen as a ruthless killer anymore. and that was the first of his bad OCD decisions regarding the original trilogy that doomed him from a public POV.
as far as 'consistant' I'd arrgue some of that point.
'your father wanted you to have it when you where old enough...' comes to mind. but lines like that would have trapped them later.
WARNING, Contains language. But THIS lady gets it. why don't so many others?cWy8jWXhdnA
dl316bh
01-24-2018, 11:51 AM
I sense andrew getting a plant graphic ready :D
I sense a lot of things, but the main one is that interacting with you is clearly a waste of my time, because you never respond with any depth to any challenge to your statements, unless "nuh-uh, you're wrong" is considered debate or discussion these days and not grade school fare. You only really respond with things on the level of "YUP" to anyone who agrees with you, because you're clearly great at articulating your own arguments, and can clearly stand opposing opinions so well you have to make up the idea that a Disney employee would come to a Ninja Turtles forum to defend a movie that's made over a billion dollars rather than someone just enjoys the movie, because I guess that's a bridge too far for you.
Andrew's been good enough to at least discuss things with me in threads, even if we disagree.
Short Term vs Long Term money and Disney went for Short.
Unfortunately, that's how corporations work. Always. If it turns out the stuff's good, great, if it's not, doesn't matter as long as it makes a lot of money. That's why I was never particularly happy with Disney buying it.
Andrew NDB
01-24-2018, 12:00 PM
It really had no other significance than "kid talks about Lukes last stand, as Luke has become myth and folktale passed from person to person", so I don't think it's a reach. Like I said, I just assumed it took place weeks or months later. If that's not what they were going for, there wasn't much point in the scene.
Oh. I forgot that part, I think. They literally mention that, don't they?
To be fair, Lucas wasn't even super consistent with that. We got an explanation for what the Force was from Yoda. Then the prequels muddies the waters with midichlorians and such.
Which wasn't contradictory. The midichlorians were explained as markers to see who had the most likelihood of having Force potential from a testing standpoint. Which makes sense in pre-Empire, Jedi Council days. It would be pretty exhausting for the Jedi Council to spend weeks training millions of people how to lift rocks, only to find out 10 guys in the bunch ever had any chance at being able to do so. Ergo, they made a test.
You have a lot of midichlorians, it doesn't mean you're guaranteed to be Force sensitive, it means you have a higher likelihood of turning out to be Force sensitive over someone with less.
I don't see it as a big deal and it didn't change a thing from the OT. Yoda wasn't talking about screening Padawans when he was telling Luke about the Force.
I've been saying that for years. It never goes over well.
It's like the freaking Alamo with Star Wars fans. Dumb.
dl316bh
01-24-2018, 12:07 PM
Oh. I forgot that part, I think. They literally mention that, don't they?
I think so. It's been about a month though and I've had a lot on my mind, though, so I can't remember for sure.
Which wasn't contradictory. The midichlorians were explained as markers to see who had the most likelihood of having Force potential from a testing standpoint. Which makes sense in pre-Empire, Jedi Council days. It would be pretty exhausting for the Jedi Council to spend weeks training millions of people how to lift rocks, only to find out 10 guys in the bunch ever had any chance at being able to do so. Ergo, they made a test.
You have a lot of midichlorians, it doesn't mean you're guaranteed to be Force sensitive, it means you have a higher likelihood of turning out to be Force sensitive over someone with less.
I don't see it as a big deal and it didn't change a thing from the OT. Yoda wasn't talking about screening Padawans when he was telling Luke about the Force.
When you lay it out, you're right, actually. I never thought the midichlorians were a big deal anyway. But for some reason that got a lot of people bothered.
I do think the force has always been vaguely defined enough that it can fit whatever you need it to, philosophical underpinnings aside. As it is, you can move stuff with your mind, persuade people, speed up, jump high and project lightning with it, all varying powers. It's kinda like space magic.
It's like the freaking Alamo with Star Wars fans. Dumb.
And every one of them thought they were Davey Crockett, waging a long, lonely battle over something of great importance when it was the most minor of details that changed almost nothing. It's always been an interesting hill for Star Wars fans to die on. Interesting and frustrating, because it's one of those things that always came up and made talking Star Wars insufferable for years.
plastroncafe
01-24-2018, 12:24 PM
One person's Dumb Detail is another's Pivotal Character Moment.
Which, let's face it...is pretty much the crux of the hate the new movies are getting.
I liked Han shooting first, because it said to me a lot about his character without him actually having to SAY it. Sure we find him in the den of scum and villainy, and yeah we know that he's smooth...or at least he thinks he's smooth, and that he thinks can talk himself out of any situation.
But then he actually kills a dude when it's clear Greedo isn't seeing things his way.
He's a literal loose canon.
And I liked that about him.
I think it makes his attachment to the Rebellion, and to Leia, more powerful.
You disagree.
Okay. Yay?
I prefer The Force to be more space magic than space science, because I have a background in science...so I find crap science to be distracting.
That's why I find midichlorians to be unsatisfying.
You disagree.
Okay.
Andrew NDB
01-24-2018, 12:26 PM
I would agree with people that, of all of the OT changes in the special editions, the Han and Greedo business is the most unnecessary of the changes. Does it bother me, though? No.
plastroncafe
01-24-2018, 12:31 PM
I would agree with people that, of all of the OT changes in the special editions, the Han and Greedo business is the most unnecessary of the changes. Does it bother me, though? No.
Congratulations.
I would like to touch up on the speed at which information travels in the new movies, and how the slave kids can be talking about Luke's final fight on the Salt planet.
Those kids are slaves on the Casino Planet. It was made clear in the poorly paced casino scene that the folks on that planet are making money by exploitation and war profiteering, by selling to both sides.
I don't think it's beyond the realm of the possible for people on that planet to have heard about the stand off with Kylo and Luke.
Especially if the Resistance is reaching out to all their allies for help, and telling that story.
And the First Order, who was also present, tells that story.
That whole planet makes money off both sides of this conflict, and it's juicy damn gossip.
Andrew NDB
01-24-2018, 12:32 PM
Well, if the kids were literally talking about Luke's sacrifice (and I guess they were) then there's really no arguing that something like that is what happened.
dl316bh
01-24-2018, 12:37 PM
I feel like it was never really an issue of the argument itself and more that, grand scheme of things, it didn't really matter much. But everyone made it out like it was sacrilege and the worst thing that could ever have been done. It feels like every Star Wars discussion for years devolved into whether or not Han shot first, like the entire movie hinged on it. I think that, more than anything, soured me on the whole thing.
plastroncafe
01-24-2018, 12:44 PM
It's been years since I've seen the re-releases, but...do any of the other upgrades in the movie actually change the narrative?
Wasn't it mostly just adding more creatures and ships to scenes, and then returning that deleted Jabba shake down?
Andrew NDB
01-24-2018, 12:48 PM
It's been years since I've seen the re-releases, but...do any of the other upgrades in the movie actually change the narrative?
No.
Wasn't it mostly just adding more creatures and ships to scenes, and then returning that deleted Jabba shake down?
Mostly. And then things they shot new like Vader boarding his shuttle in Empire, actually getting the actress who the Rancor eats to come back and shoot some new stuff, showing the whole Wampa on Hoth, redoing some of the X-Wing stuff in ANH with CGI X-Wings to make it more dynamic. The whole added epilogue to RotJ with Coruscant and Naboo probably counts. Blinking Ewok eyes, making Jawa eyes not look like toy eyes, fixing matte boxes, improving the Death Stars' explosions, etc., etc.. I can't really point to any changes I didn't like. I wish they'd have gone even further.
dl316bh
01-24-2018, 12:56 PM
Yeah, most of the changes were cosmetic. Special effects stuff. Plenty of it I like. Oddly, they seem to be a sticking point with fans too. I still see jokes in Youtube series poking fun at the things inserted. Though I don't know if that's by association with the stuff they have a major beef with.
I think only one scene per film had any significant retools. The added Jabba scene in ANH, the Wampa in Empire Strikes Back and the dance number in Return of the Jedi.
Vegita-San
01-24-2018, 01:08 PM
No.
Mostly. And then things they shot new like Vader boarding his shuttle in Empire, actually getting the actress who the Rancor eats to come back and shoot some new stuff, showing the whole Wampa on Hoth, redoing some of the X-Wing stuff in ANH with CGI X-Wings to make it more dynamic. The whole added epilogue to RotJ with Coruscant and Naboo probably counts. Blinking Ewok eyes, making Jawa eyes not look like toy eyes, fixing matte boxes, improving the Death Stars' explosions, etc., etc.. I can't really point to any changes I didn't like. I wish they'd have gone even further.
I would argue han shooting greedo SECOND. does. it COMPLETELY changes his character from possible villain, to...maybe I'll give this guy a second to get off a shot and give him a small fighting chance.
It doesn't make sense of course, since it would almost have to be them doing a holster draw old west style sitting down...but that is what I think the edit does to han solo. it softens him up just a little.
they should have stopped at the second set of changes.
Wampa stuff, OK. Jedi Rocks, OK. Improved CG xwings, OK. better looking monsters not got from a stucky's costume supply shop? OK.
Blinking ewoks? erased darth vader eyebrows? super giant jabba door? blinking ewoks?
now we are getting into ocd territory where no matter what you change, it won't make it perfect.
in other news..smh. looks like the ignore list gets a little workout. Make one little comment that the movie literally did nothing to advance the plot.... and the argument that there is no way, by what we see in the movie, that the slave kids would have been able to hear about what went down..and out come the insults. I guess we have to use the plant joke with caution, not everyone gets it ;o)
see my comment to andrew on why i thought that ending made no sense. you didn't discuss it, you basically said 'cause it's in the movie, it's ok'. hence the plant joke.
plastroncafe
01-24-2018, 01:14 PM
One of the things I liked about the original special effects was that they weren't perfect. I don't make films, and so getting to see how an effect works was always a treat. To a certain extent it made me feel like part of the process.
And so while I love deleted scenes, and additional content, I could really do without most of the cosmetic touch-ups.
Just imagine, if this had been a success, they would've thought they had "their" Star Wars and Bob Iger wouldn't have convinced Lucas to sell yet. Maybe Disney would've ended up buying it anyway since Iger/Lucas are friends but not before the Sequel trilogy was already in place.
https://pmcvariety.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/johon-carter.jpg
I know I'm alone on this one but I loved the movie and I'm sad it didn't get a sequel.
dl316bh
01-24-2018, 01:18 PM
One of the things I liked about the original special effects was that they weren't perfect. I don't make films, and so getting to see how an effect works was always a treat. To a certain extent it made me feel like part of the process.
And so while I love deleted scenes, and additional content, I could really do without most of the cosmetic touch-ups.
I can understand that. Some of the old effects really were kinda rough, though. But it's also a product of the time and the budget they had so you give it some leeway. I appreciate most of the changes though.
I know I'm alone on this one but I loved the movie and I'm sad it didn't get a sequel.
That image is from John Carter of Mars, right? I'd always meant to see that, but it just kind of slipped away from me. I've heard it was underappreciated.
Andrew NDB
01-24-2018, 01:22 PM
I can understand that. Some of the old effects really were kinda rough, though. But it's also a product of the time and the budget they had so you give it some leeway. I appreciate most of the changes though.
The special editions, and moreso the special-special editions on the blu-rays brought the OT up from something you can't show to kids/the younger crowd (without them rolling their eyes every few minutes something hokey is on screen or obviously FAKE) to something you... kind of can show them.
That image is from John Carter of Mars, right? I'd always meant to see that, but it just kind of slipped away from me. I've heard it was underappreciated.
John Carter of Mars is a funny thing. I watched it, and it just seems so boring, so derivative of other, better movies... which is ironic, because the source material actually is what inspired a lot of those movies to begin with.
NinjaPug
01-24-2018, 01:25 PM
Just imagine, if this had been a success, they would've thought they had "their" Star Wars and Bob Iger wouldn't have convinced Lucas to sell yet. Maybe Disney would've ended up buying it anyway since Iger/Lucas are friends but not before the Sequel trilogy was already in place.
https://pmcvariety.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/johon-carter.jpg
I know I'm alone on this one but I loved the movie and I'm sad it didn't get a sequel.
You're not alone. I'm a big fan of John Carter and like it more than the 3 new SW movies we've gotten.
Vegita-San
01-24-2018, 07:27 PM
It looks like a He-Man Spin Off from the 1987 movie.
With Teela by his side.
Vegita-San
01-30-2018, 07:04 PM
aWoeAXDIv7k
in mark hamil we trust. the FIRST friggen draft? anyone else need any more proof Rian is full of crap and doesn't know a thing about star wars beyond the basics?
CyberCubed
01-30-2018, 08:23 PM
in mark hamil we trust. the FIRST friggen draft? anyone else need any more proof Rian is full of crap and doesn't know a thing about star wars beyond the basics?
Rian Johnson has been a fan since he was a kid, he's read the comics/novels and based Luke's Jedi projection off one of the books from the Extended Universe. So yes, he does know about Star Wars.
Figures and merchandise in general for the last jedi has not been selling well and all the female line absolutely bombed. I think we will see some change, not because of whiny fans but because of financials.
The Last Jedi isn't bad because of Rian Johnson, any mistakes he made are forgivable, it's the direction JJ took the franchise and also Lucasfilm were the guilt lies.
plastroncafe
01-30-2018, 10:45 PM
There was a female line?
Wait, no seriously...where?!
Autbot_Benz
01-30-2018, 10:56 PM
There was a female line?
Wait, no seriously...where?!
https://i.imgur.com/2T8eL8M.jpg
Basically star wars barbie dolls for girls called forces of destiny
There was a female line?
Wait, no seriously...where?!
In the clearance rack:
https://i.imgur.com/eGj2Z0o.jpg
They don't look half bad, I don't know why they keep trying this, it doesn't work, even with Mighty Morphin Power Rangers which while mostly aimed at boys still had plenty of girl fans the "doll" line failed. The DC action figures for the DC Girls line also failed, so you can't say it's because they're dolls or they're bad quality.
I can't remember reading as many articles last year but I do remember the Rogue One toyline also did bad, though that one makes more sense, no character in that movie was memorable.
I still need to watch those forces of destiny shorts, were they bad? I never read anything positive or negative about them, I just remember the trailer looked a bit cheap but it had potential.
edit: Scratch the Power Ranger dolls doing badly, I was a kid so I don't know but they obviously did well enough to receive versions of the new cast for season 2 and for the movie. But they never tried again so either that's when they must have sold badly, which makes sense Power Rangers became a boy only franchise after the original fad ended.
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Weq0aBPYDdg/hqdefault.jpg
Andrew NDB
01-30-2018, 11:18 PM
Is that the "Suicide Action" Jyn Erso doll? And where's "Birthin' Suicidal" Padme? She doesn't rate?
CyberCubed
01-30-2018, 11:39 PM
Toys R us is also closing and most kids don't play with toys as often anymore, so I don't think it just being a female line has to do with anything.
Kids are glued to their ipads, phones, social media and youtube now, along with videogames as usual. The days of kids playing with toys is a lot shorter now and they outgrow it faster.
Toys R us is also closing and most kids don't play with toys as often anymore, so I don't think it just being a female line has to do with anything.
Kids are glued to their ipads, phones, social media and youtube now, along with videogames as usual. The days of kids playing with toys is a lot shorter now and they outgrow it faster.
We're talking about different things here.
Star Wars merchandise not just toys fell tremendously after the first couple of weeks, this is not going to make Disney happy, they make so much money on merchandise.
The female line failed, it was likely given the go since they thought Star Wars could be a more open brand but it's still mostly a boys franchise, the crosssover is not any bigger than it was back in the prequels. That's not to say there aren't female fans it just isn't the market.
People not buying toys are a different metric which is irrelevant to how Disney would consider the line a success or a failure. Think of it this way, the comics that sell a lot today and considered successes right now were failures in the 90s and cancelled because at that time that was a title that wasn't worth the time.
In the reports I read Disney was extremely happy with The Force Awakens sales so they're going to make decisions that are different to what's going on now, especially if Solo bombs in May which they expect it to. They want Star Wars to be this evergreen Marvel brand but they don't see they're running it to the ground, Star Wars can't have yearly movies without people getting tired, especially if they push uninspiring storylines and make merchandise of stuff that won't sell. Sadly I don't think they'll get the right message from this, they'll just want to go to how things "were right" with The Force Awakens since that did fantastic overall with merchandise.
Vegita-San
02-06-2018, 02:27 PM
an hour of soft ball question damage control nonsense.
4xW6woTAof0
Andrew NDB
02-06-2018, 02:33 PM
"All right, new Disney-Star Wars trilogy... show us what you've got!"
Episode 7: "All right. A New Hope."
"OK, new Disney-Star Wars trilogy... nice try. Now justify yourselves!"
Episode 8: "Nope!"
Metalwolf
02-06-2018, 08:55 PM
Kids are glued to their ipads, phones, social media and youtube now, along with videogames as usual. The days of kids playing with toys is a lot shorter now and they outgrow it faster.They aren't 'outgrowing' them faster, it's that flashing lights and sounds on a screen attract more interest. A plain toy where you have to imagine or pretend just seems ' boring' compared to a screen that does the imagining for you.
And it's not just female figures. There are tons of other stuff of Star Wars shelfwarming that one would assume boys would have an interest in, because it's just too oversaturated. Anything Star Wars used to be a special event, only coming out every so often, now it's too much, too mundane, and too soon.
ProactiveMan
02-06-2018, 10:52 PM
I do think the action-figure market is shrinking overall, but I also think that the recent waves of Star Wars figures have been pretty boring. They've been very anthropocentric, i.e. too many dull looking chuds in overalls, and not enough wacky aliens and robots.
I don't know that it's a male v female thing either. Characters like Ahsoka Tano and Sabine Wren were big hits. My guess is because they look cool, kids know who they are, and they're action oriented characters, which is kind'a important for action-figures. So yeah, Rose is a peg warmer, but I don't think Poe or Finn sold too well either.
Rouge One was pretty bland as well. A lot of plain looking characters adorned in shades of brown; blister cards sporting a photoshoped promo image of them looking vaguely irritated - like they were photographed watching a PowerPoint presentation that's been going on a little too long.
Vegita-San
03-12-2018, 04:45 PM
tommorow you get to relive the madness of a mess on demand if you dare to rent.
CyberCubed
03-12-2018, 04:49 PM
tommorow you get to relive the madness of a mess on demand if you dare to rent.
"if you dare" "relive the madness of a mess"
The movie is plenty popular and nobody is going to have a mental breakdown over rewatching this if they want to.
Autbot_Benz
03-12-2018, 04:52 PM
"if you dare" "relive the madness of a mess"
The movie is plenty popular and nobody is going to have a mental breakdown over rewatching this if they want to.
this might trigger Vegita-San but I had TLJ on Preorder since January and I can't wait to watch it again :lol:
CyberCubed
03-12-2018, 07:32 PM
I've already seen it twice in theaters, and I'll pick up the blu-ray in the coming months. I think all the Luke/Rey and Kylo Ren/Rey scenes are the most powerful and best of the movie, but I also like the side plots with Poe and to a lesser extent Finn/Rose as well.
Vegita-San
03-13-2018, 08:21 PM
So, i'm re watching this mess of a movie on amazon rental. I think my initial feelings on it where spot on. although I will admit I get so tired of tearing it apart, it almost feels like it SHOULD be watchable if you don't turn your brain on.
This thing contradicts itself left and right. most noteable with luke and reyben. Also Yoda's line to luke telling him rey already knows what's in the books and doesn't need them... so, why does she take them? sigh..
Admiral Gender Studies is femenism personified. She only becomes KIND of likeable when she says she likes Poe as he's un conscious. and even that is only because laura durn makes the goofy line that comes out of nowhere work.
Rose's 'we fight to save what we love' speech as she sneaks off a quick smooch as the death star laser just about kills her remaining friends is even more GD goofy on second viewing than it was the first time. Finn could have saved the day and gone out a hero, but this love sick crazy almost doomed them all while getting them both killed in a crash? ugh.
Most of this movie feels like a CW teen love drama between rey and ben. That also contradicts itself each act. not star wars.
The Code Breaker is utterly useless. how the hell did he even KNOW about the cloaked ships? on second viewing, Poe didn't find out until he was aboard, and he knew they failed before that so he had no time to tell them a plan he didn't know.
Gorriala walkers that do nothing other than to show that the standard walker design advanced in 30 years since. a Salt planet that might as well be ice. Goofy fox critters that solve a problem the resistance fighters shouldn't have that late in the movie.
ugh. I'm probably going to wind up seeing nine because my father still likes these things, but I Really have no interest in it.
Autbot_Benz
03-13-2018, 08:24 PM
So, i'm re watching this mess of a movie on amazon rental. I think my initial feelings on it where spot on. although I will admit I get so tired of tearing it apart, it almost feels like it SHOULD be watchable if you don't turn your brain on.
This thing contradicts itself left and right. most noteable with luke and reyben. Also Yoda's line to luke telling him rey already knows what's in the books and doesn't need them... so, why does she take them? sigh..
Admiral Gender Studies is femenism personified. She only becomes KIND of likeable when she says she likes Poe as he's un conscious. and even that is only because laura durn makes the goofy line that comes out of nowhere work.
Rose's 'we fight to save what we love' speech as she sneaks off a quick smooch as the death star laser just about kills her remaining friends is even more GD goofy on second viewing than it was the first time. Finn could have saved the day and gone out a hero, but this love sick crazy almost doomed them all while getting them both killed in a crash? ugh.
Most of this movie feels like a CW teen love drama between rey and ben. That also contradicts itself each act. not star wars.
The Code Breaker is utterly useless. how the hell did he even KNOW about the cloaked ships? on second viewing, Poe didn't find out until he was aboard, and he knew they failed before that so he had no time to tell them a plan he didn't know.
Gorriala walkers that do nothing other than to show that the standard walker design advanced in 30 years since. a Salt planet that might as well be ice. Goofy fox critters that solve a problem the resistance fighters shouldn't have that late in the movie.
ugh. I'm probably going to wind up seeing nine because my father still likes these things, but I Really have no interest in it.
Marks my spot on Vegita-San Bingo whines or blames something on Feminism SJW's or Women
ProphetofGanja
03-13-2018, 08:35 PM
So, i'm re watching this mess of a movie on amazon rental. I think my initial feelings on it where spot on. although I will admit I get so tired of tearing it apart, it almost feels like it SHOULD be watchable if you don't turn your brain on.
This thing contradicts itself left and right. most noteable with luke and reyben. Also Yoda's line to luke telling him rey already knows what's in the books and doesn't need them... so, why does she take them? sigh..
Admiral Gender Studies is femenism personified. She only becomes KIND of likeable when she says she likes Poe as he's un conscious. and even that is only because laura durn makes the goofy line that comes out of nowhere work.
Rose's 'we fight to save what we love' speech as she sneaks off a quick smooch as the death star laser just about kills her remaining friends is even more GD goofy on second viewing than it was the first time. Finn could have saved the day and gone out a hero, but this love sick crazy almost doomed them all while getting them both killed in a crash? ugh.
Most of this movie feels like a CW teen love drama between rey and ben. That also contradicts itself each act. not star wars.
The Code Breaker is utterly useless. how the hell did he even KNOW about the cloaked ships? on second viewing, Poe didn't find out until he was aboard, and he knew they failed before that so he had no time to tell them a plan he didn't know.
Gorriala walkers that do nothing other than to show that the standard walker design advanced in 30 years since. a Salt planet that might as well be ice. Goofy fox critters that solve a problem the resistance fighters shouldn't have that late in the movie.
ugh. I'm probably going to wind up seeing nine because my father still likes these things, but I Really have no interest in it.
Vegita-San, I hated the movie too but reading about how you hate it is even worse. Just stop talking about it or go on twitter like Cubed suggested
plastroncafe
03-13-2018, 10:36 PM
Marks my spot on Vegita-San Bingo whines or blames something on Feminism SJW's or Women
No no, that's femenism, which I think involves Ironman.
Shark_Blade
03-13-2018, 10:45 PM
So, i'm re watching this mess of a movie on amazon rental. I think my initial feelings on it where spot on. although I will admit I get so tired of tearing it apart, it almost feels like it SHOULD be watchable if you don't turn your brain on.
This thing contradicts itself left and right. most noteable with luke and reyben. Also Yoda's line to luke telling him rey already knows what's in the books and doesn't need them... so, why does she take them? sigh..
Admiral Gender Studies is femenism personified. She only becomes KIND of likeable when she says she likes Poe as he's un conscious. and even that is only because laura durn makes the goofy line that comes out of nowhere work.
Rose's 'we fight to save what we love' speech as she sneaks off a quick smooch as the death star laser just about kills her remaining friends is even more GD goofy on second viewing than it was the first time. Finn could have saved the day and gone out a hero, but this love sick crazy almost doomed them all while getting them both killed in a crash? ugh.
Most of this movie feels like a CW teen love drama between rey and ben. That also contradicts itself each act. not star wars.
The Code Breaker is utterly useless. how the hell did he even KNOW about the cloaked ships? on second viewing, Poe didn't find out until he was aboard, and he knew they failed before that so he had no time to tell them a plan he didn't know.
Gorriala walkers that do nothing other than to show that the standard walker design advanced in 30 years since. a Salt planet that might as well be ice. Goofy fox critters that solve a problem the resistance fighters shouldn't have that late in the movie.
ugh. I'm probably going to wind up seeing nine because my father still likes these things, but I Really have no interest in it.You secretly love this movie despite its flaws, I can tell...
You just keep coming back for more like a desperate ex.
Vegita-San
03-13-2018, 11:08 PM
You secretly love this movie despite its flaws, I can tell...
You just keep coming back for more like a desperate ex.
no, more like trying to give up something that was once good. and desperately hoping to find something still good in it before I do.
All the flaws are still present. some new ones found. just gotta have the will power to try to not seek out anything new in the hopes of finding a gem among the rough.
Spike Spiegel
03-14-2018, 10:39 PM
I've thought about this since seeing it the first time, and the only thing I really can't abide is
hologram Luke.
It just makes less and less sense, the more I try to consider it.
Vegita-San
03-14-2018, 11:38 PM
that's the problem with this mess. the more you think about it, the more it makes less and less sense.
and the harder it is to enjoy. this thing contradicts it's self so many times. ugh.
Another thing that jumped out on me. Just how many languages does rey know? she knows droid. she knows wookie. anything else? smh...
Shark_Blade
03-15-2018, 05:01 AM
'Star Wars' Star Daisy Ridley Says That Rey Has No Weaknesses
https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2018/03/10/star-wars-star-daisy-ridley-says-that-rey-has-no-weaknesses/
NinjaPug
03-15-2018, 08:22 AM
that's the problem with this mess. the more you think about it, the more it makes less and less sense.
and the harder it is to enjoy. this thing contradicts it's self so many times. ugh.
Another thing that jumped out on me. Just how many languages does rey know? she knows droid. she knows wookie. anything else? smh...
Could you list these many contradictions?
Vegita-San
03-15-2018, 08:32 AM
just the obvious ones for now..
'The Jedi must die'. 'Rey will not be the last Jedi'.
'I must destroy the jedi texts... i'm going to end it.. ' 'The Jedi texts, I've got to save them!'
'I HATE YOU!' 'There is good in Ben....(I've seen him with his shirt off, worth a shot)'
'I won't Train you...' 'Three lessons'.
'I won't go to fight with a laser sword' 'changes mind and fights with a laser sword'.....
finn Learns to stay and fight in first movie. Runs away first chance he gets in second.
just a few off the top of my head.
get whiplash trying to figure out character motivation here.
NinjaPug
03-15-2018, 08:58 AM
None of those are contradictions. Some of them are changes in opinions and motivations of characters.
You're also wrong on a lot of things. He never says Rey will not be the last Jedi. He says the Jedi won't die with him. Luke decides to train her after R2's message. Rey hating Ben but sensing good in him is no different than Luke and Vader. Luke never actually fought with a laser sword. Finn never learned that in the first movie - he only wanted to save Rey and was nearly killed. He tried to run away at the beginning of this one to get to Rey.
Just because you don't like things in the movie it doesn't mean they don't make sense or contradict earlier things.
Vegita-San
03-15-2018, 04:51 PM
'Star Wars' Star Daisy Ridley Says That Rey Has No Weaknesses
https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2018/03/10/star-wars-star-daisy-ridley-says-that-rey-has-no-weaknesses/
So basically, mary sue confirmed by mary sue herself.. smh. It's hard to root for a 'perfect' character like that...
I'm curious how digital sales are doing. more rentals than buys? or people putting their money where their keyboard fingers are and not buying?
Vegita-San
03-15-2018, 04:52 PM
None of those are contradictions. Some of them are changes in opinions and motivations of characters.
That happen 3-5 times or more during the course of the movie?
newfan
03-15-2018, 04:57 PM
So basically, mary sue confirmed by mary sue herself.. smh. It's hard to root for a 'perfect' character like that...
I'm curious how digital sales are doing. more rentals than buys? or people putting their money where their keyboard fingers are and not buying?
Don't you have to pay to rent too?
I thought she was 'too good' and that didn't appeal to me, not with everything though, there are things she would have learned from her circumstances like the fighting in general and she isn't the only character to pick up droid and wookie language after being around them. It was the force side of things, like she'd could easily just be a jedi with little training...but maybe that is where they want to take the story, that some are that way, can't tell at this point.
Vegita-San
03-15-2018, 05:09 PM
Don't you have to pay to rent too?
yep, but it's usually less. 1.99$ or so for about 24 hours.
dl316bh
03-15-2018, 05:11 PM
'Star Wars' Star Daisy Ridley Says That Rey Has No Weaknesses
https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2018/03/10/star-wars-star-daisy-ridley-says-that-rey-has-no-weaknesses/
Man, that headline is stupid. She doesn't say Rey has no weaknesses, especially not in a "she's perfect" way. Her comments are basically her own views on humanity and how things typically called weaknesses in people aren't, in part because people can change and work on things. She's basically talking about human growth and character growth in stories.
NinjaPug
03-15-2018, 07:44 PM
That happen 3-5 times or more during the course of the movie?
I mean half of what you posted wasn't accurate so they wouldn't even apply to your thinky veiled problems.
Vegita-San
03-15-2018, 07:45 PM
there's something with a star wars logo over there.. might want to buy it before toys r us goes under ;o)...
smh.
NinjaPug
03-15-2018, 08:06 PM
there's something with a star wars logo over there.. might want to buy it before toys r us goes under ;o)...
smh.
Ok. Nice deflection.
dl316bh
03-15-2018, 08:32 PM
Ok. Nice deflection.
You're just wasting your time, dude.
CyberCubed
03-15-2018, 08:53 PM
Vegita-san doesn't care, he does this all the time. There's a difference between not liking a movie and then harping on about it over and over and then coming up with bizarre conspiracy theories behind the people who made it and what goes on in the movie. Then when people try to point out his own hypocrisy, he goes on a tangent or just laughs it off. He does this all the time.
TheSkeletonMan939
03-16-2018, 07:25 AM
Now this is fun - if you register your copy of the movie with "Movies Anywhere" (which I guess is Disney's streaming service), if you play the movie through there you'll have the option to hear John Williams's isolated score (music only!).
You can't download the music or whatever, but there are other parts of the Internet for that. :tshifty:
Krutch
03-16-2018, 07:32 AM
The more I think about this movie, the more I hate it.
I love the message it's hammering home ("Let the past die.") but I hate the story it tells to say it. I think it's a poor choice to choose the second movie of a trilogy to take that stance.
Coola Yagami
03-16-2018, 09:52 AM
Vegita-san doesn't care, he does this all the time. There's a difference between not liking a movie and then harping on about it over and over and then coming up with bizarre conspiracy theories behind the people who made it and what goes on in the movie. Then when people try to point out his own hypocrisy, he goes on a tangent or just laughs it off. He does this all the time.
Eric Sachs Turtle Nostrils.
Vegita-San
03-16-2018, 10:03 AM
Eric Sachs Turtle Nostrils.
Don't try to point out the obvious to the insane. it never works. Nick Baxter Stockman. oooh, I can see his rant building up now. release the anger!
plastroncafe
03-16-2018, 11:04 AM
I don't know that I've ever seen a better example of a pot calling the kettle black.
That comparison to a bitter EX? Only gets more and more real time passes
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.